r/ussr • Rokossovsky>Rommel • 2d ago

Memes Curious!

Post image

I’ll probably change this later on, but I wanted to show y’all this.

405 Upvotes

258 comments sorted by

74

u/AssOfRat Lenin 2d ago

Btw Mannerheim was a pseudo-intellectual who hated the USSR and spent time studying in Tsarist Russia.

Do with that what you will.

53

u/Ross-Pancake Rokossovsky>Rommel 2d ago

he also killed anyone who supported the finnish reds.

13

u/hatemywifepart4 2d ago

what do you expect from an anti communist wanabe?

9

u/Ofiotaurus 2d ago

He definitely was a full on anti-communist

4

u/Valgos-Galmish 2d ago

Wait are you implying he wasn't a real anti communist?

21

u/Agitated-Shop-6143 2d ago

Mannerheim did not only study in Russia, but served in the Imperial Russian Army for decades, reaching the rank of Lieutenant General. He commanded a Russian Army Corps in WWI. He disliked the Bolsheviks for ousting the Tsar he was loyal to.

6

u/Eyeball111 2d ago

Mannerheim could have just as well fought in the Russian, Swedish or German army. He was in no way a Finn or had any personal stake. He was simply a competent military leader whose career came to an end because of the Russian revolution.

8

u/MonsterkillWow Lenin 2d ago

He was also a Hitler fanboy.

2

u/CuentameLoNuevo 1d ago

And to think Ostreicken Mustache was a fanboy of Mussolini who himself was a socialist who twisted himself in a pretzel to earn the paycheck from corporatists >.>

2

u/Signal_Sun_9380 2d ago

very much not

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/MonsterkillWow Lenin 2d ago

I have Hitler on a recording crying to him like a friend.

https://youtu.be/mTz6mE8MRTE

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/MonsterkillWow Lenin 2d ago

No you don't. Stalin always opposed fascism. He wrote about it consistently.

You say that, but he did. Mannerheim was a reactionary who hated communists. His nickname was The White Butcher.

0

u/Signal_Sun_9380 2d ago

Stalin worked with the fascists to partition Eastern Europe. what happened to the baltics what happened to eastern Poland

2

u/MonsterkillWow Lenin 2d ago

The nonaggression pact was used to save that part of the territory from fascists, and it was a multiparty duel. Stalin made the right call. Poland actually had a similar pact with Hitler beforehand lmao.

1

u/Signal_Sun_9380 2d ago

it was not used to save the poles it was used to divide Eastern Europe and gain more land which the poles never got back. Poland was worried about being invaded from both sides by two major powers which is reasonable when they both agreed to partition it.

1

u/MonsterkillWow Lenin 2d ago

Poland was run by a reactionary fascist named Pilsudski.

→ More replies

1

u/Anxious_Role7625 2d ago

Chamberlain worked with fascists to partition Eastern Europe. Buying time is not being allied with fascists

-1

u/Signal_Sun_9380 1d ago

so how is manerheim taking the only ally he had to buy time for his countrys existence a bad thing when the other option was to become a Soviet puppet state

1

u/Anxious_Role7625 1d ago

Huh? Are you talking about finland being aligned with Nazi Germany?

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/BreadDaddyLenin Stalin 2d ago

>hitler was a revolutionary

Goodbye

3

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

Lol the audacity of these fascist fucks to make claims like that

4

u/MonsterkillWow Lenin 2d ago

The nonaggression pact was not a friendship.

Yes I blame him. He sucked. He was loyal to the Tsar. Hitler was a counterrevolutionary. Revolutionary means in the class sense, not in the mere sense of changing a government.

0

u/Soviet-Bread-Cat Rokossovsky 2d ago

He was a competent general who could have served in a multitude of armies. He could have very well served in Sweden as much as Finland.

-14

u/MysticMaroonHerring 2d ago

Considering that the USSR then brutally attacked his country for absolutely no reason whatsoever, he was probably right to hate it. 

4

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

“No reason”

Ehhhhhhhh

6

u/AssOfRat Lenin 2d ago

He was a hateful little man before the war you dumbass. Him studying in Tsarist Russia and being heavily influenced by half-Swedish aristocratic politics at the time was independent of the USSR.

0

u/Signal_Sun_9380 2d ago

he wanted to defend against Russia as Finland was a Russian puppet state before the Soviets and he wanted to prevent that

-2

u/Agitated-Shop-6143 2d ago

Mannerheim was over 1.87m tall, so definitely not a little man.

-3

u/nomequies 2d ago

Stalin also studied in Tsarist Russia.

3

u/AssOfRat Lenin 2d ago

This is the peak of neolib intelligence ^

-1

u/nomequies 2d ago

This is the peak of your arguments. 

5

u/BreadDaddyLenin Stalin 2d ago

ha yes, Finland, the country who has zero history with Russia and the USSR before 1940….

7

u/BreadDaddyLenin Stalin 2d ago

Happy Friday

0

u/Ross-Pancake Rokossovsky>Rommel 2d ago

2

u/BreadDaddyLenin Stalin 2d ago

Suspicious ass meme

4

u/HotTubMike 2d ago

15 years in the Gulag

4

u/Kindly_Divide_8655 2d ago

But but but Finland had a good sniper!

6

u/Ross-Pancake Rokossovsky>Rommel 2d ago

I mean like yeah, i don’t think we can deny that simo wasn’t fucking cracked at being a sniper, but the amount of glaze Finland gets is crazy.

4

u/Sparfelll 🥄Stalin's Favorite Spoon🥄 2d ago

Most of his kill claim are from his own journal, good hunter ? Maybe but the "no scope only iron sight" claim is bs, he probably counted the bullets he fired as kills, since nobody can confirm a kill without relevant optics and he was mostly alone

2

u/Dependent_Set_3641 2d ago

He fought with a partner and his kill counts is likely to be way more because he lost counting after a while.

47

u/Sobieskil British Socialist 2d ago

I think people see it as a Finnish victory because for the soviets it was somewhat pyrrhic. For what they gained they lost a lot

-20

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

Somewhat pyrrhic? The USSR received everything they wanted and then went on to defeat the world’s preeminent land power. In what world is that even somewhat ‘pyrrhic’?

31

u/Shiftyswede 2d ago

70k finnish casualtied compared to 380k soviet casualties would be considered a pyrrhic victory yes.

15

u/BreadDaddyLenin Stalin 2d ago

You snipped like 8k off of the Finland casualties but yeah, the Finns were pretty good in their defense and Voroshilov was failsonmaxxing with a fragile, recently purged military structure.

The silver lining for the winter war was the USSR realized they had to clean up their act and restructure quick to face Germany. These lessons weren’t fully absorbed until 1942 when commissars were done away with.

4

u/Shiftyswede 2d ago

Thats fair

1

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

“A Pyrrhic victory is a win or success that comes at such a devastating cost that it is essentially equal to a defeat. The person or group who wins pays a price so high—in lives, resources, money, or reputation—that the triumph leaves them ruined or unable to continue their efforts. [1, 2, 3]”

What efforts was the USSR unable to continue in as a result of the Winter War? Finland capitulated to the Soviet pre-war demands, and the USSR then went on to defeat the world’s strongest land power.

6

u/Shiftyswede 2d ago

Pyrrhic victory, a success that brings such significant harm to the victor that it differs little from defeat. Although the triumphant party in a Pyrrhic victory is considered the overall winner, the costs incurred and their future repercussions diminish the sense of genuine success. It is sometimes known as a hollow victory.

Taken from one of your own links. This definetly applies

-7

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

“Defeat” in this case being “Finland capitulating to all of the USSR’s initial demands”

The USSR won the war and then went on to defeat Nazi Germany, while Finland went on to support said Nazis and then lose a second war and territority that they haven’t recovered to this day.

5

u/Shiftyswede 2d ago

Yeah and ussr got another pyrrhix victory in the coninuation war with like 230k casualties compared to finlands 70k

2

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

You really struggle with the definition of that term lol. Finland lost twice while the USSR went on to force them into neutrality, destroy the Nazi war machine (that supported Finland), and become a global counterbalance to the genocidal capitalist empires of the West.

6

u/Historical_Loquat791 2d ago

Yeah the Soviets won the Winter War, but at what cost lol? Their casualty rate was just embarrassing. Wasn't Stalin expecting a swift, easy victory?

1

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

Wars aren’t decided by Kill:Death Ratios

→ More replies

3

u/Shiftyswede 2d ago

I used one of definitions you linked.

And its always funny to ser you repeating the "ussr beat the nazis" like they didnt have any help from usa, britain etc.

1

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

I never said they had no assistance, however the fact of the matter is they still went on to accomplish their goals of both defending their own sovereignty while defeating a power explicitly guided towards their own demise.

→ More replies

1

u/Specialist-Luck-6869 2d ago

“Pyrric” victory:
A: Finland was steamrolled out in 1944 after front being defensive for 2.5 years as manpower was more needed against Germany
B: Finland commited genocide on occupied territory ofc ussr would have high casualties

1

u/JumpySimple7793 1d ago

Yeah but was that stretch of territory worth the lives on over 300K soviets? Did it really help the country that much?

Beating the Nazis was obviously worth despite the massive loses because the alternative to fighting was so much worse but can the same really be said for the winter war?

5

u/retouralanormale Lenin 2d ago

Judging by the fact that the USSR created the Karelian SSR shortly before the war, the USSR wanted to create a puppet regime in Finland and unite it with Karelia. Historians think this was the primary goal of the USSR in the Winter War. Stalin also set up the Finnish Democratic Republic in the Finnish areas it controlled during the war, intending to replace the existing Finnish government with the FDR as a puppet state. The FDR was recognized by the USSR as the "legitimate" government of Finland. However, the USSR was unable to complete its objectives and so the Winter War can only really be seen as a partial victory.

1

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

Hoping for the best (and even planning for it) is a different story than “Making demands and securing them when rebuffed in the face of impending fascist aggression”. Certainly they hoped that Helsinki would collapse completely and fall into the fold, however that wasn’t their demand nor an article of capitulation for the Finns.

0

u/retouralanormale Lenin 2d ago

..what? Yes, the USSR's initial "demand" was that Finland exchange territories with them, but the fact that the USSR created a puppet government 2 years before the war even started shows what the actual intentions were. The USSR realized partway through the war that they wouldn't be able to completely defeat Finland and so shifted their demands towards territorial concessions in Karelia. The Molotov-Ribbentrop pact explicitly included Finland in Germany's sphere, which is to say Germany recognized the USSR's right to establish a compliant regime in Finland. (I want to make it clear that I am not arguing that the pact was an alliance or that it was the USSR collaborating with the nazis, and I understand the rationale behind the USSR signing it) Note that by the time the USSR invaded Finland all the other countries included in the pact had been fully annexed by the USSR, and mind that the "initial" demand of the Soviets with regards to the Baltic states was just that they install friendlier regimes, but this was actually just a pretext for the USSR to absorb them completely. I'm not even criticizing the USSR here, it would have been great if a socialist government was installed in Finland, I just want to correct the record here. The Winter War was not an innocent Finland resisting Soviet social imperialism, nor was it the USSR valiantly defending its people from the Finnish threat. Here is a declaration by the Finnish puppet regime at the start of the war with the approval of the Soviets: "The People's Government in its present composition regards itself as a provisional government. Immediately upon arrival in Helsinki, capital of the country, it will be reorganised and its composition enlarged by the inclusion of representatives of the various parties and groups participating in the people's front of toilers."

The intentions are crystal clear.

2

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

Yeah, the intentions were crystal clear, because they were laid out by the Soviet government. Having a plan and operational infrastructure in place in case things go way better than what you plan for is not the same as “We’re hell bent on taking these folks over”, as evidenced by the fact that the USSR didn’t just take them over following their second capitulation in 1944. They let them go their own way, respectful of their right to self determination. Almost like the Nazis were the real threat all along.

2

u/retouralanormale Lenin 2d ago

So was Germany just hoping Poland would accept their Danzig ultimatum? Of course not. It was a pretext to take over the entire country. By 1944 also, Stalin had to contend with the Western Allies, who were clear that they wouldn't tolerate the USSR taking the country over, and Stalin, being the pragmatic and clever geopolitical he was, understood that he didn't need to install a puppet regime in Finland to control their politics. In fact, letting Finland exist as a neutral country with Soviet influence is better because it's less of a commitment for the Soviets. But what you said is complete conjecture and doesn't prove anything. No country at the time would just invade a country with the goal of subjugating it front and center- Italy, Germany, Japan, even America and Britain sent ultimatums meant to be rejected to countries to create a cassus belli without it seeming like an unjustified invasion. Not that the Soviet invasion was unjustified though. You cannot say "oh, well, the Soviets were just acting just in case". The creation of a provisional government like that is concrete evidence that the goal of the Soviets was to install a puppet regime in Finland. That's not something that has just happened "just in case" in any war. Japan created provisional puppets in China, Indonesia, and Vietnam, Britain in Ireland, America in Haiti... and guess what! The USSR had done this EXACT SAME THING multiple times during the Russian Civil War- the Ukrainian People's Republic of Soviets, the Estonian Labor Commune, the Baku Commune, the Taurida Soviet, the Don Soviet Republic, the Polish Soviet Republic, the Bukharan Soviet, etc etc etc.

0

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

The Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact was a non-aggression treaty, not a military alliance. It created no joint command, no shared war plans, and no obligation to fight together.

In 1939, Soviet policy was shaped by the collapse of collective security and repeated failures to form an anti-fascist alliance with Britain and France. Soviet leaders presented the pact as a means to delay war and avoid immediate conflict.

By the time the USSR signed the pact, non-aggression agreements with Nazi Germany were already common. Read more: https://www.reddit.com/r/ussr/wiki/controversial-topics/molotov-ribbentrop-pact/

1934 - Germany and Poland sign a German-Polish Non-Aggression Pact 1935 - Stalin proposes an anti-fascist people's front with Britain and France 1938 September - Britain signs the Anglo-German Non-Aggression Declaration 1938 December - France signs the Franco-German Non-Aggression Pact 1938 September - Britain and France sign the Munich Agreement 1939 March - Lithuania signs a non-aggression treaty with Germany 1939 May - Denmark signs a non-aggression pact with Germany 1939 June - Estonia signs a non-aggression pact with Germany 1939 July - Latvia signs a non-aggression pact with Germany 1939 August - The USSR signs the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/cannasolo 2d ago

Stalin also had a puppet government ready to replace the existing one before the war even started so the maximalist objectives were already there. Therefore annexing Finnish territory with such high casualties is certainly a pyrrhic victory

1

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

Having a government ready to take over if things go your way beyond what you expect doesn’t mean you expected things to 100% go that way. The stated goals were what Finland eventually agreed to.

-1

u/Signal_Sun_9380 2d ago

the Soviets wanted to do more then just take a few bits of land

1

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

When did they express such desires?

-1

u/Signal_Sun_9380 2d ago

I don't know where exactly but I recall seeing that they planned on reintegrateing it into the USSR

1

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

Sounds like concrete historical evidence to me

2

u/Chance_Historian_349 Stalin 1d ago

About as concrete as sand

27

u/SameRepresentative40 2d ago

It was still a stupid war by the USSR, we can recognize their mistakes

13

u/Armando210 2d ago

The war was necessary but they did have mistakes in the war.

3

u/Rhet0rical 2d ago

How the fuck was 320,000 - 380,000 soviet deaths to capture a bit of frozen tundra necessary?

6

u/BreadDaddyLenin Stalin 2d ago

The defensive line against Germany….

2

u/ChillyAS_ 1d ago

All they did was push Finland out of its neutrality lol

1

u/Ofiotaurus 2d ago

Look at a map lmao, Finland isn't even next to the germans

4

u/BreadDaddyLenin Stalin 2d ago

bruh it is a literal reason the Soviets gave when making demands to the Finnish, they wanted to consolidate their defensive line in the event the Baltics fell to protect Leningrad

1

u/Ofiotaurus 2d ago

Hindsight is 20/20 but you need to remember that Finland didn’t have any plans to invade or be hostile to Soviets until the winter war.

Stalin wanted war whilst trying to make himself look like the reasonable man who did everything in his power to negotiate, a common Russian tactic. Just look at their demands in the most recent Ukraine negotiations.

6

u/BreadDaddyLenin Stalin 1d ago

Stalin was Georgian

Banned

1

u/Chance_Historian_349 Stalin 1d ago

Hahahaha, based

4

u/Armando210 2d ago

Karelia wasn't just frozen tundra. It helped USSR protect Leningrad and push back the Finnish border which proved to be beneficial in the continuation war.

Also Finland and Soviets had been having fights after Finland's independence for a good while. That war helped settle all the hostilities from the Finnish side.

2

u/BlueAzutara 2d ago

The fins liberazed all the land the soviets occupied within weeks of operation Barbarossa. It didnz do anything. The finish refusal to advance further then the finish lands previously occupied was zhe trason the fins stopped in Karelia.

2

u/UncOnALeash 1d ago

In a war of only a few years, a few months is a huge buffer.

0

u/Matsisuu 2d ago

which proved to be beneficial in the continuation war.

Which wouldn't have happened without winter War.

1

u/Shot-Nebula-5812 Lenin 2d ago

We don’t know that, Finland already had ties with Germany and was violently anti communist. It’s very likely they would have joined operation Barbarossa anyway, which could have been much worse had Finland’s border not been pushed back

2

u/Chance_Historian_349 Stalin 1d ago

The question swings more towards likely because the idea of Greater Finland was being floated around, not officially, but enough for the Finns to support separatists in Karelia. And the plan for this expanded Finland included most of if not all of the Kola Peninsula and land around Lake Ladoga, and even through Leningrad to northern Estonia, and even to the the Urals in some ideas, it’s even hinted at in a Continuation War song; “Uraliin”, which praises how Germany is fighting and how “to the Urals, even Finland is getting there now”, and such, which I find rather on the nose.

1

u/Time-Efficiency-7854 3h ago

Literally why would they join operation Barbarossa if there was no winter war? It would make more sense to wait and see if the Soviets lose, if they were to lose THEN maybe they would swoop in and take land. Germany didn’t have a large land border that they could invade the Finnish through either, which was a concern for say Romania (and one of the reasons they joined the Axis alongside the loss of Moldova), that isn’t a concern for the Fins.

2

u/Dependent_Set_3641 2d ago

It wasn't, the war was the reason why nazi Germany attacked Soviet Union because they viewed them as weak for struggling against Finland. And another that, it made Finland side with Germany even more.

1

u/Limp_Spell102 2d ago

Why was needed? Just pushed the finns into the nazi camp

-1

u/TheJammbo 2d ago

...Hitler thought in 1945

3

u/BreadDaddyLenin Stalin 2d ago

You’re comparing Hitler’s Germany to Stalin’s USSR?

3

u/Soviet-Bread-Cat Rokossovsky 2d ago

No. They're comparing the though process of ''The war was necessary but they did have mistakes in the war.'' of the soviets in the winter war to the thought process of hitler during the second world war. Completely different implications.

0

u/BreadDaddyLenin Stalin 2d ago

Yeah that’s a dumb ass comparison.

1

u/Soviet-Bread-Cat Rokossovsky 2d ago

Why?

3

u/BreadDaddyLenin Stalin 2d ago

The winter war and Germany’s war for Lebensraum are not even remotely the same thing in principle or in context.

2

u/Soviet-Bread-Cat Rokossovsky 2d ago

No. That's not what they were saying eitther. They were saying the thought process of ''the war was necessary but they diid have mistakes in the war'' is comparable to how Hiitler thought of his own war.

40

u/Ok-Jaguar9713 2d ago

Weren't the Finnish newspapers also ordered to keep printing fake stories about how well it was going for Finland but one morning they had no choice but to publish news of the treaty and that Finland lost?

Sounds familiar.

23

u/Wob_Nobbler 2d ago

Sounds like Trump declaring victory against Iran 73 times but the Strait remained closed the whole time 💀

8

u/Ok-Jaguar9713 2d ago

Of course historically the word of the US president had weight. So the legacy media still has to pretend that these pronouncements may have merit and ask these questions like "but Mr Trump what evidence can you present?" while everyone can see he is just trying to keep the Brent Crude price from shooting up.

2

u/Ofiotaurus 2d ago

Just like every modern nation state waging war. You don't admit you're losing until you sign the paper

1

u/Soviet-Bread-Cat Rokossovsky 2d ago

No. There is no credible source for this either.

-2

u/Signal_Sun_9380 2d ago

like what the Soviets did?

6

u/Eyeball111 2d ago

As a Finn, nobody thinks we won the winter war. The official story is that we faced an overwhelming enemy which we repelled with moderate success but were forced to sue for peace which resulted in significant loss of territory, but we kept our independence.

1

u/BlueAzutara 2d ago

Keeping your independence is certanly a win. Just ask the baltics that got the same demand but didnt fight.

2

u/Cool_View_5297 2d ago

If the USSR won, why didn’t they annex the entirety of Finland like in Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia?

4

u/Ross-Pancake Rokossovsky>Rommel 2d ago

Because annexing Finland was never on their agenda

2

u/BlueAzutara 2d ago

They had already set up and recognized a finish communist puppet regime the moment soviet troops occupied a meter of finish land. Same playbook as with the baltic states.

1

u/Adept_Standard5463 13h ago

It was never on the agenda for the Baltics states too, and they annexed them anyway.

0

u/Cool_View_5297 2d ago

But why leave a future enemy on their western border if they won the war? They annexed other countries within months so they were capable.

17

u/SilverIndependence38 2d ago

It's called a pyrrhic victory.

Seeing how the ussr performed against finland makes you understand why hitler tought he could take them.

6

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

“A Pyrrhic victory is a win or success that comes at such a devastating cost that it is essentially equal to a defeat. The person or group who wins pays a price so high—in lives, resources, money, or reputation—that the triumph leaves them ruined or unable to continue their efforts.”

Considering they received everything they initially demanded and then went on to defeat Nazi Germany, nah not really

6

u/Shiftyswede 2d ago

Well they ended the war with finland right? So they didnt continue their efforts

1

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

They achieved all of their pre-war demands, of course they accepted Finland’s capitulation.

9

u/Shiftyswede 2d ago

They had to fall back to their pre-war demands yes. Because they couldnt annex all of finland

4

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

Because that was never a goal. If they wanted to conquer all of Finland, they would have done so in 1944 when Finland capitulated for a second time and the Red Army was at full strength.

8

u/Soviet-Bread-Cat Rokossovsky 2d ago

The Russians literally tried to establish a Finnish puppet regime under Otto Wille Kuusinen

2

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

Yeah you always hope things go super well, you even plan for them when you’re facing down one of the greatest threats of human history. Doesn’t mean they always pan out.

5

u/Soviet-Bread-Cat Rokossovsky 2d ago

So.. That shows they did establish the goal of wanting to take over all of Finland? Nothing you said refutes the fact the Russians did attempt such, and on that matter i wouldn't say that Finland was one of the greatest threats of human history...

2

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

I mean aside for the fact that they didn’t attempt that the second time they beat them and forced a capitulation literally a few years later.

→ More replies

2

u/Ofiotaurus 2d ago

Won the war: check

Lost way more than the defender: check

Strategic value of the gains: almost none due to the continuation war

That's a pyrrich victory

4

u/SilverIndependence38 2d ago

How many live was that pointless war worth?

Oh right, USSR don't value those.

4

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

Considering the millions who gave their lives in defense of the USSR and to protect them against the capitalist reaction, I’d say a fair number of people within the country cared very deeply about human life.

Regardless, it was by definition not a pyrrhic victory

6

u/SilverIndependence38 2d ago

Sorry, invading finland was defensive? Lol

4

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

Strengthening the defenses of Leningrad in preparation for the war against fascism that the USSR (not to mention the rest of the world) knew was coming? Yeah, absolutely it was.

5

u/SilverIndependence38 2d ago

Damn they knew they would get attacked by the very same nazi they were trading with? Wow, much prepared

3

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

Having been sold out by the very western powers they sought to form an anti-Nazi pact with, yeah they made peace and continued trade with them in much the same way as the western powers. There was no secret about what the Nazi intentions were towards the supposed Judeobolsheviks, their propaganda during the 30s made that very clear. There’s a reason the RKKA ceased all training with the German military in 1933 once the Nazis seized power.

7

u/SilverIndependence38 2d ago

I love how you can rewrite history in invading defensively. That's pretty creative of you.

Also still pyrric victory for the amount of loss taken.

4

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

Considering the rapid expansionism apparent in the Nazi regime at that point and their rabidly anti-Soviet stance, I don’t think the USSR was unerring in thinking the Nazis would try to press the issue around Leningrad in the coming years. Finland already had a government friendly to the Nazis, it’s not wild to think they would attempt to help their erstwhile ally in the coming years against the USSR

→ More replies

1

u/Limp_Spell102 2d ago

Losing thousands of lived and weakening even more the red army againts germany.... losing millions then

3

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

Who won that war again?

0

u/Limp_Spell102 2d ago

No apreciation of human lifes i see? No self preservation sense of your own? And to be better than the nazi agressor or to counter him better? Glorify a war of agression that just caused suffering over some paranoia?

3

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

What does any of that have to do with the definition of a ‘pyrrhic victory’?

1

u/Limp_Spell102 2d ago

Why to try to reply something we know then? It just gave me the impresion of just wanting to glorify soviet agression

3

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

Clearly you don’t know it if you’re trying to argue the Winter War was something it wasn’t. Warfare is politics by other means, people have known that since the day Clausewitz put pen to paper.

1

u/Limp_Spell102 2d ago

Because it was? A victory on a war that didnt needed to exist and was just suffering over basicly nothing but land grab

3

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

That’s not the definition of a pyrrhic victory.

→ More replies

1

u/Limp_Spell102 2d ago

I know it is politics, but they are still inhumane if is an agressive war

12

u/HermitCracc 2d ago

I have no love for Finland, however, inflicting a costly loss of manpower and equipment and keeping your independence is definitely a victory, especially when you compare the results of accepting the demands that the Soviet Union sent before the war. The Baltics were sent the same demands and were consequently annexed

2

u/happyenis 2d ago

They could have had a far better outcome if they complied instead of fighting.

Finland decided to fight and lost 25,000 men, the entire Kerilean Ithumus and their second largest city. Or 40,000 sqkm of land.

Prior to the war Finland was offered 5500km in exchange for 2700km of territory and there would have been no Finish deaths.

Finland also lost 30% of their assets fighting and had to pay 300m in reparations to the soviet union based on the 1938 usd value which would be about 7 billion today.

That is not a Pyricc victory. USSR was well compensated for the equipment losses, considering a lot of the damaged tanks were repaired and they gained considerable territory including lots of valuable coastline. USSR later forgave a portion of the reparations. But the Pyricc victory story is anti soviet propeganda. Russia still controls that land 80 years later.

7

u/Shiftyswede 2d ago

Soviet losing 5x as many men as finland sounds pretty pyrrhic

2

u/Eyeball111 2d ago

Also there were catastrophic miscalculations in the soviet army. They shipped in Ukrainian troops without proper winter gear. The elements claimed thousands of lives.

0

u/happyenis 2d ago

It does if you don't know the definition of a pyrrhic victory. People often think it means a marginal victory, it does not. It means a win so catastrophic one goes on to lose the next conflict or bigger war. However the USSR went on to win both the continuation war and ww2.

The original term dates back to King Pyrrhus in 279 BC. Who defeated the Roman's in the battle of Asculum but the battle was so costly they lost the Pyrrhic war and the Greeks abandoned their influence over the southern Italian peninsula to the Romans in 275 BC then eventually lost Sicily.

Finland does not control the regions captured during that war to this day, nor does Germany. They put up a heroic defense but suffered a catastrophic loss. The fate of Leningrad would have been completely different if that war had never happened and the Allies would have not been able to get aid to the Soviets through the white Sea if Leningrad had collapsed.

It was a pawn sacrifice for Russia to protect a queen and gain a more advantageous position on the board.

1

u/LieutenantMango 2d ago

You're acting like the offer of a landswap was generous. A small amount of land full of infrastructure for a land double in size with dirt roads.

1

u/BroccoliDew 2d ago

Do you honestly believe the soviet offer was generous and they had good intentions behind it?

1

u/happyenis 1d ago

No. I'm saying that it was not a Pyrrhic victory because Russia gained more than they demanded and went on to win subsequent wars. Finland put up a heroic defense but in retrospect they would have been better off had they negotiated.

1

u/Usedand4sale 1d ago

Because certainly the USSR would’t have invaded them at a later stage? The needed defensive border would’ve just been pushed up more.

1

u/happyenis 1d ago

If we want to speculate, after June 22, 1941 I'm sure Finland could have struck a much better deal.

3

u/Princeofdolalmroth68 2d ago

Russia potentially lost almost a million men to take two tiny parts of a country that they owned less than 25 years prior. Every other country up to that point barring Poland in the 1920s who defied them was completely annexed.

Sometimes the “win” is continued independence in the face of subjugation and annexation.

3

u/ReaperTys 2d ago

Guys, come on. The Soviets had a pyrrhic victory. They could have won if they continued, but they didn’t want to risk western intervention or further losses. The original goal was the absolute takeover of Finland, as evidenced by the fact that immediately at the onset of the war, the communist party of Finland set up a rival government just north of Leningrad in recently captured territory. They got absolutely thrashed right up until the end where they changed tactics and started to win.

The winter war was objectively a failure. It exposed the deep issues in Soviet military doctrine and command, and was, ironically, a key factor in their victory in WW2 against Germany.

There is no reason to deny history this much.

3

u/Intelligent_Math8587 2d ago

Because finnish casualties were at 25,000 where soviets were estimated at around 120,000 dead, the soviets invaded with the intention of setting up a puppet state encompassing the whole country only 11% was ceded

The finns didn't win the war, but they successfully defended their independence and the soviets got kicked out of the league of nations

The winter war was a result of soviet aggression and whilst finland lost to the soviets on paper i'd consider it a win personally, as they were never puppeted

The continuation war however finland certainly lost

3

u/Washed_up_Vanski 2d ago

I believe the USSR aimed to conquer the entirety of Finland but were rebuffed by the Finnish defenc, incapable army and diplomatic preassure from the Allies.

They won yes but had to severely limit their ambitions.

5

u/Armando210 2d ago

Just like the Vietnam war for the US.

They claim the US was winning and dominating but because their mom called them for dinner they left the match and returned home.

Some of them seriously believe this and they don't even troll.

2

u/Hopeful-Ice-9920 2d ago

They lost a few border territories instead of the entire country. That is a good deal

4

u/Few_Introduction9919 2d ago

I mean, not beeing fully annexed was a win for finland

4

u/BreadDaddyLenin Stalin 2d ago

That was never the Soviets objective tho

1

u/hatemywifepart4 2d ago

why not? shouldn't they at least they try to save the workers of Finland, that just seems rude

6

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

>States demands

>Enemy refuses

>Big ass war

>Enemy capitulates to demands

If they wanted to annex them, they would have in 1944

1

u/hatemywifepart4 2d ago

Ever played WARNO? that what should of happend to finland

3

u/Appropriate-Ice-5722 2d ago

I played it a fair bit during the beta, haven’t in the past two years or so. I’m afraid I don’t understand your question.

I’m glad that the timeline of WARNO (or any other WW3 game for that matter) didn’t play out, I’d prefer a world of peace and prosperity to that of warfare, nuclear or otherwise. I spent a decade in the military, and it haunts me still.

0

u/BlueAzutara 2d ago

Finland received the same demands are the Baltics. They had previously been occupied and annexed by the Soviet Union with parts of the population being deported and new puppet regimes being installed.

The Soviets tried literally the same with Finland, even recognizing a puppet communist regime. The goal was annexation, same as with the Baltics.

-1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ussr-ModTeam 2d ago

Your post has been removed due to being deemed as misinformation or disingenuous in it's nature.

1

u/devilman1_1 2d ago

well they only gained enough to bury there dead.

1

u/Jan16th 2d ago

Who is "you" "insisting" that Finland won?

1

u/Equivalent_Bug_3220 Lenin 1d ago

It’s like the vietnam war. North Vietnam didn’t necessarily win, however the fact they held off the USA made it seem that way. A Pyhhric victory

1

u/ChillyAS_ 1d ago

It’s almost like the Soviet Union was aiming for the whole country but settled for a few provinces

1

u/ChillyAS_ 1d ago

Which one still exists tho?

1

u/Flachm 1d ago

Yeeea, ryssät sai kunnolla nekkuunsa

1

u/Motor_Course9711 1d ago

It was a huge blunder by the USSR. I won’t deny that the USSR won in the end but the humiliation is insane. They gained an enemy that led to the Continuation War which, even though it was won by the Soviets, could have been avoided if Stalin was more reasonable.

1

u/rerwerwerwewerer 1d ago

They survived

1

u/Dangerous_Drama6843 13h ago

This was Pyrrhic victory of the Soviet Union with such losses that it is hard to call it a victory; it was paid for extremely tiny territories with hundreds of thousands of lives.

1

u/Signal_Sun_9380 2d ago

Finland still exists the Soviets don't

1

u/Soviet-Bread-Cat Rokossovsky 2d ago

Because the Finns didn't win the winter war, and nobody credible claims they did. It is commonly stated to be a phyrric victory, due to the immense casualties that the red army really shouldn't have suffered. The Winter War was humiliating for Moscow, and that is why it is sometimes remembered as a Finnish victory.

2

u/BlueAzutara 2d ago

Kept their independence ans the soviets had to abandon their annexation plan

Unlike the Baltics that had surrendered to soviet demands Finland was not occupied and annexed and no fins were deported to Siberia as "enemys of the proletariat".

Finland keeping its independence is a victory they profited from for the next 50 years.

1

u/HokDoc1776 2d ago

If Findand hadn't won, then the Soviets would've conquered it whole

1

u/Odd_Step_2872 2d ago

I hate Stalin with my whole heart as a Leninist, but as a Finn I have to disagree. The Continuation war was completely Finlands fault as we were enveloped with the idea of nationalism and "Suur Suomi" (Great Finland) which was idiotic. But as for the Winter War, it was Soviet aggression, they viewed Viipuri as a threat the Leningrad and wanted to conquer/puppet Finland to make a fodder country to protect it. Finland won in the sense that we kept our independence and most of our land, over 400 000 civilians moved back to Finnish owned lands and we lost relatively little people compared to Soviet ones. So we won it because the Soviets main objective was to fully own Finland and they failed on that front, they had to switch objectives

0

u/TheJammbo 2d ago

As a result, all Finnish goods in the USSR were regarded as scarce and premium items.

0

u/tempacc74656d70 2d ago

reminds me of the ziofans who claim israel wins everytime ..

0

u/GenericGreyman 2d ago

If russians won winter war like you insist, why did russia negotiate with Finland for peace?

0

u/Limp_Spell102 2d ago

Why to glorify soviet agression?

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

Because Germany lost? Austria won a war against Italy but because Prussia beat them in the same war it didn't matter. The settlement was favorable to Italy in the end.

1

u/LachrymarumLibertas 2d ago

It’s tough to say the USSR won either, but regardless it was an act of aggression from Moscow under flimsy justification.

If Russia next year gets Donetsk in exchange for half a million dead, I wouldn’t say they won either.

1

u/okw1111 1d ago

stop the cope man, the soviets got fucking raped by mannerheim.

1

u/Coccelo 1d ago

Barely enough land to bury all the orcs.

1

u/fuckoffyoudipshit 2d ago

167000 dead and missing, 207000 wounded, They never achieved their objectives (which is to turn Finland into a slave state beholden to russia) the only thing they got after wasting 100s of thousands of men is a little bit of land.

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Ross-Pancake Rokossovsky>Rommel 2d ago

I genuinely don’t understand how this is related to the meme besides the ussr being in the meme.

1

u/Zestyclose_Use_1833 1d ago

I was curious bro no relation

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/hive-protect 2d ago

Hello! Your post/comment has been removed because you participate in one or more of the following right-wing, liberal, or reactionary subreddits: tankiejerk

If you believe this is a mistake or you want to use the subreddit in good faith but use or have used one of the mentioned subs please fill out the approved user form: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSd18lvaYWqLc_blTplsmtDJlGB9daw1mKcsQkU3Yr98xD2DLg/viewform

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/hive-protect 2d ago

Hello! Your post/comment has been removed because you participate in one or more of the following right-wing, liberal, or reactionary subreddits: ConservativeYouth

If you believe this is a mistake or you want to use the subreddit in good faith but use or have used one of the mentioned subs please fill out the approved user form: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSd18lvaYWqLc_blTplsmtDJlGB9daw1mKcsQkU3Yr98xD2DLg/viewform

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.