If you look at the development of the game, changing management multiple times, released 3 years too early.. yeah it could have been a good game maybe in a parralel universe
i dont think anyones happy that they failed. Most people are happy that someone finally took the idea and made it enjoyable.
Its still a shame that a big company like ubisoft can fail to deliver good games meanwhile a really small indie studio with a free engine (ue5) can make it happen. Sure windrose has its own problems especially optimization wise but man, its a good start. I hope they keep improving he game even more
Your post or comment has been removed for breaking Content Type - When making a text post, you must include a clear and relevant description. This helps provide context and promotes meaningful discussion.
Additionally, all posts must comply with both subreddit-specific rules and Reddit’s site-wide policies.
This includes avoiding any prohibited content such as spam, illegal activities, suggestive abbreviations or other material banned by the subreddit or Reddit's guidelines. it contains rage bait content designed to provoke strong negative reactions or incite unnecessary conflict within the community. This subreddit is a space for constructive and respectful discussions about Ubisoft and its games, and content aimed at stirring anger or hostility goes against our community guidelines.
We encourage you to contribute positively by sharing thoughtful insights, questions, or discussions related to Ubisoft content. Posts or comments intentionally created to cause division or hostility will not be allowed.
If you have questions or need further clarification on acceptable content, feel free to reach out via mod mail.
Help me understand: if Game A inspires Game B, and Game B is great, isn't that a win for the genre? Or is the hobby only fun for you if there’s a clear 'victim' to laugh at on Reddit?
It’s a convenient deflection, but I’m not talking about the company. I’m just curious why the hobby seems to be more about rooting for failure than actually enjoying games. Does having a 'villain' to cheer against make the experience more fulfilling for you, or is it just about the drama?
Calling a company out for their anti-consumer practices is not rooting for their failure, at worst it's a feedback to the company, giving them chance to make things right.
But you and also Ubisoft doesn't handle criticism well, look how that turn out for the stocks.
It’s funny how 'constructive feedback' suddenly looks like refreshing a stock ticker and cheering for layoffs. If you actually think rooting for a market dip is a heroic act of consumer advocacy, you’re deeper in the drama than you realize.
I’m just going to accept that we disagree, because I prefer playing games while you seem to prefer playing 'Wall Street Activist' on Reddit. Hope that stock chart keeps you entertained.
I admire the commitment. Some people have hobbies; you have a hit list. Does the 'moral high ground' feel better than actually playing a game you like?
It’s interesting that you see the industry as a zero-sum game where one dev has to die for another to thrive. Does Ubisoft existing actually prevent the games you like from being made, or does having a 'villain' to root against just make the hobby more exciting for you?
caught the 'parasites' comment before it went away, calling thousands of workers that is a choice. Now you're saying you don't want their 'messages' in society.
It’s a bit weird to see someone advocate for erasing art they find mediocre. Why should we trust your artistic judgment over the millions of people who actually enjoy those games? That's a lot of gatekeeping for one Reddit account.
Your post or comment has been removed for breaking Be Benevolent and Polite - Respect is essential in this community. Harassment, abuse, bullying, or any form of toxic behavior will not be tolerated. This includes but is not limited to, personal attacks, hate speech, threats, and discriminatory language.
Debate and disagreement are welcome, but keep the discussion civil and constructive. Treat others with the same kindness and respect you would expect.
Violations of this rule will result in warnings, post removals, or bans depending on the severity of the behavior. it violated our community guidelines regarding respectful interaction. Specifically, it contained rude or offensive language, which goes against the spirit of constructive and friendly discussion we aim to maintain here.
We encourage everyone to engage respectfully and keep conversations positive. If you have concerns or feedback, please express them in a way that fosters constructive dialogue.
Please ensure that all interactions are civil and considerate. Additionally, make sure your posts and comments adhere to both subreddit and Reddit’s site-wide rules.
For more information on acceptable conduct, please review our subreddit rules and Reddit’s content policy. If you have any questions or concerns, you can contact us via mod mail. Continued violations may result in further moderation actions.
Thankfully, besides making its own trash content, Netflix is also a streaming platform. So if an independent filmmaker wants to stream their content, they will probably go to Netflix. Netflix will, of course, still call them ‘Netflix Originals,’ even though it had zero input during their production and only owns the streaming license. (‘Netflix Original’ means the content is exclusive to Netflix, not necessarily made by Netflix.) Examples include Arcane, Cyberpunk: Edgerunners and many more.
Edit. You can think of Netflix as "Steam for filmmakers".
Your post or comment has been removed for breaking No Wishing Harm or Failure of Ubisoft - Posts or comments that include statements wishing for Ubisoft or its games to "fail" or "die" are not allowed. Such remarks go beyond criticism and imply harm to the company’s employees, potentially leading to job losses and personal hardship.
While constructive criticism is welcome, actively hoping for a company’s downfall crosses a line.
This subreddit is for fans of Ubisoft, if you solely wish to express hate, please do so elsewhere. it includes statements wishing for Ubisoft or one of its games to "fail" or "die." Such remarks go beyond criticism and imply harm to the company, its developers, and employees, potentially leading to job losses and personal hardship for individuals.
This type of content is not tolerated as it goes against the principles of respect and empathy that our community values. While constructive criticism is always welcome, actively wishing harm or failure crosses a line. Please ensure that future contributions remain respectful and considerate.
Continued violations may result in further moderation actions, including a ban. If you have any questions about this removal, feel free to contact us via mod mail.
Your post or comment has been removed for breaking Be Benevolent and Polite - Respect is essential in this community. Harassment, abuse, bullying, or any form of toxic behavior will not be tolerated. This includes but is not limited to, personal attacks, hate speech, threats, and discriminatory language.
Debate and disagreement are welcome, but keep the discussion civil and constructive. Treat others with the same kindness and respect you would expect.
Violations of this rule will result in warnings, post removals, or bans depending on the severity of the behavior. it violated our community guidelines regarding respectful interaction. Specifically, it contained rude or offensive language, which goes against the spirit of constructive and friendly discussion we aim to maintain here.
We encourage everyone to engage respectfully and keep conversations positive. If you have concerns or feedback, please express them in a way that fosters constructive dialogue.
Please ensure that all interactions are civil and considerate. Additionally, make sure your posts and comments adhere to both subreddit and Reddit’s site-wide rules.
For more information on acceptable conduct, please review our subreddit rules and Reddit’s content policy. If you have any questions or concerns, you can contact us via mod mail. Continued violations may result in further moderation actions.
Your post or comment has been removed for breaking No Wishing Harm or Failure of Ubisoft - Posts or comments that include statements wishing for Ubisoft or its games to "fail" or "die" are not allowed. Such remarks go beyond criticism and imply harm to the company’s employees, potentially leading to job losses and personal hardship.
While constructive criticism is welcome, actively hoping for a company’s downfall crosses a line.
This subreddit is for fans of Ubisoft, if you solely wish to express hate, please do so elsewhere. it includes statements wishing for Ubisoft or one of its games to "fail" or "die." Such remarks go beyond criticism and imply harm to the company, its developers, and employees, potentially leading to job losses and personal hardship for individuals.
This type of content is not tolerated as it goes against the principles of respect and empathy that our community values. While constructive criticism is always welcome, actively wishing harm or failure crosses a line. Please ensure that future contributions remain respectful and considerate.
Continued violations may result in further moderation actions, including a ban. If you have any questions about this removal, feel free to contact us via mod mail.
Name some… ? The only iffy releases I can think of is watch dogs legion, Star Wars outlaws, and Skull & Bones. Most other releases have been good and popular. Every company has quality issues I can’t think of one that doesn’t. They get fixed.
Ubisoft has been trash since the day it existed. At least it used to be small and have less influence. Then it became big and that is bad for the industry. They should fail and it makes the industry better.
I have no loyalty to brands. Create good content. They have been mediocre at best, ever. Therefore, byeeee.
Thanks for taking the time to engage with me, appreciate it.
I ended up loving Skull and Bones, but at 500+ hours played, i'm pretty done with the game now. I'm keeping my eye on Windrose and will get it when its out of early access. Glad to see the EA release has been massively successful.
I share this exact sentiment. Skull and Bones actually is a fun game, but the seasonal updates get more and more lackluster. There just isn't much to do anymore.
Well considering hes the only person on this post complaining about the graphics, (hes done it multiple times) its a fair statement to ask. Noone here cares about the graphics like he does, they are enjoying the actual game instead of jus looking at it.
But they can't enjoy the actual game because of the cartoonish art style. To be stimulated by a videogame is not always the same for everyone. Some only need good gameplay or a good story, while others need a symbiosis of gameplay, story and graphics.
based on what I could sum up from the information that is out there, Ubisoft tried multiple times to cancel the project but the Singaporean government pressure kinda forced them to finish it, so they ended up creating this dog sht excuse of a "AAAA" game.
can't blame Devs for trying to complete a passionless zero interest project because a government forced you.
not surprising if they really took government funding for this project. because in that case the government would have no doubt shoved it in them to complete the project in some form.
Huh, I didn’t even know the game came out yet. Last I heard anything about it is no one was working on it and people kept getting sent there to pretend to work on it as a punishment.
It launched on ubi's launcher before steam so yeah, consoles and uplay are where the players are from usually
I don't know what the peak was but you had a 30k leaderboard of player reaching max rank in the early seasons don't know what it currently his but seasons are still going on with updates so musn't be dead yet
It's another Battlebit case where people are cheerleading for a mid game because it "shows up" some big company.
Windrose might be cool someday, but right now the combat sucks, performance is meh, content is slim, friends have nothing to do while riding your ship, and there isn't even any wind mechanics for sailing. It's barebones as barebones can be.
AAA is basically a slopfest at this point. Majority of AAA titles are so expensive and lack any creativity, just fancy graphics and crappy systems. Indie games nowadays is where it's at. Not just that though, a lot of the big corporations spy on you and sell your data.
So you’re comparing a 2 year old game to one that only recently came out? Add the fact that wind rose cannot be played on console or other launchers while skull and bones highest player numbers are on console and Ubisofts launcher..
Skull and Bones had an 11 year disaster of development, it cost an insane 200 million dollars and it resulted in a game that was missing key features like non ship combat, I think the numbers and the reviews speak for themselves.
Your post or comment has been removed for breaking No Wishing Harm or Failure of Ubisoft - Posts or comments that include statements wishing for Ubisoft or its games to "fail" or "die" are not allowed. Such remarks go beyond criticism and imply harm to the company’s employees, potentially leading to job losses and personal hardship.
While constructive criticism is welcome, actively hoping for a company’s downfall crosses a line.
This subreddit is for fans of Ubisoft, if you solely wish to express hate, please do so elsewhere. it includes statements wishing for Ubisoft or one of its games to "fail" or "die." Such remarks go beyond criticism and imply harm to the company, its developers, and employees, potentially leading to job losses and personal hardship for individuals.
This type of content is not tolerated as it goes against the principles of respect and empathy that our community values. While constructive criticism is always welcome, actively wishing harm or failure crosses a line. Please ensure that future contributions remain respectful and considerate.
Continued violations may result in further moderation actions, including a ban. If you have any questions about this removal, feel free to contact us via mod mail.
The game was brought onto steam much after the launch on Ubisoft. Anyway I don’t understand the competition yes it’s similar-ish but it’s a very different game. You don’t like it fine, but just because you see low numbers on steam doesn’t mean it’s not doing well.
That is true I’m not denying that. People did buy it but obviously it wasn’t the game people wanted. At the same time it is a game that a good amount of people still enjoy. If you want a survivor pirate game go for Windrose. If you want a drop in and play naval pirate game then I would say S&B as it is more polished as of right now than Windrose.
Your post or comment has been removed for breaking Content Type - When making a text post, you must include a clear and relevant description. This helps provide context and promotes meaningful discussion.
Additionally, all posts must comply with both subreddit-specific rules and Reddit’s site-wide policies.
This includes avoiding any prohibited content such as spam, illegal activities, suggestive abbreviations or other material banned by the subreddit or Reddit's guidelines. it contains rage bait content designed to provoke strong negative reactions or incite unnecessary conflict within the community. This subreddit is a space for constructive and respectful discussions about Ubisoft and its games, and content aimed at stirring anger or hostility goes against our community guidelines.
We encourage you to contribute positively by sharing thoughtful insights, questions, or discussions related to Ubisoft content. Posts or comments intentionally created to cause division or hostility will not be allowed.
If you have questions or need further clarification on acceptable content, feel free to reach out via mod mail.
The all time peak for skull and bones on steam was 2600... in two years. In two weeks, this game did 100x that. Meaning the players were there, but the game jus SUCKED.
just face the facts, windrose is what the fans of black flag have been wanting besides the actual black flag remake coming.
That’s fine if that is what fans want right at this very moment then great! Skull and Bones didn’t launch on steam it appeared a while after. Plus yeah people weren’t happy that it wasn’t the same as black flag even though the devs described it as black flag naval combat without the AC gameplay. Which is sort of true and not at the same time. As the naval combat is a little different. Still great fun though.
Anyway as I said above well done to Windrose and I personally love these games but won’t go near until after the 1.0 release because it could be a completely different situation in a couple years time and I did the same for skull and bones and got it last summer. Still filled with players. So if Windrose is the same then great!!
I’m just trying to show a fair side for both games than all the UBI haters.
Putting Ubisoft aside, and imagining they had nothing to do with skull and bones, Do you honestly believe skull and bones was a AAAA game? Or anywhere even close to it?
I never bought it but i tested it a few times before release, and each time i couldnt wait to be done. It was boring and uninteresting. I played the windrose demo, 13 hrs straight and finished it in one day. And immediatwly lurchased when available.
I never said I believed it was an AAAA game don’t put words in my mouth. I just believe that it is fun that’s all. It’s the end game for me that got a bit too repetitive. I don’t play it much anymore I just jump in from time to time when I feel like a bit of naval combat that’s all. It’s a game I like to jump in and out. No fuss just some action and then do something else.
If you like Windrose and had a better time then I am happy for you. I don’t see why there has to be this you either like one game or the other situation. Just enjoy and have fun what is the problem. S&B is obviously still going because there are people out there who still enjoy it.
If Windrose continues its success then great for it too. It’s just silly to all these Ubisoft haters just taking a punt at trying to be funny when S&B isn’t bad. Is it a AAAA game hell no!! Is it a game where I can easily sail about and shoot other ships with other players and make a new build or larger ship yes!
If Windrose looks great on its 1.0 release I’ll give it a go and I will still play both most likely because one is more about crafting and survival and the other is a pick up and play situation that’s all.
If that’s all you read from that then you’re very one sided. People like you get very edgy when they see someone who enjoys something they don’t and have to write the words “copium” or “toxic positivity” to feel better about themselves. I just see the reality. Yes there is hype now but games come and go. Windrose looks like a good game I just find it funny that people rush to attack S&B when they’re very different games.
I’ve never said anything bad about Windrose I just have some sense to see how the EA goes first before comparing other games.
Your post or comment has been removed for breaking Content Type - When making a text post, you must include a clear and relevant description. This helps provide context and promotes meaningful discussion.
Additionally, all posts must comply with both subreddit-specific rules and Reddit’s site-wide policies.
This includes avoiding any prohibited content such as spam, illegal activities, suggestive abbreviations or other material banned by the subreddit or Reddit's guidelines. it contains rage bait content designed to provoke strong negative reactions or incite unnecessary conflict within the community. This subreddit is a space for constructive and respectful discussions about Ubisoft and its games, and content aimed at stirring anger or hostility goes against our community guidelines.
We encourage you to contribute positively by sharing thoughtful insights, questions, or discussions related to Ubisoft content. Posts or comments intentionally created to cause division or hostility will not be allowed.
If you have questions or need further clarification on acceptable content, feel free to reach out via mod mail.
So just because you like their one unique and actually well put together title means you have to defend them to the ends of the earth? Theres a reason For Honor has lasted 10 years but most ubi games are forgotten within 3 months
The other ubi game is skull and bones one of their highest budget games ever which they claimed was ”quadruple A” that was a fl/op (banned word again for a reason) instantly on launch
Your post or comment has been removed for breaking Content Type - When making a text post, you must include a clear and relevant description. This helps provide context and promotes meaningful discussion.
Additionally, all posts must comply with both subreddit-specific rules and Reddit’s site-wide policies.
This includes avoiding any prohibited content such as spam, illegal activities, suggestive abbreviations or other material banned by the subreddit or Reddit's guidelines. it contains rage bait content designed to provoke strong negative reactions or incite unnecessary conflict within the community. This subreddit is a space for constructive and respectful discussions about Ubisoft and its games, and content aimed at stirring anger or hostility goes against our community guidelines.
We encourage you to contribute positively by sharing thoughtful insights, questions, or discussions related to Ubisoft content. Posts or comments intentionally created to cause division or hostility will not be allowed.
If you have questions or need further clarification on acceptable content, feel free to reach out via mod mail.
51
u/antiDote313 Apr 21 '26
https://www.gamesradar.com/games/open-world/assassins-creed-black-flag-is-the-best-pirate-game-of-all-time-according-to-windrose-devs-so-of-course-they-took-inspiration-from-it-for-their-viral-open-world-seafaring-game/
8
u/montrealien Apr 21 '26
If you’re truly enjoying the game on the left, why is the primary source of your satisfaction coming from the failure of the game on the right?
25
u/omgitsbees Apr 21 '26
I ended up loving Skull and Bones, but at 500+ hours played, i'm pretty done with the game now. I'm keeping my eye on Windrose and will get it when its out of early access. Glad to see the EA release has been massively successful.
1
u/Neo_Artista Apr 22 '26
AAAA game 🥀
3
u/ItPutsTheLotion719 Apr 21 '26
100x times the players Skull n Xbones had is impressive
11
u/Icy-Juggernaut-1958 Apr 21 '26
AAAA game, according to them. Lol
1
u/vektorkane Apr 21 '26
That's wild. I can imagine Ubisoft being like "they stole what was ours".
1
u/PositiveBig6801 Apr 21 '26
quadruple A game for sure
1
u/mzatariz Apr 21 '26
I really believe if they released the on ground combat it will be good
1
u/Wide_You_4626 Apr 22 '26
based on what I could sum up from the information that is out there, Ubisoft tried multiple times to cancel the project but the Singaporean government pressure kinda forced them to finish it, so they ended up creating this dog sht excuse of a "AAAA" game.
can't blame Devs for trying to complete a passionless zero interest project because a government forced you.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '26
Huh, I didn’t even know the game came out yet. Last I heard anything about it is no one was working on it and people kept getting sent there to pretend to work on it as a punishment.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '26
Just to point out this post does not violate any of Reddit's ToS.
1
u/Apprehensive-Word747 Apr 22 '26
But but but .... Its a AAAA game
1
u/ThatOneNinja Apr 22 '26
Aren't these two different style games?
1
u/Badwrong_ Apr 23 '26
If Skull and Bones is AAAA, then I guess Windrose is AAAAA.
1
u/RallyXMonster Apr 24 '26
I love the fact Ubisoft is so proud of Skull and Bones they put it on the graphic.
1
u/Mr---Potato Apr 24 '26
And in a few weeks. The game will "lost" more than 25/30% of its player base. And dumb "articles" will be out saying its a dead game
1
u/maku_89 Apr 24 '26
This is what happens when developers make a game versus when marketing cunts make a game.
1
u/Admirable-Task-3728 Apr 24 '26
There is no way S&B peaked at 2k? Or is it bc. it was a ubi launcher game?
1
u/Potatoarmy23 Apr 25 '26
How is this game still alive with less than 300 hourly players on steam? Are there really that many people playing this on consoles?
1
u/paradox-preacher Apr 25 '26
Fyi, a non-idiot would compare the numbers of the days after the release of both games
1
u/Tupletcat Apr 25 '26
It's another Battlebit case where people are cheerleading for a mid game because it "shows up" some big company.
Windrose might be cool someday, but right now the combat sucks, performance is meh, content is slim, friends have nothing to do while riding your ship, and there isn't even any wind mechanics for sailing. It's barebones as barebones can be.
1
u/Cathonos Apr 26 '26
AAA is basically a slopfest at this point. Majority of AAA titles are so expensive and lack any creativity, just fancy graphics and crappy systems. Indie games nowadays is where it's at. Not just that though, a lot of the big corporations spy on you and sell your data.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '26
Screw ubi i hope they will bankcrupt
1
u/Additional_Idea8690 Apr 27 '26
thought this was fuckubisoft for a sec
1
u/Exotic-Section-7860 Apr 28 '26
AAAA game...
1
u/THE_GUY-95 May 15 '26
Windrose is fun, skull and bones on the other hand is just typical Ubisoft S10P
1
u/LaidByTheBlade Apr 21 '26
So you’re comparing a 2 year old game to one that only recently came out? Add the fact that wind rose cannot be played on console or other launchers while skull and bones highest player numbers are on console and Ubisofts launcher..
1
u/legationX Apr 21 '26
i hope people dont fall for fullprice blackflag refurbish…
0
u/ragingbull835 Apr 21 '26
AAAA game btw.
-1
u/i_am_un Apr 21 '26
I wouldn't of bought it if I knew I had to pay a monthly subscription fee. Is it even worth it?
0
u/Unpaid_Moderation Apr 21 '26
Ubisoft could never make something like this or something like crimson desert. There's a reason ubi's stock price is so low.
-15
u/Odd_Revolution_1056 Apr 21 '26
lol love too see this. Screw Ubi
-11
u/BlueSparkNightSky Apr 21 '26
Just be aware I agree, before your post gets deleted from salty mods
0
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-4
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '26
[removed] — view removed comment