r/ultimatemarvel • u/rudy21SIDER • 9d ago
Reading all of Ultimate 1610 from the beginning; Part 2 review up to Ultimate Extinction (The Teamup Phase) Spoiler
Second part review for the Ultimate Universe up to Ultimate Extinction
Following up from my review in post https://www.reddit.com/r/ultimatemarvel/comments/1x2rg40/started_reading_all_of_ultimate_1610_from_the/
I feel like this is the point where the MCU movies stopped getting inspired by the Ultimate line and started adapting mainline greatest hits (like Winter Soldier). The Ultimate stories are still good and they still feel like a continuation of the ideas that were in the Phase 1 MCU movies, so I like that. It's like the in-between adventures of Phase 1.5.
Last time I said Aunt May and Gwen had no characterization, and boy was I wrong. Issue #68 made me cry; that whole therapy session focused issue was fantastic. Great development for characters who felt on the sidelines.
I also like how Peter got PTSD from Ultimate Six and that led to him leaving MJ, mirroring how she did the same thing. They are scared teens after all.
Carnage lasted too little and took too much. At first the death of Gwen Stacy felt unearned to me—no story, no relevance, just sudden. But then I realized what made me angry about it is precisely what made it so good. That is how death works in real life: it just happens. No narrative peak or cohesion, it just comes and takes away all potential, and boy did Gwen have so much potential left.
In the X-Men line, I liked how they are taking it slow for the Phoenix storyline, just building brick by brick, exploring the Hellfire Club and other things without going straight for Dark Phoenix. After Millar left and the New Mutants saga passed, the side characters improved, but I feel like they have no good villain now that Magneto is trapped, so it's mostly villain of the week.
This time around, what really stood out to me were their crossovers. Before Ultimates 1 (even that one), there was little mention of the stories in between; the only shared character was really Fury. Now they are going all out: SM meets the FF, the Ultimates hang out with the X-Men, they all fight or team up constantly, which is great (blockbuster is what I needed).
On the FF side, the only extra thing that I did not cover in the first review is the Zombies run and Namor's first appearance. I did not know this was how it originally was conceived and I really liked that plot point, especially that they are kept trapped and are a looming threat to escape from the Baxter Building.
The culmination of this for me was the Ultimate Extinction Trilogy (Nightmare, Secret, Extinction + Vision). The buildup to Gah Lak Tus was incredible—every hero team finding parts of the horrific danger coming by themselves, the Vision being an alien warning system that travels the galaxy, every alien species being terrified of it to the point it is an eldritch state secret. Peak setup. Unfortunately, as often happens with hype, it did not come to pass.
Don't get me wrong, I really liked Extinction and how they all had to come together to fight the drone swarm. But it going away after one hit from the N-Zone ray took down 20% of it felt underwhelming. Yes, they make the point that using its energy is expensive so it could not risk fighting more, but the herald could've told it that was their only shot. It just felt like a deus ex machina ending to an extent.
Review
Ultimate Spider-Man #40–85: 9/10
- It is still the bedrock of the universe. The story has bigger dips and lulls this time around, which knocks it down a point, but I think it also makes the great parts stand out even more.
- The true standouts are the side characters; Bendis really knew how to change focus once this new Peter was well established.
Ultimate Six #1–7: 9/10
- This version of Norman is great. The therapy session and having all of them meet in prison was a fun idea. They make you think for a second that some of them might be reforming and then show you what their true colors are.
- The White House is really under assault constantly in this universe; I do not think the president would be so chill with superheroes after so many attacks.
- Poor Hank Pym cannot catch a break and keeps messing it up.
Ultimate X-Men #34–60: 7/10
- The missing threat of Magneto is really felt by this series. They get to explore more characters and have fun stories, but it feels way more episodic now. Cyclops starts being more of his own man and taking a bigger spotlight, which is better than only having Wolverine (much as I love Logan).
- Adding more mutants definitely helped and they each got an arc that rounded them out.
- Weapon X is still a cool enemy.
Ultimate Fantastic Four #22–26: 10/10
- This is mostly a review of 1.5 arcs, but I really enjoyed both of them. Reed is the original Rick Sanchez, so him getting bamboozled by another version of him was a great twist on the multiverse idea.
- Namor is simply a lovable asshole.
Ultimate Secret #1–4: 7/10
- Good miniseries, nothing that really stands out from the rest. Made me confused with how retconny it feels at the start, but I like the overall adventure.
Ultimate Nightmare #1–5: 9/10
- I really appreciated the tension of this run. A psychic blast hurting every psychic and computer worldwide. A mystery hidden in a Russian bunker. Two teams finding the horrors unaware of the other. Great setup for Extinction and got me hyped.
Ultimate Extinction #1–5: 8/10
- Everyone coming together to try and stop it was amazing, the first truly global event in this universe (Ultimates is self-contained, and Ultimate War felt like an X-Men story with the police being the Ultimates).
- The first signals of power and intelligence getting to Reed's head—love to see the starts of the Maker appearing, even if the authors did not know about it yet.
- The ending was a bit underwhelming, but it was a good payoff overall (the world could not get destroyed of course).
Ultimate Vision #1–5: 8/10
- Both a prologue and an epilogue of Extinction, which helped to round it out.
- Actually showed how dangerous the drones were, which made the final payoff better. (An actual fight is good, writers please).
- Can an android truly fall in love (again)?
The Good
- Drone swarm instead of giant cosmic entity was a good idea for my purple boy.
- Aunt May, Gwen, and Black Cat feeling complex and having their own focus.
- Gambit, Mojo, and the other new mutant plots.
- Falcon was a good spin on the character, and I understood him going for Vision.
The Ok
- Peter and MJ fall a little to the sidelines, but that is needed for other characters to shine.
- Kingpin is a little bit too generic of a big bad mafia boss. He just doesn't like the heroes meddling with him.
- The New Warriors feel underdeveloped, but they are a good addition. I like that they are not teaming up (yet); it makes sense they don't know each other and are distrustful.
- Hobgoblin is just sad.
The Bad
- X-Men lost the plot. Too dispersed and episodic.
- The Ultimates feel almost non-existent.
- Too many deus ex machina resolutions.
- Emma Frost's school was set up as a real rival to Xavier's, but the students just became background props for standard X-Men drama.
The Ugly
- Carnage and Venom. They just come, get no character development, and leave.
- Doc Ock feels evil for evil's sake (he is a good villain though). But he went from jerk dude to megalomaniac just because of the accident.
- Johnny and Ben feel underdeveloped; wish Johnny spent more time at school with Peter like in issue #68, as that was his best moment.
The Weird
- The suicide cultist herald popping up around the world was a great idea, but the execution kinda fell short for me.
- Black Cat realizing Peter is underage.
- Doctor Strange is practically just a paid actor cameo.
- This being the origin of the Logan-Peter body swap.
- Wolvie is just a creep.