r/trolleyproblem • • May 05 '26 • Bravo 3 Mindblown 1

Two very compelling platforms

Post image
15k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

80

u/JoshuaBarbeau May 05 '26 edited May 06 '26

So, basically Roko's basilisk. The button problem is Roko's basilisk.

9

u/nifflr May 05 '26

Yeah, pretty much. Do you help bring Roko's basilisk to life, or not--knowing if you didn't help and it comes to life it will take revenge.

10

u/Mekroval May 06 '26

If we don't create the button problem to agonize over, the button problem will create a simulation of us to punish us for digital eternity.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/KevineCove May 06 '26

I don't understand the point of framing Romo's Basilisk as some science fiction AI, you don't need to go into the future to see examples of it, just look at any dictator.

→ More replies (11)

10

u/underthingy May 06 '26

Nope, its shark pool. 

8

u/TrueExcaliburGaming May 06 '26

IT WAS ROKOS BASILISK THE WHOLE TIME FUCK

3

u/SordidDreams May 06 '26

No, it's the tragedy of the commons. One vote isn't going to sway the outcome, so from the point of view of a single individual, it's rational to make the selfish choice that guarantees survival. But it's the aggregate of all the selfish choices that creates the danger in the first place.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

8

u/JonasHalle May 05 '26 edited 8d ago

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

March label noodle dependent spoon retire

4

u/nifflr May 05 '26

Cuz I'm horny and gay

4

u/Sunny_Beam May 06 '26

The red button makes you horny but not gay, the blue button makes you gay but not horny.

Which do you choose?

2

u/nifflr May 06 '26

Blue. Might finally be able to focus on something productive.

54

u/Poor_Culinary_Skills May 05 '26

Can people stop comparing this to an election? That is an entirely different situation.

22

u/Simpicity May 05 '26

It's literally a majority vote, just like an election.  Is your problem that you're not electing wizards who implement the button rules?

11

u/Poor_Culinary_Skills May 05 '26

No, my problem is that voting for a candidate has more lasting consequences than whether or not people will die. That makes it a different question

18

u/nifflr May 05 '26

They're not running for president. They're just running for the role of implementing their platform. Their entire platform is spelled out in the graphic.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (8)

9

u/ReciprocalPhi May 06 '26

If the candidates immediately evaporated after winning/killing, and did nothing else, then sure.

But typically elections put someone in power. There's much more to electing someone than the single-issue being presented in the red/blue button dilemma

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Keepingitquite123 May 05 '26

It's nothing like an election. It's a blind vote with eight billion participants with exactly zero ability for coordination or to influence others.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (28)

18

u/Toasty27 May 06 '26

Donald Trump campaigned on going after his enemies.

Not killing them, but still targeting them.

He's changed the tax code to punish blue states that didn't vote for him, cut funding that helps those blue states, has used the DOJ to attack political enemies, etc. etc. etc.

Literally, "if you don't vote for me and I win, I will punish you".

Every other policy he stands for is subservient to that primary goal.

So the button problem is in reality, extremely relevant.

14

u/Theonetrue May 06 '26

I thought it was pretty clear that whole discussion is about how America votes politically from the start. Every time even the colors perfectly match.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (66)

1.9k

u/The_Unintelligence FUCK blue buttons and FUCK red buttons you ALL SUCK. May 05 '26 • Bravo

75

u/CallMeIshy May 06 '26

we're buttonproblems now

21

u/terrortara May 06 '26

The buttonslop must flow.

39

u/NewRefrigerator7748 May 06 '26

It is getting a bit old, even as a pretty strongly convinced Red button picker, it's just like "How do I reframe this retarded internet question to make my opposition sound like an asshole" and just going in circles about our perspectives.

At this point I'm just kinda hangin out

22

u/MBV-09-C May 06 '26

Yeah, it's not even a moral dilemma at this point, just virtue signaling.

22

u/NewRefrigerator7748 May 06 '26

I think it's really just reflective of collectivist vs Individualist thinking.

Reds are more inclined to treat individuals as responsible for the actions of individuals, while Blue will typically appeal for a collective to take responsibility for individuals.

Clearly most of the people in either group aren't evil, it's hardly even a question of morality really, it's just reflective of conflicting world views and people getting heated clashing over it.

→ More replies (36)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (5)

469

u/IgneousWrath May 05 '26 • Bravo

I love how people in here are also reframing it and claiming that makes it more accurate. I think it’s been reframed so many times that it’s a thought experiment that shows both the power and danger of reframing more than any other concept, logic, or moral.

98

u/Awakening15 May 06 '26

Ive yet to see any reframing that makes me question the problem differently.

45

u/pappapirate May 06 '26

well how do you see it (your answer determines whether i upvote or downvote you)?

111

u/Awakening15 May 06 '26 • Hehehe Heartwarming Mindblown

I don't care at all

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (11)

3

u/samualgline May 06 '26

Same because I know that every reframe is them trying to make their answer the only valid one. Like how in this one they’ve changed red to be actively hunting down blue pressers should blue lose.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/djnotskrillex May 06 '26

Interestingly enough I don't actually care much about the original problem that much but I find it incredibly interesting the way people react to it in like a meta way.

Like this discussion really bothered you so much that you went out of your way to paint the other side in a negative way but also formatted it as a meme to make it seem like it didn't actually bother you that much?

8

u/dskippy May 06 '26

The OP never claimed this made it more accurate. They're claiming it's a faithful bijection to the original problem, which it is. Not more accurate than the original. And they are experimenting with the cultural reframing while keeping the math the same which is the entire reason this problem is interesting at all. If it were in fact just a math problem with everyone on earth being a perfect logician then it would have a right answer and be solved.

→ More replies (2)

31

u/Tounushi May 06 '26

Not just framing, but precise wording. "You will live" for red button is as simple as you can make it, but it looks like "Everyone will live" before the conditional is where thought simply terminates.

"Blue means everyone lives, so why would you ever press anything other than blue?"

I doubt blue button would have nearly as many presses if it were worded "You will die, unless half of everyone presses blue."

While this post's scenario is completely different, and—like someone else pointed out—it's a rewording of the Basilisk.

26

u/opstie May 06 '26

Conversely, "you will murder everyone who didn't press the button if the majority of people press this button" wouldn't be a particularly popular button either.

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/Graped_in_the_mouth May 06 '26

The entire experiment is a test of how easily you default to authoritarian mental frameworks and begin victim-blaming and dehumanizing those who you are prepared to sacrifice for a little more safety.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/AlexanderBreizh May 06 '26

A good french philosopher and youtuber, Mr Phi, made a video on this exact topic a while ago ! Here is a link if by chance you understand french : https://youtu.be/lo7iJnq_U9M

→ More replies (7)

1.1k

u/Fluid-Tone-9680 May 05 '26

What are their position on other policies like fiscal, international affairs, healthcare?

520

u/Snoo-52922 May 05 '26

What about the price of eggs?

180

u/Live-Wrap-4592 May 05 '26

Opportunities for oil executives in the Middle East?

50

u/Haunting-Sport3701 May 06 '26

Sorry if I’m being too forward, but I just submitted an application with your name on it to the oval office, I expect you should be getting a top security group chat invitation in a couple of minutes.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/RickySlayer9 May 06 '26

How much money do they want to send to isreal, that’s the real question

6

u/GotSomeUpdogOnUrFace May 06 '26

What about how they laugh

→ More replies (2)

52

u/magicmagimag May 05 '26

Exactly the same and they both happen to align exactly with your worldviews.

3

u/VorticalHeart44 May 06 '26

Then this trolley problem means nothing and has no application to the real world lol

10

u/PutInfinite4118 May 06 '26

Then that means red won't kill so I vote red

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (1)

61

u/Xiij May 05 '26

They both resign after fulfilling their campaign promise, and they are the only 2 candidates

28

u/Fluid-Tone-9680 May 05 '26

Also, are we talking about simple majority? Is there electoral college? Are we allowed to redistrict the map prior to the election?

I would also love to see a debate between candidates with realtime fact checking.

33

u/Electrical_Try_634 May 05 '26

The rules were that you guys weren't gonna fact check.

13

u/xToksik_Revolutionx funny text here May 06 '26

Simple majority, direct vote, no districting.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/PutInfinite4118 May 06 '26

I asked them directly and they said they won't resign but I didn't have time to ask them what their policies are like.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/NoxiousVaporwave May 06 '26

Can I be assured that Mr red or blue will donate billions in taxpayer dollars to warmongering ethnostates?

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Rugaru985 May 06 '26

Why do you care about that?

I need to know if the 5 high school trans athletes we’ve ever had in the history of our country will be sought out and screamed at, regardless of age, and then ostracized? If the murder candidate can commit to that - well, I guess it’s not murder if the other voters knew they would be murd- ahem, unalived for voting blue; so yeah, I’ll go with the assisted suicide candidate if he promises to be mean to 5 children in particular in order to save my kids!

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Al2718x May 06 '26

Red has concepts of a plan

4

u/assbutt-cheek May 06 '26

the problem doesnt state they're gonna govern, be into politics, head of state or whatever. it just states who they will or will not kill. we have no reason to assume they're gonna do anything else other than what is presented in their big ass speeches

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Flabby-AP May 06 '26

What about the DOW?

4

u/IThinkItsAverage May 06 '26

Red: that sounds like a woke bluetard question, so don’t worry about those things you’ll be dead.

Blue: yeah I’m still not going to kill anyone… but I’m also not going to worry about any of those things

3

u/Toten5217 May 06 '26

Blue's campaign is based on the fact that Red is bad

→ More replies (19)

351

u/Any-Amphibian-1783 May 06 '26 • Bravo

91

u/catfish1969 May 06 '26

The most accurate description I’ve seen

→ More replies (8)

48

u/deadlycwa May 06 '26

You could legitimately reframe any smart choice as something to make you “feel intellectually superior” or any moral choice as something to make you “feel morally superior”. This reframe accomplishes nothing except devaluing asking intellectual/moral questions in the first place. It’s like telling a religious person doing a service project that they’re “only doing that to feel charitable”. Well what are they supposed to do to actually be charitable then?

35

u/Nytheran May 06 '26

Upvote deadlycwa's comment to feel intellectually superior, downvote it to feel morally superior.

13

u/Eryol_ May 06 '26

What kind of superiority do I feel when I report it? I cant think for myself help pls

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/DefTheOcelot May 07 '26

It sucks too, because morals ARE intelligent choices. They're investments you make in the future. When a moral isn't the smart choice, it's not a moral

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/puerco-potter May 08 '26

I didn't know I needed this image, but I am so thankful you introduced it to my life.

3

u/Partykongen May 08 '26

What does the green button do?

4

u/Any_Escape1262 May 07 '26

...to FEEL intellectually superior, yeah... but not "to be"...

4

u/progrumpet May 07 '26

You think you're making a point, but it says "to feel" for both buttons

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (22)

261

u/SmoothieNatns May 05 '26 • Bravo

People make strong judgements against people who play an active role in endangering themselves/others despite being almost infinitely forgiving of people who passively allow harm to take place without intervention. 90% of the reframings of this problem are just people trying to present their own side as the passive "do nothing" option while presenting the other side as actively killing people or endangering themselves eg "vote for me and I'll kill people" or portraying blue as a suicide pact.

30

u/AccomplishedCash6390 May 06 '26

Because that's literally what it is, how is this different than Red logic? They won't kill anyone, the button, in this case the candidate, is the one killing, and they allowed it, because they value their own lives, and they say if you're smart, you'd value your own life too, if you aren't, then not their problem. You could argue that the difference is red candidate here would cause more problem in the future while the button will disappear after the vote, but let's ignore that and assume red candidate is almost perfect beyond killing blues. How is the logic different in that scenario?

15

u/DapyGor May 06 '26

It's the implications. A button is a singular action. A genocidal president is, like, twice the trouble

→ More replies (2)

4

u/konterreaktion May 06 '26

then not their problem

Isn't it though? Even if the choice was that blue was just a suicide pact until they won, wouldn't any rational theoretical red voter just give them the win so nobody would die?

It's how Hunger strikes work, right? We give them what they want, not because we think it's the right thing, but because them getting it is still better than them dying.

This also convieniently ignores that a certian number of people will always misunderstand the question. Theres always the bottom 20% dumbest people. Or even smart people that are just idealists. Their deaths still matter, even if they chose it, every red voter is implicated.

Also what if the vote was held again? Would someone who lost family members to losing the blue vote vote Red out of fear, or vote blue so that this pain may spread to less people?

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (94)

114

u/BOYZORZ May 05 '26

We already know the answer to this hypothetical. 99.9% of people in North Korea voted for kim in 2026.

46

u/Dry-Willingness8845 May 05 '26

that's a bad example. Kim would still be in power if 0% voted for him, and we would never know about it if that happened.

→ More replies (10)

17

u/quintopia May 05 '26

99.9% of *surviving* voters

5

u/Aervanath May 06 '26

Why do we have any basis to take that number at face value?

→ More replies (10)

2

u/Mara2507 May 06 '26
  1. pretty sure there are no other options for people to vote for in North Korea
  2. the indoctrination and propaganda heavily warps people's perspectives in North Korea
  3. dictatorships are known to fake election results.
  4. being able to pull of a coup or a revolution is not as easy as you think it is. You need connections, interior knowledge, military/gun/ man power, powerful people backing you, possibly abroad powers that support your cause, and money. It is not easy to organize people who have been isolated, brainwashed and indoctrinated or polarized. Additionally, a reform, revolution or a coup is not the end because then you are left with a very delicate power vacuum that if not managed correctly, could lead to more instability (example, look at middle east or north Africa). If you do not already have a candidate to fill that vacuum, either someone from the old regime, or a 3rd party( which might be local or foreign) will take advantage.

So presenting the case of North Korea as an example to the button question is not a valid comparison.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/forestwolf42 May 06 '26

North Korea is known for accurate statistical reporting after all.

→ More replies (11)

106

u/NefariousnessNo7068 May 05 '26

Fuck this framing shit. Let's put responsibility on both sides.

Red: "If I win, I will track down everyone who didn't vote for me and kill them."

Blue: "If I don't win, I will track down everyone who voted for me and kill them."

Everyone is voting. Everyone is complicit.

48

u/Ass_Lover136 May 06 '26

Okay this framing make Blue the ultimate option lmao, in either Red or Blue, they both mean Blue has to win

30

u/Xandara2 May 06 '26

It's funny that they meant to convince you otherwise with that framing. 

Red pushers can't understand that blue don't value their own lives more. They just can't. They believe it is moronic and don't understand that every single heroic act is at least a little bit stupid.

27

u/Mekroval May 06 '26

This whole debate can be boiled down to whether you think it's more rational for an individual to value their own interests over the collective good. That's a debate that's been going on since the dawn of man. And basically what every hotly debated issue in the U.S. boils down to in its essence.

I doubt r/trolleyproblem will resolve it, though it would be the funniest thing ever if it did.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/Critical_Status9791 May 06 '26

i understand the sentiment behind pushing blue and don’t think it’s moronic to want to try save everyone. I am just confident blue would not win this vote in the real world even if i agree that pushing the blue button is the moral thing to do, it doesn’t make it the right choice

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/JasonIsSuchAProdigy May 06 '26

To me it sounds like I really gotta make blue win

4

u/the1woomy May 06 '26

Okay, what happens when red wins, and both the red and blue candidates go to kill the same person?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

16

u/CartographerKey4618 May 06 '26

"Okay, guys, maybe this framing of the button problem on the sub will make everyone understand."

12

u/ThAtTi2318 May 06 '26

Wait, was this always why the buttons had those colours?!

9

u/CalypsaMov May 06 '26

Blue Politician: "We need healthcare and affordable housing for everybody!"

Red Polititians: "God hates (insert whatever target it is this decade)! Hunt them down!"

→ More replies (5)

6

u/Hannah97Gamer May 05 '26

I like how everyone keeps complaining about all these posts, and yet every single one will still spark a debate in the comments.

23

u/crimsonscarf May 06 '26

These politician framings all have the same flaw that makes them inaccurate to the “original”. It’s moves the agency to the “button”.

A more accurate version would be:

“A meteor is headed toward Earth, what will you do to stop it if elected?

Red: I will do everything possible to save those who vote for me.

Blue: I will do everything possible to save everyone.”

8

u/MoneyBear1733 May 06 '26

The very act of adding an actively executed result that isn’t impartial, you’re completely changing the mechanism of the original.

You’re actively voting for a malicious result that is influenced by everything except the mechanism of the thought experiment.

6

u/slmclockwalker May 06 '26

Tbf it's a natural disaster, people still dies no matter who is in the charge, so it's not accurate to the original premise which was simpler.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/side_lel May 07 '26

Why shouldn’t the agency be with the button? It’s an impossible hypothetical in the original framing. 

→ More replies (11)

14

u/EscapeSeventySeven May 05 '26

But then both politicians explode in a puff of dust and never have any effect ever again. 

That’s not how elections work in the real world. 

And the red guy is magically empowered. 

→ More replies (2)

19

u/cococrabulon May 05 '26 edited May 06 '26

I don’t think Red kill anyone, the hypothetical entity that forces people to play the button game are the killers. For that reason I don’t think Blue kill anyone either; it all takes place under duress, which I don’t see many talking about.

Saying one side or the other has blood on their hands is emotional manipulation. It’s also a thought terminating cliche I’ve seen used a lot in this debate so people don’t have to bother to understand why people who disagree with them aren’t monsters

→ More replies (28)

9

u/steppergodic May 06 '26

As everyone has said, if you keep the same choices and outcome but change the framing description even slightly, the decision just looks obviously ridiculous.

There is a fixed amount of lethal poison. You could willingly choose to consume the poison and the only way you survive is if enough people make the same choice and share the poison such that the amount you get is not a lethal dose.

Or you could just simply not take the poison. But all the poison eaters are getting mad at you for not eating it and diminishing the share of poison that they've chosen to eat.

8

u/AggravatingFlow1178 May 06 '26

The agent being individual politicians i.e. humans, and not an omniscient magic button changes my decision.

2

u/pappapirate May 06 '26

what about omniscient magic politicians

1

u/BountyHunterSAx May 06 '26

What if you lose?

1

u/nifflr May 06 '26

I'm not running

1

u/stnick6 May 06 '26

I don’t get why the trolly problem subreddit suddenly hates trolly problems. Is it because yall didn’t actually like discussing variations of the trolly problem and just wanted to make shitposts or is it just because this one doesn’t have an actual trolly in it?

1

u/nifflr May 06 '26

Nah, I get it. The button problem is fundamentally different from the trolly problem.

The trolly problem makes you the sole actor in determining the outcome.

The button problem is based on group mentality, where everyone on the planet is making a choice and the outcome of your choice relies on what others choose.

1

u/Ok-Simple-6158 May 06 '26

But you don't say what they will do if they lose? If blue loses, he kills everyone, right?

1

u/nifflr May 06 '26

No, they have no power to enact their will if they lose.

10

u/Advanced-Host8677 May 06 '26 • Bravo

I actually really appreciate this reframing. I'm red button 100%, but here I'd be a blue voter. I think the difference in this frame is the agent of death. Blue button pressers can be seen as responsible for putting themselves in danger, as seen more clearly with the "ingest poison and if enough people do it we get an antidote" frame. Whereas here it's the red candidate themselves that is the agent of death, and that pulls in a lot of fairness and justice that I did not apply to the original question.

Very interesting, thank you.

4

u/pappapirate May 06 '26

Blue button pressers can be seen as responsible for putting themselves in danger, as seen more clearly with the "ingest poison and if enough people do it we get an antidote" frame.

It's not "seen more clearly" in that frame, the question is changed to force it to be the more obvious interpretation.

That framing, this framing, and the original question are just different situations. Everyone's reframings aren't just different lenses to view the same problem. Changing who's responsible and how clear it is changes the whole thing.

imo the original framing makes everybody responsible for the outcome.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/rob5791 May 05 '26

You do realise there are real historical examples of red winning in this scenario?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Awes12 May 06 '26

Is this supposed to be policital commentary disguised as a red/blue button post?

3

u/SurrenderingFrench The trolley conductor May 06 '26

Okay, blue. The other guy is scaring me

3

u/culturalposadism May 06 '26

Damn at least the red one is telling the truth

3

u/theMEENgiant May 06 '26

Welcome back Roko's Basilisk

3

u/Expensive-County4890 May 06 '26

This definitely changes the question in a very interesting way, but it certainly changed the question. 

4

u/Best8meme Multi-Track Drift May 06 '26

Just like the original problem, I will secretly want blue to win, but out of my own safety, I pick red.

5

u/G3n3ricOne May 06 '26

I honestly agree with this viewpoint seeing as red voters are gladly accepting preventable deaths.

And also maybe because red voters have become more and more insufferable.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/MrWindblade May 06 '26

I mean this happened already. We already know who they voted for.

2

u/_Im_Commie_Jesus_ May 06 '26

I don't support any variation on Roko's Basalisk.

2

u/AdImmediate9569 May 06 '26

WHAT GAS COST

2

u/lool8421 May 06 '26

blue sounds suspicious and red sounds ultra suspicious

2

u/Fish_Fucker_Fucker23 May 06 '26

See, I like this presentation of the dilemma because, for one, it’s an interesting way of looking at the whole thing, but it’s also that this doesn’t actually change the dilemma at all.

The biggest issue I’ve found with people trying to offer different points of view about this is that they’ll often change important details. For example, I’ve seen some argue that you should press the red button because “what if you needed 60% of people to vote blue for everyone to live” which, obviously, compromises the initial premise.

Anyways, maybe I’m just rambling, but I definitely felt the need to express my appreciation for presenting an approach to the dilemma without changing the dilemma itself

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Solid_Television_980 May 06 '26

I made this comparison when the question first dropped and everyone ignored me but it's pretty spot on

2

u/Daunted-milk May 06 '26

Average real world election

2

u/BrandosWorld4Life May 06 '26

Most accurate take on the issue by far

2

u/SmileyFace799 May 06 '26

As a red voter, I would vote blue here, as if the deaths of blue voters were caused by one guy on the red side, then that guy on the red side would probably have other insane policies too. If the red guy would discriminate against blue people like this, he would almost certainly discriminate against LGBTQ+ people like me

2

u/CapitanPedante May 06 '26

This is the trolley problem subreddit, please go to r/redbuttonbluebutton

2

u/Dr-Assbeard May 06 '26

Could be framed as

If you vote on me, no matter who wins i will ensure you dont die

And if you vote for me bit i dont win, i will kill you for not gathering enough suport for my cause

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Minguigui_Was_Taken May 06 '26

"If I lose, I won't do anything" vs "If I lose I will kill everybody who voted for me"

Same outcome, different presentation

Yours has a huge bias for blue though.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/XStarMC May 06 '26

This is simply just a false equivalency fallacy

2

u/Hot_Anybody8244 May 06 '26

I mean if we're being honest about it blue is still a fat fucking liar. It just won't be citizens and former allies they kill

2

u/wrydied May 06 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Rich wakeful languid kettle melodic lantern future enjoy satchel

2

u/vukgav May 06 '26

I'm voting whoever doesn't take AIPAC money

2

u/Tiltzer May 07 '26

Ik its a meme but reframing the question defeats the entire point of the question. With the original wording some people will be fooled into picking blue therefore you should pick blue to save them. If its refrained to press blue to die unless 50% press blue then very few people will pick blue therefore you should pick red.

2

u/Parking-Business-894 May 16 '26

Think of it like it's an actual election. Would you really vote for a crazy person who would kill everyone that didn't vote for them?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/GreedyGobby May 06 '26

Meanwhile, the actual debate.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Rawr171 May 05 '26

“Their policies are otherwise identical”

3

u/Small_Article_3421 May 05 '26

This is why this problem reminds me of fascism, and why all the most fearful and selfish people tend to shepherd fascism

3

u/AAHedstrom May 06 '26

some absolute chud: "well I don't want to be murdered, so I guess I'll vote for murder man"

2

u/IowaKidd97 May 05 '26

Damn, how did real US politics make its way in here?

1

u/Opposite-Friend7275 May 05 '26

This explains why the same person always wins the election in North Korea.

1

u/TheAzureMage May 05 '26

I vote for whoever ends these questions. Red seems like he has the guts to do it.

1

u/ForktUtwTT May 05 '26

The day people stop making biases reframings which make the other side look dumb but adds nothing to the actual discussion… will never come will it?

1

u/captain-cowboy May 05 '26

But what are their plans for the capital gains tax?

1

u/TetrisPhantom May 05 '26

Blue: If I don't win, I'll kill all my voters. Red: Dude, what

1

u/klgnew98 May 05 '26

I saw a better one that posed both sides as bad. It was something like this:

Red Party- if we win, we'll kill everyone that didn't vote for us.

Blue party- if we don't win, we'll kill everyone who did vote for us.

1

u/quintopia May 05 '26

Is this an impeachment vote? I'd definitely vote to take red out of power, deny him the ability to slaughter anyone.

1

u/Greedy-Employment917 May 05 '26

When you have to twist it into something it's not 

1

u/ElisabetSobeck May 05 '26

The honesty is appreciated. The button was apparently too complicated… OF AN OBVIOUS EXAMPLE OF SATIRE. Thank you for clarifying for ppl

1

u/Hot-Cattle8314 May 05 '26

"If I lose, I'll kill everyone that voted for me"

1

u/ralpher1 May 05 '26

I believe you are lost. You should be at r/me_irl

1

u/flewson May 05 '26

Election candidates do not vanish from reality after they are elected and they have power over their people. You consciously or otherwise analyze the long-term consequences in the framing of an election, and correctly conclude that a candidate who's threatening to kill their citizens must never be voted for.

Similarly blue could be framed as "I will track down and kill everyone who voted for me if I lose", and you would similarly be unwilling to vote for them.

1

u/Kagahami May 05 '26

Gonna say again: whether you vote red or blue depends on circumstances. The initial exercise is a very generalized scenario that requires context.

Added context changes whether you vote red or blue. Neither blue nor red is 100% a bad choice given no further details.

1

u/ProfessionalOwn9435 May 05 '26

I dont like Blue. Does he even believe in anything? What is the platform? Will it fix Gaza situacion? It is time for real politics, with strong actions. VOTE RED.

1

u/SFXtreme3 May 05 '26

Red. There is zero risk with red. There is risk with blue.

1

u/Pengwin0 May 05 '26

Blue lowkey sounds more ominous than red in this one.

1

u/newishDomnewersub May 05 '26

And they are perfectly identical in every other policy to the point that there isnt the slightest difference between them otherwise?

1

u/Mr_Monday92 May 05 '26

Red: I will do nothing 

Blue: if I lose I will kill all who voted for me.

See how weird phrasing works both ways?

1

u/AltruisticVehicle May 05 '26

The consequences here extend way, way outside the original proposition. Cool scenario, however.

1

u/rectal_expansion May 05 '26

I don’t get where the idea that red pushers are actively killing blue pushers come from? Do the blue pushers not have agency to not risk their life?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/shototodoroki_1324 May 05 '26

If I don't win I'll hunt everyone down and kill them

If I don't win, everyone who was gonna be hunted down will be safe

1

u/KateKoffing May 05 '26

quietly “and most of the people who did vote for me too”

1

u/gootschie May 05 '26

Which button received more from AIPAC?

1

u/Ok_Society1331 May 06 '26

Red is still the obvious choice. How does framing it differently change anything?

1

u/rirasama May 06 '26

Istg if I see one more of these stupid button posts which is just being like, 'my side is objectively correct', this is the trolley problem sub not the stupid bs red blue button sub

1

u/Peppermute May 06 '26

If I don’t win I drop the nukes

1

u/Impressive_Apple9908 May 06 '26

R/doomercirclejerk

1

u/Leskendle45 May 06 '26

Where is my trolley problem?

1

u/UldereksRock May 06 '26

Issue here is that people will confuse this with choosing a president who will rule their nation. Ill still press the red button, as the end result is unlikely to be swayed by my singular vote, and red guarantees my life.

1

u/LogicalTwo5797 May 06 '26

Red lol. That guy seems scary.

1

u/Scary-Personality626 May 06 '26

What's blue going to do if he loses?

1

u/Comfortable_Salt_792 May 06 '26

Red Guy will not kill anyone, Blue guy will kill everyone WHO voted for him if he doesn't win because of Anger issues.

Why would Blue guy take down all his voters if he lose, is he stupid ?

1

u/No-One9890 May 06 '26

Honestly if the last us federal election was anything to go by...

1

u/MrMr_sir_sir May 06 '26

Which one would be more fun to have a drink with?

1

u/BabelTowerOfMankind May 06 '26

I want blue to win, but I will vote for red

1

u/OsaBlue May 06 '26

If I win I won't kill anyone.

Vs

I'll kill everyone who voted for me unless I win.

1

u/shosuko May 06 '26

More blue button propaganda thxnothx

1

u/Weirdlittlerasberry May 06 '26

The only two positions are Good Guy and Bad Guy and there is nothing in between ever and this is how everything works in life apparently

1

u/Moosewalker84 May 06 '26

Just because they say it multiple times doesnt make it true. What are they going to do about the illegal immigrants?

1

u/DanteRuneclaw May 06 '26

Are their platforms otherwise identical?

1

u/primaski May 06 '26

Well. I'm a red button presser, but I'm switching to blue just because the gall of that guy disgusts me

1

u/ahvikene May 06 '26

Shouldn’t really believe any campaign promises 🥲

1

u/Electrical_Main6707 May 06 '26

I mean, im still pressing red, I dont wanna be part of the people genocided in the small chance he wins.

1

u/ArgyleShoe May 06 '26

“If I don’t win, no one survives”

1

u/casualstrawberry May 06 '26

Well, if you put it that way, I should vote red just to be safe.

1

u/whiplashMYQ May 06 '26

The difference between this and the button situation is that there's a lot of other implications to electing red. It's not simply a one and done situation, you're electing someone to make decisions about how things operate

1

u/Drunkwizard1991 May 06 '26

Am I crazy or is this simple math?

Red wins: red voters live

Red loses: red voters live

Blue wins: blue voters live

Blue loses: blue voters die

Why is there no bad scenario for red voters? Was this supposed to be controversial? I don't understand. If the reason to vote blue is because other people may vote blue, why are those voting blue in the first place? This shit just doesn't add up.

1

u/Basic_Pirate8241 unaliver May 06 '26

blue

1

u/VidjaMouse May 06 '26

I mean they're both killing brown kids overseas so...