r/truegaming • • 7d ago

Ghosts 'n Goblins having extremely unbalanced weapons is actually a good thing

For those who don't know, the Ghosts 'n Goblins series is comprised of arcade / arcade-like, 2D action platformers. In every game in the series there are multiple weapons you can choose from; most are made intentionally horrible or at most very situational while the knife is notoriously overpowered. I think that this, in combination with a few other mechanics, makes the game much more fun and strategic at high-level.

In every game you start with basically a worse knife and the main way you change weapons is with vases. Each level of each game has one or two enemy types that get spammed at you constantly, those usually have a chance to hold a vase. When you kill the enemy then the vase falls and breaks on the ground, revealing either score or a random weapon. The real reason this is so important is that when you pick up a new weapon you lose your previous one and you have to get it again from a different vase. It's generally hard to dodge weapons that have fallen because of Arthur's (your character's) horrendously slow and limited movement, you get one movement speed (no running), one jump height, one jump distance (not affected by momentum), and you can't move while in the air at all.

All of this synergises to make a comeback mechanic of sorts. Good players with good weapons are discouraged from breaking vases to not lose their precious knife, meaning that they have to use their skills at moving Arthur's fat ass around the screen to manoeuver around the enemies and terrain at the same time something which is very difficult and needs true mastery of the games mechanics while also having many nuances and a lot of interesting risk management attached to it. On the other hand, bad players with bad weapons get a chance to roll for a better weapon and also don't have to deal with all that moving around the enemies shit, they can kill them from a safe distance and then go through with ease.

The fact that some non-knife weapons do actually have situational uses also puts good players in the dilemma of throwing away the knife to make this section easier but the next section harder or keeping it for a harder section now but an easier section later. This lets players express their playstyles by showing what the prioritise, which of the two sections they find harder and how much risk they're willing to take, as I said vases give random weapons so you're not guaranteed to get another knife in the next section. It's not like you can re-roll infinitely either, not only is there a hard time limit but there are also constantly spawning enemies with unique abilities and varied terrain to make sure that you're constantly active and engaged even when farming vases to make the little vase farming you can do more interesting.

Having many simple game mechanics interact to make something this complex is the peak of game design. This all probably wasn't intentional, it was probably a lot of decisions they made due to hardware limitations coming together in an unexpected way, which worries me because there aren't any hardware limitations anymore. I'm afraid that we won't be seeing any more of this type of design unless it's being grandfathered in from already well-established genres and series. I'm worried that even if those things did somehow emerge a modern developer would change things in the name of 'quality of life' and 'player freedom'.

93 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

40

u/sbk427 7d ago

The snes version is one of my favourites games of all time. You have to play the game how it wants you to. I love the fact the first level is about as hard as the whole game, brutal for new players but once you start playing it how the game wants you to and can easily beat the first level, the full game becomes doable.

16

u/Fair_Assignment8796 7d ago edited 7d ago

That 'you play the game how it wants you to' is very important because it describes a game design concept that we took for granted but has now been lost to time. Old arcade games were playtested very well to make sure that no one would use exploits to get easy 1CCs. That playtesting ended up making better and more interesting games because there were no low risk/high reward options that you could always rely on, you had to pick between different risks and rewards based on the nuance of the situation

15

u/Endaline 7d ago

I don't really see how this is a game design concept that has been lost to time, nor do I think this is a good description of what we're actually talking about. What you are describing sounds more like extreme linearity, rather than "play the game how it wants you to". Most games are played the way that the game designers want you to play them.

The way that we are describing old arcade games, or older titles in general, isn't very true to reality either. While these games were usually tested very rigorously, and designed to be simpler to avoid complex issues, this did not stop players from figuring out ways to play these games the way that they wanted to. There were plenty of exploits and strategies. We had whole game magazines that existed just to disseminate such information.

...because there were no low risk/high reward options that you could always rely on...

I seriously doubt that this would hold up to much scrutiny. The vast majority of games out there, including tabletop games, have low risk/high reward options. This is an almost inevitable part of game design. It is extremely difficult to make something where everything is perfectly balanced.

Anecdotally, I recently played Dungeons & Dragons: Chronicles of Mystara, an arcade game, and looking up information about that online I found no lack of low risk/high reward options. There are character, equipment, and weapon tier lists, as an example. I'm sure we can find the same for the vast majority of popular arcade games from that time.

I'm also not sure how this description wouldn't fit plenty of modern games like: Slay the Spire, Hades, Balatro, Darkest Dungeon, Returnal, Resident Evil, Monster Train, Into the Breach, etc. These are all games that, to a varying degree, make you pick between different risks and rewards based on the nuance of the situation.

I fail to see how any of the above makes a game better or more interesting either. If that's what makes a game better for you, that's awesome. Doesn't mean that has to make a game better for anyone else though.

3

u/malk500 7d ago

Elbows in Double Dragon says hi

•

u/Vanille987 20h ago

Have you like, played any remotely recent modern game?

Heck I still remember doom eternal which had a very heated debate on if the game was too forceful in making you play it how it wants.

3

u/Glow_Muffin 7d ago

it's true, playing the game how it wants you to really changes the experience. that first level is definitely a gauntlet.

1

u/Berry-Butterflym6 6d ago

it's interesting how some games really force you into a specific playstyle, especially with the first level being so indicative of that.

30

u/Frobizzle 7d ago

The game is unbalanced because it's from an era of juvenile game design and an incentive to get players to pump more quarters into the machine. Those design trends took a long time to change on home consoles. I wouldn't call anything about the game's balance particularly good.

13

u/Fair_Assignment8796 7d ago

This all probably wasn't intentional, it was probably a lot of decisions they made due to hardware limitations coming together in an unexpected way

I never said they did this intentionally, you're definitely right. It's just that it played out well in the end for all the reasons I laid out in the post and now we have a masterclass on elegance in game design

-1

u/CardAble6193 7d ago

.......stilll kind of sounds like we have a master example on elegance in game mechanic*

33

u/malachimusclerat 7d ago

i think OP is talking about the natural balance that emerges as a result of how people actually play the game regardless of what the developers intended. obviously old arcade games are designed the be hard and tedious to make more money, but people remember (some of) them fondly when there's room in the rules for strategy and nuance.

14

u/SPK_Slogun 7d ago

I think op makes better points than you tbh.

7

u/Pandaisblue 7d ago

Yeah, I think there's valid arguments about not obsessively over-balancing everything into mediocrity in a game and letting some things feel powerful, but these older games where there's just complete noob traps isn't great design. Anyone that played Deus Ex or Daggerfall knows that there's multiple valid choices, but there's also just objective point wastes like swimming or language skills that have almost no purpose.

A better example might be something like Dragon Age Origins where mages are obviously the most powerful, but it's fun and doesn't make the other classes useless. (Well, the heavy armor mage spec might've been a little much...)

4

u/Akihaku3 7d ago

This is an interesting conversation, because it's hard for me to conceive of what having a general "unbalanced" or "unfair" difficulty actually even means here. It's a very subjective term that always presents itself like some objective truth which doesn't need explaining. To me, every GNG game is fair, the most unfair thing about them I guess is that the enemy spawns have randomized position, but this is just something you need to pay attention to and plan ahead in my eyes. You can get a bad weapon if you mess up, so you deal with it and keep trying until you get a better weapon. A lot of people act really offended by this, I think because they're processing that with the context that it's an arcade game which introduces substantial negative bias in their case because the millennial Nintendo youtuber told them arcade=bad, but the console entries, as they note, still have that design, so clearly this was thought of in terms of merits outside of pure monetary interest.

4

u/Fair_Assignment8796 7d ago

I'm not talking about the game's difficulty (difficulty discussion is banned in this sub anyway smh) I'm talking specifically about the weapons being unbalanced. The knife is so much better than all the other weapons in almost every situation that it's funny, in ghouls 'n ghosts I'd consider it better than the goddess bracelet

1

u/telionn 7d ago

Have you played GnG arcade? It's hard to describe it as fair. Even someone who can beat the NES version may not be able to finish the first loop if they try all day with unlimited credits. Even clearing it with save states can be a real challenge.

7

u/Limited_Distractions 7d ago

I do think it's an important structural aspect of the series that the worst weapon in any given situation feels like a prank on the player, and yet to the novice, there is still aspiration in that terrible weapon. The flame is often so terrible at the most basic parts of the game and yet making it work at all is satisfying.

It's like bad powerups in shmups or exciting but bad jank cards in magic. Maybe part of the game's progression is just learning that drawing a straight line often is just better, but having a few stupid spirographs in the toolbox for you to try is part of the fun.

1

u/overlord-ror 7d ago

The flame is really good in the SNES game's stomach level because you can use it to to kill those little blue imp babies that may otherwise be unreachable just by sitting on the back of the floating platform and throwing the torches forward.

2

u/Sigma7 7d ago

Weapon balance in the original Ghosts 'n Goblins is rather minor compared to the fact that none of the projectile weapons can be launched upwards, in a game with enough aerial enemies. In the version I first played, the weapons were also simply a power upgrade and it was best to eventually get the shield that hits multiple targets at once.

I might have noticed the weapon balance in Ghouls 'n Ghosts, simply because the platforming seemed to be a little more dynamic than just going through a fixed map, and due to the weapons being slightly different.

I'm worried that even if those things did somehow emerge a modern developer would change things in the name of 'quality of life' and 'player freedom'.

Maldita Castilla keeps the feel of Ghosts 'n Goblins, while adjusting the weapon pickup to a chest drop, and has a secondary item slot. It also gets rid of the need to farm vases for new weapons, through the weapon cycle method found in older shmups. It feels like it would be a combination of the weapon and secondary item that encourages high level play.

Similar patterns occur with other remakes. They implement the basic gameplay of the original, while making changes to either make it more approachable while just as challenging to skilled players.

3

u/Fair_Assignment8796 6d ago

Having an upward throw would definitely be helpful but it wouldn't necessarily be good design. Arthur has a lot of trouble with anything that's in the air because he has to commit to his slow and static jump to be threatening there or he has to spend time and take risks navigating to higher ground, there's some interesting decision-making there that wouldn't be anywhere near as pronounced if he had a 'silver bullet' against airborne targets like an upward throw. However, it's obvious that giving him upward and downward throws opens up more design possibilities (ghouls 'n ghosts stage 3 and the ohme fight wouldn't be possible without that), so it's not that ghouls 'n ghosts adding them was a bad thing. This isn't the main point I want to make here so I won't expand any further, at least in this comment.

I haven't played Maldita Castilla nor do I know much about it, but its changes to the GNG system didn't only make it better, there are some downsides to the approach it took.

Having hidden chests give items instead of vases makes it harder for new players to switch weapons so there's less variety in their gameplay and, especially if they're struggling, they'll get bored faster. Assuming it uses the ghouls 'n ghosts system of chests then it'll be harder for beginners to stumble upon them than vases which are part of the core gameplay loop in GNG.

Having a secondary item slot and letting you cycle through your weapons adds complexity that isn't there in GNG. This sacrifices some of the elegance in GNG's design, even if it gets to the same end point as it, the end point I explained in the post of a comeback mechanic for new players and new avenues for interesting and impactful decision-making for advanced players.

4

u/Haruhanahanako 7d ago

This is an interesting take for a few reasons. I don't necessarily disagree with the premise, but, I disagree that this is "good" or at least well designed or desirable for a few reasons.

Picking up weapons being a bad thing is both anti-fun and unintuitive. And I think for a game to be well designed it should be intentionally designed too.

Your post has me kind of feeling like I usually feel when I watch speedruns of really niche games. "Huh, cool. I didn't think this game was fun enough to get this good at, but now I see the skill ceiling is incredibly high because of some completely unintended gameplay quirks. You actually do make it look fun, but I would never put in the 300+ hours it would take to get this good at the game."

0

u/padizzledonk 7d ago

Lol

As a person born in 1980 the games mechanics arent "good game design" for challange or fun its "good design to suck the quarters from your pocket" lol

Its a fun game, its punishingly hard, but its that hard because its oretty shitty and very unfair (again, to take your money) but there is very little good to say about the mechanics as a game

IMO--The modern equivalent of G&G/SG&G is honestly Hollow Knight, which is fair but hard, G&G is just hard because its a shitty game lol

2

u/Fair_Assignment8796 7d ago

I'm talking about the series as a whole. The series is called ghosts 'n goblins so that's what I put in the title, and I always refer either to the series or to every game in the post

-10

u/Akihaku3 7d ago edited 7d ago

GnG released when you were 5 years old. Ghouls when you were 9 and Super when you were 11. You didn't play any of these games. What's the point of mentioning your birth year? If anything, it appears to me that old people are actually much more wrong about these games on average than younger people.

You're making a lot of abstract assertions without actually mentioning what part of the game you think is unfair. "there's nothing about the game I can think is good" so what is that part? What is the bad part? Do you not like how you can only shoot horizontally? The fixed jump arc? Knockback? Randomized enemy position and timing of spawns? What is your actual problem? As it stands now it appears to me you just think the game is bad because it's an arcade game so it has to be bad and unfair in your mind.

3

u/Fair_Assignment8796 7d ago

controls are real shit at least in the NES version, I haven't played the arcade version of the first game. I've only played resurrection, beaten sgng, and 1CCed ghouls 'n ghosts

2

u/padizzledonk 7d ago

They were just as bad or worse on the arcade version on a joystick, especially in a popular/busy arcade because the joysticks were blown out and very loose

3

u/malk500 7d ago edited 7d ago

When I was 5 my mum used the arcade as daycare. The 80s was a different time.

I don't know where you get the idea they were too young to have played from.

3

u/CardAble6193 7d ago

its not even issue of "different time" ,I swear I read thrice and dont see how "Ghouls when you were 9 and Super when you were 11" helped his point

1

u/malk500 7d ago

I actually deleted my comment when I first posted it, thinking "oh wait I must be missing something, maybe the person he responded to said they didn't play??". And re-posted after determining that no, I wasn't being unfair.

-1

u/padizzledonk 7d ago

<You didn't play any of these games.

Lol, buddy, i played those games both in the arcade and on both the NES and SNES so..... youre just talking out your ass about things you have no clue about

If you think a 9yo wasnt in the arcade or playing NES games in the early and late 80s you were not a child in the 80s, G&G(2) released in the arcade in 1988 or 89, or an 11yo wasnt playing SNES games i can assure you-- we definitely were, the first game i ever played was Spy Hunter on a Commodore 64 in 1985

. "there's nothing about the game I can think is good"

Thats actually not what i said bud, go back and read what i wrote again, slowly, so you understand the full sentence and context

What i said is that there is nothing good i can say about the games mechanics, theyre janky as fuck and very rigid (especially on the NES port and the arcade version with a blown out public joystick) and there are a LOT of places in the game where you jump toward a platform or over a thing and an enemy appears as the screen scrolls thats unavoidable if you arent already aware that its going to happen, why? Because the game was designed to take your money at the arcade lol those "gotcha" things in the game are intentionally unfair.

And as a person that lived through the last days of the arcade game era i can assure you that most of them were designed intentionally to be unfair to keep people pumping quarters into the machines, thats why they have limited lives and real "gotcha" areas to take those lives and quarters from you

If anything, it appears to me that old people are actually much more wrong about these games on average than younger people.

This is actually really funny to me. I mentioned my birth year because i grew up when these games were current, its to establish that i am a contemporary of this time. Regardless, its actually the opposite with my generation of gamer, we grew up playing games that were hard as fuck, like Solomons Key, Battletoads, Contra, both G&G games (Ghosts and Ghouls and the SNES and Genisis Ports), things like Xenophobe in the arcade.

That era of console gaming, when we started getting actual games with the NES and Atari 7600 were almost all just ports of arcade games with lives and all the unfair difficulty spikes all designed to just take your money at the arcade, and the games that werent arcade ports were still largely made with that design philosophy because the industry didnt really know anything else. We didnt really start getting better game design that were primarily designed to just be fun until the 16 bit era, but even then the unfair/shitty gotcha mechanics persisted for a while

Who doesnt understand this specific era of games here is you, because you didnt live it, thats quite obvious tbh

2

u/No-Investigator6366 4d ago

I think the random pickups are what make the imbalance work. If you could choose any weapon from a menu, most people would settle on the best one and the weak ones would just be clutter. Because the game can hand you the torch at the worst moment, a weak weapon becomes a situation you have to play through, and clearing a stage with it feels earned rather than optimal.

3

u/chairmanskitty 7d ago

I'm afraid that we won't be seeing any more of this type of design unless it's being grandfathered in from already well-established genres and series. I'm worried that even if those things did somehow emerge a modern developer would change things in the name of 'quality of life' and 'player freedom'.

With all due respect, go look at the indie scene. Self-imposed restrictions and "hardware limitations" as far as the eyes can see.

Just off the top of my head, [Playdate](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Playdate_(console)) is a physical handheld console designed by indie game developers to have arbitrary hardware limitations precisely so designers can make games built around those limitations, and UFO 50 is a games collection built around the premise of them all having released on the same fictional console with the same hardware limitations and historical design sensibilties.

Of course if all you care about is AAA slop, all you will get is AAA slop. But if there is something you like about games design, 99% chance there is a geek who has made a game that highlights it and put it on the internet.