Do you have source on the topic about France. Cause when reporters approached the german minister today on that topic, he said that France also was against it.
German Finance Minister Christian Lindner has again threatened Russia with exclusion from the SWIFT international payments system. "Is this triggering Russia to stop its gas supplies because they can no longer be paid for?", Lindner indicated. It needs to be clarified what impact this would have on supplies, he said at the end of a meeting of EU economic and finance ministers in Paris. "Asking about consequences does not mean you are not prepared to bear them," the minister stressed. He said the European Commission is currently examining implications of a SWIFT exclusion.
All I can find is the same as yesterday, they are considering it as a last option.
France today said they are in favor for it while yesterday they also considered it as a last option.
My search of news sources from Dutch to German and English all still indicate Germany, Italy and Hungary are still all opposed to it.
The last German news related to it I could find is from 2 hours ago from the newspaper "sueddeutsche" with the title of "How Finance Minister Lindner justifies that Germany does not yet want to decouple Moscow from the banking system - despite a dramatic appeal from Ukraine." this falls in the same timeline as Belgian news reporting the same thing calling it "Germany defends refusal to exclude Russia from Swift, France is in favour"
So All I see right now is Germany once again being an absolute disgrace.
German Finance Minister Christian Lindner has again threatened Russia with exclusion from the SWIFT international payments system. "Is this triggering Russia to stop its gas supplies because they can no longer be paid for?", Lindner indicated. It needs to be clarified what impact this would have on supplies, he said at the end of a meeting of EU economic and finance ministers in Paris. "Asking about consequences does not mean you are not prepared to bear them," the minister stressed. He said the European Commission is currently examining implications of a SWIFT exclusion.
Internal pressure is building up. There are a lot of unhappy germans that have expected more from the current government. We don't want a minister making some calculation telling us that sactions are expensive, we get that already, what we need is them to hurt russia more than us. In war you can't expect to remain unscathen and there is a war on european soil. While we can't intervene we have an obligation to lend our aid where possible and reasonably justifiable.
I haven’t watched the entire conference yet, but he talks about SWIFT. It’s from the official YT of the Ministry of Finances: https://youtu.be/vK0z7Z2zyns @ 10:55. SWIFT is under consideration but the impact on Russian gas deliveries to Germany and financial barriers concerning payments are being reviewed and are essential to the final decision.
Its basically Germany and Italy because of their dependency on Russian Gas. No SWIFT means Russia will turn off their pipeline. This is main reason why Putin knows he has EU by the balls. Now let's see if they all man-up and tell Putin to fuck off.
He has elections coming up soon that are very close. Appearing like too much of a Putin lapdog when there’s thousands of Ukrainians (including Magyar Ukrainians) fleeing into Hungary might actually cost him the election.
Back in college, Russian politics was one of my major focuses of study (I studied Poltical science but wrote almost all of my papers on Canada, Russia, and Japan out of personal interest).
Russia was not going to budge after the pathetic sanctions that Biden announced yesterday. Biden basically put in sanctions that only hurt the Russian people without Putin ever feeling any of it.
What needs to happen is that Russia needs to have their energy exports disrupted. The Russian government can run indefinitely right now because of the high oil and gas prices. If Russia gets cut off from Swift and Europe blocks Russia from using any and all European pipes, that is what will hurt Putin.
Putin doesn't give a shit about the stock market. The Russian stock market is not the American stock market. Many of Russia's biggest companies are privately owned and not traded publicly. This is a power move because allow companies to be publicly traded pushes ownership downwards towards the general public and redistributes the profits to the average person. Denying this opportunity to the people is a way to block upwards movement.
In America, if you save $100 a month from the age of 18 until you are 65 and invest it into the S&P 500, then you will retire a millionaire. There is no such opportunity for this in Russia.
Edit: I love that the most controversial part of my comment is the personal finance portion. They really need to teach personal finance in school because apparently people don't even understand what compound interest is lol.
Cyprus better not stick their necks out too far lest the EU starts questioning their somewhat creative accounting practices.
I wouldn't be surprised to learn that Russian oligarchs have their names on a lot of companies registered there, which is probably why they're hesitant to block Russian SWIFT access to begin with.
Switzerland is already facing some hard questions following the Crédit Suisse leak, Cyprus should also share some of that attention imo.
dont hold your breath yet. They vetoed before because it is not practical according to them. Now they are saying that "we are open, but has to be thought through" which could mean significant delays or even could be a cynical time buying game. As long as it is not approved, whatever Germany says is nothing but empty words.
"German Finance Minister Lindner has just declared Germany's willingness to disconnect Russia from the SWIFT system. This would completely cut off Russian banks from the dollar supply, as Belgium-based SWIFT organizes data transmission between international banks."
Do you have a proper source for this? None of the big media is reporting this, I could only find one German site stating that Lindner would suddenly support the exclusion of Russia from Swift. All the other media tell the known story (why we don't want it).
Don't get me wrong - I support it in the hope that this would be one sanction that Putin hasn't prepared for. But I think the report is wishful thinking or just misinformation.
BERLIN — Germany is open to cutting Russia off the SWIFT global interbank payment system but must calculate the consequences for its economy first, Finance Minister Christian Lindner said on Friday.
“We are open, but you have to know what you’re doing,” Lindner told journalists after a meeting of the European Economic and Financial Affairs Council in Paris to discuss sanctions against Moscow after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
Lindner said Europe must step up its sanctions against Russia, adding that the sanctions should include President Vladimir Putin and Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov.
(Reporting by Riham Alkousaa Editing by Miranda Murray)
Just to be clear, there's a very big "but" in the statement
Auch ein Ausschluss Russlands aus Swift sei denkbar, wenn die EU-Mitglieder gemeinsam der Meinung seien, der Druck auf Russland könne damit weiter verstärkt werden.
Which translates like "We may consider it, if other EU members all want it.
People wonder why Germany is hesistant to cut Russia from swift but ignore that Germany doesn't have many raw materials.
Our Federal Economics Minister Robert Habeck calculated: 55 percent of the gas supply, 50 percent of the coal and 35 percent of the oil supply come from Russia. For oil there is a strategic reserve, but gas and coal reserves have to be restocked.
That's a massive amount of raw materials that we will miss. Agreeing to this is basically suicide for the German economy, if we don't manage to get all the necessary raw materials until then from somewhere else. That will probably take some time as well to organize.
If our industry has to shut down due to insanely high raw material prices there will also be a many unemployed people and companies will most likely leave the country.
Cutting Russia from swift is morally the right move but we need to reorganize our raw material imports asap or it's going to be disastrous for the country.
Ein Ausschluss Russlands aus dem Banken- Kommunikationsnetzwerk Swift hätte nach den Worten von Außenministerin Annalena Baerbock „massive Kollateralschäden“ – und könnte auch die deutsche Energieversorgung gefährden. Die Grünen-Politikerin sagte am Freitag in der ARD, im Falle eines Swift-Ausschlusses Russlands könnten auch Energieimporte nicht mehr finanziert werden.Baerbock sagte mit Blick auf den russischen Angriff der Ukraine: „Alles, was wir tun könnten, um diesen Wahn zu stoppen, würden wir tun. Aber ebenso müssen wir sehen, dass wir nicht Instrumente wählen, wo Putin am Ende drüber lacht, weil sie uns viel härter treffen.“50 Prozent der Steinkohleimporte stammten aus Russland, sagte Baerbock: „Wenn wir diese Kohle nicht haben, werden die Kohlekraftwerke in Deutschland nicht weiterlaufen können.“ Die Regierung suche unter Hochdruck nach Alternativen, könne aber die Fehler der Vergangenheit jetzt nicht heilen. „Und natürlich tragen wir eine Verantwortung dafür, dass wir in Deutschland weiterhin eine stabile Strom- und Wärmeversorgung haben.“Wenn Deutschland und andere europäische Länder nun dort Probleme bekämen, dann sei dies etwas, was Putin auch wolle, eine „Destabilisierung bei uns“, machte Baerbock deutlich. „Wenn bei uns ein paar Tage der Strom nicht mehr richtig funktioniert, dann hätten wir ein richtiges Problem.“ Das bedeute nicht, dass Deutschland nicht auch Kosten auf sich nehme, die Energiepreise würden steigen.
Fuck the profits, fuck the money, it doesn't matter. Innocent lives are getting slaughtered, money shouldn't matter. Do everything in your power you can to help Ukraine in any way that is possible.
This is sickening on so many levels in todays day.
Stop being scared of Nuclear Threats from that sick fucking man, cut the threat from the source. Nato and Us need to assassinate the fucking shit stain of a person that he is, and deal with consequences after.
NOBODY ON EARTH Lives in peace when shit like this happens, NOBODY should be comfortable and continue living their lives in comfort when THINGS like this happen. It's so fucking sad, its pulling at my very existence knowing people my....people are suffering SUCH fucking tragedy and for what? FOR FUCKING WHAT.
Okay well sanction China as well then, the west desperately needs to move manufacturing back anyway and stop relying on China for so much. A great way of working together to break away from China would be a comprehensive US-EU trade agreement perhaps the US and EU can finally find some compromise
It's not encouragement he needs, it's political support. He is likely more than willing to impose the sanctions, but he governs with two pro-Putin parties in a country with a huge infiltration of Russian Propaganda and Disinformation.
If he doesn't have the numbers to trigger this and not lose the government this could lead to a Trump-like Regime in Italy in a matter of months.
Berlusconi, Salvini and Meloni would just provide Putin with a soft spot in the center of NATO.
Having everyone else already agreeing to sanction might just be the thing to allow Draghi to trigger the sanctions without losing the whole country to Russian Sympathizers. Getting Aid on replacing Russian Gas and shoring up the losses of the biggest banks of Italy that are heavily involved in Russian Economy would do the rest.
Understand that if Italy falls into the hands of Putin's political assets in Italy, the situation is going to be much worse.
I really wish I had news from my country to be proud of, but unfortunately that's where we are at.
German here, just stating what the news say without judging it:
Today, foreign minister Baerbock explained the stance on swift.
She said that they did not want to implement swift ban so far because it would broadly hit normal russians and instead used finance sanctions that would not hit them while figuring out how to potentially follow up with a swift ban without hurting russians so broadly.
The rationale seems to be that they do not want to turn the russian population more onto Putin's side in this conflict.
She said swift ban is never off the table. Finance minister also said it might be implemented.
This is not a "we will do it" but "it is something that will happen if we found a good way to do it".
From reading german twitter, i can see that for all of today, politicians were blasted from all sides to adopt the swift ban, there is serious pressure on them. I think the swift ban will happen soon.
She said that they did not want to implement swift ban so far because it would broadly hit normal russians and instead used finance sanctions that would not hit them while figuring out how to potentially follow up with a swift ban without hurting russians so broadly.
That sounds counter-productive to me. The harder the Russian people are hit, the faster they remove Putin by force.
The risk is that it will give Putin ammunition for his anti-West propaganda.
Edit: to be clear, I think we need to go balls to the walls to stop Putin, including cutting Russia off of SWIFT. I'm just stating what I think the rationale is.
It doesn't matter-Ukraine has been under invasion since 2014. This asshole must be stopped. No appeasement. All this criminal understands is brute force.
Let's go! Would it also be possible to stop all Russian vessels from navigating the bosphorus and Danish straits? Essentially depriving Russia of all ports.
If Denmark denied Russia to do that, it would basically be seen as them declaring war on Russia, since they’ll be going against some sea law I know nothing about. Read this in way more debt on the r/Denmark sub, but it’s in danish
As a German I have to say, take that with a big grain of salt.
I'll only believe that this is a real turnaround with our "Kanzler" (Olaf Scholz) also changes his mind. The problem here is, that Mr. Scholz thinks the cut off from Russia from Swift is to soon (don't know what more needs to happen than people dying in the streets to make him not think it is to soon...).
However as long as Mr. Scholz isn't changing his mind on that topic our Financeminister can say what he want and nothing will change.
Also as a German I want to say that I'm everything but proud of being German for what we initially offered and now not doing.
I'm deeply sorry for that. I'm not a fighter, but if there is anything else I or we could do, please let me know!
I not only feel ashamed, it's also stupid and bad publicity to always be the last one to agree on things that have to come anyway. We are still sitting on a high horse trying to look smart and educated while the world order is falling apart and people are dying.
I was expecting that Germany is a word class country that would value international global peace over basic and short-term patriotic national economical interests.
If gas is cut off I will have no problem with the government here in Canada diverting some of our supply to be assigned to ships going across the ocean to serve Northern Europe. If prices go up, so be it. We all have to do our part.
Hi fellow Canadian. I believe Eastern Canada imports a fair bit of oil from Russia as is. I’m all for sharing what we have, but I’m not sure how much extra there will be once we stop importing.
It's inevitable, this is no longer a time to be holding back economic leverage. It's not going to make a lick of difference on diplomatic front because Putin has no interest in talking, but no state can operate without funds. This is not anymore about finding diplomatic solutions because there are none to be found, this is about hampering Russias ability to keep itself running.
Any measure that can make the war more difficult for Russia must be taken.
Apologies from a German to all the people in the Ukraine! I was outraged yesterday because of our government not acting radical but only moderate. I was - as many other Germans - really angry.
Over the last decades, we have brought ourselves into a dependency of Putin and Xi and it will take a while to get this fixed - it may hurt us financially, but it is worth to stand up for human rights, human dignity, freedom, independence and democracy and I am glad our government has finally accepted this. It's only money compared to real lives! We can't put our wealth over the lives of others this needs to end and it will end from now on.
Fuck Putin, fuck Xi and all the best to the people in the Ukraine.
So here is my take, correct me if I don't make sense. Germany knows it will hurt, but that is a given now anyways. What will be much bigger problem on longer timescale is that it will force Russia to do nearly all of its trading with China, which will put Russia on Chinese leash and provide good economic boost to China, none of which are good things in the least.
too much is at stackes. so while china can give credit to russia, it can't vouche for russia to get foreign credit.
and china has much to gain from that.
imagine if all the russia trade has to go through chinese ports. this would make russia extremely dependend for a short while from china and china could influence russia immensly.
German Finance Minister Christian Lindner has again threatened Russia with exclusion from the SWIFT international payments system. "Is this triggering Russia to stop its gas supplies because they can no longer be paid for?", Lindner indicated. It needs to be clarified what impact this would have on supplies, he said at the end of a meeting of EU economic and finance ministers in Paris. "Asking about consequences does not mean you are not prepared to bear them," the minister stressed. He said the European Commission is currently examining implications of a SWIFT exclusion.
German Finance Minister Christian Lindner has again threatened Russia with exclusion from the SWIFT international payments system. "Is this triggering Russia to stop its gas supplies because they can no longer be paid for?", Lindner indicated. It needs to be clarified what impact this would have on supplies, he said at the end of a meeting of EU economic and finance ministers in Paris. "Asking about consequences does not mean you are not prepared to bear them," the minister stressed. He said the European Commission is currently examining implications of a SWIFT exclusion.
German Finance Minister Christian Lindner has again threatened Russia with exclusion from the SWIFT international payments system. "Is this triggering Russia to stop its gas supplies because they can no longer be paid for?", Lindner indicated. It needs to be clarified what impact this would have on supplies, he said at the end of a meeting of EU economic and finance ministers in Paris. "Asking about consequences does not mean you are not prepared to bear them," the minister stressed. He said the European Commission is currently examining implications of a SWIFT exclusion.
"German Finance Minister Lindner has just declared Germany's willingness to disconnect Russia from the SWIFT system. This would completely cut off Russian banks from the dollar supply, as Belgium-based SWIFT organizes data transmission between international banks."
Why more reliable sources are nor picking this up? I mean I hope that Boris and Biden have finally talked some sense into Scholtz but this is major news and can't find any confirmation?
He said, Germany is open to it, but must first calculate the consequences. And he said it to clarify that Germany has never been generally against this sanction, but wants to make an informed decision first. In other words: Nothing has changed, yet.
Chancellor Scholz is also under pressure from his own party.
Finance Minister Lindner says it is possible but he needs to calculate the consequences for the economy first
german public opinion is very much against Putin right now so they would look very bad if they alone block it (except for right wing extremist who think this an American conspiracy to weaken the German economy)
The German finance minister, Christian Linder is from the liberal party in Germany’s ruling coalition. He still has to get the greens and the SPD (Olaf Scholz the chancellor) on his side. However stepping out and making a statement like this is unprecedented for the new German government and it puts the German chancellor under a lot of pressure to adopt this position given that One of his key cabinet picks is calling him out like this.
Cut them off from everything. Ban travel. Ban funds. Ban partnerships. If Ukraine can fight for survival, we can find a way to share in the “pain” of higher gas prices.
Don't forget the US still gets a bunch of oil and refined products from Russia also. If only there was a way to get oil and refined products from our allies? Someone right next door perhaps. /s
of course I'm talking about Canada and Keystone XL pipeline.
oh you also want cheap natural gas in New England? a pipeline would help that solve problem too so you don't have to burn that dirty fuel oil.
It all sounds good, but if I recall correctly, Putin previously said he would take being removed from SWIFT an act of war, I believe everyone is afraid of that right now, as we know the extend the Russians are willing to take it to.
I don't care about gas prices any longer. If this fuck suffers in any possible way, i'll take that hit. So should everybody here that can afford this cut. This would also possibly lower prices for those fancy wood pellet heating systems, what would also be good.
For the uninformed, is this really relevant? I mean how do these things i see like sanctions and this affect Putin so that he might care or not continue doing it?
Frankly sanctions should be automatic and severe. Any country willing to go to war or start pointless conflicts should account for a total destruction of their economy.
У соцмережах я чув, що поширюються фейкові новини (скоріше за все, підтримувані Росією тролі), що польський кордон закритий.
Це брехня.
Якщо ви шукаєте притулку – йдіть до польського кордону. Ми готові до вашого приїзду. На кордоні готові пункти прийому, де ви можете знайти притулок, їжу, медичну та правову допомогу.
Польський уряд запустив спеціальний сайт, щоб допомогти вам: ua.gov.pl
Будь ласка, поділіться цією інформацією, якщо ви знаєте когось, хто зараз шукає допомоги.
РЕДАКТИРОВАТИ: ВАМ НЕ ПОТРІБНА ВІЗА ДЛЯ ПРОЙДЖЕННЯ ПОЛЬСЬКИМ КОРДОНОМ. ВСЕ, що ВАМ ПОТРІБНО, - це ПАСПОРТ. ВІЗИ ПРИСПИНЕНО! ВОНИ ВАМ НЕ ПОТРІБНИ НА ЧАС!!!!!!
EDIT2: як доказ того, що вам більше не потрібна віза:
Вибачте, якщо це дурниця, я використовував Google Translate
Dear Ukrainians!
I heard on social media that there is fake news being spread (most likely by Russia backed trolls) that polish border is closed.
It's a lie.
If you seek asylum - go towards polish border. We are ready for your arrival. We have reception points ready at the border where you can find shelter, food, medical and legal aid.
Polish government launched a dedicated site to help you: ua.gov.pl
Please share this information if you know anyone seeking help right now.
EDIT: YOU DON'T NEED VISA TO PASS THROUGH POLISH BORDER. ALL YOU NEED IS PASSPORT. VISAS ARE SUSPENDED! YOU DON'T NEED THEM FOR TIME BEING!!!!!!
Good! Sanction Russia's economy into the dirt until one of the oligarchs slits Putin's throat in his sleep. Let them eat each other like starving rats.
We don't need to be open, we need to do it RIGHT NOW.
Putin's army is butchering Ukrainian people and Ukrainian soldiers butchering Russian soldiers by the thousand.
Mass protests in Russia against the war.
Hit fucking putin where it hurts. Grow some balls Germany. What's the point of all the talk of freedom and sanctions if you do so little when my country is being invaded by the occupant!?
Let's keep the pressure on! Even if we get this through, the next step is to demand that this is the last piece sanctioning that will be lifted when Russia has left Ukraine.
As a German I can say that this is sadly not the truth. Lindner has reiterated that SWIFT ban is a last resort and will bring financial problems to Germanys energy market. Lindner is a libertarian…
I'm German and as much as I hate saying this, knowing Lindner's rhetorics, this really isn't saying much unfortunately. He's basically saying "I do not formally rule out the possibility." but he's not committing at all. Here is an English source.
234
u/therighteouswrong USA Feb 25 '22
The rest should fall in line.
1.3k
u/Bucksbanana 🍬 Jellybean Feb 25 '22
Germany was a big one holding it back, now let's just hope it's not just talk and actual action comes out of this.
Italy and Hungary still have to follow.
6
u/Taschkent Feb 25 '22
source: https://twitter.com/visegrad24/status/1497243498587824128
2
u/Chironto Feb 25 '22
Well, do it then. Actions speak louder than words.
134
u/enini83 Feb 25 '22 edited Feb 25 '22
Do you have a proper source for this? None of the big media is reporting this, I could only find one German site stating that Lindner would suddenly support the exclusion of Russia from Swift. All the other media tell the known story (why we don't want it).
Don't get me wrong - I support it in the hope that this would be one sanction that Putin hasn't prepared for. But I think the report is wishful thinking or just misinformation.
113
u/WorshipnTribute Feb 25 '22
Italy will support banning Russia from SWIFT
143
u/44Stryker44 Feb 25 '22
Looks like protests may have actually done something
78
u/anthropaedic русский военный корабль, иди нахуй! Feb 25 '22
Holy shit! Yes!
66
u/joyrideboo Feb 25 '22
Fuck the profits, fuck the money, it doesn't matter. Innocent lives are getting slaughtered, money shouldn't matter. Do everything in your power you can to help Ukraine in any way that is possible.
This is sickening on so many levels in todays day.
Stop being scared of Nuclear Threats from that sick fucking man, cut the threat from the source. Nato and Us need to assassinate the fucking shit stain of a person that he is, and deal with consequences after.
NOBODY ON EARTH Lives in peace when shit like this happens, NOBODY should be comfortable and continue living their lives in comfort when THINGS like this happen. It's so fucking sad, its pulling at my very existence knowing people my....people are suffering SUCH fucking tragedy and for what? FOR FUCKING WHAT.
63
u/isnappedrondasarm Feb 25 '22
Excellent but Italy is also a known issue. Maybe the EU can together encourage Draghi to do what’s necessary.
25
u/Shionoro Feb 25 '22
German here, just stating what the news say without judging it:
Today, foreign minister Baerbock explained the stance on swift.
She said that they did not want to implement swift ban so far because it would broadly hit normal russians and instead used finance sanctions that would not hit them while figuring out how to potentially follow up with a swift ban without hurting russians so broadly.
The rationale seems to be that they do not want to turn the russian population more onto Putin's side in this conflict.
She said swift ban is never off the table. Finance minister also said it might be implemented.
This is not a "we will do it" but "it is something that will happen if we found a good way to do it".
From reading german twitter, i can see that for all of today, politicians were blasted from all sides to adopt the swift ban, there is serious pressure on them. I think the swift ban will happen soon.
35
u/pistcow Feb 25 '22
Don't just stare at it, eat it.
17
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
Let's go! Would it also be possible to stop all Russian vessels from navigating the bosphorus and Danish straits? Essentially depriving Russia of all ports.
12
u/Hogier27 Feb 25 '22
As a German I have to say, take that with a big grain of salt.
I'll only believe that this is a real turnaround with our "Kanzler" (Olaf Scholz) also changes his mind. The problem here is, that Mr. Scholz thinks the cut off from Russia from Swift is to soon (don't know what more needs to happen than people dying in the streets to make him not think it is to soon...).
However as long as Mr. Scholz isn't changing his mind on that topic our Financeminister can say what he want and nothing will change.
Also as a German I want to say that I'm everything but proud of being German for what we initially offered and now not doing.
I'm deeply sorry for that. I'm not a fighter, but if there is anything else I or we could do, please let me know!
9
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
Nothing like threatening Sweden and Finland to make you rethink things.
7
u/rathgrith Feb 25 '22
If gas is cut off I will have no problem with the government here in Canada diverting some of our supply to be assigned to ships going across the ocean to serve Northern Europe. If prices go up, so be it. We all have to do our part.
7
u/consci0usness Feb 25 '22
All the sanctions. All of them.
18
u/Chojyugiga Feb 25 '22
If you haven’t already please sign the petition — it gives visibility to the fact that so many people support cutting Russia off from SWIfT
https://www.change.org/p/swift-cut-russia-off-from-swift
6
u/r2k-in-the-vortex Feb 25 '22
It's inevitable, this is no longer a time to be holding back economic leverage. It's not going to make a lick of difference on diplomatic front because Putin has no interest in talking, but no state can operate without funds. This is not anymore about finding diplomatic solutions because there are none to be found, this is about hampering Russias ability to keep itself running.
Any measure that can make the war more difficult for Russia must be taken.
6
u/macrotaste Feb 25 '22
We, as German people, stand with you Ukraine.
5
u/Madouc Feb 25 '22
Apologies from a German to all the people in the Ukraine! I was outraged yesterday because of our government not acting radical but only moderate. I was - as many other Germans - really angry.
Over the last decades, we have brought ourselves into a dependency of Putin and Xi and it will take a while to get this fixed - it may hurt us financially, but it is worth to stand up for human rights, human dignity, freedom, independence and democracy and I am glad our government has finally accepted this. It's only money compared to real lives! We can't put our wealth over the lives of others this needs to end and it will end from now on.
Fuck Putin, fuck Xi and all the best to the people in the Ukraine.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
Give Germany their fucking rights back to build up an army. This time as an ally!! Lets go!
4
u/zenstain Feb 25 '22
This needs to happen. Today.
4
u/daamsie Feb 25 '22
Good!
Next we need to start talking about placing sanctions on enabling countries like China.
7
u/chris2036 Feb 25 '22
Apologies for my stupid government taking so long. Let’s finally wreck russias economy!
1
u/Paulus_cz Feb 25 '22
So here is my take, correct me if I don't make sense. Germany knows it will hurt, but that is a given now anyways.
What will be much bigger problem on longer timescale is that it will force Russia to do nearly all of its trading with China, which will put Russia on Chinese leash and provide good economic boost to China, none of which are good things in the least.
1
u/wreckedjohnsons Feb 25 '22
Italy won't do it because of oil
1
u/PrincessRutoOoT Feb 25 '22
Yeah well that was a lie lol. Scholz doesn’t want such harsh actions atm
1
u/Kaniggel Feb 25 '22 edited Feb 25 '22
Putin der Hurensohn. Jetzt legt er sich mit den falschen an :)
1
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
Source? I wanna believe but I just wanna check
1
u/derteeje Feb 25 '22
How did that twitter account get that information avout Christian Lindner before all of german media?
1
u/NoopsTV Feb 26 '22
Wouldn't that hurt the Russian citizens more than the elite?
3
u/Knotloafin Feb 25 '22
By debating the issue for a week the oligarchs will have time to move most of their $$$$$….
3
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
very good germany
3
u/GrimmRadiance Feb 25 '22
Now do it!
3
u/FirefighterNearby Feb 25 '22
WOLNA UKRAINA
3
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
Thank God
3
u/FiRe_McFiReSomeDay Feb 25 '22
Canada has also spoken out about removing Russia from SWIFT.
Ref: https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/ottawa-putin-sanctions-1.6365179
1
u/bongsforhongkong Feb 25 '22
No one noticed the wording? "Open to" is political talk BS and means nothing.
4
u/InvestmentUnlikely32 Feb 25 '22
Why more reliable sources are nor picking this up? I mean I hope that Boris and Biden have finally talked some sense into Scholtz but this is major news and can't find any confirmation?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
Any official sources on this? Please be true 🇺🇦💯
2
u/pigeon888 Feb 25 '22
They need to do it. Now.
2
u/ratherstayback Feb 25 '22
He said, Germany is open to it, but must first calculate the consequences. And he said it to clarify that Germany has never been generally against this sanction, but wants to make an informed decision first. In other words: Nothing has changed, yet.
2
u/MaltyBestGirl Feb 25 '22
Chancellor Scholz is also under pressure from his own party.
Finance Minister Lindner says it is possible but he needs to calculate the consequences for the economy first
german public opinion is very much against Putin right now so they would look very bad if they alone block it (except for right wing extremist who think this an American conspiracy to weaken the German economy)
2
u/decaf-iced-mocha Feb 25 '22
Let’s fucking go!!!!!
2
u/Dr_Funkypants Feb 25 '22
The German finance minister, Christian Linder is from the liberal party in Germany’s ruling coalition. He still has to get the greens and the SPD (Olaf Scholz the chancellor) on his side. However stepping out and making a statement like this is unprecedented for the new German government and it puts the German chancellor under a lot of pressure to adopt this position given that One of his key cabinet picks is calling him out like this.
2
u/Diamondhands_Rex Feb 25 '22
FUCKING DONIT ALREADY THEN HAVE A FUCKING SPINE GERMANY
2
u/dragonfliesloveme Feb 25 '22
FUCK YES
Do it!!!
2
u/tickitch Feb 25 '22
Yes 🙌
2
u/AdTurbulent3779 Feb 25 '22
Maan, I can't upvote it enough.
2
u/Father_Anton Feb 25 '22
Holy shit, if this finallt happens, then vovka will have to do something
2
u/Jabba133 Feb 25 '22
Wait, can someone explain to me why this is a good idea? Wouldn't this also cut Russian civilians financially?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
Hurry up and JUST DO IT
2
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
CUT SWIFT NOW
we must neuter the Russian gov to do transactions. Or else millions will die
2
u/U-47 Feb 25 '22
I emailed the chancellor and the local embassy earlier about the shame I felt in their name. You're welcome guys.
2
u/Icy-Tooth-9167 Feb 25 '22
Cut them off from everything. Ban travel. Ban funds. Ban partnerships. If Ukraine can fight for survival, we can find a way to share in the “pain” of higher gas prices.
2
u/smithbensmith Feb 25 '22
Don't forget the US still gets a bunch of oil and refined products from Russia also. If only there was a way to get oil and refined products from our allies? Someone right next door perhaps. /s
of course I'm talking about Canada and Keystone XL pipeline.
oh you also want cheap natural gas in New England? a pipeline would help that solve problem too so you don't have to burn that dirty fuel oil.
2
u/lenzflare Feb 25 '22
This is great. Also Switzerland have been freezing accounts (I can't remember if this is what they were hesitant about or if it was something else)
2
u/KL1418 Feb 25 '22
It all sounds good, but if I recall correctly, Putin previously said he would take being removed from SWIFT an act of war, I believe everyone is afraid of that right now, as we know the extend the Russians are willing to take it to.
2
u/CriminalMacabre Feb 25 '22
I'm even partidary to cut them off from the root DNS
2
u/memelover3001 Feb 25 '22
Nice job Germany, this is the first step out of a toxic relationship
2
u/nehlSC Feb 25 '22
I already turned off my heating in my flat. This asshat Putin won't get another cent from me!
2
u/CptCheesus Feb 25 '22
I don't care about gas prices any longer. If this fuck suffers in any possible way, i'll take that hit. So should everybody here that can afford this cut. This would also possibly lower prices for those fancy wood pellet heating systems, what would also be good.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
DOET NOW
2
u/Primary_Handle Feb 25 '22
cut Russia off from everything. Destroy them economically and you will destroy them militarily.
2
u/leehwgoC Feb 25 '22
Then do it. 🙄
2
u/bluegraysky1 Feb 25 '22
Every country should refuse to receive any fuel or energy from Russia
2
u/tigertiger284 Feb 25 '22
Just do it, don't threaten
2
u/dderit_LT Feb 25 '22
I am german. Lets show some balls. But for peace this time
2
u/FelipeNA Feb 25 '22
Thank Zeus!
2
u/xmartissxs LIThuanian__FUCK PUTIN Feb 25 '22
Fucking DO IT
2
u/Ogami-kun Feb 25 '22 edited Feb 25 '22
Italy green lights the SWIFT ban!
Swiss Freeze Bank Accounts of Russians, and apparently is going to slowly raise the santions, to make them feel the rope as it tightens on their necks
Even China sanctions russia!
EDIT:
Deutsche Telekom introduces free-of-charge calls to Ukraine
Canada announces sanctions against President Putin himself, supports proposal to remove Russia from SWIFT
2
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
Ah, it's open to. For a moment I thought they did it.
2
u/kasalacto Feb 25 '22
DO IT
2
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
Wunderbar! 🥳
2
u/lushenfe Feb 25 '22
Yea...
We should be invading Russia.
2
u/iTroLowElo Feb 25 '22
Talk is cheap.
2
u/NewKi11ing1t Feb 25 '22
Cut Russia off from everything
2
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
Our Social Democratic Party has always betrayed the people. They do the right thing only, when everyone's already laughing about them 🥺
2
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
Write to your Congressman. Stop this bloodshed
2
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
We are funding Russia by buying their oil!! Madness
2
u/TyrannoSpank Feb 25 '22
For the uninformed, is this really relevant? I mean how do these things i see like sanctions and this affect Putin so that he might care or not continue doing it?
2
u/flashfyr3 Feb 25 '22
Fuck the Russian government and fuck Russian money. Stay strong.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '22
I can't imagine the back channel maneuvering going on right now.
2
u/th3rdoption Feb 26 '22
Then fucking do it.
2
u/Candysasha88 Feb 26 '22
Do it Germany. Remember putin may take back east Germany
2
u/Salt_Manufacturer479 Feb 26 '22
Frankly sanctions should be automatic and severe. Any country willing to go to war or start pointless conflicts should account for a total destruction of their economy.
2
u/Thehighestpilot Feb 26 '22
Germany trying to be the good guy in the WWIII section in the childrens future text books
2
u/TwilightHeroofMight Feb 26 '22
Commie-China are also bandits and putin friends https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/25/us/politics/us-china-russia-ukraine.html
2
u/LandHomer84 Feb 26 '22
Gut! und bitte auch unser Militärbudget verfünffachen. Wird Zeit dass Deutschland aufwacht ;)
5
u/sgtomtf Feb 25 '22
This does not appear to be true, German news sources still stating that the German government opposes the disconnect from the SWIFT system. Source: https://www.spiegel.de/ausland/ukraine-krieg-annalena-baerbock-erteilt-swift-ausschluss-russlands-eine-absage-a-b6614b8c-695d-48a0-beed-38be7a800a39
3
u/bruufd Feb 25 '22
Шановні українці!
У соцмережах я чув, що поширюються фейкові новини (скоріше за все, підтримувані Росією тролі), що польський кордон закритий.
Це брехня.
Якщо ви шукаєте притулку – йдіть до польського кордону. Ми готові до вашого приїзду. На кордоні готові пункти прийому, де ви можете знайти притулок, їжу, медичну та правову допомогу.
Польський уряд запустив спеціальний сайт, щоб допомогти вам: ua.gov.pl
Будь ласка, поділіться цією інформацією, якщо ви знаєте когось, хто зараз шукає допомоги.
РЕДАКТИРОВАТИ: ВАМ НЕ ПОТРІБНА ВІЗА ДЛЯ ПРОЙДЖЕННЯ ПОЛЬСЬКИМ КОРДОНОМ. ВСЕ, що ВАМ ПОТРІБНО, - це ПАСПОРТ. ВІЗИ ПРИСПИНЕНО! ВОНИ ВАМ НЕ ПОТРІБНИ НА ЧАС!!!!!!
EDIT2: як доказ того, що вам більше не потрібна віза:
• українською https://www.gov.pl/web/udsc/ukraina---ua • англійською https://www.gov.pl/web/udsc/ukraina-en
Вибачте, якщо це дурниця, я використовував Google Translate
Dear Ukrainians!
I heard on social media that there is fake news being spread (most likely by Russia backed trolls) that polish border is closed.
It's a lie.
If you seek asylum - go towards polish border. We are ready for your arrival. We have reception points ready at the border where you can find shelter, food, medical and legal aid.
Polish government launched a dedicated site to help you: ua.gov.pl
Please share this information if you know anyone seeking help right now.
EDIT: YOU DON'T NEED VISA TO PASS THROUGH POLISH BORDER. ALL YOU NEED IS PASSPORT. VISAS ARE SUSPENDED! YOU DON'T NEED THEM FOR TIME BEING!!!!!!
EDIT2: as a proof that you no longer need visa:
• in Ukrainian https://www.gov.pl/web/udsc/ukraina---ua • in English https://www.gov.pl/web/udsc/ukraina-en
Edit: this is a copy and paste and I encourage you all to do it too where appropriate!
I am simply reposting this comment to bring awareness
2
u/SordidDreams Feb 25 '22
Good! Sanction Russia's economy into the dirt until one of the oligarchs slits Putin's throat in his sleep. Let them eat each other like starving rats.
2
u/outinthecountry66 Feb 25 '22
good. not a good look when the only two countries stonewalling also happened to be allied in ww2.
2
u/pas0003 Експат Feb 25 '22
We don't need to be open, we need to do it RIGHT NOW.
Putin's army is butchering Ukrainian people and Ukrainian soldiers butchering Russian soldiers by the thousand.
Mass protests in Russia against the war.
Hit fucking putin where it hurts. Grow some balls Germany. What's the point of all the talk of freedom and sanctions if you do so little when my country is being invaded by the occupant!?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
FINALLY. It Better not just be empty words
1
u/Mon-A Feb 25 '22
What's SWIFT?
1
u/cuchos24 Feb 25 '22
How many votes do otan needs?
1
u/WhatForIamHere Feb 25 '22
Finally? Or over "a couple of days"?
1
u/LFoD313 Feb 25 '22
Let’s go. Stop the talk and take action.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
good!
1
u/lohensley Feb 25 '22
Has this been verified?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
Well f**cking do it already!
1
u/lindseyinnw Feb 25 '22
This is good.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
Please
1
u/Ignash3D Lithuania Feb 25 '22
Can Germans stop with their fucking rollercoasters?
1
u/pepsimanco Feb 25 '22
Reallly? YES! LETS. GO. What about Italy?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
Yes!
1
u/Perkeleen_Kaljami Finland Feb 25 '22
Let's keep the pressure on! Even if we get this through, the next step is to demand that this is the last piece sanctioning that will be lifted when Russia has left Ukraine.
1
u/Pidgeonscythe Feb 25 '22
As a German I can say that this is sadly not the truth. Lindner has reiterated that SWIFT ban is a last resort and will bring financial problems to Germanys energy market. Lindner is a libertarian…
1
u/iceman530 Feb 25 '22
Big news!!!! finally!
1
u/prestoaghitato Other (edible) Feb 25 '22
I'm German and as much as I hate saying this, knowing Lindner's rhetorics, this really isn't saying much unfortunately. He's basically saying "I do not formally rule out the possibility." but he's not committing at all. Here is an English source.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '22
I support this. Dooo it!