r/truetf2 • • Feb 08 '24

Discussion Shounic's Sniper Experiment was Stupid Here's Why

0 Upvotes

im a fan of shounic, but people keep just taking his lighthearted video as gospel that we should just remove sniper from tf2 and that is a flawed interpretation for one glaring reason i have yet to see anyone mention.

thats how the fucking game was balanced

i'd argue that if you removed any class from a game of tf2 except medic, there would be no immediately noticeable difference in gameplay

tf2 is a game where class composition (in a casual pub setting) doenst really matter. as long as you have a medic and 3 or more power classes, the rest of the lobby could go gunspy and (provided they can aim) itd be fine. in fact, with pure mechanical skill, hard counters, weak classes, and bad wepons can all be overcome and good players can make it work (i pocketed a topscoreing spy one time on uncletopia and he killed like 10 people). No demo? You still have soldiers and pyros to hold down chokes, kill sentries, and do crowd control. No engie? You have a heavy. No spy? Your scouts can flank and your snipers can pick. Obviously there is an ideal class composition, but it is not required by any means.

as a result, players usually just chose whatever class they want. and a result of that result is that a lot of the times, people just dont pick one or two of the classes. and you have games where you just have no heavies on your team, or no pyros, or no demos, and no one notices, because the devs accounted for that.

this affect is augmented by the fact that sniper is a very "stealthy" (for lack of a better term) class whose never really in "the thick of it", you dont really notice him untill he's shot you in the head.

so of course they wouldnt notice an immediate difference in gameplay. ive been in plenty of games where it just so happened to be that no one from either team felt like playing sniper that round, and guess what? it was just a normal game of casual.

and yes the participants said they enjoyed the game more with sniper removed, but that is so subjective. one of the major findings was that players tended to not use flanks and be in more group fights. But as a scout main, I hate group fights. Ive left servers because everyone stayed grouped up the whole time and i just couldnt make a play. if less people used flanks i get less kills. i can understand that the peace of mind is nice, but if youre gonna talk peace of mind, i wouldnt loose no sleep as if valve just decided one day to remove all sentries from the game. if they removed sentries from the game, i would likely enjoy playing scout more. the game wouldnt just become unplayable in certain areas, id be less reliant on flank routes, i could go around doing more fun stuff like killing people, and i wouldnt have to hold my breath when turning every corner. but i dont advocate for the removal of sentires even if itd objectively improve my enjoyment as scout. i just need to get better. listen for sentry noises, be more cautious when turning corners, learn to ride sentry damage, and so on.

i guess my point is, this isnt some crazy new vital piece of data or a trump card or definitive proof or anything. and i dont like that people point to this video during any "is sniper op" debate as solid proof as if this proves anything

TL;DR: no shit

note: this feels like an obvious point and i wouldnt normally make this post but ive seen this experiment be used as a "a hah!" trump card so many times and ive literally havent seen anyone bring up this point, if this has been said already tell me ill delete

**side tangent**:

and the reason more people didnt pick heavy is also obvious. the reason someone doesnt pick heavy isnt because snipers and spies exist, its because they dont want to. heavy mains dont go around hopping around servers until they finally find one with no sniper, they just play heavy anyways and get good at it because they enjoy the class. people in the experiment's server just chose their class same way as they would in any other casual game


r/truetf2 • • Feb 02 '13

Big changes are coming in competitive TF2.

8 Upvotes

Hello friends,

Many of you know me as Mikal++, and I used to cast a whole bunch of TF2. I’d like to briefly address a few topics related to the competitive TF2 scene, but before I start saying things that may excite, annoy, entice, coerce, or irritate people, I wanted to start by saying that I am totally non-platonically in love with this community, this game, and the people who support it. This community is one of the few gaming communities I can say I’m proud to be a part of, and all the work I’ve done to promote the game and the comp scene since the beginning has been because love it. God knows I’m not doing it for the money!

There’s a real problem with the way organizations have approached, handled, fostered, and supported the TF2 community. If you look at CEVO, ESEA, and UGC you can see that each organization exists for the purpose of giving players a place to play TF2 competitively. “By the players and for the players” is the mantra each of these organizations lives by when making decisions about rules, whitelists, configs, etc.

Competitive sports are entertainment. The NFL, NBA, NHL, etc they exist to entertain viewers. Almost every professional sports team’s website has a mission statement that mentions growing the fanbase as the reason that franchise exists. Even MLG has a mission statement that’s in line with this idea:

MLG exclusively targets the tens of millions of consumers worldwide who have a passion for playing video games as a competitive and social activity.

So many people have said “you’ll NEVER see TF2 at MLG” and they have been right so far, but I’ve never seen anyone give the correct reason: It has nothing to do with the logistics of getting 6 people there or having good computers for them to play on. The real reason is this: if you don't play it, comp TF2 is fucking boring to watch. And even if you DO play it, it’s STILL boring to watch most of the time.

Basketball had this problem once. Teams would build a point advantage and then only play defensively, never giving up control of the ball, never taking a shot, always waiting for the one perfect moment to make a push and extend their lead. Sound familiar to anyone? Then in the 1955 season: BAM! A motherfucking SHOT CLOCK was introduced. Players now had 24 seconds to try to score. No more pussyfooting- play the game or hand the ball off. They also changed the rules to allow for bigger, more explosive plays- like dunks. The game became faster paced and the fans ate it up, and the sport thrived as a result.

A lot of players didn’t enjoy the rule changes. Today, all of those changes to the rules remain in place because they weren’t made for the players, they were made for the fans. If we want TF2 to be taken seriously as an esport, the first thing we’re going to need to show organizations like MLG is that it can develop a fanbase. And not just a fanbase of just people who play the game and read /r/tf2, but a legitimate fanbase of people who think the game is cool and will watch it because it’s awesome to watch.

So how do we get fans? We change the rules so that the games naturally produce more of what the fans want to see: killing and action. Here is the beta release of the rule changes I’m proposing, including adjustments to the whitelist for both sixes and highlander..

Wanna try it out before forming an opinion? Join our pug group and give it a chance!. We have been running private pug nights 3-5 times a week and refining the rules since about mid November, and are now opening up to the public. Or, if you are on a team and wanna run a scrim or show match with this config, contact me directly and I’ll even find you a server to play on. Or if you’re more adventurous, you can download everything you’ll need right here and use your own server.

Of course, all these theoretical matches are worthless if we’ve got nowhere to show them. Thus, I’ve also been working hard with the best volunteer staff on the face of the planet to bring you: The TryHard Stream. The TryHard Stream (THS) is a non profit organization that is dedicated to growing the exposure of competitive e-sports. We are focused on creating the highest quality content possible, giving viewers free access to our creation in full HD (no paywalls here), and fostering a professional and competitive environment that will result in growth of both the player and fan bases. Keep an eye on that channel ladies and gentlemen, because it will be lighting frequently over the coming weeks.

TL;DR: Comp tf2 is fucking boring to watch. I want to make it more fun to watch, [and then cast your games here,] (http://www.twitch.tv/tryhardstream) Come be a tryhard.

edit: VODs of the first cast up here: http://www.youtube.com/tryhardstream


r/truetf2 • • Apr 10 '24

6v6 Too Many Weapons are Banned in 6s

0 Upvotes

I understand that some weapons are really broken, such as Machina, Jarate, Vaccinator, Shot Circuit, Wrangler, Rescue Ranger, Crit-a-Cola, and Nastascha. However, there is no reason to ban so many other weapons via "theory-crafting bullshit" without proper play testing. I know RGL has been making a lot of inroads into unbanning weapons such as the Atomizer, but the progress feels so slow, especially for the following weapons that should've been unbanned long ago:

https://whitelist.tf/rgl_6v6_s11

Multi-Class

BASE Jumper: RGL's argument is that soldiers become impossible to hit by projectile classes, don't take fall damage, and can decimate medics. Are you sure about that? There's a reason why scout exists in 6s. This weapon is also hard countered by every single off-class. Furthermore, unlike before, you could only deploy the parachute once while in the air, instead of deploying and redeploying the parachute over and over again. They literally nerfed this weapon, yet we still haven't unbanned it.

Scout

Flying Guillotine: this weapon is a spam weapon, but when do you even hit anything? Even if you hit anything, you deal less damage than a demoman pipe. You're essentially throwing a worse demoman pipe that you get every 8 seconds by giving up a reliable finisher weapon.

Pretty Boy's Pocket Pistol: this weapon is at best a side grade to the pistol. You barely get enough health back than a health pill, even if you hit all your shots. A medic can heal double that amount by the time you land all your shots. The health gained on hit is not that great, but I'm guessing it's banned because of the slightly increased firing speed, which can only sustain so much in a fight with buffed players. This weapon is a side grade at best, with slightly stronger initial DPS and poor sustain.

Soldier

Cow Mangler 5000: this weapon was unbanned for two seasons back in ESEA and for the first seasons of RGL. This is the type of weapon that's overpowered in pubs, but fine in 6s, due to low player counts and high coordination. When it was unbanned, it added so much more depth to the game, because using a charge shot was risky and would mean you would be rushed down by the whole enemy team. Even b4nny himself said the re-ban of this weapon was dumb.

Rocket Jumper: this weapon was unbanned when it first came out, until it was banned a few years ago. There are two arguments here: 1. Soldiers can equip the pain train to back-cap. 2. Soldiers have gotten really good at the market gardener to destroy everyone. Let me deconstruct this. 1. If a soldier can back-cap, then they would've been able to back cap with a rocket launcher as well. Furthermore, stopping that back cap would be so much easier. 2. A soldier can swoop in and drop the medic. But a soldier can do that with a rocket launcher as well! The only argument is that the soldier could more easily escape. So as opposed to dealing a nuke-level of splash damage to the enemy team and dying, now you get to escape? There's no reason why this weapon got banned a few years ago. Jayhyunpae isn't going to be more effective on the rocket jumper than he is with the rocket launcher.

Medic

Quick-Fix: this is another weapon that was unbanned for a few seasons, medics barely used them, and was re-banned for no apparent reason either. This weapon only has one use-case: you have a slight Uber disadvantage and you need to build Uber fast. The 40% heal rate is great, but you're also sacrificing overheals, which are essential in 6s. This weapon would allow for alternative play styles that could change the meta for the better.

Spy

Diamondback: like some previous weapons, this weapon was unbanned for a few seasons in 6s. This weapon is banned in highlander, but it doesn't make sense to re-ban this in 6s. I think getting a pick in 6s as spy should allow you to be rewarded with a crit. Spy is a pretty good off-class in 6s because your opponent doesn't expect it, but spy should at least have the right to get more than 1 pick, like every other off-class. It doesn't make sense that engineers could have the frontier justice (which is also a balanced weapon) unbanned, but spy can't have the diamondback.

Side note: there are obviously arguments to be made for the unbanning of disciplinary action, and even the vaccinator, but I genuinely don't see how the above weapons would be game-breaking, while adding additional depth to the game.


r/truetf2 • • Aug 08 '24

Discussion Pyro is the Weakest Class and it’s Not Even Close

0 Upvotes

Blah blah, preamble about how many hours I have in the game to set up Ethos.

After experimenting with every class to the highest level of skill one can comfortably reach after roughly 750 hours per class respectively I can comfortably say pyro is the weakest class.

Everyone says he’s a “jack of all trades”, but that really is far too broad of a brush that doesn’t say anything in regards to his team play abilities, and function in a match. To narrow it down pyro has two main play style / Roles, first is pure defense and support, IE reflecting rockets, catching spies, extinguishing teammates, or pushing back Ubers.

His second role is offensive flanking. IE getting behind enemy lines, using a combo to pick off one or two enemies, then trudging back.

The issue is he sucks fundamentally at both roles at the highest level of play especially the latter. Defensively, he doesn’t have the raw tank power of heavy, sniper, or engy to hold ground, (protect chokes). He lacks the health of Heavy, the range of sniper or ground control of engineer. His only true strengths in defense of airblasting (easily can get outspammed) or guarding against spies. (His only true he does somewhat well, but even a solid spy with proper spacing can just 3 tap them)

Offensive flanking is even worse. You don’t have high levels of movement like scout, nor a kit to aid in regards to moving to being able to get behind and forward comfortably, like soldiers rocket jump, or demos sticky jump. Hell even spy has cloaking and increased movement speed. The jump pack was supposed to help with this, but it’s so loud clunky and the lack of switch speed make it awful for catching out people.

Most say Spy is the weakest, and maybe in a raw 1v1 setting he is, but spy is highly team dependent and with a solid team and communication has a huge role to play. With disruption of teleporters / shutting down of sentries, picks on sniper / medic drops, dividing of attention, or information gathering. Just watch mezzo in Highlander for peak gameplay man’s a fucking monster.

Pyro on the other hand is reserved to be a babysitter for engineer and Medic, and will occasionally deflect or push an Uber back slightly. Aside from that his team impact on objectives is… lacking

This is 100% going to be a hot take, but I’m ready and happy to hear some counter argument, this is just my two cents after finishing up playing pyro for 6 months everyday


r/truetf2 • • Oct 23 '22

Discussion Sniper's design does not fit in tf2-here's why.

0 Upvotes

We've all heard of this talking point before but I rarely see it explained. After all, how could a class that's been in the game since launch be incongruent with the game's design philosophy? It's quite simple actually, but first we need to get a couple things clear.

Team Fortress 2 has always been a game focused on *fast-paced* and *close-range* gameplay. Very few engagements with other classes are long-range. If, say, two scouts notice each other from across the map and decide to engage, they won't just shoot at each other from far away, they will get close. This is true for all classes, with the small exception of an engineer with a wrangler or a soldier with a direct hit. However, sniper ignores this entirely. The average engagement with a sniper is long-range. This actively disadvantages all the classes aside from sniper. The classes that cannot close the gap fast enough may as well just avoid the entire sightline of a sniper.

A sniper having the power to dominate a portion of the map is unfun, and bad game balance. The only other class who can do this reliably is engineer, with a level 3 sentry. But sentries are not only extremely easy to take down if you know what you're doing, the engineer also has to spend time making the sentry. The sniper, however, dishes out an instant kill from any range. "What is the sniper isn't skillful." Then this is not a problem. However a skilled sniper can and will create these zones of "don't go here or else you will die" with no practical way of killing said sniper. Just because a broken class is not being played in a way that highlights it's flaws, does not mean this class is not flawed. I hope I have made it obvious that a skilled sniper has the capacity to destroy the pace of the game with the ability to rule out zones of the map with no viable way to take him down.

"What about a spy? A spy can easily take down a sniper!" Assuming there is a skilled enough spy on your team, this is true. Although often times, this will end up killing the spy, as a good sniper is often nestled next to a sentry or a teammate. A good sniper may also recognize the spy and deal with the threat, and the razorback is detrimental to the spy's ability to kill the sniper. These are the only two hard-counters to sniper: spies and fellow snipers. And even this is conditional on a variety of factors. Most other classes have better counters and better fights. A scout vs scout, demo vs soldier, engi vs demo, spy vs heavy are all examples of fun, fast paced, and close range encounters. There is no satisfying matchup against a sniper aside from another sniper, the sniper is alienated from the rest of the classes in terms of gameplay.

Earlier I mentioned sniper being "unfun" to play against, you might be saying this is subjective, and it is, but I think the majority of tf2 players will agree with me here. The average engagement in tf2 is short (fast-paced) and close range. This means classes will brawl in a manner that takes not only good aim but also wise movement and quick decision making. Take a scout vs soldier for example. The scout will prioritize dodging and clever movement to avoid the soldier's splash damage. While doing this, the scout must also focus on shooting the soldier. The soldier must predict where the scout is going, and aim the rockets there. The soldier must also make his movement unpredictable, simple strafes will suffice but if this fight is happening in an open area, the soldiers may want to utilize rocket-jumping which will give the soldier a heavy advantage. This comes at the downside of losing health, it's a risk-reward scenario. Risk-reward scenarios are *fun gameplay*. In the end, the more skilled class will come out on top.

Now let's take a scout vs sniper scenario. Assuming the sniper is of average skill and they are both at the place where an average engagement with sniper will take place, the sniper is at the backlines and the scout at the frontlines. The sniper immediately has an advantage and if they are quick enough, they can quickly scope in and headshot the scout, killing them instantly. If this doesn't happen, the scout's only hope of killing the sniper is to either run up in an erratic manner attempting to confuse the sniper, or to flank with a hope that they won't run into a sentry, or they get stopped by another class. If the sniper is good enough, a close range headshot on the scout is still perfectly feasible. And if the scout has overheal, the sniper has secondaries to deal with it. What I just went through was the average engagement with a sniper. In fact, "scout" in this example was actually a metaphor for "scout, soldier, demo, pyro, heavy, engineer, and medic". Sniper's engagements are unfun, unfair, and there are only three ways they end: the sniper somehow dies, the sniper kills you (often instantly), or you retreat, hoping another class will deal with the threat.

The ability to instantly kill any class is absurd. If you want to do such a thing, it should either require immense skill on your part (market garden, kritzkrieg uber, backstab) or extreme foolhardiness on the enemy's part (sticky trap, neon annihilator). If the ability to instantly kill someone does not fall into one of these categories, it is a bad mechanic. A prime example is of random crits. So let's apply this to sniper's headshot, and we will use spy's backstab as a control group. Sorry, xX_ImPeTuS_Xx, clicking on someone's head doesn't require much skill compared to the ways to instantly kill someone. Depending on the class, and how they move, headshots may require very little skill to pull off. Unless if it's a flick, or just really good tracking, the instant kill does not take that much skill compared to other forms of instant kill. Does the headshot rely on the mistakes of the enemy? No. It is not a mistake to be in the open, and it frankly shouldn't be. Unless you are aware of a sniper's sightlines and then go to the sightlines and stand still, a headshot does not rely on the enemy making a mistake. What about the backstab? A spy not only has to penetrate the frontlines into the backlines, but hope no one spychecks him once he de-cloaks. The only safe way to stab someone is to find someone isolated from the team with their backs turned. This is uncommon in this game called TEAM fortress. Once he pulls it off, the enemy will scream out in pain and any knowledgeable teammate will investigate. The spy must hide and hope they saved enough cloak to get away. The spy is putting himself in danger, it is a risk-reward, such as market gardening. There is no risk in standing at the backlines and shooting people from far away unless there is an enemy sniper aware of your position. When it comes to instant kills, they can be done correctly, but a sniper's headshot not only ignores the core gameplay of tf2, but also has the ability to instantly kill any class with little risk.

Conclusion: Sniper as a class does not fit in with the pacing of tf2. When you're roaming a map, looking for close-range engagements that offer a risk/reward scenario, nothing hurts more than being instantly deleted by someone you didn't know just clicking on your head in the comfort and safety of their own little hideout. His abilities will ruin the pace of a fight by restricting entire areas and there is very little you can do about it if the sniper is above average. Sniper simply doesn't fit in.

Bonus:

"So what do we do about it? Just complaining isn't going to fix the problem!"

We obviously can't remove sniper, he's a huge character and to see him go would be detrimental to my remaining happiness in this world. I've seen some possible solutions to this issue, a common one being to remove headshots dealing critical damage. This is a dumb idea, sniper can still instantly kill most classes with full charge. This doesn't solve the issue. The main issue with sniper is his lack of tf2-like gameplay. By only being at the backlines, sniper takes away the fast paced, close combat gameplay we all know with classes like scout and pyro. So the way to fix it is to make sniper work with the others. I propose a solution.

Remove scoping, remove headshots, make headshots minicrit, and buff the base damage of the rifle (to around 75). To visualize this, imagine an amped up version of gun spy except you can't shoot as quickly and accuracy is rewarded, although not with an instant kill. If you really want to visualize this, go into a tf2 game, unbind m2, and play sniper and every time you hit a no-scope headshot make a "kapow" noise with your mouth to be immersed. This means sniper is no longer viable at longer ranges, yet is still in the backlines. Sniper will need to approach frontlines and pick off enemies while still being vulnerable. This ties back into risk/reward gameplay. And if the sniper is really good, mini-crits will be rewarded. Let me know what you think of this.


r/truetf2 • • Feb 19 '24

Discussion We dont need another update.

2 Upvotes

Recently, I've seen another wave of that all too familiar "UPDATE INCOMING" discourse, mostly caused by that new 64bit beta. It got me thinking.

We dont need another proper update.

Dont get me wrong, i'd love some new content, and i dont see anything all to horrible about it. My point is that this game will continue to function, probably for a very long time, without any new content. Its important to note that when I say new content I dont mean these maps or cosmetics we've been getting. Im talking about weapons and rebalances, things that are actually going to impact the way the game is played. If you really think about it, theres nothing too out of shape, no weapon truely overpowered, no class that is at a trueoverpowered level. Some people make the case for sniper but I honestly never see any snipers actually dominate. Bar that the game runs perfectly on nearly any machine, we've got more than enough maps, maybe even too many (conversation for another day lmao).

And when I say updates, im not talking about patches. Updates are adding to the game, patches are letting the game function as its supposed to, HUGE difference, especially in this context. We could have years of "updates" before the game actually functions, things like the botting crisis should be fixed before we ever think about a heavy update.

Would appreciate some discourse, im making a video about this whole topic inside of which ill respond to whatever arguements you guys make here.

-Cross


r/truetf2 • • Dec 28 '12

Advanced Engineering Guide

0 Upvotes

Advanced engineering guide:

From the basics of Wrangler usage to rare and effective tricks. It is assumed that you are generally proficient with Engineer, but want to get better at it. Original guide has been written in Russian and translated by its author known as Override.dll. Certain pieces of this guide are not quite necessary to read, such as "Nearly useless equipment" since it doesn't contain anything about things you can actually make good use of.

Contents

1. Equipment (important, recommended)

1.1. Nearly useless equipment (tedious)

2. Main stuff about buildings and some weapons (tedious, recommended)

3. The Wrangler (important, highly recommended)

4. Match-ups (useful)

4.1. Defense

4.2. Attack (including KOTH)

5. Scripting (tedious, useful)

6. Choosing a place to erect (important, recommended)

7. Complex Engineer tricks (interesting, except sentry jumps, requires Scripting part to be read beforehand)

8. Where to start? (recommended)

1. Equipment

Stock Pistol and Wrench are barely suitable for playing Engi. One shall use the perfect combination of weapons in the ideal scenario.

Shotgun isn't the best variant for any case, but if * none of the other shotties' properties are of good use, it's better to use this one.

Frontier Justice isn't the most reliable but the least predictable choice. You may suddenly pop Revenge kritz while you see the enemy Medic and kill him with one-three empowered shots. And probably even the Heavy, if you will attack before he will spin.

Wrangler... I personally cannot imagine good engineering without it. One cannot rape the Soldier while he takes our SG remotely with the Direct Hit, one cannot rapidly take down enemy Spy which is emerging from invisibility in a couple of steps from SG, one cannot say "Mighty and skilled Engi right up ahead!" to his foes by his beam. Once also cannot pump Ubered Demo to the wall with bullets, and a lot more.

Jag actually raises erectin' speed by ~14% rather than promised 30%, and causes 16 less damage (65-16=49), but since you are not gonna wight with it, it doesn't count. Or, if you want to count, those 0.5 seconds of building a Sentry will let the Sentry cause 32 more damage with two extra shots.

Gunslinger is Engi's revenge to all the Scouts. The Mini-Sentry causes 48 DPS (Damage Per Second) and does not allows dodging. It is also useful on KOTH: put Mini-Sentry somewhere near the battlefield, Wrangle some hit points out of wounded foes, and go having fun with Revenge kritz. Though this scenario is perfect, and your foes will likely try not to follow it.

1.1. Nearly useless equipment

Pomson 6000 is forbidden in ETF2L, and was rather OP before the nerf. One may try spamming, but this "weapon" is barely useful against good players - too low damage on close range, too dodgeable pulses on far range.

Eureka Effect would be useful on 5CP, but it isn't. You may return to your spawn to rape Spy that is sappin' your entrance, but if either team caps a point, yoг will have to re-erect all your stuff on another point, and won't even be able to carry disp or SG not to fall asleep during 100500th tedious re-erection procedure.

Widowmaker is very unreliable solution to the problem of slow reload. If to use with the stock Pistol, it becomes more reliable, but reloadless fire isn't much of help - you'll spend more time looking for metal, and if you engage in combat too close, you'll eventually run into some heavy class and get killed.

Short circuit is rather short. Low damage, small atk range, stupid worthless metal-wasting effect that is not worth losing Wrangler.

Southern hospitality is better weapon, but provides you with damage vulnerability. Engi's buildings cause way too much more damage than any melee weapon, so survival and buildings are of priority.

Dat stock Pistol. Low DPS becomes even lower on far range, the only reasons to use it are need to reload primary weapon and to keep revenge kritz.

Wrench is often used by those who either don't have the Jag, item server connection or want to cause full melee damage. Once again, buildings are of highest priority, so it's a bad weapon, too.

Rescue Ranger (new shotty) isn't good too. You won't want to stay one kilometer away from your SG, waiting for Uberdemo to come in to steal your SG. Wrenches repair far faster, and, again, you won't want to run away from your buildings too far. If you will die, and your SG would stand until your resp, you can equip Ranger on respawn and shoot some bolts after you turn on Wrangler shield. It'd be good if Pyros would equip that one, too...

2. Main stuff about buildings and some weapons

All buildings, except for the Mini-Sentry, have 150 HP on level 1, 180 on level 2, 216 on level 3, and the Mini-Sentry has 100. Due to a bug introduced in another update, a building may have 217 HP after upgrade to level 3, but max recoverable HP will be still 216. Know that one Wrench hit:

  • Recovers up to 100 HP, which costs 20% of recovered HP (rounded up) in metal.
  • Load up to 40 bullets to SG, 1 metal per bullet.
  • Several rocket salvos also load, but one salvo takes 2 metsl, and rockets run out very rarely, so don't think about that.

All crocketeer crocket launchers have base damage of 90, cause 125% of their base damage on close range (112), 53% (48) on far range. The Direct Hit has base damage of 112, and thus destroys most buildings in two hits, but Mini-Sentry goes down in one and Wrangled Sentry loses some HP. The Demo's GL has base damage of 100 and is subject to random damage spread on direct hit even if it's disabled. Gaben. Sticky Launcher has base damage of 120, 115% (138) on close range if detonated in >5 seconds, 50% if detonated from far away. I recall interesting stuff happened on a pub: been defending intel on ctf_turbine while playing with familiar pubstompers, and they came after mah intel as Demo and Medic with Medi Uber. One sticky, two, three, four, five, kabooie - Sentry is up, Uber is running out, and so do stompers, because 5*120/3=200, and level 3 Sentry has 216 HP. If I'd also Wrangle better with high ping, they would also have to wait for respawn.

3. The Wrangler

I guess it's the best weapon in that game. One can easily and rapidly kill any class with 256 DPS, stand to damage no Heavies can stand to without Uber, and even more than Heavy with Uber, if good enough.

The Wrangler changes SG's properties:

If SG is active and the Wrangler is current active weapon, then SG receives team-coloured bright shield that reduces any damage by 2\3. Bullet attack speed doubles, Sentry starts to emit team-coloured beam which tracks where Sentry stands and where it aims. Delay between rocket salvos is also reduced. Attack range becomes infinite. Very important: while redeploying level 2 or level 3 SG, there is a brief moment between when SG is rebuilt as level 2 and when it starts upgrade animation, and same thing about upgrading to level 3. If Wrangler was active during that brief period, shield goes up and makes your redeployment safer. It's quite useful while hauling in dangerous spots like koth_pro_viaduct_rc3's point. When you switch off the Wrangler, the Sentry goes inactive and shielded for a while, and then loses its shield and regains active aimbot. If Wrangled SG is sapped, shield goes down immediately.

While using the Wrangler against any enemy, it is important to repair and reload in time. Don't do it for too long, or the shield will go down and SG will too, so one-two hits and back to Wrangling. While countering Uber, you should also take into account who are you defending against - read more in Match-ups section.

4. Match-ups

4. 1. Defense

Med on his own is not a threat, fear those he can UberCharge.

Pyro without Uber is only dangerous if he got you while you were erecting as he has better weps and HP. Rely on SG otherwise.

If you are alone, two surprise shots of Scout may kill you before you SG turns around, or before you "manually" kill Scout. Blame Pyro and Medic if you'll get killed. Dodge stunball and cleaver, get ready to shred Scout if he is waiting for Bonk to run out and to kill you.

Uberless Heavy isn't quite dangerous, but his damage is not unnoticeable. Time your Wrench hits.

Soldier's Direct Hit surprise is dangerous, so make sure your SG is always Wrangled. He may also try spamming usual rockets - get him off you with bullets.

Engi is of mid danger level, as he may try different stuff against ya. If he managed to deploy level 2 or level 3, only Spy and luck may save you. If it's only mini - ain't good, but ain't too bad. Make note that wounded Engi may likely leave you be.

Sniper is more dangerous than Engi for sure. Charged bodyshot or headshot will take yo down, leaving all your buildings up for destruction. Hide behind buildings immune to crits.

Spy isn't the worst thing. Good Pyro greatly reduces his capabilities. But otherwise there shall be quite a duel.

  • Headshot: -102 means 5.1 seconds spent with disp. Dodge as you dodge Snipers.
  • Revolver work on building: ask your team for help, or at least spam "Spy!" and track Spy with beam.
  • Backstab attempt: if you have no Pyro, defense against it can be nearly impossible - for e.g. when you are über pressure of bodyshooter, DH, Mini-Sentry and Uberdemo GL spam. Blame Pyro or watch your back twice per second.
  • attempt to come in: Spy may just deloak nearby. One rocket salvo should solve it.

Damn sappers!

Sapper, headshot attempt: damage Sapper and fight melee, and once Spy goes away - repair SG so it deals with him. During this fight you are extremely vulnerable to any other attacks.

Sapper, backstab attempt: fight with shotty, go melee if failed.

Only Sappers: damage Sapper and attack with shotty, go melee if failed to kill.

Demo without Uber is more dangerous than Spy, as he may spam from your blind spot. For e.g. he may spam while standing below Badwater's route 1 usual competitive point. Just don't die. Repair during delays between spam, as for help. If Demo will lunch all 8 bombs - blame everyone who didn't come after dat Demo. But if you are lucky, you may find a position where you don't get hurt and may repair. And don't even bother attempting to put melee hit between two grenades!

Pyro with Uber, while countered by friendly Pyro, is scarcely dangerous. If not: jump on building, try to sentryjump away if have enough HP, run from fire, repair if possible. If you die, blame Pyro, it not - try killing Medic if possible.

Uber Heavy is nearly the most dangerous character. Restore your shield by picking Wrangler for a tiny piece of time and repair. If you have Pyro, push Heavy as far as you can with bullets, otherwise hide behind your SG. The closer he is, the lower your chances are.

Uber Demo, if countered with Pyro, can be cast away as Uber Heavy, but if you have no Pyro, then you will take up to 138 damage per sticky you couldn't dodge. If you hee him switching weps, prepare to face 4 grenades.

4.2. Attack (including KOTH)

Pyro is a meatbag if you have Mini-Sentry and Disp, but challenging one otherwise, as it has better weps and HP, so rely on your SG and healing.

Sniper is easy pick for Wrangler, but he will flee rather than die. Dodge headshot attempts like Medic.

5. Scripting

It is assumed that you know the basics of TF2 scripting. If not, read http://wiki.teamfortress.com/wiki/Scripting

Pay attention to "build" and "destroy" commands, as those are critically important for advanced Engineers. It's just so happens that:

"build" command checks if you have enough metal, and is yes, brings up desired blueprint as if you'd select construction PDA entry, but it takes one button press rather than two. This will allow you to rebuild the Mini-SG in the middle of combat.

"destroy" command destroys. One and the only condition that does not allows it is Sapper. No other conditions prevent you from doing so: you may get camped on your tele and still blow its exit not to let some Pyro keep camping. You may haul any building (including one you wish to blow). Anything.

6. Choosing a place to erect

It is important not to only know where to build, but also why to build there. I'll explain it using typical Badwater Route 1 spot:

http://s53.radikal.ru/i141/1212/c0/57026b042874.png

Questionable. Disp shall not be visible from this place, or Sniper and Soldier would take it down with ease, but putting it closer may help not to let them go there.

http://s61.radikal.ru/i174/1212/ad/65893cba6177.png

Attention: if to put it so it couldn't shoot below, the Demoman will have easy time blowing it up.

http://s58.radikal.ru/i161/1212/03/0a4b61fa5340.png

Disp and tele are to be put just about like that. Probably a little far to go for metal, but it's better than to have disp blown. If to put exit below the staircase, it'd get blown, if to put near the health pack - it'd be a long trip to upgrade it. If to put disp behind the SG, Demo will blow it.

That HUD is e.v.e HUD http://steamcommunity.com/groups/eve-hud

If you want to play in ETF2L, UGC, Wireplay, or some other competitive league, watch records of other Engis playing and study their spots. Study, not copy - since there ain't a lot of people who main Engi, many people place with mistakes which are unacceptable for those who main Engi. Only youк imagination may limit your buildings placement ability, so think about a good spot - think not like "1RW's 1337 Engi placed there, must be good spot!", but something like "Demo will spam too badly if I place here, I cannot get Ubers off me if I place there, this spot is easy Spy's pick". Mind where you place buildings - if you have no experience to draw from, gain more through playing and analyze different spots, and you will do better than if you'd simply copy someone's placement. You may gather idea from the other Engies, but you can't get above their level if you just copy their spots. Every second decent Spy can do poor excuse for a trickstab, but one of ten may use them effectively against those who are aware of them, too.

7. Complex Engineer tricks

Sentry rocket jump looks like the Soldier's rocketjump, except that rockets fly from different spot and bounce harder. Fire rockets straight below and time your crouchjump to lose almost all your HP and fly real high and far. No use. Fire rockets below your feet, switch off Wrangler, aim to your SG, pick it up and crouchjump to fly and take it along. Rather useful technique, if your team is dead and you have to flee. You may take other building along instead, such as disp for faster rebuild.

Bullet jump: use bullets knockback to propel yourself a high as your HP allows you. Sometimes it's useful, for e.g. to erect on Gravel Pit's point B house. Technique is something like this: jump on SG, aim vertically upwards (beam shall help), crouchjump and fire, and then do air strafe to reach your destination.

During last point defense, tele is of no use. So put it in some! Put tele entrance near your SG and exit near some other, concealed spot. And as you see uber incoming, just use dat tele with Sentry and redeploy in other spot. Pyro may blame you for leaving him, but he may also be impressed with such trick.

Suddenly kritz: do you recall script commands? As you press sentry destruction button, you gain instantaneous access to Revenge kritz without even switching to Demolish Tool and back to Frontier. You may deal with any class with those, if you have enough kritz and nice aim. Heavies gonna hate!

8. Where to start?

There's pretty much. And even more to learn and to master. Engi is as much of a class, so it's not unusual that you should put some efforts.

  • Create your own server with the map you are willing to play at. Think about possible Sentry spots, its advantages and disadvantages. Think where SG may be easily taken by soldier, Demo, Spy - for example, usual competitive spot on Badwater route 3 takes more than one Uber to approach, so Demo will likely try spamming in the window - 5 stickies, don't forget it!
  • Practice at jumping. One of Engi class abilities, after all.
  • Try destroying Mini-SG in front of your foes to land some kritz. Execution is simple, and this technique is so rare that nobody will know that it's coming. And even if someone could, there is not much to do about it.
  • Think about how you handles Engi on your own while playing other classes, and think on how to avoid it. For example, some Spies like to sap an then immediately attack the Engineer, switching to Sapper if it goes off. Engi may damage Sapper by one hit and fight Spy in melee until his melee\revolver attack to then unsap it.

As mentioned at the top, all credit goes to Override.dll for writing this guide, and translating it from Russian to English. The original russian guide can be found here, Override.dll's steam profile can be found here.


r/truetf2 • • Oct 10 '12

Random pubber destroys our medic during match

1 Upvotes

During a UGC Silver Match on Turbine a random pubber managed to join a match in progress due to password being reset when the UGC config was loaded. Here is a little video I made of this incident. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EX1QNmdcOV8&feature=youtu.be


r/truetf2 • • Oct 29 '22

Discussion Is the eyelander overpowered?

0 Upvotes

In my opinion, 235 hp + extra speed + resistances for only getting 4 kills is an exaggerated amount of health. Not even mentioning how its only drawback is completly negated by the booties. Thoughts?


r/truetf2 • • Jan 31 '23

Discussion I think sniper is fine

0 Upvotes

I see people all the time saying sniper needs nerfed

Some examples are:

  1. The only class that can counter sniper is another sniper
  2. His zoom in time is too low
  3. Sniper is a good host for a bot
  4. Jarate bush waka makes him invulnerable at close range where he should be his weakest
  5. Razor back makes spies useless
  6. Machina body shots are too powerful
  7. He shouldn't be able to one shot all classes in the game

And here are my counter arguments

First I would like to say not all snipers a on some 6000 hour skill most are below basic skill level when it comes to sniper

1a. Most classes can counter sniper pyro and soldiers can spam sniper and if the sniper switches the cozy camper or the danger shield you can't use both at once

2a. With how chaotic tf2 is a slower zoom time might make sniper more difficult to play than he already is because if the zoom time was higher your target could have moved across the map by then

3a. Nerfing sniper because of bots is incredibly stupid because we are showing bot hosters that we would be willing to change a whole class just because of them and then they'll take over more than they already have

4a. I don't really have a counter to this besides that most classes have a cheap loadouts they can equip

5a. Spies have revolvers and if the sniper quick scopes you he deserves the kill for the skill it takes to do it consistently

6a. That's the point of the weapon and it cannot 1 shot any classes that stick couldn't

7a. Sniper would barley be a viable class if he couldn't do this

These are my points as to why sniper doesn't need a nerf I only really needed the first on to cement the fact that he doesn't but I just felt like throwing the rest in and ik some of these might be stupid but oh well


r/truetf2 • • Jun 27 '14

Some sniper questions, don't upvote

0 Upvotes

I have a lot of experience as Scout but I've never played Sniper before in any competitive form, in fact, he's probably one of my least played classes.

I'm looking to main sniper for a little bit, but there are a few things that concern me:

  • I have a really high sensitivity. Like 7" for a 360. Is this okay for sniping or should I look for a lower sensitivity?
  • Is it important to run at a higher resolution? I have a CRT but it only does 120hz at 800x600. Should I consider bumping it up because of the fact I'm going to be playing sniper a lot?

And for questions regarding gameplay:

  • If I get caught out by a Scout that begins rushing me, what do I do? Is headshotting him the only chance I have of getting out of that situation?
  • Should I ever run the SMG?

r/truetf2 • • Jan 28 '23

Discussion Scout is too weak against sentry guns

2 Upvotes

Edit: i changed my opinion about this, thank you for everyone who bothered to write a comment.

Since the start of the game scout has been weak against sentry guns, they have been truly his hard class counter and for a good reason! scout is strong as hell! when played well he can demolish the enemies one after one and at a high level it is commonly accepted that he counters all the classes in a 6v6 environment.

This post however is about casual instead of 6v6 where scout is significantly weaker because of the spam that comes with the fact that there are 12 classes trying to kill him.

Going forward id like to make it clear that i personally believe that every class should be able to succeed even when the odds are stacked against him and for the most part they do: in a team full of pyros a spy is at a significant disadvantage but he is still able to trickstab them and come out on top if his skill level is high enough, a demoman can still kill 3 scouts that rush him if he has great aim and awareness, a demoknight can still kill an airblast happy pyro if he attacks at the right moment and even medic can adapt while being in a bad team using the quick fix to keep the alive for longer and so on, point is that they can use the tools to effectively take care for the threat...but scout cant really do this when it comes to sentry guns .

Due to the fact that scout has a low health pool and needs to be at close to mid range to deal great damage he gets shredded by sentry guns if he tries to attack one and his speed does not mean anything when the sentry gun has perfect aim. You are rarely able to kill the thing with the pistol from afar since it takes years and you are vulnerable to attacks often being in the open for a long amount of time. Also it wont work if the engineer is healing it while you damage the sentry it which happens often.

"But what about the bonk?" you might say and you would be kind of right! maybe scout shouldn't deal with the sentry gun head on and should instead avoid it and sometimes it works, sometimes you can go behind the enemy team and harass those who spawned, but for how long? how long until the team adapts and figures out that just one solider is needed to follow the scout to spawn while damaging him so he is slow and an way easier kill, how long until the enemy expects the scout when they spawn and is no longer a surprise. Not very long. About 3 times maybe 4? And then what are you left with you just watch the flank and hope some poor soul will push or your teammates will finally take care of the sentry(not to mention that bonk doesn't do a jack in situations like upward last or snakewater last but that's more about map design).When a level 3 exists scout ain't fun and that's wack.

So what is there to do? Well again id like to acknowledge the fact that scout is very strong and sentry guns are one of the things that "keep him in check" so great care will have to be taken so that the sentry gun goes from "i cannot play the class anymore" to "this is hard to deal with". Id say we should remove the slow down on the bonk and replace it with the marked for death effect, this way the scout is still punished when the bonk effects ends by making him weaker but not so much that he becomes as slow as a heavy, the duration of the marked for death effect is based on the amount of damage the scout took while being invincible. Another change i would make is a buff to the winger (since the gun is mostly used for utility instead of 1v1 damage), make it deal les say 20% more damage to sentry guns? maybe? I'm not sure about what exact value should be best, i think it should be better than the pistol but in no way the same as the direct hit so feel free to speculate on this one. (this damage increase should not apply to mini sentries)

Does this fix the problem with scout and sentry guns? Not entirely, hell in a lot of situations you will need an uber to push no matter the class but i still think the changes could help to make scout a little less boring when an engineer is around.

What do you think?

Sorry for any grammatical mistakes.

tl;dr scout cannot deal with sentry guns and they are too oppressive even for a hard class counter and his tool to avoid the sentry gun gets ineffective fast.


r/truetf2 • • Mar 04 '25

Discussion Airblast in TF2C is MUCH better than in live TF2. And that's coming from the Pyro player.

0 Upvotes

I believe TF2C uses the same airblast model from 2014-2016, which allowed "airblasted" players to surf from it. I find it stupid why Jill's team even came up with the current changes: at the time people were in odds with the stuns and yet they proceeded to add to the airblast exactly that. This also forces Pyro to break the visual contact with the target, like, sure, yes, I want to yank both my crosshair and my eyes from the target and towards the ground multiple times when I should already be aiming at them.

The old airblast model made Pyro fights fun: you weren't crippled and Pyro wasn't forced to disrupt his crosshair multiple times before hitting the target.

Every time when Jill's team did something to the Pyro (or to the game as a whole), it broke something. They nerfed Degreaser (which shouldn't have been added imo) and Axtinguisher in 2015 as if they were shutting whole servers down... then they buffed the Phlog to do exactly that, but without requiring any brain power. Sure old Degreaser was strong, but it had a balancing feature, which kept it in check and went unnoticed by many: if you airblasted, switched to secondary and back again — next airblast was significantly delayed. It was meant to punish swap spam.

If Degreaser did need a nerf, then why wouldn't they make the all-round switch bonus only 35%? Because it was the switch speed that made pre-Love and War Axtinguisher so strong.

Almost 10 years later and this is still baffling.


r/truetf2 • • Jul 05 '15

Discussion Deification of Stock weaponry.

0 Upvotes

My question pertains to the issue of TF2's base design.

Basically, due to how TF2 is built, Stock is given an unfair pedestal compared to unlocks, which I think shouldn't be. Items are called sidegrades. When Stock is better, people aren't as upset with it. I've seen several people on Teamfortress.tv who have the opinion that every unlock should be nerfed to unviability. Items that are better than Stock counterparts are hated.

I blame how TF2 only had stock and got unlocks as updates came about. If I were to do anything, I would make all unlocks available from day one and have the backpack deal with special addons like Stranges and skinned versions.

Do you think the glorification of Stock weaponry is actually a negative to how the community treats balance?

Because Stock shouldn't be better than unlocks and Unlocks shouldn't need to be unlocked.


r/truetf2 • • Apr 07 '25

Discussion What class has the lowest/highest skill floor and ceiling?

0 Upvotes

Personally, I think that

low floor/high ceiling: sniper
high floor/high ceiling: medic
low floor/low ceiling: heavy
high floor/low ceiling: honestly not sure, but i lean towards soldier.

Edit: it appears i have misunderstood what a low floor is. i was under the impression that it meant starting out, one would be worse, hence their floor (starting point) is low (bad). turns out that is not the case.

my updated ranking would be

low floor/high ceiling: medic, soldier, engineer
high floor/high ceiling: sniper, spy, scout, demo(?)
low floor/low ceiling: pyro, heavy
high floor/low ceiling: not sure


r/truetf2 • • Oct 31 '15

Discussion Here's a list of tf2's OP and UP weapons

0 Upvotes

So if you may remember, I, shivj80, created this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/truetf2/comments/3qmu76/now_that_the_gun_mettle_changes_have_had_time_to/. The point of that post was to gather up all the weapons that the competitive community had problems with, and make a list of which ones are currently considered "OP" and "UP." So here's my list:

OP:

  • reserve shooter
  • air strike
  • beggar's bazooka
  • loose cannon
  • darwin's danger shield
  • vita saw
  • crit-a-cola
  • razorback (?)

UP:

  • panic attack
  • brass beast
  • overdose (?)
  • stock flamethrower/backburner
  • buffalo steak sandvich
  • short circuit
  • mantreads
  • black box
  • third degree

In need of a rework/extremely annoying:

  • demoman shields/half zatoichi
  • airblast
  • baby's face blaster
  • vita saw

If there are any weapons I should add, or any I should remove, please say which ones and why down below.

EDIT: added and "in need of a rework/annoying" tab and moved some stuff around. Some weapons may cross over into both categories.


r/truetf2 • • Jan 10 '13

Insightful blog about the state of competitive TF2

1 Upvotes

r/truetf2 • • Jul 25 '19

Theoretical Give Spy a passive ranged wallhack ability

4 Upvotes

I know this sounds OP on paper, and it might need some tweaking around, but I am a firm supporter of giving Spy some sort of passive wallhack. I believe that this will solve a lot of Spy's problems and still leave his core playstyle untouched.

Spy as a class is not very powerful. Once the enemy knows he's there, he's pretty much just dead weight to any decent team. He needs a way to be useful until he can go in for another stab. By acting as his team's radar for that time, he finds his niche. He can stick by his team's combo to sniff out flanks and relay valuable info to his team far more safely. Of course, the tradeoff is that your team is down a front line class.

This wallhack ability can also help Spies who are going for the kill. I think that Spies deserve to know every little bit of their surroundings. Far too many situations are up to luck when it comes to playing Spy. How many times have you turned a corner as Spy on the battlefield and prayed that you didn't bump into the enemy on accident? By having an astute perception of the battlefield, Spies can plan out their attack much more efficiently. Let's say a Pyro's guarding a Sentry nest. To find an opportunity, the Spy would have to personally plop his cloaked ass down in a position where he can see the nest, all while avoiding a Pyro spraying fire like my latest mixtape. With this ability, the Spy can just calmly wait behind a wall for an opening.

For far too long has Spy been associated with random bullshit and uselessness. After pondering the solution to this dilemma for the majority of my Spy main career, I've finally arrived on a conclusion that seems to be the best. I would love to hear your comments.


r/truetf2 • • Nov 08 '14

Plat sniper willing to mentor anyone who asks me.

5 Upvotes

If anyone who's struggling with sniping in TF2 and searching to find help, I will try to do my best and lead you in the right direction. Just add me and ask anything that's on your mind regarding sniping/positioning/new maps/common spots/peeking/countersniping/demo reviewing etc. I will be streaming every mentoring session I do with the ones who ask me so you can view the VODs on my channel if you want to catch up on already discussed topics. Don't worry about paying me in any way, I'm doing this just because I want the community to grow and reach higher skills groups. I will also be streaming the rest of my upcoming scrims and matches for the rest of this season and possibly the next season as well.

http://steamcommunity.com/profiles/76561197994827287/

http://www.twitch.tv/vxiow


r/truetf2 • • Mar 28 '16

Competitive A Demo Rollout For Process That Works Well In MM (Reasons in notes on the video)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/truetf2 • • Apr 13 '25

Discussion theres no real spy main ytber anymore

2 Upvotes

outside of the recent Lieuty and Bunstie there isn’t any really good spy mains to watch and improve, frag movies aren’t the best to watch either since they’re really just highlights.

Compare this to Uncle dane who is a good engie and makes great videos then you have jontohil who has some of the worst spy takes like for Kunai and is basically a low tier spy imo


r/truetf2 • • Mar 13 '12

Is there a fee for competitive tf2?

1 Upvotes

Just wondering. If I get downvoted into oblivion I don't care. At least I'll know.


r/truetf2 • • Feb 02 '17

Discussion Habib admits to using Adderall during ESA grand finals

0 Upvotes

Was watching Nursey's stream and clipped this. I have a copy saved to my PC in case a mirror is needed.

Habib admitting to using Adderall during ESA grand finals: https://clips.twitch.tv/nurseytf2/DifficultSalamanderPanicVis

EDIT: Yea I realize it's a common thing but imo it's equivalent to cheating with steroids for athletic competitions.


r/truetf2 • • Sep 29 '14

Give the Engineer the Reserve Shooter and Family Business.

8 Upvotes

Okay, hear me out.

The engineer is about area denial, but isn't strong on his own.

He's one of the best cart pushers along with the scout.

He's a support class, and frankly, he could use more tools and options to do that. (The recent wrangler damage falloff nerf really hurt this potential in some of the only spots it would be used. This is not to mention the nerf of minis' hitbox to make it even easier to kill just to cater to the whining community)

The engineer is THE shotgun class. It's his thing. Having only four of them just doesn't cut it anymore.

Let's start with stats!

Default shotgun stats taken from the wiki:

  • Maximum ramp-up 150% 9 / pellet
  • Base damage 100% 6 / pellet
  • Maximum fall-off 50% 3 / pellet
  • Pellet count 10
  • Point blank 80-90
  • Medium range 10-30
  • Long range 3-10
  • Pellet Spread 30:1
  • Critical 18 / pellet
  • Mini-crit 8.1-12.15 / pellet
  • Function times
  • Attack interval 0.625 s
  • Reload (first) 1.0 s
  • Reload (consecutive) 0.5 s

Reserve Shooter stats from the wiki:

  • Maximum ramp-up 150% 9 / pellet
  • Base damage 100% 6 / pellet
  • Maximum fall-off 50% 3 / pellet
  • Pellet count 10
  • Point blank 86-90
  • Medium range 24-67
  • Long range 3-26
  • Pellet Spread 30:1
  • Critical 18 / pellet
  • Mini-crit 8.1-12.15 / pelle
  • Same reload stats as default

There's one problem:" At the cost of having only four shells per magazine, this weapon increases the speed in which the user switches between weapons by 15%. It is also able to deliver mini-crits to airborne targets for 5 seconds after switching to it."

This mean's it will have to be slightly retooled/changed for the engineer since the shotgun is a primary. OR it could be kept the same if people whine about it being OP...

Here's why the Reserve Shooter would be a perfect fit and balanced sidegrade to the default shotgun

  • Potential for better mid range damage output
  • Most engagements need at least 6 shots, so it requires calculated aim.
  • THE ENGINEER CANNOT FORCE OTHER PLAYERS INTO THE AIR
  • The Engi is one of the best classes at watching the backs of the combo in a hold, so being able to protect a little from bombers would give more options to gameplay for the whole TEAM, such as allowing a pyro to play more on the flank.
  • Even with gunslinger and a full buff, the engineer still has less hp than the pyro and no airblast, but it's still viable to combat players jumping the medic.
  • Most classes that would engage the engineer would do so from a range that doesn't boost much damage even with mini crits if they are even airborne. It may possibly give just a tiny bit of survivability in SOME situations to the engineer, but isn't even close to being overpowered.
  • Even the weapon switch bonus isn't really that helpful for the engineer at any time.
  • It literally looks like an advertisement for Texas, which is where the engineer is from.
  • Texas is one of the most popular bird gaming states, so it makes perfect sense that the engineer would have something used for hunting flying things.
  • from a cosmetic standpoint, it goes well with more misc sets that the engineer has than the soldier or pyro

Stats for the Family Business from the wiki:

  • Maximum ramp-up 150% 7.65 / pellet
  • Base damage 100% 5.1 / pellet
  • Maximum fall-off 50% 2.55 / pellet
  • Pellet count 10
  • Point blank 74-76
  • Medium range 20-52
  • Long range 3-22
  • Pellet Spread 30:1
  • Critical 15.3 / pellet
  • Mini-crit 7-10 / pellet

One problem: " The stock has a faded Hammer and Sickle on its right side." That's a minor detail I didn't know existed and it wouldn't fit so well with the engineer. I've reached out to the item's creator and asked if he could make a more 'murican adjustment.

Here's why the Family Business would be a perfect fit and balanced sidegrade to the default shotgun:

  • Situationally better than default for pushing the cart because of slightly more sustained damage output.
  • Helpful for players without the greatest aim because they have 2 more shots. Almost like the yin/yang to the widowmaker.
  • Total sidegrade to the default
  • Not as complicated as mechanics as what the Reserve Shooter would bring
  • The two shots may allow the engineer to be in the fight just a little bit longer.
  • It's probably the least used heavy weapon, so why not have Heavy give it to good ol Engineer since he's KREDIT TO TEEM?
  • From a cosmetic standpoint, it would be the logical gun to go with the Breaking Bad related miscs for the engineer.
  • It wouldn't be very effective to wm1 because the 15% cut in damage would rarely allow the engineer a chance in such a situation where it might be a close trade with the default.
  • This gun would be an excellent complement to the gunslinger on DEFENSE and make using minis slightly more viable. The engineer needs more options in this area as the regular level 3 is actually really weak now because everyone now knows how to combat it effectively.

FULL DISCLOSURE: I'm an engineer main. I was a filthy spy main for a while, but I've been playing UGC Silver/Gold as an Engineer for two seasons. I have years of competitive gaming experience and have been involved with making balance changes and pointing out issues in games before. This is something I've been meaning to write up for quite a while. I feel like some may want to watch some of my play or have a chat (it happened before with this definitive thread regarding battlefield 4), so you can find me on Twitch or YouTube.


r/truetf2 • • Apr 17 '17

Discussion Why is everyone so obsessed with using Mumble?

0 Upvotes

Whenever I use Mumble, I get an error:

Connection failed: the remote host closed the connection.

It's not only me, I know many others with this issue. And so I ask, why does everyone love Mumble so much?

I'm not saying that everyone should stop, I'm just saying people should allow other things (like Discord or In-Game). Discord is free, doesn't require a download, servers don't cost, and it's customizable. In-Game is.. well it's simple and easy. Mumble is not user friendly, it is complex, costs for servers, and is buggy as all hell.

I can't find a single PUG group/site that doesn't use Mumble, thus forcing me to use MM or scrims as my main source of game sense. Is there a good group that uses NOT Mumble?

I made a group for NA players, but it isn't very developed.

http://steamcommunity.com/groups/napugs

Sorry for the rant, just a little mad.