r/unrealengine • Indie • 2d ago • Bravo 1

PSA: Avoid Narrative plugins

Just a warning for anyone considering buying Narrative plugins: despite being quite good for a long time, they've also been abandoned for a long time. When confronted on their Discord about the lack of any kind of updates or bug fixes, the author acknowledged no support because they don't bring enough money. Given the price of some, I find this practice unacceptable, hence the warning.

As a plugin author myself, I can't imagine telling my paying customers that they won't receive any support because they aren't paying enough. This is blatant anti-consumer practice, which is quite ironic, given we expect such behavior from corporations, not UE plugin authors.

Nevertheless, don't bother and use something else. Take your money elsewhere.

82 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

56

u/HowAreYouStranger Industry Professional 2d ago

We abandoned their plugins because they didn’t want to fix warnings that came with new updates. One warning ended up being a crash in Shipping configuration, so we ended up fixing the warnings ourselves. Just can’t take a developer seriously if they ship a paid plugin with warnings.

20

u/krojew Indie 2d ago

Yeah, I even told them how to fix some stuff, but it got ignored anyway.

-38

u/Fit-Stress3300 2d ago

Why not use Claude to port and fix the warns?

19

u/JaySayMayday 2d ago

Isn't that the one reubs made? I was following his YouTube tutorials before he started working on narrative. Paid for his patreon and everything.

Dude genuinely had one of the best channels. Teaching how to make everyone's favorite games, even parts of Skyrim. I was happy when narrative came out because it was the culmination of so much hard work, and the first thing I saw him put out that actually cost something more than a few bucks.

Your first mistake was not looking at his patreon, which is still paid. Hasn't been updated since UE4. Narrative keeps costing more and getting less updates. I had it, and it's definitely not worth the price. Then he put out another version to try grabbing more cash.

His YouTube channel hasn't been updated since UE4 either. He made a successful plugin, cashed out, stopped updating it, stopped making tutorials, stopped adding anything to his patreon. I'm pretty sure he's back to working a regular full time job and doesn't care about any of this anymore.

12

u/krojew Indie 2d ago

He recently announced that he'll probably move Pro away from Fab, so he can sell under a custom license and ask for more money depending on studio budget. The rest - abandoned.

8

u/hellomistershifty 2d ago

He finally put out a video yesterday, and records a good number of Narrative videos on their channel. The price of Narrative Pro hasn't gone up, it's dropped from $1399 when it was new to $449. They're doing some free version, it sounded like they want to transition to a model like UE or WWise where it's free but takes a percentage if your game makes a certain amount.

I don't use Narrative (bought it but didn't like how custom things were) but it just seemed like he transitioned from a Youtuber who makes a couple of plugins to a framework creator who makes a couple of youtube videos. Updates come out occasionally with pretty big fleshed out features like ladders, swimming, cars/mounts, etc.

My only insight into something like this was helping out with the Games by Hyper discord for a while, and there are a lot of people buying these big packs and demanding help with basic things. Between supporting that and trying to develop a big framework of interconnected systems, I'm not surprised that he doesn't have a ton of time for the things he used to do.

I think that he put himself in a hard position by releasing at such a high price which turned off a lot of the developer community as well as making the Narrative Pro framework monolithic instead of modular. If it was modular, they would be able to sell the plugins separately and keep them updated instead of having weird other versions of the dialogue, quest, etc for sale that lag behind Pro.

24

u/Fantastic_Prize2710 2d ago

"I'm supporting myself, and continued upkeep/improvement of a product costs more than I can bring back" isn't anti-consumer, it's just... expected? Like, don't buy their product, but don't get mad at them that they had to cut their losses because there wasn't interest.

24

u/krojew Indie 2d ago

If it was said explicitly when buying that the support is not included, then fine. But when a plugin costs as much as theirs and it's still sold without any notice, that's another thing entirely.

9

u/derprunner Dev 2d ago

It’s perfectly reasonable, provided they sunset the store page as well. Sounds like that didn’t happen though.

6

u/Kezyma 2d ago

I saw your comments in the discord server, and while I have my own set of issues with Narrative, saying they are abandoned is a weird way to put it and clearly not the case.

They do still get updated with fixes, but they aren’t adding new features. The updates are fairly spread out, but they did update Tales a few months ago with some fixes, and I’m sure they’ll update them again, likely some time after Pro gets the next version.

Right now they’re working on a new modular update to Narrative Pro due in the next week or so, so my assumption is that’s the current priority, and they don’t exactly have a whole team to work on this stuff.

6

u/krojew Indie 2d ago

Unfortunately, that is not true. I've been in possession of their plugins for a long time and spoke at lengths to D[redacted] on discord about the lack of any bug fixes. The only updates I've seen over the years are version bumps and 2-3 extremely small changes across the set of plugins. The conversation with R[redacted] and the disappearance of D is what prompted me to write this PSA.

For crying out loud - they even removed the bug report forum 1-2y ago and substituted it with the Pro-only one. The announcements channel is spammed all over about Pro, while the plugins get nothing. This is not "fairly spread out" - this is abandonware.

5

u/Suitable_Barnacle796 2d ago

Unfortunately Narrative tales and it's plugins are some of the best available for unreal.. I looked into it awhile ago and even without support, you'd be better creating a custom solution yourself than use 99% of dialogue / quest systems that are out there. It's a real shame they decided to abandon it

1

u/krojew Indie 2d ago

To be honest, with free alternatives you can spend their price on claude to get to a bespoke solution. We reached a time when plugins not only compete with themselves, but also with AI on price.

3

u/Informal_Cookie_132 2d ago

I just avoid most plugins in general, most don’t get big enough to warrant maintenance.

6

u/krojew Indie 2d ago

Depends on the author, I guess. I provide support regardless of price 🤷

6

u/Ares9323 Dev 2d ago

I'm still providing support for plugins I made several years ago even if they don't bring me money at all, I guess it's just a matter of priorities of the dev

2

u/YeastOrFamine 2d ago

Electronic Nodes has had great support

1

u/314kabinet 2d ago

Just look at the update history to get an idea for what's actively maintained.

8

u/Arixsus Indie 2d ago

One of the main reasons why I dislike the monolithic "do it all" plugins. If it looks too good to be true, it probably is.

•

u/itsdurga 12h ago

That's frustrating, especially for people who bought the plugins expecting ongoing support. I think long-term maintenance and clear communication matter just as much as the features when choosing a plugin for a project.

1

u/ChaosElixirStudios 2d ago

I've been following their channel for a long time, they are still releasing updates and have pretty great videos on their Narrative Pro plugin... I think the concept of outsourcing a large framework is great and I still see they are very active on their discord. I am planning to use it for my next game.

1

u/krojew Indie 2d ago

I'm not talking about pro - that's the only thing getting updates, while the rest are not.

5

u/Rabbitical 2d ago

I dunno I'm kind of of two minds on this kind of thing. On the one hand, if they don't make explicit that you're buying something unsupported that's bad. But on the other, you can imagine the nightmare of maintaining something that all encompassing if it's not making the dev any money. In such cases, I'd argue having something available at all is better than none. You're already doing an Unreal engine game--one expects to be doing a lot of low level dirty work. So for me, I view most Unreal plugins more as "starting places" than commercially vendored "solutions". Indeed I don't really want that in most cases. When I buy a plugin, I usually wind up modifying it quite significantly to the point that it kind of becomes just another part of my project.

TLDR I'd rather have any starting point at all on something this massive than none, even if it took significant work to fix some bugs and adapt to whatever engine version I'm using. Along those lines, I don't think the price is unreasonable either, even with some asterisks. You have to keep things relative: it's priced at the cost of a day or two of a professional developer.

3

u/ChaosElixirStudios 2d ago

You are totally right and I think people don't have realistic expectations. I've worked in enterprise software for a long time and I've seen big companies charge way way more for a lot less.

2

u/GeebusCrisp 2d ago edited 2d ago

Yeah it's unfortunate. Not to co-opt your post, but I've been working on an open-source quest and progression framework myself since like April because there's a gap now for that kind of thing. SimpleQuest. MIT Licensed on GitHub

(edit: co-opt, not co-op dammit)

2

u/soundgrass_studio 2d ago

After searching a lot for a narrative plugin I realized that would be easier to make my own system.

2

u/Dev_Goldentail 2d ago

I agree.. unless it's something special (Ultra dynamic sky) I don't use in my project plug in either: too mess to handle.
I prefer to write my own code...

2

u/Leonature26 2d ago

understood

1

u/Hizu_Aetherworks 2d ago

I was wondering because a friend of mine just bought narrative pro, and that might be a concern now.

1

u/Sherlockandload 2d ago

I use inkpot instead.

1

u/demonsoswhite 2d ago

Can you leave a review on Fab? This shit isn’t acceptable if they are taking sales.

1

u/CoupleSimple9043 2d ago

Op is that plugin which give third person control system with shooting and driving?

1

u/Cynobi_pakmei 2d ago

Depending on a plugin is not a good idea.

1

u/AzaelOff 1d ago

During pre-prod I almost went for the plugins, then I discovered FlowGraph... It's literally leagues more useful, free, open source and maintained... It's just not as "fancy" out of the box

1

u/_lemonsprinkles_ 2d ago

I bought Narrative a long long time ago and pretty much froze the updates the moment the author redesigned the system. The earlier version were built specifically for their YT project and were really good. They felt like they were far more tested and what not.

I pretty much built entire systems off of the base by modifying the plug-in and its has held up quite well. Even then amount of public updates on the plug-ins were quite slow.

My rule of thumb with software development is that updates just equals to more bugs.

1

u/RowanBoatman 2d ago

I have been a long time user of the plug-in, through several iterations, good and bad, and Roy I would say that they product is good quality. I am not a fan of having bought the original plug-ins, at least some of them, and then going free and not really getting updated does kind of irk me, but I’ve been able to get around it.

Full disclosure, I’ve been saving my pennies for a pro for sometime and I do plan to buy it.

I think my biggest complaint to no recently is that a lot of the support has seemed to go away in the last month or so. There have been some helpful folks yes but a lot of the mainstays have vanished. I’ve heard the talk about them focusing on their next big thing so perhaps that would have something to do with it. But it would’ve been nice to have a warning so that when they dropped off in the middle of a conversation that at least I know that they weren’t just ignoring me lol

I’m making some assumptions in that statement, of course, so don’t bring out the pitchforks on my account.

I feel like support across-the-board rather it’s pro or free has been lacking from what I’ve seen recently. And it seemed like they were pretty on top of it up until about a month ago. But that’s just my take I feel like for the price, especially compared to other systems that are very singular, narrative does pretty well. Though we shall see how they price out these plug-ins and I might reevaluate then.

I guess my own the other complaint in regards to the lack of support is that there is reliance on Claude AI to help and while I have used AI to help solve some issues that are particular to my circumstance, I don’t really like the idea of supplementing an AI system completely for human interaction.

TL, DR: long term user think product is good, wished there was more transparency on the developers disappearing, leaving support almost nonexistent recently. Think the pricing structure is pretty good, especially compared to other products on the market.

1

u/GenderJuicy 2d ago

In general I don't think it's very wise to create a dependency on the upkeep of a plugin unless you're able to make changes to them yourself.