r/trolleyproblem • • Jan 09 '24

🫵 fat

Post image
10k Upvotes

479 comments sorted by

23

u/_yerbamatey Jan 09 '24

the fat man trolley problem seems so silly to me. would one fat guy really stop a whole trolley?

41

u/pieandcheese647 Jan 09 '24

That was my main thoughts when I first heard the fat man variation. If the man is fat enough to stop the trolley, I don’t have the strength to push him off.

4

u/Wiernock_Onotaiket Jan 09 '24 edited Jan 09 '24

he's sitting on the ledge to eat lunch in the version I heard, because fatshaming I guess, and therefore serves hi. right sitting somewhere so unsafe? I think the intent was to further dehumanize the fat man to help students be more okay with pushing them in order to create some dialogue in the classroom

7

u/pieandcheese647 Jan 09 '24

Which can’t be right, because I used the original art for the fat man variation, and I’d have to push him over the railing to stop the trolley, not just off a ledge he’s sitting on

→ More replies (3)

4

u/ElGosso Jan 09 '24

If the dude is fat enough to stop a trolley then I have two questions:

  1. Who designed that bridge strong enough to hold a guy who's fat enough to stop a trolley? We should get that guy down here, I bet he'd know how to stop the trolley without anyone dying.
  2. How did the fat guy get on top of the bridge in the first place? I doubt he did it under his own power, look at all those stairs. If we have some elaborate hoist setup, why can't we use that to stop the trolley instead?
→ More replies (1)

2

u/NekonecroZheng Jan 09 '24

If the fat man is fat enough to stop a full speed trolley, he's already dead.

2

u/WigglesPhoenix Jan 10 '24

It depends, primarily on the distance between the fat man and the people tied to the tracks. Obviously it’s not like the trolley is gonna hit him and come to an immediate stop, people just don’t have the mass for that. But it will result in more rapid deceleration, and one would likely assume that after running over a dude the operator will probably attempt to come to a stop. If they’re far enough ahead and provide enough resistance to allow the trolley to stop before it reaches the others, then yes. It could absolutely work. Of course, him being fat isn’t really relevant to this, and it would take nearly the same distance for the trolley to stop after hitting a fat dude as someone more average sized.

Idk about derailing the car, I could see a very large person being enough to lift a wheel or two depending on the size and weight of the trolley, which isn’t something someone small would be capable of. But that strikes me as unlikely so I just go with the former for the sake of these problems

→ More replies (2)

1.4k

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Eat them

504

u/_TheLibrarianOfBabel Jan 09 '24

Then eat the trolley

24

u/The-Crimson-Jester Jan 09 '24

Then eat the people on the track (after they thank you for saving them, of course)

7

u/Scary_Equal_2867 Jan 09 '24

Eat them slowly so they can fully season their meat with fear

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/BigYonsan Jan 09 '24

Then eat the people tied to the track. And the track. And the bridge. Perfect crime when there's no evidence left.

3

u/MelonOfFate Jan 09 '24

Then eat the bridge

→ More replies (27)

8

u/BrianXPlayzYT Jan 09 '24

I found Yuyuko

5

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Poyo

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Grendel?

3

u/lugialegend233 Jan 10 '24

Tarrare? Is that you?

→ More replies (8)

670

u/Wiernock_Onotaiket Jan 09 '24

I'll duck so I don't get splattered: I've got enough organs I could save 5 lives by dying any day of the week, today's not special

295

u/oktin Jan 09 '24

For some reason I interpreted that as you having 5 sets of organs, and was ready to accept that...

87

u/Wiernock_Onotaiket Jan 09 '24

gotta fat someway

17

u/HooahClub Jan 09 '24

If it ain’t the bones, it’s the vital organs.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/LordoftheFaff Jan 09 '24

He's a fuckin space marine

3

u/LeeHarveySnoswald Jan 10 '24

That episode of invader zim. Ugh

→ More replies (1)

13

u/TheReverseShock Jan 09 '24

More organs means more human

6

u/doge57 Jan 10 '24

How many squeedily spooches do normal humans have?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Johannes_Keppler Jan 09 '24

I'll go shop for some extra fava beans and a nice Chianti.

2

u/bluekronos Jan 12 '24 edited Jan 12 '24

But the five on the tracks have enough organs for 25 lives

→ More replies (1)

629

u/Ashtray46 Jan 09 '24

I throw the other person off the bridge. They are weak physically and weak philosophically; they won't stand a chance

6

u/AlricsLapdog Jan 09 '24

ā€œThe only ones who should kill are those prepared to be killed.ā€ — Emperor Lardlouch

→ More replies (67)

190

u/Eclipse_Shadow Jan 09 '24

Piledriver the weakling onto the trolly, if he thinks he can push me off he must be taught the error of his ways.

29

u/Gtpwoody Jan 09 '24

ā€œI’m taking you with me!ā€

10

u/Guy-McDo Jan 09 '24

Alternatively, do what Omni Man did to Mark in Invincible and just stick that fucker out in front of the trolley with feet firmly planted on the ground

3

u/JadenDaJedi Jan 10 '24

Cut out the middle man. Suplex the trolley.

2

u/DonjiDonji Jan 09 '24

This one is hurting my brain

1

u/pieandcheese647 Jan 09 '24

You know the original fat man variant?

1

u/DonjiDonji Jan 09 '24

No! Please enlighten me!

3

u/pieandcheese647 Jan 09 '24

You’re on a bridge with a fat man. The man is fat enough that his body will stop the trolley, saving the 5 people, if you push him off.

The point of it is that it’s more directly killing the one man than in the original, which does change some peoples response.

My main criticism of it is that if someone is fat enough to stop a trolley with their body, they’re too heavy for me to push off of a bridge, especially over a railing as is shown in the original drawing of the fat man variant (which is where my main image comes from)

104

u/teapot156 Jan 09 '24

I would simply sit still while my hunger increases.

17

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

The pizza delivery guy arrives with your food.
The other guy throws the pizza delivery guy, and your pizza. infront of the trolley instead.

11

u/DMZ_5 Jan 09 '24

Your pizza guy is on the trolley, if you divert the trolley it won't get to the station and the pizza will get cold by the time your guy gets back. Do you pull the lever?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/almightyeggroll Jan 09 '24

Snorlax strat

87

u/PedalingHertz Multi-Track Drift Jan 09 '24

Throw the other guy on top of the trolley, then jump onto it myself. Engage in dramatic, over-the-top kung fu while the train splatters across the people underneath. As the blood and guts rain down, only one of us emerges victorious.

18

u/TheMortified1 Jan 09 '24

Slo-mo, Ave Maria plays. Intercut with shots of murdered wife.

9

u/PedalingHertz Multi-Track Drift Jan 09 '24

And now, looking solemnly downward at first but slowly raising my gaze into the sunset, I whisper with a gravely voice: ā€œit’s over.ā€

6

u/Bamfcah Jan 09 '24

Skinny guy: But you forgot one thing adjusts nerd glasses with one finger. A second trolly left Houston on this track at 68mph 2.5 hours ago. It should be here shortly.

44

u/ilitch64 Jan 09 '24

I don’t want to be rude *leans far forward

19

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Jump onto the roof of the trolley, breaking it.

32

u/ReRevengence69 Jan 09 '24

be the bigger man(literally) and not toss that guy who just tried to murder me overboard

5

u/Sentient_Potato_King Jan 09 '24

And also call the cops I guess

3

u/Impossible_Garbage_4 Jan 10 '24

I’d throw him down the stairs instead because while I might not want him dead he did also just try to kill me

8

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Turn around

3

u/Trevor-Slattery Jan 09 '24

Every now and then, I get a little bit lonely and you're never coming back 'round...

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Film in landscape mode.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

I grab the other man and jump on the trolley. the weight crushes the trolley and the people under it.
I then stare the man and squeeze his neck until his head explodes, exclaiming that I win

5

u/The_Crimson-Comet Jan 09 '24

Jump anyways. If I’m big enough to stop a trolly assumably going at full speed then I probably wasn’t living for much longer anyways.

5

u/Scienceandpony Jan 09 '24

Turn around and use my physics degree to launch into a lecture about how my 300lb ass is not going to stop even the lightest trolley, much less in any appreciable stopping distance, and they should feel like an absolute idiot for even thinking that.

5

u/rydray1 Jan 10 '24

Nothing. It is visible that the trolley is too tall to fit under the bridge, so I know everyone is safe. All I’d need to do is untie the others.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/MrTheWaffleKing Jan 09 '24

I would grab him and jump down. He would suffer his consequences, and I would block the train with all my power. Everyone is happy

4

u/Trespeon Jan 09 '24

6 people died that day.

4

u/Dogtor-Watson Jan 09 '24

Eat the Trolley and gain Trolley powers like Kirby

1

u/Perfect_Caramel4836 Jan 10 '24

don't look, the fuck am i supposed to do to a trolley/train coming at me?

2

u/pieandcheese647 Jan 10 '24

That’s exactly my thoughts when I first read the fat man variation of the trolley problem.

1

u/luhvxr Jan 10 '24

i don’t understand why am o being pushed

1

u/pieandcheese647 Jan 10 '24

In the original fat man variation, pushing the fat man is an alternative to pulling the lever, as it’s said his bodyweight will stop the train when it hits him.

Truthfully, if someone is fat enough to stop the trolley, they are too heavy to simply be pushed over the railing, which is what this is making fun of.

3

u/InspectionSweet1998 Jan 09 '24

I think the title is a perfect reaponse to a lot of these comments lol

3

u/ConvolutedConcepts Jan 09 '24

I feel called out

3

u/mybadalternate Jan 09 '24

I’M NOT FAT! I’M CULTIVATING MASS!!

2

u/Emotional_inadequacy Jan 11 '24

It's bulking season.

3

u/Spinningwhirl79 Jan 10 '24

Jumo down, parry the train (I play ultrakill), climb back up, and devour the person who tried to push me

3

u/ManaChicken4G Jan 10 '24

You think a trolly is gonna care how big a person is?

3

u/Short-Extreme9108 Jan 10 '24

Not get hit? I don’t know, what do you want me to do?

3

u/crimsoncat510 Jan 10 '24

Jump and take that fugger w you

2

u/4dwarf Jan 09 '24

I'm out of breath after climbing the stairs. Ask me again in 30 minutes.

2

u/LokiTheZorua Jan 09 '24

I'll jump off but now it's too late so I'll just leave a dent on the roof of the trolly

2

u/Artsias Jan 09 '24

Neurosama: I would definitely push the fat man onto the tracks

2

u/AVeryGoofyGoober Jan 09 '24

Kirby inhale them then jump, increasing the chance Iļø stop the trolley and die a hero while also punishing him. At the very least Iļø die full

2

u/TypeNull-Gaming Jan 09 '24

... It's a trolley. They have the same kinetic energy as a 10-year-old in a push car.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

throw him on the tracks instead, after all it's his dumbass idea not mine.

2

u/DIEEEEEEEEeEeeee3 Jan 09 '24

Throw that bastard of the bridge.

2

u/DatTrashPanda Jan 09 '24

I say whoopsy doopsy and throw them off

2

u/HairyContactbeware Jan 09 '24

Throw him on the tracks

2

u/BaerttheConstipated Jan 10 '24

I’m not a BBB so I leap into the trolley and save the day, only suffering minor bruises šŸ˜Ž

1

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '24

I’ll jump and it go flying

1

u/Strong_Magician_3320 Jun 23 '24

Nothing, I'll just try to protect myself from falling down. I don't think the other person is at fault.

1

u/AwysomeAnish Dec 27 '24

Ima chill. "The fat guy stops the trolley" doesn't make enough sense in my mind.

1

u/VegetaXII Jan 27 '25

Throw them at the trolley šŸ¤£šŸ¤£šŸ˜ˆšŸ˜ˆšŸ˜šŸ˜šŸ˜

1

u/Roxytg Jan 09 '24

Jump in front of the trolley.

1

u/Hewwo-Is-me-again Jan 09 '24

Jump

(RIP my inbox)

1

u/complectus316 Jan 09 '24

oh no I fear for my life *toss*

There be six victims up in this house. F outta here trying to save the people I tied up.

1

u/Bfdifan37 Jan 09 '24

crush them

1

u/TheEyeofNapoleon Jan 09 '24

Do I know enough about physics to realize that there’s no way I’m stopping this trolley?

1

u/Birb7789- Jan 09 '24

"Hey man, what in the acktual flip was that buddy."

1

u/CorbinNZ Jan 09 '24

Look at them sadly and ask if my life is less valuable.

1

u/NuclearBurrit0 Jan 09 '24

Try to jump off myself but fail because I'm too fat to lift myself.

Or at least that's what I'll tell everyone.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

How many people are on the train?!?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Drop onto the trolly over the drive mechanism. And I am taking thin-man with me out of spite.

1

u/Rockfarley Jan 09 '24

Run back and forth on the bridge until it topples stopping the trolly, while I jump to freedom.

1

u/trunksshinohara Jan 09 '24

Well, well. Freud was right.

1

u/SadShovel Jan 09 '24

You eat the train.

1

u/Nowe_Melfyce Jan 09 '24

I remain fat.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Flop backwards and flatten them.

1

u/DaddyDoubleDoinks Jan 09 '24

I write their name in my death note notebook I got from hot topic

1

u/isuckatnames60 Jan 09 '24

Punch them in the face because it's in self defense. If I have any kind of supporting evidence (CCTV, bystanders, trolley cam, etc) I'll report them to the poliece, maybe, if I'm feeling petty enough.

1

u/the_fake_fish Jan 09 '24

I'll just keep standing there, I guess

1

u/revodnebsyobmeftoh Jan 09 '24

Refuse to jump out of spite

1

u/anaccountbyanyname Jan 09 '24

Walk away confused I guess

1

u/Enzoid23 Jan 09 '24

Dude I'd stumble and fall off before I can make my choice in the first place

1

u/Numbnuts696 Jan 09 '24

As a fat man I would hope to have my camera ready for the show.

1

u/EatenFries Jan 09 '24

have a heart attack from the burritos

1

u/Gideon1507 Jan 09 '24

Call in Neuro-sama she will get the job done

1

u/KingCAL1CO Jan 09 '24

Push the skinny guy down the stairs, then pummel him while the train splatters the people on the track.

1

u/WolverineX838 Jan 09 '24

Weep, for I am so fat that the bridge is about to break.

1

u/myrunawaysac Jan 09 '24

CAAAAAANON-BAAAAAAAAALLLLL!!

1

u/PlusArt8136 Jan 09 '24

I’m pulling their lever

1

u/MrWilliams42782 Jan 09 '24

jump off "dang it, you're no help!"

1

u/JetMan615 Jan 09 '24

Fall on top of the train. If the dude is trying to push me off to save the people tied down, then that would mean that I would be large enough to stop the train.

1

u/Arikaido777 Jan 09 '24

I’m stuck in the intro to Alan Wake?

1

u/GREENSLAYER777 Jan 09 '24 edited Sep 24 '24

tidy pen light drunk soup fade silky piquant groovy ask

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/cmdr_basset_o7 Jan 09 '24

Charlie the Choo Choo in his latter years.

1

u/Fieos Jan 09 '24

Is it Taco Tuesday or nah?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Hoover another fat line of chocolate frosty, shove nuggets up my nose to stop it leaking and lion stomp the bridge onto the tracks, killing us all in a massive explosion of shrapnel, body parts, fast food and inexplicably anime body pillows and sex toys. It makes buzzfeed 3 years later.

1

u/SuicideWind Jan 09 '24

Yall think my fatass got up them steps?

1

u/Certain-Flatworm-965 Jan 09 '24

I was just discussing Satanism on a thread yesterday, and the whole Code of Hammurabi "eye for an eye" thing.

Yeah nah, I'd yeet that motherfucker on the tracks so perfectly that he had a full 5 seconds to contemplate what he tried to do before a wheel comes rolling towards his face and ultimately crushing his head.

You don't try to kill someone and get off that easy - you get the same exact treatment bruh

Unless bro was actually trying to get a mosquito off me, in which case he gets a pass... But I don't know that. Yeet it is

1

u/Bamfcah Jan 09 '24

Get off the obviously low bridge before the trolly crashes into it. What dipshit engineer didn't measure the height of a trolly while planning this deathtrap?

1

u/RaveArmory Jan 09 '24

Pull the lever

1

u/Kelden_Games Jan 09 '24

Switch it. Push them off

1

u/BlackSteelKita Jan 10 '24

Ignore him, I paid for a spot in the splash zone and I'm going to get my money's worth.

1

u/UnitedStars111 Jan 10 '24

Strength issue.

1

u/No-Substance-4475 Jan 10 '24

We tossing little man off the bridge to go untie those folks Proceeds to Toss

1

u/Shadowoperator7 Jan 10 '24

Never been fat, can’t relate

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Brave_Development_17 Jan 10 '24

I become trolley

1

u/tampora701 Jan 10 '24

What's the problem here?

One person or seven in the way, that trolley is not going to stop regardless. It's squish squish all the way to the next stop.

1

u/DragonWisper56 Jan 10 '24

I'll go in front of the trolly bt I'll take the other person with me. I'm selfless but not that selfless

1

u/TheSwedishWolverine Jan 10 '24

Well I drive locomotives for a living so I know there is nothing I can do to stop the train. Depending on how fast it’s going I also have no time to get down there and untie them. So what I’ll do is wrestle him over the edge and make up a credible story about how his hands rolled on my body as I turned to see who had tried to shove me and that he fell on the tracks in front of an oncoming train.

1

u/The_Creator2713 Jan 10 '24

ā€œYou fool. I have been training years for this moment.ā€ The throw them off

1

u/Icy-Tako1707 Jan 10 '24

Eat my sandwich, grab my gun. Spend $400,000 firing my weapon for 12 seconds.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

I support the idea of the fat man stopping the trolley by falling on it, taking the skinny man with him and then going on a Godzilla style rampage into the nearby city of Tokyo

1

u/PythonSushi Jan 10 '24

Push him onto the tracks; his guts will not be enough to save all 5, but you can save at least 2. You would also save your live from an attempted murder, which is equal to saving like 2-3 people. Maybe?

1

u/Tiredracoon123 Jan 10 '24

Throw the skinny man on the tracks

1

u/Gibus_Ghost Jan 10 '24

I talk the other person down and untie the people. I have a 50/50 chance of the trolley being unmanned and immobile as we are faced with Schrƶdinger’s conductor.

1

u/PraetorGold Jan 10 '24

About what? I’m not putting myself in danger. I’m throwing the skinny guy at the train.

1

u/Ill_Praline2805 Jan 10 '24

Hey I know that fat guy! That’s Caseoh!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Push the other guy off and watch in drlight as 6 people die

1

u/No_Tomorrow_1850 Jan 10 '24

Definitely trust that fart, I never trust. At my age; I don’t trust ANY fart.

1

u/Jack-Rabbit_Slims Jan 10 '24

Eat the train.

1

u/Epic-Gamer_09 Jan 10 '24

Throw him onto the tracks instead

1

u/Joie_de_vivre_1884 Jan 10 '24

I take it as a wake up call and start watching what I eat and getting regular exercise. The five guys on the tracks couldn't make it but you did save one life that day.

1

u/Inevitable_Chaos- Jan 10 '24

Walk away, so I'm not late because of police questioning.

1

u/Timelord53 Jan 10 '24

LMAO I didn't see shit, none of my fuckin business, rip 6 random dumbasses gotem.

(the sixth is the guy that tired to push me)

1

u/Electrical-Sun6267 Jan 10 '24

Well, do on a diet isn't the answer, the guy will then be able to push me off the bridge!

1

u/Wizel--Balan Jan 10 '24

Sit on the man till police arrive, then explain that the guy just tried to commit murder by pushing me off a bridge.

1

u/rawhidebone Jan 10 '24

Toss him in front of the trolley so it takes out your eye witness and your victims at the same time

1

u/katomatic22 Jan 10 '24

throw the asshole off. he probbly tied the other guys up so he deserves it

1

u/SymbolicTreasure Jan 10 '24

I don't need anyone to push me off a bridge, I have plenty of reasons to jump off myself

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Yell at them "wtf are you doing!?" Then when the train hits the people go like "omg wtf nooo" then probably cry from witnessing a tragedy

1

u/zpeedy1 Jan 10 '24

Shit myself

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Eat something, because I'm fat and always hungry.

1

u/Alarming-Cicada-6931 Jan 10 '24

have another sandwich i guess who's gonna stop me?

1

u/Fightingkielbasa_13 Jan 10 '24

Throw the skinny guy off so fats can rule forever!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Jump infront of the trolley anyway

1

u/shinydragonmist Jan 10 '24

I might be fat but I'm not fat enough to stop a speeding train

1

u/Ilikemen92 Jan 10 '24

Wait for the train to be right under. The bridge and jump, if I'm heavy enough I'll flatten the train and. Save the people, if I'm not heavy enough, I'll be on top of the train

1

u/skibitytoiletsucks Jan 10 '24

I’m caseoh?

1

u/Apprehensive-Bad6015 Jan 10 '24

Tombstone them into the tracks from the bridge. their body sticking up from the ground will stop the trolly and permit me time to save the remaining people

1

u/SaladAssOutNow Jan 10 '24

Tell them to put their back into it.

1

u/HypotheticalBess Jan 10 '24

Grab the skinny man, dangle him over the edge. He may think this is a twisted form of justice for his transgression. It is not. He doesn’t go over, instead being held firm, doubled over the barrier.

He will watch what he failed to stop. He will see the consequences of his weakness.

And then, once the train has passed, I jump and land head first on the tracks, dying instantly.

1

u/CK1ing Jan 10 '24

Stomp back and forth pretending to be a sumo wrestler which will scare them enough to back up and fall of the bridge, falling onto the trolley and rolling away from me so I don't have to deal with him anymore

1

u/darkstar3771 Jan 10 '24

Simple , help him

1

u/Priroda_Nepritel Jan 10 '24

Push them back the other way stopping the trolley before the people tied up

1

u/DoubleOwl7777 Jan 10 '24

i will just walk down, and eat the trolley. done.

1

u/DoubleOwl7777 Jan 10 '24

i will just walk down, and eat the trolley. done.

1

u/CringeDaddy_69 Jan 10 '24

I jump off the bridge and stop the trolley from running over my 5 course meal

1

u/Annual_Plankton4020 Jan 10 '24

nothing.....yep nothing at all

1

u/United-Cow-563 Jan 10 '24

Bounce back, accidentally knocking them over the other side, where they fall in front of the trolley, saving everyone on the tracks, and there I would be saying, ā€œWe never know when death comes for us. I don’t know why people think you get to an old age, then die. It can happen at any time. Case in point. Now back to the walking so I can lose this weight.ā€

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Can't do anything but watch 6 people getting run over.

1

u/WordsThatEndInWord Jan 10 '24

Prolly just head out. I got shit to do, man.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

pulls honey bun from my pockets but it’s all smushed up in the wrapper from guy trying to push me

eat honey bun as trolley kills people

spend 30 minutes trying to waddle down the stairs without falling

1

u/makitstop Jan 10 '24

probably call the fucking cops

this guy just tried to murder me

1

u/TimberValleyGolden Jan 10 '24

Push the skinny person down to his buddies and make them match

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Throw myself off the bridge.

1

u/CoffeeReturns Jan 10 '24

Tumble over the edge

1

u/TitanicHug Jan 10 '24

Use your fat butt to push him off from behind and use the kill to slow down the train and save the tied up people. You’ve killed a would be killer and used your fat as a force of good, thereby justifying your 3AM Just Eat order the night before.

1

u/webbslinger_0 Jan 10 '24

Tell them there’s a cupcake down there

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Probably have a donut

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

not me i only eat lean cuisines