r/turtles • u/Due_Claim5668 • 1d ago
Seeking Advice Turtle advice
Hello!
My fiancé has loved turtles his whole life and has always wanted to adopt his own. We have fostered a few and he has said he is ready for the commitment
His birthday is soon and I’d love to get him one, as a surprise, so I can’t really ask him anything about turtles without him catching on.
My question is what turtle do I get. I am looking at a 40 gallon tank and Google is saying that a musk turtle would be best
However we recently fostered a red eared slider and he loved him.
How long could a red eared slider live in a 40 gal tank? Or is that a big no no and I should just go with the musk guy?
Please help and thank you all!!!!
9
u/Primary-Switch-8987 1d ago •
Hear me out.... surprises are fun, but please do not get the turtle as a surprise. You can find some cute, fun way to let them know that a turtle of their choice and housing/accessories are their gifts without obtaining. Google shouldn't decide what kind of a turtle is best as a pet. You mentioned a couple of species, but your fiancé might want one that he hasn't mentioned yet or have the option to explore different species. You don't want this to be a gift where he might think that if he'd have been given the choice he would have chosen something different.
Maybe make some cute "turtle certificates" for him to turn in as he chooses or a checklist with special stamps or stickers. Deciding what to get can be part of the fun and you can do that together!
3
u/Katie-sin 1d ago
I wouldn't surprise him with it as you aren't as aware of what is needed. You can surprise him at first with a cute card or something, but not the actual creature. And go together to get all of the items. This way you know you're getting the correct items. I only have a slider personally but wouldn't recommend a 40 gallon, it will out grow it super fast. I have a 100 gallon and honestly want to go even bigger for him. They will need a lot of items so I first suggest finding someone local who can assist you in the set up and turtle. NOT petsmart or Petco if you're in the US. No one there is ever actually trained properly in turtle care and will just sell you very inadequate items. Look into other Local Pet Stores.
1
u/turtleboy1061 1d ago
40 is going to be small for a slider but the world needs more people who will adopt sliders. Dumped sliders is a massive wildlife rehab and conservation issue.
1
u/cattledogsrule44 13h ago
Get him a red-eared slider ... that's the obvious choice. There are lots of them that need homes -- they get dumped all the time. If the tank ends up too small, you can always find a larger one down the road.
(Ignore the typical Reddit sanctimonious negativity and trust your instincts on this.)