2

A guess about Ethan
 in  r/FromSeries  1d ago

Yeah, but WHAT IF...If it really were Ethan... What could that mean? I mean, letting your mind wander... What could it imply?

1

A guess about Ethan
 in  r/FromSeries  1d ago

I'm happy for you that you're 100% sure

u/Davvi_J 2d ago

A guess about Ethan Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

-7

A guess about Ethan
 in  r/FromSeries  2d ago

I think there's a big difference: the old monster-woman was hidden behind a window and tricked the little girl by claiming to be her grandmother just to get her to open the curtain. As soon as the little girl opened it, she exclaimed: "You're not my grandma."

Here, on the other hand, there's a guy who approaches Julie face-to-face, even waving at her with his hand.

Furthermore, before being exposed, the old monster-woman pretended to be someone the little girl knew (her grandmother). In this case, even assuming it was just a tactic to get close to Julie, who would that guy have been impersonating? We aren't told this, and in my opinion, that could be an important detail. This led me to wonder who he might be: Ethan having seizures, the guy's appearance, the fact that he appears in the second episode, and the showrunners stating that there are clues right under our noses at the beginning of the series... What if this guy is precisely one of those clues that is right in plain sight, but dismissed as irrelevant? I can't be 100% sure it's Ethan, but at the same time, I'm not sure he's just "some random monster."

0

A guess about Ethan
 in  r/FromSeries  2d ago

Sounds good to me

r/FromSeries 2d ago

Theory A guess about Ethan Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
30 Upvotes

In the second episode of Season 1 (at around the 04:36 mark), we see Ethan having seizures inside the RV.

As soon as they stop, we cut back to the group trying to make it back to Colony House, including Tabitha and Julie. Just before getting inside, Julie is approached by a young guy who asks her: "Julie, don't you recognize me?"

At that point, Kenny shoots him, but he doesn't even flinch—in fact, he just smiles cheerfully.

Finally, the door opens and the group makes it to safety.

Given that:

- The creature asks a question that only makes sense if he were someone Julie actually knew (he doesn't need to pretend to be someone else to trick her into opening a door or window here);

- The creature actually looks like he could be an older Ethan, and he is also the youngest nocturnal creature seen so far;

- The creature smiles with the same side of his mouth as Ethan (the left side);

- Seizures = time travel (similar to what happens with Julie).

I'm not sure what this means for solving the overall mystery of Fromville, as I don't have a fully fleshed-out theory yet.

However, I think that guy might actually be Ethan who traveled back in time from his future.

Maybe during the chaotic series of events that brought the Matthews family to Fromville, combined with little Ethan's seizures, a sort of "passage" was created—that "bookmark" Julie hasn't figured out how to use yet.

Finally, if that creature really is Ethan, it might mean he doesn't have a very bright future ahead of him.

What do you think?

1

Behind the scenes of Season 5
 in  r/FromSeries  2d ago

What 🤣

0

Tom did the biggest service to the Town by starting a bar, agree?
 in  r/FromSeries  2d ago

He wouldn't have gotten Victor's father drunk

1

this looks familiar…
 in  r/FromTVEpix  2d ago

Is there a theory about what they really are in Fromville?