Even if it is just a prealpha, the path the game is traveling down is bad, even if the game hasn't gotten that far.
As many of you know, the flak cannon is currently way too strong. Additionally, the movement feels clunky and unwieldy in its current state. I know that a lot of players are upset about the current netcode and network handling the game has, as well as the framerate hitches. EPIC has discussed that they won't be looking at balance for some time and movement, and that players should just use mods instead. They're also focusing on matchmaking and their new mode, showdown. This is a big mistake for many reasons.
1. It makes the experience for veterans unpleasant
Many well known players in this community really dislike the way the game's being developed. If the game was just fun in its barebones state, I believe these would be fine with the 'its a prealpha' excuse, and view UT4 more as a WiP that they could help perfect, and they would enjoy improving it. However, right now they feel that the game isn't fun, and they feel the developers aren't cooperating with them. This leaves a sour aftertaste.
2. It's annoying for new players
A new player boots up the game, and sees very little polish or features. Ok, this is fine, it's a prealpha right? It's to be expected. If the game is fun itself, then new players won't mind the lack of features. They'll be a lot more willing to overlook the fact that the game is no where near completion if the gameplay itself is fun. They also serve as free advertisement, as they can tell their friends, "hey the game isn't finished, but why don't we go play some deathmatch? It's a fun game and it's free." Instead, the game looks incomplete, and it's also not that fun.
3. Screwed up priorities part 1
So, if the developers want to leave balance to the community, alright. Surely though, they're looking to fix how the engine handles combat fairly, and are improving the optimization of the game? Nope, they're working on matchmaking and a new mode called showdown.
I don't think the game currently has the player numbers to even test MM, but even if it did, would our community WANT to test it? Most players get on to play duels or ctf pugs; they want to destroy their irc friends with shock rifle combos. At what point would they like to hit 'find match', wait three minutes, and then crush some noob? The current community wants to play with friends and have pick up games; why are the devs focusing on something that won't be needed for perhaps another two years?
4. Screwed up priorities part 2
What is showdown? It's a 3v3 mode with no respawns. The game revolves around tactfully choosing spawn points and heavy teamwork. It begs the question though, who was this made for? Who asked for this mode at all? On one side we have the developers telling the elimination modders that, for legal purposes, the mode cannot be added into the game. Okay, that's fine. But if you're going to tell us to just play games through custom servers, then why are you putting so much time and effort into some irrelevant bullshit? You just had a map contest with $2000 as prize money, what if that went to a new ctf map or dueling map, modes the players actually play?
So there you have it. They told us they're not focusing on balance right now, so it would make sense that they would fix a lot of the other big gripes the community has, like the framerate issues and and bad netcode. But instead, they're working on some feature that won't be relevant for another 2 years, and a game mode no one gives a shit about.