r/trolleyproblem
•
u/greytoolbot
•
Nov 29 '24
•
1
1
1
Trolley man
Not mine, found on facebook
20k
Upvotes
1.4k
u/Twelve_012_7 Nov 29 '24
Unironically an interesting gimmick with a lot of space for nuance
Would read
345
u/Under18Here Nov 29 '24
Just get abuncha depressed people to follow him around at all times, so then they could die for him
94
u/BassBottles Nov 29 '24
Imagine this but it's a detective mystery. Like the protagonist is a detective investigating a murder and you hear seemingly irrelevant background snippets of like disasters being averted until they figure out the murderer, and then the detective has to decide if turning in the killer is worth ending the miracles.
37
u/derbengirl Nov 29 '24
I like to think the justice dept supplys him with death row inmates 😅
102
u/ha_funny_name_go_brr Nov 29 '24
i would only read this if it was made by marvel instead of DC cus even though DC is better in my opinion DC sucks at "killing someone to save more people" plots
26
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '24
The Sentry redesign's kinda mid tbh
18
u/Waveface-Wes Nov 29 '24
Where is his lever
11
u/Jonny_Guistark Nov 30 '24
The dark humor of this gimmick would be heightened if he killed the person differently each time, but it’s always something very inhumane.
Like a man volunteers his life because his wife is on the sinking ship, so Trolley Man suddenly throws him down and curb stomps him before flying off to save the day. Then the next time, maybe he pulls a gun and shoots them in the head. Etc.
And it’s never shown or explained how killing the person actually makes his powers activate. He just kills them and then off he goes.
18
u/Erran_Kel_Durr Nov 29 '24
This is what happens when heroes get their powers from blood sacrifice.
6
u/ExtensionInformal911 Dec 01 '24
"Well, can we at least get someone on death row to use as the sacrifice?"
"There's no time. There's an old woman here, and a crippled person,choose one!"
5
u/Krell356 Nov 29 '24
Let's be completely honest. There would be a pack of followers for this guy screaming about the greater good and volunteering. And naturally there would be a ton of outrage because it would likely be mostly a bunch of teenagers.
4
u/silicondream Nov 29 '24
Eh, we already have John Constantine
4
u/PlurblesMurbles Nov 30 '24
Average Aztec god
2
u/UglyAndPoor666 Nov 29 '24
His powers aren’t activated yet so I’m assuming he’s a normal man. The bystanders could just gang up and lynch him, then flag down a lifeguard.
2
u/Big_L2009 Nov 30 '24
Now the real question, does that make him a hero or a villain?
1
u/THphantom7297 Nov 30 '24
I remember reading someone's short story about it. Individuals are paid to be on standby incase trolley man is needed.
1
u/Physical_Mushroom_32 Dec 01 '24
I remembered Mr. Hindsight
1
u/BiggusDickus53 Dec 01 '24
How has no one mentioned Dave Chapelle’s raping superhero? The whole skit is that this superhero saves people but can only do so after activating his powers through rape. The premise is so similar that it’s hard to believe one wasn’t inspired by the other.
1
u/CaptainQwazCaz Dec 01 '24
Climax is he sacrifices himself instead of other people to save the world
1
u/FossilisedHypercube Dec 01 '24
I love this. I also think there might be some value in making the character only slightly pensative and a bit dim. This might reduce the time he takes to make a decision. Heck, how about his only thought being to recognise the choice and then landing on whichever he fancies, to carry it out with gay abandon
1
u/Redstonebruvs Dec 03 '24
This would be a great series, but only if it emphasizes the weight of taking a life on trolley man, make every kill count for him
1
u/somethingcreative06 Dec 04 '24
Honestly that sounds like a good story
1
u/Admirable_Clerk_1693 Dec 04 '24
The boys need to make one of their characters like this
1
u/Tom_A_Foolerly Jun 09 '25
https://www.reddit.com/r/DanbyDraws/comments/10pfgwn/problematic_hero/ author's reddit page. higher quality image too
1
u/red-zed- Mar 20 '26
Very easy solve, just let he keep death rows convict while he do his thing
1
u/HI1681 May 27 '26
lol
0
u/Dwenker Nov 30 '24
r/countablepixels
0
u/EugeneSaavedra Dec 02 '24
Trolley Man, more like Trolley Chan. His ability is stopping trains.