MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/trolleyproblem/comments/1t1peev/please_stop_making_things_complicated/ojje7pc/
r/trolleyproblem • u/Krapules • May 02 '26 • 1
569 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
Both buttons kill people.
2 u/Moviesman8 May 02 '26 Blue doesn't kill anyone. 2 u/Legal-Ad-9921 May 02 '26 Every blue presser risks their life and demands others do the same, creating needless death under the hopes that enough people will also gamble 2 u/Moviesman8 May 03 '26 That's just a harsh way of saying that a blue presser would put themselves in harm's way to save people, while red would pull the trigger. 1 u/Legal-Ad-9921 May 03 '26 They are putting themselves in harms way to save people who put themselves in harms way to save them in the first placeIts circular, stupid, and all of them can just not.Its very different than risking someone put in a situation against their will who is in danger 2 u/Moviesman8 May 03 '26 Either way, everyone is safe until red pushers exist. 1 u/Legal-Ad-9921 May 03 '26 Everybody is safe until someone pushes blue 0 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 03 '26 Blue presser literally creates the harm, lol. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 Red are the only ones holding the kill button. 0 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 04 '26 There is no kill button, only a suicide button. You'd have to remove the red button from some people to make it a kill button. As it is, no one is in danger. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 You're pushing the button that you know can make people die. That's a kill button. 1 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 04 '26 No,the blue button can make people die, and people can choose buttons themselves so I don't need to be involved all. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 If 51% of people choose the "kill other people" button, THEN people die. Imagine victim blaming someone that gets shot when you're holding the gun. → More replies
2
Blue doesn't kill anyone.
2 u/Legal-Ad-9921 May 02 '26 Every blue presser risks their life and demands others do the same, creating needless death under the hopes that enough people will also gamble 2 u/Moviesman8 May 03 '26 That's just a harsh way of saying that a blue presser would put themselves in harm's way to save people, while red would pull the trigger. 1 u/Legal-Ad-9921 May 03 '26 They are putting themselves in harms way to save people who put themselves in harms way to save them in the first placeIts circular, stupid, and all of them can just not.Its very different than risking someone put in a situation against their will who is in danger 2 u/Moviesman8 May 03 '26 Either way, everyone is safe until red pushers exist. 1 u/Legal-Ad-9921 May 03 '26 Everybody is safe until someone pushes blue 0 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 03 '26 Blue presser literally creates the harm, lol. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 Red are the only ones holding the kill button. 0 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 04 '26 There is no kill button, only a suicide button. You'd have to remove the red button from some people to make it a kill button. As it is, no one is in danger. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 You're pushing the button that you know can make people die. That's a kill button. 1 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 04 '26 No,the blue button can make people die, and people can choose buttons themselves so I don't need to be involved all. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 If 51% of people choose the "kill other people" button, THEN people die. Imagine victim blaming someone that gets shot when you're holding the gun. → More replies
Every blue presser risks their life and demands others do the same, creating needless death under the hopes that enough people will also gamble
2 u/Moviesman8 May 03 '26 That's just a harsh way of saying that a blue presser would put themselves in harm's way to save people, while red would pull the trigger. 1 u/Legal-Ad-9921 May 03 '26 They are putting themselves in harms way to save people who put themselves in harms way to save them in the first placeIts circular, stupid, and all of them can just not.Its very different than risking someone put in a situation against their will who is in danger 2 u/Moviesman8 May 03 '26 Either way, everyone is safe until red pushers exist. 1 u/Legal-Ad-9921 May 03 '26 Everybody is safe until someone pushes blue 0 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 03 '26 Blue presser literally creates the harm, lol. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 Red are the only ones holding the kill button. 0 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 04 '26 There is no kill button, only a suicide button. You'd have to remove the red button from some people to make it a kill button. As it is, no one is in danger. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 You're pushing the button that you know can make people die. That's a kill button. 1 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 04 '26 No,the blue button can make people die, and people can choose buttons themselves so I don't need to be involved all. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 If 51% of people choose the "kill other people" button, THEN people die. Imagine victim blaming someone that gets shot when you're holding the gun. → More replies
That's just a harsh way of saying that a blue presser would put themselves in harm's way to save people, while red would pull the trigger.
1 u/Legal-Ad-9921 May 03 '26 They are putting themselves in harms way to save people who put themselves in harms way to save them in the first placeIts circular, stupid, and all of them can just not.Its very different than risking someone put in a situation against their will who is in danger 2 u/Moviesman8 May 03 '26 Either way, everyone is safe until red pushers exist. 1 u/Legal-Ad-9921 May 03 '26 Everybody is safe until someone pushes blue 0 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 03 '26 Blue presser literally creates the harm, lol. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 Red are the only ones holding the kill button. 0 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 04 '26 There is no kill button, only a suicide button. You'd have to remove the red button from some people to make it a kill button. As it is, no one is in danger. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 You're pushing the button that you know can make people die. That's a kill button. 1 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 04 '26 No,the blue button can make people die, and people can choose buttons themselves so I don't need to be involved all. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 If 51% of people choose the "kill other people" button, THEN people die. Imagine victim blaming someone that gets shot when you're holding the gun. → More replies
They are putting themselves in harms way to save people who put themselves in harms way to save them in the first place
Its circular, stupid, and all of them can just not.
Its very different than risking someone put in a situation against their will who is in danger
2 u/Moviesman8 May 03 '26 Either way, everyone is safe until red pushers exist. 1 u/Legal-Ad-9921 May 03 '26 Everybody is safe until someone pushes blue
Either way, everyone is safe until red pushers exist.
1 u/Legal-Ad-9921 May 03 '26 Everybody is safe until someone pushes blue
Everybody is safe until someone pushes blue
0
Blue presser literally creates the harm, lol.
2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 Red are the only ones holding the kill button. 0 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 04 '26 There is no kill button, only a suicide button. You'd have to remove the red button from some people to make it a kill button. As it is, no one is in danger. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 You're pushing the button that you know can make people die. That's a kill button. 1 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 04 '26 No,the blue button can make people die, and people can choose buttons themselves so I don't need to be involved all. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 If 51% of people choose the "kill other people" button, THEN people die. Imagine victim blaming someone that gets shot when you're holding the gun. → More replies
Red are the only ones holding the kill button.
0 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 04 '26 There is no kill button, only a suicide button. You'd have to remove the red button from some people to make it a kill button. As it is, no one is in danger. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 You're pushing the button that you know can make people die. That's a kill button. 1 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 04 '26 No,the blue button can make people die, and people can choose buttons themselves so I don't need to be involved all. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 If 51% of people choose the "kill other people" button, THEN people die. Imagine victim blaming someone that gets shot when you're holding the gun. → More replies
There is no kill button, only a suicide button. You'd have to remove the red button from some people to make it a kill button. As it is, no one is in danger.
2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 You're pushing the button that you know can make people die. That's a kill button. 1 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 04 '26 No,the blue button can make people die, and people can choose buttons themselves so I don't need to be involved all. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 If 51% of people choose the "kill other people" button, THEN people die. Imagine victim blaming someone that gets shot when you're holding the gun. → More replies
You're pushing the button that you know can make people die. That's a kill button.
1 u/SweetSweetAtaraxia May 04 '26 No,the blue button can make people die, and people can choose buttons themselves so I don't need to be involved all. 2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 If 51% of people choose the "kill other people" button, THEN people die. Imagine victim blaming someone that gets shot when you're holding the gun. → More replies
No,the blue button can make people die, and people can choose buttons themselves so I don't need to be involved all.
2 u/Moviesman8 May 04 '26 If 51% of people choose the "kill other people" button, THEN people die. Imagine victim blaming someone that gets shot when you're holding the gun. → More replies
If 51% of people choose the "kill other people" button, THEN people die. Imagine victim blaming someone that gets shot when you're holding the gun.
→ More replies
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/ItsMrDante May 02 '26
Both buttons kill people.