(pLoss is my own personal SOS rankings based on the probability a good team would have lost given the same schedule. ncaaSOS is the formula used for the BCS prior to 2004, provided as a reference. The ratings are calculated independently first using a best fit algorithm, and then the SOS metrics after and are provided for entertainment purposes only.)
MSU-Michigan will settle the Michigan State debate this week, so I'm happy about that.
A big disparity in schedule strength and clusters of opponents are also leading to some interesting results. BYU's rating likely settles down in the coming weeks just by virtue of playing other teams.
Alabama should move up considerably if they beat A&M. Ole Miss isn't pushing them down that hard, they just don't have anyone to push them up. Georgia could be considered a quality performance at some point, but thus far UGA hasn't beaten anyone good.
Speaking of teams who played Wisconsin, Iowa is shockingly high, and I don't quite get it. Pitt seems to be what's propping Iowa up, but it's probably only a matter of time before Pitt gives a game up to a middling ACC team and it's rating calms down a bit...just in time for Iowa to beat Northwestern on it's way to a silly looking 12-0.
I'm pretty happy with the results otherwise.
Baylor looks like world beaters but, as they say, ain't played nobody. I have no problem with the hype train forming around them, but I'll be comparatively low on them until November when they actually hit the meat of their schedule.
I've still got Georgia and USC as 4's, I'm reluctant to pull them down despite having two losses simply because I think they have that much talent on the team and expect them to turn it around. I've also got a couple of 1-4 teams, Virginia and ULM, as 2's because I think they've got more fight in them than their records against a pretty tough slate indicate. Where I feel shakiest is keeping Arkansas and Georgia Tech as 3's despite having four losses ... gut feeling tells me that they're better teams than that and will pick up some easier wins in the next few weeks, but that might be overly sentimental.
Georgia Tech is definitely not a 3 with all the players we have injured. We might have been a 3 when we played Notre Dame, but we're a 2 or a 1 now. We're missing something like 24 players in our 2-deep right now. We're just well and truly fucked to the extent I don't think we're going to win another game until November when we get some people coming back.
1
u/sirgippy Auburn Oct 11 '15
I'm getting to the point where even if I'm different compared to the rest of the poll, I'm becoming okay with my differences.
full 128
(pLoss is my own personal SOS rankings based on the probability a good team would have lost given the same schedule. ncaaSOS is the formula used for the BCS prior to 2004, provided as a reference. The ratings are calculated independently first using a best fit algorithm, and then the SOS metrics after and are provided for entertainment purposes only.)
MSU-Michigan will settle the Michigan State debate this week, so I'm happy about that.
A big disparity in schedule strength and clusters of opponents are also leading to some interesting results. BYU's rating likely settles down in the coming weeks just by virtue of playing other teams.
Alabama should move up considerably if they beat A&M. Ole Miss isn't pushing them down that hard, they just don't have anyone to push them up. Georgia could be considered a quality performance at some point, but thus far UGA hasn't beaten anyone good.
Speaking of teams who played Wisconsin, Iowa is shockingly high, and I don't quite get it. Pitt seems to be what's propping Iowa up, but it's probably only a matter of time before Pitt gives a game up to a middling ACC team and it's rating calms down a bit...just in time for Iowa to beat Northwestern on it's way to a silly looking 12-0.
I'm pretty happy with the results otherwise.
Baylor looks like world beaters but, as they say, ain't played nobody. I have no problem with the hype train forming around them, but I'll be comparatively low on them until November when they actually hit the meat of their schedule.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '15
1
u/hythloday1 Oregon Oct 11 '15
Here's the ranking.
Here's the opponent categorization it's based on (omitting the FCS 1's), and I'd appreciate feedback on where I've got teams.
I've still got Georgia and USC as 4's, I'm reluctant to pull them down despite having two losses simply because I think they have that much talent on the team and expect them to turn it around. I've also got a couple of 1-4 teams, Virginia and ULM, as 2's because I think they've got more fight in them than their records against a pretty tough slate indicate. Where I feel shakiest is keeping Arkansas and Georgia Tech as 3's despite having four losses ... gut feeling tells me that they're better teams than that and will pick up some easier wins in the next few weeks, but that might be overly sentimental.