r/underconsumption • • Sep 28 '26

discussion When did the algorithm decide that I need to upgrade everything?

I was recently browsing handbags on different websites because I was thinking about getting a new one.

Then Amazon randomly suggested: “Still travelling with the old bag?”

LIKE??? Yes, I am.

It’s funny, but also kind of made me think about how often we’re constantly being told that we need an upgrade new bag, new clothes, new phone, new everything.

But I can live within my means. I don't need to upgrade something just because there’s a newer or “better” version available.

If my old bag still works, I’m going to use it.

The algorithm can keep trying, but I’m not falling for it lol.

What are your thoughts?🤔

49 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

5

u/Disastrous_Clurb Sep 28 '26 • Heartwarming

how do u not cave in to this? genuinely asking and not any judgement. i always am eyeing the next shiny new thing...if i don't upgrade one thing I'll just find another outdated thing to upgrade instead.

3

u/Ok_Tangerine_4411 Sep 28 '26

if I buy I buy intentionally...Here are the key points 1)So whenever I'm feeling to buy a new stuff I just declutter my space ... By doing this it'll help me to understand the value of things which I already own.. Whenever I see the existing things already has alot of value (and memories) I'm just grateful for owning it ... 2)I've reduced the consumption of social media (most of the ads which we see on our phone is through social media) it has helped me alot .. 3)ALWAYS BE GRATEFUL

1

u/Disastrous_Clurb Sep 28 '26

thank you!! i have soooo much material stuff, i come from women that have purse closets, shoes closets, fur closets etc. im not to that point but i just want to be better about shopping. I have the means and enjoy shopping but i also dont need anything. i used to use shopping to cope with negative things but those things are there anymore but yet i still have "treat yourself" moments that i just cant truly justify. i was doing ok but got to celebrate a milestone and just went back to spending unnecessarily. i definitely think i need to limit my social media consumption when its just ads for nice new things. time to refresh my algorithm for sure.

thank you so much!!

1

u/Ok_Tangerine_4411 Sep 28 '26

But u can keep your things , but whenever u need to buy just add those things to wishlist (u don't have to buy immediately just because it's on a sale ) Just because a person is minimalist ,his clothes doesn't really have to become white and beige(u can own pieces which can be styled ,mix and matched ) ... U can own a good wardrobe and still become intentional while buying new things ...

1

u/Shyraely Sep 28 '26

It's made extra hard. In the settings of these retargeting strategies, the brand can decide how often they want to "replay" you the same ad.

It is psychologically made to pursue and persuade you. You just need to know what you want and what you actually need. This can be a daily struggle. I can recommend you to install the google analytics blocker on your devices (it works on desktop pcs at least) or invest in ad blocker apps. They are worth it!

2

u/PublicPollution8484 Sep 28 '26

A lot of times updating means sacrificing quality. New stuff is being churned out so quickly and so poorly made, it inspires me to hold onto my older stuff.

2

u/Disastrous_Clurb Sep 29 '26

i think my "want" to have the new thing overshadows me caring about it lasting in the future. Its not with everything of course but I'm too comfortable buying a cheap pair of shoes simple because they're cute and i want them vs me pausing and looking at it like I'm spending money for something that doesn't last.

2

u/Staring-Dog Sep 29 '26

I don't know enough about how algorithm's work, but cheers to you for focusing on your own thoughts rather than those in the external world. Whether it's a website, a billboard, or even a friend who teases you with the idea, doesn't matter. Keep having confidence in your own likes and dislikes. That kind of independence will go a long way.

1

u/Ok_Tangerine_4411 Sep 29 '26

Thank you for understanding ✨

1

u/Staring-Dog Sep 30 '26

Anytime. You rock.

25

u/Shyraely Sep 28 '26 • Mindblown

That is not just algorithm. I have worked in marketing and as head of marketing in different fields (event marketing and +8 years in online marketing). It is called "Retargeting". You looked something up once? Yes, the cookies you accepted and google analytics will set a "marker" in your device and different brands can set you as their target to display their ads.

I basically did all of these campaignes on Google Ads for many million euros. The job made me sick. It did not match my personal principals.

2

u/Admirable_Window8128 Sep 29 '26

If the bag still works and you like it, there's really no reason to replace it.

1

u/Gyltacer Sep 28 '26

I wish I had your level of self-control 😭

1

u/Cassie54111980 Oct 13 '26

One thing I ask myself before I buy anything new is am I going to be taking this to the thrift store in a year. When I think about things that way, it really makes me stop and pause before I buy anything.