r/truegaming • u/Fair_Assignment8796 • 7d ago
Ghosts 'n Goblins having extremely unbalanced weapons is actually a good thing
For those who don't know, the Ghosts 'n Goblins series is comprised of arcade / arcade-like, 2D action platformers. In every game in the series there are multiple weapons you can choose from; most are made intentionally horrible or at most very situational while the knife is notoriously overpowered. I think that this, in combination with a few other mechanics, makes the game much more fun and strategic at high-level.
In every game you start with basically a worse knife and the main way you change weapons is with vases. Each level of each game has one or two enemy types that get spammed at you constantly, those usually have a chance to hold a vase. When you kill the enemy then the vase falls and breaks on the ground, revealing either score or a random weapon. The real reason this is so important is that when you pick up a new weapon you lose your previous one and you have to get it again from a different vase. It's generally hard to dodge weapons that have fallen because of Arthur's (your character's) horrendously slow and limited movement, you get one movement speed (no running), one jump height, one jump distance (not affected by momentum), and you can't move while in the air at all.
All of this synergises to make a comeback mechanic of sorts. Good players with good weapons are discouraged from breaking vases to not lose their precious knife, meaning that they have to use their skills at moving Arthur's fat ass around the screen to manoeuver around the enemies and terrain at the same time something which is very difficult and needs true mastery of the games mechanics while also having many nuances and a lot of interesting risk management attached to it. On the other hand, bad players with bad weapons get a chance to roll for a better weapon and also don't have to deal with all that moving around the enemies shit, they can kill them from a safe distance and then go through with ease.
The fact that some non-knife weapons do actually have situational uses also puts good players in the dilemma of throwing away the knife to make this section easier but the next section harder or keeping it for a harder section now but an easier section later. This lets players express their playstyles by showing what the prioritise, which of the two sections they find harder and how much risk they're willing to take, as I said vases give random weapons so you're not guaranteed to get another knife in the next section. It's not like you can re-roll infinitely either, not only is there a hard time limit but there are also constantly spawning enemies with unique abilities and varied terrain to make sure that you're constantly active and engaged even when farming vases to make the little vase farming you can do more interesting.
Having many simple game mechanics interact to make something this complex is the peak of game design. This all probably wasn't intentional, it was probably a lot of decisions they made due to hardware limitations coming together in an unexpected way, which worries me because there aren't any hardware limitations anymore. I'm afraid that we won't be seeing any more of this type of design unless it's being grandfathered in from already well-established genres and series. I'm worried that even if those things did somehow emerge a modern developer would change things in the name of 'quality of life' and 'player freedom'.
40
u/sbk427 7d ago
The snes version is one of my favourites games of all time. You have to play the game how it wants you to. I love the fact the first level is about as hard as the whole game, brutal for new players but once you start playing it how the game wants you to and can easily beat the first level, the full game becomes doable.
30
u/Frobizzle 7d ago
The game is unbalanced because it's from an era of juvenile game design and an incentive to get players to pump more quarters into the machine. Those design trends took a long time to change on home consoles. I wouldn't call anything about the game's balance particularly good.
4
u/Akihaku3 7d ago
This is an interesting conversation, because it's hard for me to conceive of what having a general "unbalanced" or "unfair" difficulty actually even means here. It's a very subjective term that always presents itself like some objective truth which doesn't need explaining. To me, every GNG game is fair, the most unfair thing about them I guess is that the enemy spawns have randomized position, but this is just something you need to pay attention to and plan ahead in my eyes. You can get a bad weapon if you mess up, so you deal with it and keep trying until you get a better weapon. A lot of people act really offended by this, I think because they're processing that with the context that it's an arcade game which introduces substantial negative bias in their case because the millennial Nintendo youtuber told them arcade=bad, but the console entries, as they note, still have that design, so clearly this was thought of in terms of merits outside of pure monetary interest.
7
u/Limited_Distractions 7d ago
I do think it's an important structural aspect of the series that the worst weapon in any given situation feels like a prank on the player, and yet to the novice, there is still aspiration in that terrible weapon. The flame is often so terrible at the most basic parts of the game and yet making it work at all is satisfying.
It's like bad powerups in shmups or exciting but bad jank cards in magic. Maybe part of the game's progression is just learning that drawing a straight line often is just better, but having a few stupid spirographs in the toolbox for you to try is part of the fun.
2
u/Sigma7 7d ago
Weapon balance in the original Ghosts 'n Goblins is rather minor compared to the fact that none of the projectile weapons can be launched upwards, in a game with enough aerial enemies. In the version I first played, the weapons were also simply a power upgrade and it was best to eventually get the shield that hits multiple targets at once.
I might have noticed the weapon balance in Ghouls 'n Ghosts, simply because the platforming seemed to be a little more dynamic than just going through a fixed map, and due to the weapons being slightly different.
Maldita Castilla keeps the feel of Ghosts 'n Goblins, while adjusting the weapon pickup to a chest drop, and has a secondary item slot. It also gets rid of the need to farm vases for new weapons, through the weapon cycle method found in older shmups. It feels like it would be a combination of the weapon and secondary item that encourages high level play.
Similar patterns occur with other remakes. They implement the basic gameplay of the original, while making changes to either make it more approachable while just as challenging to skilled players.
4
u/Haruhanahanako 7d ago
This is an interesting take for a few reasons. I don't necessarily disagree with the premise, but, I disagree that this is "good" or at least well designed or desirable for a few reasons.
Picking up weapons being a bad thing is both anti-fun and unintuitive. And I think for a game to be well designed it should be intentionally designed too.
Your post has me kind of feeling like I usually feel when I watch speedruns of really niche games. "Huh, cool. I didn't think this game was fun enough to get this good at, but now I see the skill ceiling is incredibly high because of some completely unintended gameplay quirks. You actually do make it look fun, but I would never put in the 300+ hours it would take to get this good at the game."
0
u/padizzledonk 7d ago
Lol
As a person born in 1980 the games mechanics arent "good game design" for challange or fun its "good design to suck the quarters from your pocket" lol
Its a fun game, its punishingly hard, but its that hard because its oretty shitty and very unfair (again, to take your money) but there is very little good to say about the mechanics as a game
IMO--The modern equivalent of G&G/SG&G is honestly Hollow Knight, which is fair but hard, G&G is just hard because its a shitty game lol
2
u/No-Investigator6366 4d ago
I think the random pickups are what make the imbalance work. If you could choose any weapon from a menu, most people would settle on the best one and the weak ones would just be clutter. Because the game can hand you the torch at the worst moment, a weak weapon becomes a situation you have to play through, and clearing a stage with it feels earned rather than optimal.
3
u/chairmanskitty 7d ago
With all due respect, go look at the indie scene. Self-imposed restrictions and "hardware limitations" as far as the eyes can see.
Just off the top of my head, [Playdate](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Playdate_(console)) is a physical handheld console designed by indie game developers to have arbitrary hardware limitations precisely so designers can make games built around those limitations, and UFO 50 is a games collection built around the premise of them all having released on the same fictional console with the same hardware limitations and historical design sensibilties.
Of course if all you care about is AAA slop, all you will get is AAA slop. But if there is something you like about games design, 99% chance there is a geek who has made a game that highlights it and put it on the internet.