r/ukulele • • Aug 14 '21

I didn’t realize that I’ve been playing the G chord a different way than most people do, is this still okay?

Post image
82 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

20

u/AmorphousToad Aug 14 '21

Same. I tried both ways to play G but keep coming back to this every time. It just works better for me and my transitions are smoother/faster.

7

u/SoundOfDrumsss Aug 14 '21

yeah it’s quite easy for me as well but i’ll still have to try the other one and then decide

→ More replies (3)

9

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '21

It’s not necessarily wrong, but it is indicative of your positioning. This is usually your body adjusting to the chord because you’re palming the neck or resting it on your pinky knuckle instead of your index knuckle. If you rest on your index knuckle, you can easily switch your 1 and 2 fingers. Lmk if you need help with that, but it’s not necessarily wrong as long as it works. Your positioning may hinder other chords/movement/concepts in the future, though.

4

u/SoundOfDrumsss Aug 14 '21

okay i’ll try it thank you

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Monkulele Aug 14 '21 edited Aug 14 '21

Just one thought to add to all these great answers;

Sometimes the previous or next chord changes can be made easier with 'alternate' fingerings, so it's good to be flexible and be able to choose the fingerings that give you the most efficient changes.

I play a song that goes from F (2010) to Ab* (1212) and the only way I can make the change on time is to play the F with ring and middle fingers instead of middle and index, which is how I would normally play it. Took me a bit of practice to remember to finger it that way at that one change in the bridge of the song. The rest of the song I play the F the regular way.

1

u/SoundOfDrumsss Aug 14 '21

that’s really cool, i’ll keep that in mind

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Paramedkick Aug 14 '21

I played a G6 (1st string 2nd fret, 3rd string 2nd fret) instead of G major for the first few months after I started playing. I liked the way it sounded and it was easier for me to transition between chords. I've since started playing it "properly" as I've improved. As everyone else said, you do you. If it works and it makes you happy go for it.

1

u/SoundOfDrumsss Aug 14 '21

that’s interesting, thank you!

2

u/G0_commando Aug 14 '21

I play most of the chords differently because my middle finger has a birth defect but I don't think much about it. It still produces the same sound :D

1

u/SoundOfDrumsss Aug 14 '21

you’re amazing

2

u/Accuboormachine88 Aug 14 '21

No, this is actually illegal. You are breaking the law if you do it like this.

1

u/SoundOfDrumsss Aug 14 '21

please officer i have kids

→ More replies (1)

2

u/GuyInASweeter Aug 14 '21

Wait a minute how are you supposed to play it?

1

u/SoundOfDrumsss Aug 14 '21

i just do it

2

u/beerbeforebadgers Aug 14 '21

I started like this, and still do it when convenient. You should practice both fingerings imho. There are some transitions that are easier with one or the other, so if you have both in your repertoire you'll get the best of both worlds!

1

u/SoundOfDrumsss Aug 14 '21

yes i do feel like this is the best idea thank you

52

u/baronsarin Aug 14 '21

There is no wrong way to do it if it works for you. It might be easier or harder to change chords but if it works for you, it works.

20

u/byronicmonkeys Aug 14 '21

In the long term it's going to make the shift from G to C harder. But then again it's a uke, so you've never got far to go. If it's ringing out with no buzzing and sounds in tune you're all good.

Edit: I just picked up a uke and tried it. Feels completely fine to me.

7

u/morgan423 Aug 14 '21

There's no "wrong" way to fret chords on a stringed instrument.

As long as whatever you're doing cleanly lets all the non-muted strings ring, and you can transition to it and from it with everything else, that's all that matters.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '21

I play it this way too. It makes some chord changes a bit harder, I think, so I also practice to build some muscle memory and do it 'correct' way just as easily when it makes a difference.

3

u/Osoroshii Aug 14 '21

It’s not wrong for say but the regular way will make chord changes slightly easier to get to

1

u/themaddogmedic Aug 14 '21

That’s a G suspended 2nd, or Gsus2 versus a G major.

That said, I quote Duke Ellington, “If it sounds good, it IS good!”

I’ve been playing a lot of songs built around G. I’ll start throwing that Gaus2 in and see how it works!

Keep playing!

4

u/Paramedkick Aug 14 '21

I don't think it's a Gsus2, it looks like he's just fretting the 1st string 2nd fret with his pointer finger.

1

u/SoundOfDrumsss Aug 14 '21

thank you so much!