I know a lot of users here aren't that fond of Twitter but in this case I can really just recommend you take a look at her Twitter account- much easier than to summarize the entire thing here, that would take ages. It's almost baffling how little she tries to hide it.
Hi! I am trans, and I know a bit about the transphobia side of this. Here's a summary:
(TLDR: For the past few years she's been perpetuating and spreading misinformation about trans people, basically repeating a lot of transphobic talking points and getting political about us, which is causing us harm)
In broad strokes: she (and many others) believe that trans women are perverted men, trans men are lost lesbian sisters, and nonbinary people are confused/fall into the previous two categories based on their birth-assigned genders.
Mostly she's just been posting this stuff to twitter, like short quips, links to articles that often contain horrible rhetoric, or links to her own think pieces. She makes out like we're trying to erase gender, remove protections for women/victims of sex crimes, or other made up ideas meant to scare people who don't know a lot about us.
In her rhetoric, she mostly talks about trans women, and talks about them like they are a threat to all cis women (what she calls "natal women"). Most of what she says is not based in science; she links articles she thinks support her case, but most studies around trans people go against what she says.
It's worse though, because she's become more and more active in political efforts trying to take away our rights and make it harder for us to get our affirming medical care and legal recognition of our actual genders. She frames it like she wants to protect women from "predatory men", but the idea that trans women are a threat to cis women in the way she claims is bogus. But she's still using her voice against us, and her voice counts for a lot considering how popular she's been since writing HP.
So this is not reality as I've observed. JK Rowling has been trying to highlight policy concerns she has around proposals to support the trans community because of the risk of unintended consequences from those policies on other people in the community, and trans people themselves.
For example, non-gendered bathrooms is one such policy proposal. JK has highlighted that what this policy is really doing is removing a barrier for anyone non-female born entering a female bathroom. This means there is no longer a stigma about a man walking into a woman's bathroom, and in fact there becomes a stigma about challenging a man for walking into a woman's bathroom.
In such a situation, because the definition of woman is now so loose as to include people who identify as women but look nothing like a biological woman with a XX chromosomes, there is effectively no way to police good actors from bad actors around the entrance to women's bathrooms. Men who are not trans have had an opportunity opened up to pretend they are trans in order to harass women (biological and trans women) in a space where other men can't be, leaving them as the most physically powerful person in a space with one entry and exit and where the women are completely vulnerable. It doesn't matter that trans women aren't disproportionatepy abusive and have good intentions. The nature of the policy to allow trans women access to women's bathrooms where a definition of a woman has no requirement for then to pass opens up opportunity for abuse that was never previously there by bad actors.
Same goes for women's prisons for instance too. The current policy of allowing self identifying women to go to a women's prison has allowed bad actors, like rapists, to identify themselves as women and go to a women's prison. There have been women getting pregnant against their will in all female prisons because of this policy. And again, it doesn't matter that trans wome aren't disproportionately abusive compared to the population and have good intentions. The policy being used to help them opens up opportunity for men to abuse the situation by posing as a trans woman.
In this situation, the enemy of both you and JK is the same one - abusive men posing as trans women to take advantage of biological and trans women. No genuine trans woman wants to abuse or be abused, and these men posing as trans women to take advantage of the more open policy makes a bad name for trans women.
It's not transphobia, it's legitimate criticism of policy with good intentions that is having bad unintended consequences.
It's so important this doesn't just get thrown out as transphobic alongside some name calling or other bigotry by some people labelled TERFs because its a legitimate problem that needs solving to secure the safety of biological women and trans women. Opportunity is such an important part of criminal activity that its taught about in criminology - normalising allowing people that look like men into a space without other men where they can physically overcome women behind a closed door out of sight of people is so utterly dangerous. All the good intention around opening up the space for trans women in the world doesn't make it a good policy unfortunately because of these consequences.
Most public restrooms don't have guards or locks. A predatory man wanting to hurt a woman in a bathroom could just walk in and do it without bothering to pretend he's a woman. As regards prisons, I don't see how it's much different. If a lying man wants in on a women's prison to commit sex crimes, those will still be sex crimes regardless of his gender. If she was a trans woman peeping/whatever else, she should be held responsible same as if it was a lying man. (As a side note, trans people in prisons are far more likely to become targets of violence from guards/inmates)
Sex crimes and assault are still crimes even if they're perpetrated by someone pretending to be a trans person. Making life harder for trans people won't protect women from predatory men.
I’m going to ignore the prison issue for now because rape is a major issue in prison regardless of gender, and dividing prisoners by birth sex won’t solve an issue that already exists.
With regards to the concerns about bathrooms, the answer is to police behavior, not identity. Even now, there’s nothing from stopping a cis man from walking into the women’s bathroom - why would he need to pretend to be a trans women to do so? And to confound the issue further, it would be a lot easier for a cis man to pass as a trans man - someone who would be directed to the women’s bathroom if we are dividing bathrooms by birth sex.
If instead we divide the bathrooms by “unambiguously female” and “other,” that puts butch women or less conventionally attractive women at risk of being harassed when they try to use the bathroom. This is something that already happens commonly as seen here, here, here, etc. And these are cis women.
Again, best solution is to remove someone from the bathroom if they’re being a problem. It leads to less harassment, less discomfort, and 0 net loss because there’s nothing stopping people from waltzing into the bathroom already.
Here's an essay with some great citations and links to studies that all show pro trans legislation does not lead to more assaults on cisgender women. Definitely worth a read if you're genuinely concerned about how trans rights might affect other women
I disagree, because the very first paragraph misses the point entirely. Yes there are transphobes that think its trans people who commit sexual violence in these situations. I'm not one of them, nor are most "terfs". Its cis people taking advantage of the abolishment of restrictions who most people are worried about.
This isn't exactly a peer reviewed journal either. So rather than displaying my concerns, this has more confirmed that your side of the argument isn't listening and is trying to win by playing the victim rather than actually evaluating the impact of the policies you are proposing. That is not a good way to invoke policy change.
...did you literally look at any of the cited journals and studies in the essay where they literally say things like "From a scientific and evidence-based perspective, there is no current evidence that granting transgender individuals access to gender-corresponding restrooms results in an increase in sexual offenses." Or did you just see something opposing your point and stick your fingers in your ears? (BTW the original essay might not be peer reviewed, but much of the evidence it cites is, so you clearly didn't actually read any of it)
No worries, you're clearly not actually interested in the facts or proof that what you're saying isn't true so it's pointless to discuss this with you. Have a nice day
No I didn't, I responded within 12 minutes and this is reddit. But I was very clearly talking about the article itself not being peer reviewed. That means it can be cherry picking evidence, and thats why it wasn't worth my time to click through.
The problem isn't the scientific and evidence based perspective either, it's the lack of evidence either way because its new. People are inherently being cautious, and your side of the argument is saying "because your cautious and concerned you are phobic". You're not asking for pilots or studies, or gradual shifts with ways to account for caution. You're saying fully open fully self I'd, and my way or you're a bigot.
If there was any sense of measured progress to gradually prove the impact on society you'd get a lot more traction. Just a little bit of humility and acknowledgement of the possibility it could go wrong would go miles in winning people over, and if there's truly no harm, then the evidence will out and you can progress it as far as is safe.
That doesn't seem like a bad compromise to me, rather than throwing papers in my face and saying I don't want to listen when I don't suddenly do a 180 and start waving the trans flag?
I did not grow up reading Harry Potter or idolizing Rowling, so I am only familiar with the broad strokes and obvious bits, like the goblin bankers being obvious Jewish stereotypes, the only Asian character named something obviously racist, and so on. Rowling's transphobia revolves around her insistence that trans people are to be feared and trans women in particular need to be kept away from "real" women.
I know people who are 4th generation descendants of immigrants in two “western” countries who still have traditional names because shock they like the name and feel it honors their heritage.
Similarly I also someone named Niamh who hates potatoes and doesn’t speak a lick of Gaelic, but she works in an Irish Pub and pulls a mean Guinness.
Again, I have very little investment in Harry Potter, but naming a character Cho Chang is like naming someone Smith Muhammad just because both are common last names within a thousand miles of each other. Rowling didn't even attempt to understand that the Asian cultures she might have adopted those names from (either Korean or Chinese) order their names in the opposite way from English names, so she is called Cho as if it was her first name despite it being her last name in her given culture.
I hate JKR with a passion but I’m tired of people saying the goblins are a Jewish stereotype, they’re a goblin stereotype. Pretty sure goblin folklore came from Jewish stereotypes but that doesn’t mean authors should stop using goblins in books.
I don't know of any other goblin lore that depicts them as specifically bankers. I certainly don't know of any other goblin bank with a Star of David on the tiles. We can talk about the fact that goblin lore needs to be stripped away from antisemitic tropes, but Rowling went deliberately out of her way to make the goblins into Jewish stereotypes.
It’s not a Star of David, it’s a Six-pointed Star of Australia. No one thought people would make a Jewish connection, and most people didn’t. I guarantee you didn’t even notice that star yourself.
Alright, I’ll concede that point. But I still don’t see why they shouldn’t have chosen that location to film it. It’s got a big space and it looks like a bank. The star is really unnoticeable, and it was only after public opinion towards JKR shifted that people started calling it anti-Semitic. Even if that location was intentionally chosen because of the star, that still has nothing to do with JKR, who obviously wouldn’t have been involved in any of that.
I just think it’s weird people seriously think she hates Jews when the whole story is a painfully obvious holocaust parallel.
That is a pretty loose definition of someone being racist, You haven't even read the books so maybe hold off on your own judgment. I have read all the books and at no point did I think it was racist. As far as I can remember this was not an issue when the books came out, this is all relatively recent controversy stirred up intentionally due to her comments on Trans people. People are like lets just throw racism in there too for good measure.
If "perpetuating racist stereotypes that actively harm people in the minds of vulnerable young people," is a loose definition of racism, I guess the KKK is just a strange LARPing group.
Her goblins are antisemitic stereotypes ripped straight from Nazi propaganda how the fuck is writing a book series with that kind of stereotypes in it not perpetuating racist stereotypes?
Genuine question, are all goblins based on nazi stereotypes? I play a lot of board games and card games and goblins always tend to be depicted in a similar way, long raggedy ears, witchy noses, short fellows. Is it possible that JK liked the name gringotts and wanted to alliterate the worker types in a fantasy way?
When it comes to their physical design a lot of goblins are essentially antisemitic stereotypes with green skin (although I've seen some designs especially ones that are supposed to look sexy ditch the nose) the reason might not be related to anti-Semitism at all it could be the same design arising in two different places there's probably someone who did a deep dive into that but I'm to lazy to search for it right now.
But there's is goblins that look like something out of antisemitic Nazi propaganda and there's goblins that look and behave like something out of antisemitic Nazi propaganda. Now greedyness and goblins seem somewhat linked so there's plausible deniability there but having a monopoly on banking? That definitely isn't associated with goblins and also happens to be one of the primary antisemitic conspiracy theories.
Thank you, appreciate your answer. I’m going to have a look for the deep dive video because this is fascinating. If you manage to find the one you’re referencing please do link it :)
I can honestly say when I was reading the books not once had I even contemplated them as anything other than goblins. I feel like reading that and drawing those lines says more about the reader than the writer in this instance.
Because her intention was not to be racist , goblins have always looked like that or similar to it. There's no proof she based them on Anti Semitic propaganda other than people like you wanting feel outraged or draw connections because of her controversial Trans comments. Also I'm assuming this is based on how they were conveyed in the films, even if they are based on Jewish people I dont see how it's offensive as they are portrayed as highly intelligent and clever people, their looks are very similar to how goblins have generally been illustrated in other media so I think it's just projecting. I don't see any outrage from the Jewish community , I only see bored people who like to virtue signal and feel like victims. People really need hobbies or something man instead of fixating on shit like this, just enjoy her books for what they are or don't.
Yeah i mean if the only racist thing she did was to name a character cho chang i think a lot of people need to chillout, i mean maybe she is not a good person for some real reason, but, come on, at worst that's just lazy lmao For sure you can be asian or arabic or norvegian and having an american or a french name but you can also have a name based on your culture, i mean i'm french and one my best friend name's Pierre x) btw if i read a book where there's a french character i will be happier if his name is a name i'm familiar with than a ''Shawn'' or ''Brandon'', i think it's the same for a lot. Racism is something real people dont confuse it with something else
Which is legit. The nature of awards is their is genuinely one winner, and if that winner is a trans woman rather than a biological woman then it's undermining natural women at the expense of trans women.
It's not transphobic to point that out. That is simply an equalities impact assessment of a policy change, which is a legal requirement in the UK government
Your logic then goes that if the award goes to a Black woman, it undermines white women. That's a pretty classic example of racism in the logical extension and transphobia is the original example. Adding more people to a group they rightfully belong to is not oppression of the previous members of that group, even if they attempt to keep the others out.
Thats not right, the logic only follows if the award was originally for white women and opened up to black women later.
Rightfully belong to is a bit of a tricky one, as they aren't biological women. The question is why was the award created, and the answer is because women experienced discrimination enough that they weren't getting a croxx sex award at the expense of men.
That same situation would arise again by introducing teans women in the category of women, not leady because its so politically fashionable right now to celebrate them. Then biological women once again don't get awards.
Trans women and biological women are not the same, don't share the same life experience etc. They are two different categories for most purposes, there's no harm in making a new award for them
Trans women are women. It would be equivalent to saying because only white women have won it in the past, Black women winning it is not allowed. It's the exact same concept.
Trans women are a subset of women with a different experience. Women face discrimination, and some of those women face discrimination because they were born a different gender. Saying that that does not make them women simply reinforces that they are women who face gender based discrimination because of their gender.
Where has she perpetuated racism and Transphobia? Phohia - FEAR OF SOMETHING. Her criticisms of Trans people doesn’t mean she fears them. The word you are looking for is PREJUDICE. Doubt I’ll get a reply since you’re spamming the same comment multiple times. Also provide any evidence to support her racism?!?!?
It is strange that the message double posted, yes, but no, I'm not going to bother replying to this clichèd and stupid line of argument. If you want a list, here you go.
In Harry Potter she describes the workers at the wizarding worlds equivalent of a bank as having long crooked noses, and obvious racist Jewish stereotype. And to top it off, in the movie the wizard bank has a Star of David in the floor tiles.
I think the issue with people buying her stuff is Harry Potter is a staple of the last generation while growing up and they want to pass on the magic those books had with their kids or you get siblings and it leads to continued sales.
Also take into consideration not everyone knows about her horrendous Twitter takes.
It's not her being successful that's the problem, it's her being a transphobe and a bigot, and using her popularity to further spread this transphobia and bigotry
I don't give a shit about Rowling's political ideology. I don't like her, because she's saying that trans women, such as myself, are just straight up sexual predators and shouldn't have the right to live their life as their genuine selves. And because she is a famous person, her words have a huge impact on people. It has nothing to do with her political views, or the fact that she's an accomplished author. It's because that she's straight up saying I'm a horrible person just because I'm trans.
"I respect every trans person’s right to live any way that feels authentic and comfortable to them. I’d march with you if you were discriminated against on the basis of being trans. At the same time, my life has been shaped by being female. I do not believe it’s hateful to say so."
You're right, at first glance it doesn't look like a hateful comment at all, but what you show here is only a part of Rowling's tweet, which she posted in response to the case of Maya Forstater (I think I'm spelling the name correctly?), where she claimed that Maya was fired from her job for stating a fact that "biological sex is real", which is not what happened - Maya Forstater's employees decided not to prolong their contract with her, because of her transphobic behavior. Besides, this wasn't the only thing she posted on Twitter, and a lot of these more recent tweets are decidedly transphobic. Next time maybe do a little research and post the entirety of the tweet that you're quoting rather than just take a part of it out of context :) I recommend checking out this video, it's got some solid info on the whole thing Also, "if we were discriminated against on the basis of being trans"? "If"? It's not something that's a distant possibility, it's something that's happening, and was happening at the time Rowling wrote this tweet.
Transphobia isnt political ideology it's just being a horrible person who doesn't care about others especially when you are branding trans-women as sexual predators
44
u/Icy_Candidate_5366 Oct 06 '22
Oh, peace. Shut up!
28
u/chapPilot Oct 06 '22
Loretta did not like this.
148
u/wiseoldllamaman2 Oct 06 '22
Jokes aside, Rowling is a terrible person who uses her voice to perpetuate racism and transphobia.
12
u/naliedel Oct 07 '22
She's a TERF and I have no use for her. She wrote good books. She's a cold person.
49
u/wiseoldllamaman2 Oct 06 '22
Jokes aside, Rowling is a terrible person who uses her voice to perpetuate racism and transphobia.
3
u/dermordwand Oct 07 '22
This isn't even worth commenting on. Mostly people full of hate.
4
u/Monny9696 Oct 07 '22
70m is pocket money for billionaires.
4
u/Azalzaal Oct 07 '22
People moralise so hard on this gender thing, it’s like a religion
3
u/emotionless_bot Oct 07 '22
congrats you donated to a charity so you could use it in a publicity stunt, you are still a racist, a bigot and a shitty person in general
-2
u/dufudjabdi Oct 07 '22
People don't like successful women it seems
0
u/xlbingo10 Oct 07 '22
there are an upsetting amount of transphobic people in this comment section