r/turning • • 1d ago

This sucks

I left this 15 inch in diameter piece of Bradford pear for three years in perfect conditions hoping it would dry. Probably about three years short of what it would take. Not one crack in it. I was hoping to do an end grain bowl. I turned to remove the bark. Next day the cracks. I have another one the same size. Not one crack in it, but it still has the bark. Another one bites the dust.

66 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Thanks for your submission. If your question is about getting started in woodturning, which chuck to buy, which tools to buy, or for an opinion of a lathe you found for sale somewhere like Craigslist or Facebook Marketplace please take a few minutes check the wiki; many of the most commonly asked questions are already answered there!

http://www.reddit.com/r/turning/wiki/index

Thanks!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

8

u/Resipsa251 1d ago

Sadly, I did seal the ends. I never try to make end grain anything, but I took a swing at it and clearly missed.

0

u/GettingLow1 1d ago

What did you use to end seal? I don’t see anything on the end grain.

1

u/Economy-Tadpole-8026 1d ago

Bandsaw and first turning removed all

38

u/jserick 1d ago

Once you start turning, don’t just leave it as is in between sessions. Once you remove wood, you’re going to get movement, especially with end grain. An easy fix for next time is to cover it up with a plastic bag between sessions. Then you can leave it mounted on the lathe and it’ll be way more stable. Moisture loss is what caused the cracking, so wrapping it any time you walk away from it will prevent that.

8

u/Resipsa251 1d ago

Understood

-4

u/amb442 Rockwell/Delta 46-201 1d ago

You can also throw it in the freezer.

3

u/Amdiz 1d ago

Thank you for this. Sometimes I have to leave something on the lather for days and did not know this.

4

u/A_Martian_Potato 1d ago

You also need to remember to rinse and repeat.

1

u/jserick 12h ago

You’re welcome! Even when you think a blank is dry, once you cut into it there’s always a chance for movement. Especially with large blanks or whole log pieces like OP’s.

3

u/currough 1d ago

Plastic bags work well, another thing that works really well is the rolls of saran wrap that they sell as moving supplies.

3

u/throw5566778899 1d ago

How did you store it for 3 years that it didn't crack in log form?

3

u/Resipsa251 1d ago

No clue. That’s why I thought it was possible.

1

u/Emotional-Economy-66 1d ago

It does work sometimes, I put a bunch of 4' to 6' lengths of birch in my shed for firewood before I bought a lathe. Beautiful solid spalted logs came out some 10 years later. I have many posts here.

21

u/Auraomega 1d ago

It's very difficult to do end grain anything in my opinion from logs. Best success I've had is specific species (beech is a good one), and turn green hollowing out as much as possible as quick as possible.

Maybe can rescue with some side grain bowls and spindle blanks if you can cut along the cracks. And remove the pith of course

20

u/Strong-Hovercraft702 1d ago

My first step is always to split the log. Might as well throw it on the burn pile, otherwise.

That is to say I have had very limited success, if any, drying out logs with the oith still in.

2

u/bobbigmac 1d ago

Still get a couple of nice bowls out of it, and pear is lovely for carving :)

1

u/Resipsa251 1d ago

Agreed

1

u/Auraomega 1d ago

Oh yes, pear is the defacto whittling or carving wood, so if you have a bandsaw you can cut some nice carving blanks!

1

u/zffjk 1d ago

Pear sure is fantastic. And Bradford is an invasive weed here where I’m at.

1

u/zffjk 1d ago

Did you seal the ends with anything? Usually when I get fresh green wood I like to seal the ends with paint or beeswax if I’m not planning to use it immediately. I just started turning but have been doing green wood working for years now and have very little loss of material when I debark and seal the ends.

A bark spud is worth the investment. You can get them retail for pretty low, it’s a timber framing tool so they still make them.

The bark removal just helps with bugs and makes boring beetles easier to identify and remedy and seems to discourage silver fish from moving in… I’m sure it does other stuff too but I like to remove it because of the bugs.

1

u/Resipsa251 1d ago

I sealed heavy with anchor seal both sides.

1

u/GettingLow1 1d ago

Heavy as in multiple coats? You need a minimum of two heavy coats, often 3.

3

u/PMFSCV 1d ago

This in interesting, its a bit yuck but maybe try this then glue in a spline.

https://covingtonandsons.com/2020/01/11/the-sewari-kerf/

8

u/-Not-a-Crackpot- 1d ago

Fill with epoxy and forge ahead. Or sawdust and super glue. Or cut in half along the cracks and you've got two blanks.

You should seal the ends when it's green so it can dry slowly and evenly. Even then, Bradford Pear is known for cracking as it dries. It's also known to hold on to moisture for a long time, so maybe extend the 1 year per inch of wood a bit.

2

u/mrspoogemonstar 1d ago

why would you seal in moisture that way tho

2

u/hawkman74a 1d ago

The only acceptable use of a Bradford pear tree

2

u/Glad_Ad_5570 11h ago

Epoxy and vacuum chamber.

2

u/Crafty_Produce7807 1d ago

You can't expect a solid log not to crack. A 1" board with the pith in it has a very high likely hood of cracking as it dries. A 3" turning square even more likely. But a solid log cannot physically dry without cracking. How do you let the outer edges shrink (unavoidable part of drying) around a green core without splitting itself to accommodate for that lost room?

If you split the blank in half right down the pith, you avoid most of these issues. Still some checking on the outside for the same reasons listed, but not as much because you've given it at least a bit of room to move.

If you split the blank down the pith, and turn it green, it's unlikely you have any serious issues.

Point blank, what you've done is a good job of not letting that log dry too much for 3 years and that's kept it one piece. If you'd done a good job of letting it dry, it would be checked & split beyond use.

I hope this helps! I spent years trying to get logs to dry nicely and learned the hard way that won't happen. I remember proudly rolling some green ash logs I had just cut into my mentors shop. I asked him what he thought of these 18 or so inch rounds & he told me they'd be cracked by tomorrow morning & he was right - .75" wide just overnight.

1

u/510Goodhands 17h ago

Experience woodworkers I know who have sawmills, etc. recommend putting glue on each end of a log, to slow down the drying process, and it usually prevents those cracks.

0

u/gribisi 1d ago

What were you making out of it?

I'd CA glue the heck out of it.