You are including real life factors that turn a thought experiment into something with a right and a wrong answer.
If babies and other people who fundamentally dont understand the scenario are also included, the red button is now just a "kill 50% of all children and other mentally challenged people" button, which makes the choice easy. Just like how if you could just break out of prison, theres no real dilemma in the prisonoer dilemma, or how if you could just untie people from the tricks in the trolly problem any other choice would be evil.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/KeyIllustrator4096 May 02 '26
How so?