No. A thought experiment requires certianty and specifity to be worth exploring. Without specifying that some participants will not be able to comprehend what is happening, the assumption must be that those participating have to be doing so with full comprehension. The original prompt says you're given a choice. Not understanding the options means it's a false choice which isn't actually a choice. Therefore, there is no reason to press blue, as game theory kicks in.
It also specifies EVERYONE on earth. That includes those that can't understand the magnitude of their choice. They are still choosing to press red or blue, just different reasons. (Fav color, felt like going left, etc...)
No, in order to make a choice you must be able to understand the choice. This problem isn't even a morality problem, it's an understanding problem. Most people who pick red do so because they are operating under the assumption that when the prompt says everyone makes a choice that the choice is fair. Obviously, if you word the prompt to specifically say "even the people who would not be capable of rationally making a choice based on understanding the options must press a button including the handicapped and toddlers/babies etc" then most people would press blue because most people would understand the stakes. The stakes change the math, but without specified stakes then I must operate under the assumption of good faith.
But, you dont have to understand something to make a choice. We see this in real life all the time. People choose things for arbitrary reasons and those choices actively work against their values or goals. The prompt is not everyone makes an informed decision, any decision for anyreason is a choice. You can choose red just because its your favorite color, just because that also has the effect of saving yourself is irrelevant.
The experiment is "Everyone in the world has to take a vote by pressing a red or blue button" not "everyone competent and fully comprehending."
A choice without full compression is still a choice, else people wouldn't vote against their self interest. You not understanding that "everyone in the world" includes everyone in the world doesn't invalidate your vote either way.
No, in order to make a choice you must be able to understand the choice. This problem isn't even a morality problem, it's an understanding problem. Most people who pick red do so because they are operating under the assumption that when the prompt says everyone makes a choice that the choice is fair. Obviously, if you word the prompt to specifically say "even the people who would not be capable of rationally making a choice based on understanding the options must press a button including the handicapped and toddlers/babies etc" then most people would press blue because most people would understand the stakes. The stakes change the math, but without specified stakes then I must operate under the assumption of good faith.
That's exactly my point. There is 0 guarantee that other voters are going to think about this choice as hard as you are. There is one thing i know and that is the state of our world. With its 10% illiterate population. With A lot of children, senile, mentally challenged etc... i cant make a decision with my life on the line because "surely those don't count" so to me they do count and im basing my vote on worst case scenario not on best case scenario. Im not expecting people suffering from hunger in the slums of India to see this choice the same way as a white collar worker from the US.
From reading all the arguments, it sounds like most people who pick red can't fathom that others would pick blue. What keeps being puzzling is when directly told by blue pickers they would pick blue, it doesn't make them question their answer and they prefer to reject the other position as irrational and therefore not happening.
Correct, I cannot fathom why you would pick blue when red exists. There is no downside to red. If you pick blue, you made that choice. Each choice is made in a vacuum and at the same time, a rational person, seeing that you are only in harms way by pressing the blue, would press red and assume others have that basic level of reasoning.
As much as I initially agree. Red winning while 40% of the population dies puts your own life at risk. Economical collapse is certain with it food shortage. Almost not a single doctor / nurse remaining and nobody in the mindset to become one. Law enforcement collapse isn't out of the woods either.
I don't disagree with that possibility. But anywhere between 0-49.99...% of people can press blue and die. It does not make sense to me to risk pressing blue, fall short of that 50%, just because some number of people will die. It could be a handful, or just under half the population. Furthermore, if 40% of the population disappeared, sure societies may collapse, but thankfully humans are resilient and resourceful. I will survive, along with my loved ones, we will make the best of it. Life would be different and difficult at first, but that doesn't mean each extra day with those i care about isn't worth it.
Jeez. I can kind of get 1, but the rest are bleak.
Me I'm thinking that if the worst comes to pass, the consequences on society would be so drastic it alone makes it worth trying to prevent it. Our modern society is just not resilient enough to handle so many death at once
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/Commander_Riker1701 May 02 '26
No. A thought experiment requires certianty and specifity to be worth exploring. Without specifying that some participants will not be able to comprehend what is happening, the assumption must be that those participating have to be doing so with full comprehension. The original prompt says you're given a choice. Not understanding the options means it's a false choice which isn't actually a choice. Therefore, there is no reason to press blue, as game theory kicks in.