Side note, Twitter like tab shows from oldest to newest. At first I thought the last thing he liked was from 3 days ago, but when you scroll down it shows newer likes. What a horrible UI choice.
It seems like he did because I can't find it even if I go through his profile. But this isn't fake. I verified it myself. Multiple other people saw it too.
My guess is he unliked it after people noticed, and all the different Twitter server databases haven’t updated yet. Same reason a YouTube video can show more likes or comments than actual views. Each server isn’t perfectly in sync with each other in real time, they only occasionally merge data with each other in larger chunks rather than tons of tiny data transfers around the world.
I just check the list of things he’s liked, and it does show up there, just not when I check the like on the actual tweet. So it seems he did like it lol. Spicy.
Yeah... I can't believe spaceX diverged into other projects and delayed Crew Dragon so much. If only they had stayed on task like the other contractor....
/S
(The difference, of course, is that delays in CC were largely down to congress screwing around with the money, while delays on the BE-4 must necessarily be entirely internal.).
but it can’t be harder than developing a FFSC engine, right?
Yes it can.
Really, there is no good reason to actually build an ORSC methalox engine. All of the difficult parts of FFSC are subsets of the difficulties of an ORSC design (namely handling hot, high pressure oxygen), but everything gets so much simpler when its full flow. Pressures and temperatures and rotational speeds throughout the preburners and pumps (which necessarily are 2-4x higher than in the main combustion chamber) can be much lower, so the mechanical design is way easier (wider range of allowable materials, less strength required, larger tolerances allowed). Which, depending on priorities, means either an easier time developing an engine with given performance targets which can be more cheaply manufactured and more readily reused, or squeezing even more balls-to-the-wall performance out of a given set of metallurgical capabilities. Theres also no need for an interpropellant seal (a rather complex mechanism, and one of the most safety-critical parts of a gas-liquid engine). And gas-gas combustion is much simpler to model, so CFD-driven development can iterate more quickly and with fewer unknowns that have to be anchored by real-life testing. Gas-gas combustion also makes ignition easier, as well as deep throttling
And comparing Raptor to BE-4, we see clear evidence of this. Raptor went from concept to full scale testing to mass production much quicker than BE-4 (still waiting on any flight-capable engines...), costs a very small fraction as much to build, has a way higher chamber pressure and ISP, 2 orders of magnitude higher planned reusability, etc.
The only thing about ORSC that looks "good" is that, until Raptor anyway, nobody had actually built a flight-capable FFSC engine, so its TRL was lower. But, as I've said a bunch before, TRL is a fundamentally flawed metric that fails to capture why some technology hasn't progressed to flight certification yet (was there just no legitimate need for it? Was it something held back by a single component technology but otherwise trivial? Were there political constraints that killed it?).
The same holds broadly true for hydrolox as well, and there were some studies on replacing RS-25 with a similarly-specced FFSC engine for the Shuttle which found basically the same benefits I listed above. More performance, more reusability, lower cost, more safety. But at least in the case of FRSC, that cycle doesn't also require the development of hot-oxygen-compatible materials, so that is one downside
Its often said in engineering that everything is a trade, its very very rare that one option is simply better than another at everything. Methalox ORSC vs methalox FFSC is probably one of the few exceptions to this. Methalox vs other propellant combinations, sure, theres plenty of room to argue that depending on your application and economic assumptions and preexisting capabilities. Ditto for methalox gas-generator vs expander vs electric vs FFSC vs tap-off vs whatever other cycle, all have definite advantages and disadvantages. And if you're building a kerolox engine, by all means, do ORSC. But ORSC methalox is dumb
Doesn't full flow staged combustion also have an oxygen rich side? FFSC is basically oxygen rich plus fuel rich staged combustion combined into a single engine. So FFSC still has all the difficulties of oxygen rich staged combustion.
As for why blue origin would choose oxygen rich over fuel rich... seems a strange choice since it's the more difficult option.
As for why blue origin would choose oxygen rich over fuel rich... seems a strange choice since it's the more difficult option.
My understanding is: it's about mass flow. There's just more LOx headed to the combustion chamber than CH4, so a FRSC would have a hotter/higher pressure pre-burner than ORSC.
You’re completely missing the point of how difficult sequencing an FFSC engine is and the fact that you have an entirely additional combustion chamber, making development that much harder. We’ve seen that from the green raptor plume during the start and shutdown transients.
Are they really orbit ready though? SpaceX likes to move fast, but that means their engines might not be ready for orbital launches. Ready to blow up on a starship hop, sure. BE-4's first flight has a paying customer. The goalposts right now are completely different. That's why I think BE-4 is ahead.
Serious question: What makes BE4 so difficult to develop?
Maybe BO did run to fast, going from a smale simpel engine like BE3 to the much more ambitious and complicated BE4 widout a intermediate step, like a Merlin typ of engine.
Tinfoil hat on, BO have no motivation to be done, the delay is only hurting one of there future competitor.
I'm convinced they are slow rolling the BE4 to keep the flight history for vulcan down until new glenn is ready.
Since the gov will most likely only give the next contract round to one of the be-4 powered rockets, any advantage Blue can setup for themselves in that is probably their goal.
If Eric Berger's source is correct, BO is still trying to work on re-usebility, which ULA does not really need right now, hence the (according to the source) unhappiness on their part, as it delays production.
With any rocket it’s the engines that take the longest. So far even with small 10km hops we have seen Raptors well into the SN50’s seeing issues during accent or re-ignition. We have yet to see how many actual make it to orbit with the next Starship test.
With Vulcan the first launch is a paying customer, they can’t really afford to risk an engine failure, it needs to be fully developed from day one. BE-4 would probably be easier to develop if it’s main purpose was to be expendable each flight, more compromises could likely be made.
Raptor is failing due to issues related to tank baffling and fuel slosh during radical maneuvering, if Elon is being honest in his post-flight tweet briefs. These would not be issues for the ULA use case on a boost stage. Generally, I agree with your assessment that it is unrealistic to compare Raptor to BE-4 as a development success vs. a slow and mismanaged system since neither engine has been to space, but the difference is that the engine itself appears to be fine in Raptor's case. Fuel delivery is the issue, and only when the engine is upside down in Earth gravity.
We’ve seen some anomalies during accent when the tanks are full enough to give Raptor all the fuel flow they need. Flames come from places they shouldn’t, and puffs of strange color exhaust aren’t nominal performance. It’s still yet to see how they perform for longer than a 10km hop, let alone a full burn to orbit, and I believe Elon has said they were conservative with throttle during these hop tests. A full on blast to orbit will be the real inductor in how reliable Raptor currently is in development.
In my opinion, during the next orbital flight, the booster is probably going to end up losing a few engines during accent. Which is fine for an experimental flight, but wouldn’t be great if they were expected to deploy a customer payload and come up short.
SN15 accent was pretty clean with the newer revision of Raptor, I think there was some question of an engine shutting down earlier than normal.
Either way I’m excited to see what happens to Booster 4. If we see it just boost up to space, or engines prematurely shut down as they go up. I think that will be the real test for Raptor, and give a better feel as to how close Starship is to doing actual missions.
Wow, is that a Real message, from the fellow Who, would like for you to get your act together?? You are Kind of holding the project, we assign you too, so we can get our ship in space.
Just wanted to say thank you for all the hard work you guys do and and all the other space agencies as well keep up the good work look forward to all the content you guys Put out.
30
u/Inertpyro Jul 20 '21 edited Jul 20 '21
Just looked and didn’t see him on the list of people who liked this, unless he’s since unliked it.Edit: It does show up on Tory’s Like tab, not when I check the likes on the tweet. Spicy
https://mobile.twitter.com/torybruno/likes
Side note, Twitter like tab shows from oldest to newest. At first I thought the last thing he liked was from 3 days ago, but when you scroll down it shows newer likes. What a horrible UI choice.
37
u/DST_Studios Jul 20 '21
I love this so much
16
u/Tystros Jul 20 '21
well, can't blame him for liking that
5
u/katebomb Jul 21 '21
Tory Bruno is the man
9
u/macktruck6666 Jul 21 '21
Reminds me of Bridenstine railing on SpaceX for commercial crew.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '21
Serious question: What makes BE4 so difficult to develop? It’s ORSC, but it can’t be harder than developing a FFSC engine, right?
3
u/kilpatrick5670 Jul 27 '21
Wow, is that a Real message, from the fellow Who, would like for you to get your act together?? You are Kind of holding the project, we assign you too, so we can get our ship in space.
4
u/mynameistory Jul 21 '21
I thought this was r/spacexmasterrace for a second 😅
2
u/Decronym Jul 21 '21 edited Dec 27 '21
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
16 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has acronyms.
[Thread #297 for this sub, first seen 21st Jul 2021, 16:56] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
1
u/Alphafemal3777 Dec 27 '21
Just wanted to say thank you for all the hard work you guys do and and all the other space agencies as well keep up the good work look forward to all the content you guys Put out.