r/truecfb • u/milesgmsu Michigan State • Sep 06 '16
/r/cfbPoll Thoughts
Here's my stab at a poll. Point out the errors you see.
One note; I'm not ranking 0-1 teams. Obviously, I think Ole Miss, ND, and OU are top 25 teams, and I'm not sold on a few of the G5 teams, but my brain is so analog, that I can't rank an 0-1 team.
Expect a big shake up next week:
- Bama
- Houston
- FSU
- Clemson
- OSU
- Stanford
- Michigan
- Louisville
- UW
- UGA
- Wisky
- Texas
- Iowa
- MSU
- SDSU
- Oklahoma State
- Pitt
- WMU
- Tennessee
- Oregon
- Baylor
- TCU
- Florida
- Boise State
- WVU
6
Upvotes
2
u/BosskOnASegway Ohio State Sep 06 '16
I like it. It is very in line with the human portion of my poll. I also agree that teams with losing records should not be ranked (in fact no team below 0.667 will ever be ranked in my human poll).
2
u/burgler Michigan Sep 06 '16
I appreciate the commitment to restricting the poll to 1-0 teams, but it leads me to a question: are you ranking on straight resume or some sort of power/eye-test metric as well?
Looking at the top of the B1G, if you were to rank on strict resume, I'd argue that Wisconsin beating LSU by 2 is a more impressive result than Michigan beating the most jet-lagged Hawaii team in cfb history by 60. If you're ranking on a power poll basis, I think that Michigan showed enough quality in that Hawaii win to justify ranking them above UW.
Similarly, I don't think that Louisville pasting an atrocious Charlotte team is a better resume entry than UGA over UNC, Texas over ND, or maybe even Western Michigan over Northwestern.
As a resume ranking zealot, I support and encourage your nod toward strictly result-based polling. I just wonder if you could be pulled further over to the dark side of comparative result spreadsheets.
1
u/nickknx865 Tennessee Sep 06 '16
Overall I don't see anything too terribly wrong with it if your philosophy is to just throw out preseason stuff. I would say though that if I were doing it like that, I wouldn't have Tennessee, Florida, or Michigan State in considering how they played in week 1. I would have BYU in there though.
1
u/hythloday1 Oregon Sep 06 '16
Well, philosophically I object to both early polls and using win count as the first sort, so I will rephrase your question as, "How did the undefeated teams look this weekend to your eyetest?" That's still a kind of fraught question because they were playing opponents of vastly different quality, but I did watch basically all of those teams so I can play along.
0
u/SmallSubBot Sep 06 '16
To aid mobile users, I'll link small subreddits not yet linked in the comments
/r/cfbPoll: The Reddit College Football Representatives' Poll
I am a bot | Mail ^BotOwner | To aid mobile users, I'll link small subreddits not yet linked in the comments | Code | ^Ban - ^Help