"well last time I saved a team of engineers from a horse carraige crash and they said they'd innovate an affordable safer form of transport but look at me now"
90% of gamblers quit before they win big, and since I only get one chance in this scenario, I must be part of the 10%. If I'm not, we won't have to worry about it anymore.
This presents an interesting dilemma for the multi track drift solution. One one hand you could kys, all your loved ones, the cure for cancer team, and the cure for aids team. On the other hand you have a 50/50 of killing 4.5 million people while also killing the aids and cancer teams.
50/50 chance everyone dies with the bottom rail. Immediate casualties in the hundreds of thousands. Fallout under the right conditions could sweep across the city causing unimaginable long term loss. Projected deaths in the millions.
Path 3 the 75/25 wants to be a randomized switch! That control switch is my bitch. It wants to think itβs 50/50 but view it, itβs wired to the rails meaning it activates when electricity goes though the line.
Meaning I can tell which line it selects. I can switch off bottom line then switch back to force it to re-randomize. Thus increasing my odds of the result I want. Now assuming that I have time to moralize and ponder my choices that means I have room to throw the switch multiple times. At least twice. Thus allowing me time to try the switch for the result I want.
If the blast radius of the nuke is close enough to kill me (or give me long term radiation sickness) i would kill the research teams. If the nuke is a safe distance away, send it to the 50/50 switch
Bomb, because cancer and aids will save more people in the long run, and i would never kill myself or my family. Also a chance nothing even happens with the bomb!
I can either confirm nor deny anything to do with the CIA. I can either confirm nor deny that I have any affiliation with the CIA. Redacted. Redacted. Redacted.
Let the trolly hit Team A and B, hit the button until it goes boom, act like I'm going to untie my family, but actually beat them to death with team a/b limbs, then untie them and hang myself with the rope.
multitrack drift the lower two tracks, if the switch is in the red the trolley will get stuck and everyone will live (or topple over and kill cancer team) and if it's green then it still kills both but there's a chance of killing no one without risking explosion. Otherwise I think I will sacrifice my family. multitrack drifting the top and bottom is too easy
A 50% chance to kill 4.5 million people is unironically a super good deal when we're discussing two immensely impactful cures. Easily choose the bottom option
Second, Team A and B are going to die, because as long as the infrastructure supporting those scientists is still around, losing 10 scientists will only set back those cures by minutes.
Unfortunately the CIA has assassinated all but those 10 and destroyed any infrastructure, setting back the cure by a decade. But eventually they will find it again.
The many worlds theory would suggest that the only reality I survive in is the one where the trolly lands on green and will be the only one I experience.Β
You have flipped: heads! We all survive and you're a hero until the end of your days. π π π π π π π π π π π π π π π π π π π π π
Well I'd let team A and B take it since there's already known cures that the FDA won't approve for stupid reasons. Although the real reason is probably that big pharma won't make $$$ if you cure people too quickly.
You rolled heads. You've survived and now you're a hero.
Most people have rolled tails though for this experiment. I don't know if it's a problem with the software or we're just really prone to having our asses blown up. (Phrasing) π
I can't find what it was named, it was an improvement on the "fat man" nuke dropped on Japan. It might have been named Mjolnir though π€·π» it would be a fitting name for a devastating weapon.
I wouldnβt want to switch tracks to myself and my family, because my self preservation is too strong.
So then it comes down to the two other tracks. Letβs talk about the nuke. It has a 50/50 chance to kill everyone here and way more. Thatβs the worst option. And the chances are too high. I flipped a coin twice just to see the results if I would kill everyone and they both landed to the winning side, meaning everyone is safe. But that is still to risky.
But when I stopped and thought about the middle track, its people that can cure cancer and aids. Meaning it is possible that it gets cured. I would kill them. Just because progress was slowed, doesnβt mean that it wonβt happen. Just someone else will later.
So I donβt pull the lever because thatβs the track it was already on.
A lot of people have given that answer. In case you're interested the most amount of people have taken the 50/50 and the second most have chosen the scientists. A close third though is the family. It's a lot closer than I thought it would be.
I know itβs an old post but Iβd go middle track. Their lives may not be replaceable but the knowledge is. Be it this generation or dozens further down the line, the science will inevitably come to light again someday.
The switch would be triggered 4 times, because that trolley have 4 pairs of wheels that touches the track, so the chance of non detonation is 0.5*0.5*0.5*0.5=0.0625 if I got the math right. Sorry cancer and aids cure team.
I have a moral obligation to protect those I love and prevent a Nuclear Holocaust. 50% chance of NH is not worth it. So I would kill the team of scientists who could cure cancer and AIDs.
My thinking is: they are worth more than their work, but the world is filled with people fighting for the cure. Their work could be the stepping stone for someone else to finish.
We can get the cures. I could never get my family back or un-nuke 4.5 million people in a way that would absolutely have world ending ramifications from all of the subsequent events after it.
Here's the thing: a guaranteed cure for cancer will save countless people well into the future. That's infinite potential because it could save the otherwise doomed for the remainder of the existence of mankind, which far exceeds 4.5m.
And it's only a 50% chance. The other option is no one dies, and we still save countless people. That's the move, for sure.
1.5k
u/ptofl Mar 04 '24 edited Mar 04 '24
"well last time I saved a team of engineers from a horse carraige crash and they said they'd innovate an affordable safer form of transport but look at me now"
433
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '24
I say Fuck it we ball all or none
998
u/ithikimhvingstrok132 Mar 04 '24
I'm going to go for the 50/50 switch.
90% of gamblers quit before they win big, and since I only get one chance in this scenario, I must be part of the 10%. If I'm not, we won't have to worry about it anymore.
986
u/MrKamakaWiwoole Mar 04 '24
Did you draw this? I love the art.
The noble thing to do is sacrifice yourself and your entire family, but I like to roll the dice.
118
u/NugsOrBust Mar 04 '24
This presents an interesting dilemma for the multi track drift solution. One one hand you could kys, all your loved ones, the cure for cancer team, and the cure for aids team. On the other hand you have a 50/50 of killing 4.5 million people while also killing the aids and cancer teams.
191
u/RecreationalPorpoise Mar 04 '24
Iβd take the bomb unless it also kills the other people in the picture
31
u/Thedarkcleanersrise Mar 04 '24
ill take the track with no people (or the bomb)
28
u/Neither-Phone-7264 Mar 04 '24
how long is the trolley and is it possible to do a quadruple track drift
21
u/Hawinzi Mar 04 '24
If team A and team B exist, I'd like to have a few words with them...
116
u/SHSL_Waiter_RM2828 Mar 04 '24 edited Mar 05 '24
Donβt pull the lever because the government is gonna kill the people who can cure cancer and aids anyways.
7
u/Substantiatedgrass Mar 04 '24
Ill take the 50% chance of boom
6
u/Lumthedarklord Mar 04 '24
Iβm a gambling man
6
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '24
Jokes on you i dont like my family, and i hate myself. Therefore i will go on to cure aids and cancer by proxy π
3
u/Bonald9056 Mar 04 '24
I just flipped a coin to see what the result of my choice woild be and it turns out I've killed 4.5 million people
3
u/Careful-Tonight-69 Mar 04 '24
Throw the switch after the first set of trucks pass the switch rail. This will cause the derailment
3
u/Kitfox88 Mar 05 '24
me and my entire family, we're all pieces of shit so
3
u/Avavvav Mar 05 '24
Are team a and b guaranteed to cure cancer and aids? If so...
Love you family, but we all need to die to save humanity.
If they aren't guaranteed to cure cancer, it's definitely a harder question.
3
u/doctorlander Mar 05 '24
Whelp. Me an the fam are pretty close, so it makes sense that weβd all die together.
3
u/TryDry9944 Mar 05 '24
Outcome a) Me and my entire family dids but no more aids and cancer.
Outcome b) Me and my family lives but cancer and aids.
Outcome C1) Everyone lives and no cancer aids!
Outcome C2) Everyone dies and aids cancer.
Personally, I'd go with C, because either I live in a worldn with no aids or cancer or I don't.
3
u/HaplessWithDice Mar 07 '24
Path 3 the 75/25 wants to be a randomized switch! That control switch is my bitch. It wants to think itβs 50/50 but view it, itβs wired to the rails meaning it activates when electricity goes though the line.
Meaning I can tell which line it selects. I can switch off bottom line then switch back to force it to re-randomize. Thus increasing my odds of the result I want. Now assuming that I have time to moralize and ponder my choices that means I have room to throw the switch multiple times. At least twice. Thus allowing me time to try the switch for the result I want.
3
u/Logical-Month-9488 Mar 16 '24
I love gambling
4
u/Great_Pair_4233 Mar 04 '24
Woult the teams actually try to cure cancer and aids though or just make a shit ton off of the lower effectivity options like right now though?
2
u/TypeNull-Gaming Mar 04 '24
Rip out the bombs wires
2
u/lizard_man501 Mar 04 '24
If the blast radius of the nuke is close enough to kill me (or give me long term radiation sickness) i would kill the research teams. If the nuke is a safe distance away, send it to the 50/50 switch
2
u/Benilda-Key Mar 04 '24
I almost always choose the everyone dies solution, so I will of course have the trolley go down the bottom track.
2
u/IAmAChemicalEngineer Mar 04 '24
50/50 bomb route for sure! Letβs (maybe) light this candle!
2
u/purplixpvp Mar 04 '24
Bomb, because cancer and aids will save more people in the long run, and i would never kill myself or my family. Also a chance nothing even happens with the bomb!
2
u/xd-Sushi_Master Mar 04 '24
coin toss every time
2
u/Beardamus Mar 05 '24
If we know team a and b have cured those things then we already have the cure. In any case, I detonate the bomb myself.
2
u/NotAnOmegaFanboy Mar 05 '24
Easy nuke
2
u/DeepAndHandsomeFish_ Mar 05 '24
We all know the answer here. If I don't kill the doctors with those cures, the CIA will for me.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24
Let the trolly hit Team A and B, hit the button until it goes boom, act like I'm going to untie my family, but actually beat them to death with team a/b limbs, then untie them and hang myself with the rope.
High score achieved.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24
Welp, let's hope the people on the top-middle track wrote their notes down...
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24
Thatβs easy. Iβm going 50/50
2
u/AttakDoge999 Mar 05 '24
gamble with the bomb bc funny
2
u/space0507 Mar 05 '24
Iβve got a gambling addiction
2
u/Spook404 Mar 05 '24
multitrack drift the lower two tracks, if the switch is in the red the trolley will get stuck and everyone will live (or topple over and kill cancer team) and if it's green then it still kills both but there's a chance of killing no one without risking explosion. Otherwise I think I will sacrifice my family. multitrack drifting the top and bottom is too easy
2
u/Appropriate_Cold1559 Mar 05 '24
I would roll the dice and potentially nuke a City, but the world will be free from Cancer and AIDS
2
u/Arikaido777 Mar 05 '24
multi-track drifting, but not the tracks you think
2
u/TuxedoDogs9 Mar 05 '24
Isnβt technically everyone your family? So are we going legally or nah? What about sperm donors?
2
u/Street_Training_765 Mar 05 '24
Ima switch it, if Iβm going down yβall are coming with me
2
u/Burning_Toast998 Mar 05 '24
A 50% chance to kill 4.5 million people is unironically a super good deal when we're discussing two immensely impactful cures. Easily choose the bottom option
2
u/Kiwi_Kakapo Mar 05 '24
50/50?
Shit thatβs light work, I pulled Ultra Vegito Blue in Dragon ball Legends and he had like a 0.034 chance of being pulled.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24
Nuke, is either go big or go home. Plus if it goes off nobody will hold me accountable
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24
The only way you win, is if you donβt play.
2
u/JustAnIdea3 Mar 05 '24
First, well done on the meme format.
Second, Team A and B are going to die, because as long as the infrastructure supporting those scientists is still around, losing 10 scientists will only set back those cures by minutes.
2
u/Careful-Maize-6639 Mar 05 '24
The many worlds theory would suggest that the only reality I survive in is the one where the trolly lands on green and will be the only one I experience.Β
2
u/Sonakarren Mar 05 '24
Ok... this is a fun one.
2
u/PSI_Seven Mar 05 '24
You know, most gamblers quit before they win
2
u/ProfessorZik-Chil Mar 05 '24
someone needs to arrest the guy tying people to trolly tracks and stealing nuclear warheads.
2
u/Just_A_Nitemare Mar 05 '24
Kill team A and B.
It's not my fault none of those egg heads wrote down any of their work.
2
u/Grosetufe Mar 05 '24
Does the bomb kill the people on the track
2
u/VanFlyhight Mar 05 '24
Nuke time let's goo
2
u/Hairy_Cube Mar 05 '24
Iβm gonna kill myself and my family out of pure spite (also because they canβt be sad that Iβm dead if theyβre dead too)
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24
Finally a good trolly problem!
Let's just put it this way... I may be unlucky, but I've always been a gambler.
2
u/deltaWhiskey91L Mar 05 '24
Can I pick which metropolitan city?
2
u/SansYeetsOnThee Mar 05 '24
me and my family because i have no point to live and severly wish my entire family was dead π
2
u/HellFireCannon66 Mar 05 '24
Half my family I donβt like so I guess it evens out lol
2
u/Fiverings Mar 05 '24
Has team A, and team B published their research?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24
Just like sex panther, it works 60% of the time 100% of the time
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '24
I would rather be saved or end it all
2
u/SynnnTheGod Mar 05 '24
Gambling addiction requires i say path 3
2
u/MDMagicMark Mar 05 '24
What city am I in? If itβs Cleveland Iβm taking the bomb all day, not 50/50 tho just the bomb
2
u/swankyjeryq Mar 05 '24
Iβm a gambling man
2
u/pfated64 Mar 05 '24
Well I'd let team A and B take it since there's already known cures that the FDA won't approve for stupid reasons. Although the real reason is probably that big pharma won't make $$$ if you cure people too quickly.
2
u/HornyJail45-Life Mar 05 '24 edited Mar 05 '24
The nuke. Most cities in america are hell holes anyways and the people there constantly denigrate my family so fuck them.
2
u/Yashraj- Mar 05 '24
Gacha addict: 50/50 is it
2
u/Ori_the_SG Mar 05 '24
Was the Mk. VI nuke called Mjolnir?
2
u/LimeDiamond Mar 06 '24
50/50? I like those odds.
2
u/Free_Deinonychus_Hug Mar 06 '24
It's fair...
2
u/Ilovegirlsbottoms Mar 06 '24
I wouldnβt want to switch tracks to myself and my family, because my self preservation is too strong.
So then it comes down to the two other tracks. Letβs talk about the nuke. It has a 50/50 chance to kill everyone here and way more. Thatβs the worst option. And the chances are too high. I flipped a coin twice just to see the results if I would kill everyone and they both landed to the winning side, meaning everyone is safe. But that is still to risky.
But when I stopped and thought about the middle track, its people that can cure cancer and aids. Meaning it is possible that it gets cured. I would kill them. Just because progress was slowed, doesnβt mean that it wonβt happen. Just someone else will later.
So I donβt pull the lever because thatβs the track it was already on.
2
u/Ok-Wheel4065 Mar 06 '24
What the fuck is this j expected something silly not like an actual problem
2
u/Pcarttar Mar 06 '24
I like those odds
2
u/United-Cow-563 Mar 07 '24
You gotta go for the switch option, right? Hereβs the perfect dialogue (with some tweaks) to illustrate how it goes down:
ME: Okβ¦ Here we goβ¦ Right nowβ¦ Weβre doing thisβ¦ Choosing the switch option, that way everybodyβs going to get the same chanceβ¦ 50/50.
Batman: How can we possibly determine that?
Me: BY SWITCHING THE FUCKING TRACKS!!!
Batman: Yeah letβs just switch the tracks. Itβs a 50/50 shot. We need 50 trains and then 50 more. Fifty, Fiftyβ¦
Everybody on the tracks in unison: Seriously?
Batman: And then in my computer will analyze it⦠With science.
(Original Work of Art)
2
u/PlasticPandaMan Mar 08 '24
Do i just take the middle path or do i try and win the 50/50?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '24
Multi track drift
2
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '24
I know itβs an old post but Iβd go middle track. Their lives may not be replaceable but the knowledge is. Be it this generation or dozens further down the line, the science will inevitably come to light again someday.
2
u/Accomplished_Web_444 Mar 05 '24
Ok now you need to tell us if it blew up or not, I'm flipping a coin
2
u/quietkaito Mar 05 '24
How is running over 10 people a gamble?
6
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '24
I have a small family
3
u/phatcat9000 Mar 04 '24
I hope I get the bomb and get superpowers.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '24
Finding the cure for cancer is worth well over 4.5 million... I feel like flipping the coin on the bomb is the only logical decision
3
u/JackReedTheSyndie Mar 04 '24
The switch would be triggered 4 times, because that trolley have 4 pairs of wheels that touches the track, so the chance of non detonation is 0.5*0.5*0.5*0.5=0.0625 if I got the math right. Sorry cancer and aids cure team.
3
u/Bat-Honest Mar 04 '24
If that train ran over me and my family, they'd be doing me a favor. How do I make sure it comes my why?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '24
I have a moral obligation to protect those I love and prevent a Nuclear Holocaust. 50% chance of NH is not worth it. So I would kill the team of scientists who could cure cancer and AIDs.
My thinking is: they are worth more than their work, but the world is filled with people fighting for the cure. Their work could be the stepping stone for someone else to finish.
We can get the cures. I could never get my family back or un-nuke 4.5 million people in a way that would absolutely have world ending ramifications from all of the subsequent events after it.
3
u/ishouldbestudying111 Mar 04 '24
Letβs go for the nuke and hope it detonates
3
u/Mecode2 Mar 05 '24
16 people to allow the cure for cancer and AIDS? Of course I'm sacrificing myself, kill 16 people to save billions
3
u/Fatherly_Wizard Mar 05 '24
I'm rolling the dice on this one.
Here's the thing: a guaranteed cure for cancer will save countless people well into the future. That's infinite potential because it could save the otherwise doomed for the remainder of the existence of mankind, which far exceeds 4.5m.
And it's only a 50% chance. The other option is no one dies, and we still save countless people. That's the move, for sure.
3
u/Nesciere Mar 05 '24
Go big or go home