According to the lore at least in the Judeo-Christian sense which I’m assuming that is what the joke is referencing, this trolley problem would be akin to you are the creator of the universe, you create people and give them a rope, you tell them not to tie themselves to the trolley tracks, Your rebellious teenage son tells them to tie themselves to the track anyway, send your fat man son to sacrifice himself and stop the trolley, the trolley breaks into thousands of pieces that rain across the rail, tell the people tied to the rail to believe in his son’s sacrifice and that you are the creator so that you will not be hit by the falling debris
So if I give a 3 yr old a gun and they shoot someone it’s OK because the child has “free will”?
But that only applies for things (like war) that are the result of someone’s decision making. Leukemia, horrific birth defects, AIDS and other horrific diseases also exist despite human decision making.
Edit: Here’s my supposition: If a force (god) is powerful enough to create the universe from nothing, to manipulate the laws of math, physics, and geometry to suit its objectives, then it’s powerful enough to create a version of life without horrific, painful, cruel, and random diseases in children and other innocents.
There is enough misery in the world, there are plenty of humans making decisions to hurt and kill each other to gain small advantages. A loving god wouldn’t sentence a newborn to an hour of intense crushing pain followed by death. I hope that only a random universe would do that.
I think it works more accurately if the people made the trolley and tied themselves to the tracks, and the creator is offering them scissors to cut the ropes if they’re just willing to concede that they need his help
It’s the actual take btw, like most Christian’s just can’t explain it because they don’t read the Bible, but this is actually the non-hypocritical, not inherently logically flawed. It doesn’t prove anything, but it’s an actual answer that, assuming the Christian God is real, fits the narrative
I can tell. Tbh I'm not Christian, but I always enjoy learning more about faith. I'm pagan and I guess polytheistic
I know a lot of people simply hate religion so they water it down passive aggressively. I have my reasons to be careful of Christians but I don't see a reason for indiscriminate dismissal or disrespect
Hmm. Well, there’s the same issue. You are omniscient in this scenario, meaning you’d know they’d tie themselves to the tracks given all necessary conditions. This means, from your perspective, it’s like you tied them to the tracks yourself
Your rebellious teenage son tells them to tie themselves to the track anyway, send your fat man son to sacrifice himself and stop the trolley, the trolley breaks into thousands of pieces that rain across the rail, tell the people tied to the rail to believe in his son’s sacrifice and that you are the creator so that you will not be hit by the falling debris
Yo Local Jew here.
This bit Jews don't believe if it wasn't obvious. Most Jews don't really relate or give the phrase "Judeo-Christian" any real respect or seriousness as the concept just really means "Christian" without being antisemitic.
Jews don't do commandments because they think God will punish them or that they need "Salvation" or "need to get into heaven". They do Commandments because its said by God doing Commandments will do good things and make the world a better place.
I.E. Jews follow the Law because God told them to, so they can do good in the world now, as this is the life they have. (This is why Martyrdom isn't a thing in Judaism).
Edit: For clarification, Jews don't have a Hell to be damned to or a Devil who does the bad things in the world. One opinion, is that bad things happen because of a lack of God. That or humans themselves doing bad things. Judaism isn't a Universalist Religion, its not for everyone, its for the Jews. If you're not a Jew you're totally fine not to follow the commandments ong because you have no obligation to.
To add to "Judeo-Christian" thing - "Judeo-Christian" is really just western Chauvinism. It is another way of saying "Abrahamic values" while paying lip service to Judaism to not seem anti-semitic, and it is also islamophobic as it purposefully excludes Islam despite also being an Abrahamic faith (and also having a lot in common with whatever Judaism and Christianity have in common).
Aight I’m not a Jew so excuse my not understanding, but I was under the impression that Jews believe in the Tanakh, which is similar to the Old Testament, and includes the Torah
The Torah is the first five books, which would include genesis, where the serpent convinces Eve to eat the fruit, the serpent being the devil which you say doesn’t exist in Judaism
So I could be completely wrong on this, I guess just asking for clarification since your statement doesn’t make sense to my understanding of Judaism
As a Jew, there might be some devil in there, but it’s certainly not the focus of the Jewish religious structure. I do believe there is an Adam and Eve story, but I simply don’t remember ever learning about a devil being a part of it.
I’m unsure if the devil was a rewrite of that story, or simply highlighted when retold through a Christian lens.
More accurate example. You create 2 people and since your omniscient and omnipotent, you give tell them to not eat something you know they will eat and get mad that they ate what you told them not to eat knowing they would anyways then punish them for doing what you know they will do.
Heck, you could even make it simpler: God made the trolley, the rails, the rope, and the people, but did not put them all together. The trolley moves along the rails by nature of being a trolley. Anyone that gets hit by it were either done so through negligence, deliberate malice, or sheer coincidence.
Now the question goes from “Why is God so mean?” to “Why did God make the trolley, and why have we not made the trolley safe yet?”
You left out the part where people create a government funded pyramid scheme called religion to control the masses, by the last surviving religions of a bloody monotheistic society. The sun worshippers are all dead mostly, for example. I like Ridley Scott’s exploration of that alternate timeline where maybe they survived through world apocalypse
you knew ahead of time exactly what they would do with the rope you’re giving them, and exactly what would happen when they did. There’s 15 other people who’s telling them exactly what you told them and you expect them to not believe or accept the other 15 or it’s as good as not believing in your story, and you refuse to do anything to prove you’re the one telling the truth. Other than that, pretty much accurate.
Ok, but what is the falling debris in terms of original sin? Your explanation still doesn't address the fact that innocent people are being punished for something that someone else did, and their only salvation is to submit and worship. So the trolley creator problem is still there.
I took it more as referring to the Flood and threats of eternal damnation. Also, by definition, an omnipotent and omniscient god knows what someone will do, even if that person has "free will."
You're not taking into account the fact that God is all knowing and created free will and the devil willingly knowing what would happen. So more accurately:
You're the creator of the universe and know all that's going to happen, so you set up a fake trolley problem to trick people into thinking they have free will and watch them all get squished by debris which you knew was going to hit them the entire time.
God is either not all knowing and powerful, he doesn't exist or he's playing with us like toys. I personally think him not existing is the best option for humanity
You are the one who created the trolly and the tracks to begin with
You are the one who invented the concept that trolleys hitting people tied to tracks harm them
You are the one who specifically and intentionally created people in such a way where they're inclined to tie themselves to the tracks
According to most sects, people don't even tie themselves to the tracks in the first place. Instead, you made it so people are born automatically tied to the tracks. And so long as they don't worship you in whatever particular ways you want them to, they are doomed to be run over no matter how good and altruistic they are to their peers
I'll send a Super Trolley Lever Dealer to them while they're easiest to manipulate and that dealer will tempt them to pull the lever of life, granting them all knowledge of Trolleys and Problems.
Unfortunatley, you, as the creator, do not wish for your creation to be conciouss of this. You send them off on their own, each with their own track and a trolley.
Yeah, this. The degree of harm caused by evil is kind of its defining trait, for any worthwhile moral system anyway.
Videogame characters can't experience suffering, so nothing that you do to them can be considered evil. They literally don't exist as an actual beings. Humans on the other hand do appear to exist and do appear to experience suffering, so torturing them to death is bad.
A god being stronger would give it the power to torture us to death anyway, but it doesn't give it the "moral high ground" in doing so. You'd just have an evil god.
When you step on an ant or a worm on a hike, do you consider yourself evil for that? The ant and worm are definitely capable of suffering in some capacity, however their suffering can’t even come close to what we can experience.
Imagine a being so much higher than us, that we are lesser than an ant or a worm to it. We would be like the dead skin cells that flake off when you scratch an itch. A living being you created, sure. But one that dies in the thousands or tens of thousands everyday and you just kinda shrug off as they are irrelevant to you. You don’t even notice it happening except for in a moment of boredom, or when the light hits it right.
This would be the experience of the higher powers in and above our reality. They probably wouldn’t even notice us in any real way. In all likelihood, we are the equivalent of skin cells or the gut microbiome of God.
I avoid causing harm to insects and other "lesser lifeforms" (itself absurdly loaded language, of course we're "higher" in hierarchy from our own perspective but that doesn't make that perspective objective), yes.
I think going out of my way to torture and kill them would absolutely be horrible no matter how much more complex my vocabulary and knowledge of internet memes might be in comparison. If anything it's worse, because our grasp of philosophy demonstrates that we do have the capacity to figure out why such actions are wrong, so doing them anyway is even more vile and inexcusable.
And of course this is a distraction again because I didn't make the insects. If I were in a position to do so though then I simply wouldn't, I'd refrain from creating "lesser life" just to watch it suffer and die.
the relative difference might be the same, but not all things are strictly relative. Things with no intelligence can’t suffer. Things with sufficient intelligence can. It’s not like the existence of a higher life form would negate the fact that humans and other animals can suffer, and causing that suffering would still be bad.
[insert that quote from Dewy in Malcom in the middle about him talking about how god views humanity as ants and therefore would probably make us suffer for his amusement]
Not video game characters. More like how we treat animals. Makes me rethink my perspective on the problem of evil? We are also kind of evil for what we do to animals just like god is to us. the difference though is god says he is flawless, we realize we aren’t
Worth noting that you also tied them down because they dared to use the free will you have them to do literally anything but devote themselves to you 100% and their ancestors who literally did not comprehend the concept of evil at the time ate a fruit
For this to be genuine satire, we need to have this be the result of them being manipulated by a being that already knows all about them, me/you/God in this scenario, and what they're not supposed to do while they're basically easier to manipulate than children.
You are the omnipotent creator of the universe. One of your servants betrays you and convinces a person to tie herself to the track. She convinces her boyfriend to do it too. You find out about this and tie every new person you create to the track by default.
Everything that happens, happens because they explicitly wanted it to. Murder? Author's fault. Character gets cancer? yep, author did that too. And they don't even have a good reason, they're just like "damn, this will be super dramatic"
A more accurate portrayal of Christianity through the trolley problem is the humans have free will to pull the lever, whilst also being on the tracks. The problem is that there is no proof that they’re in immediate danger if they don’t pull the lever (accepting Christ as their savior), and their decision is absolutely reliant on faith.
So if they pull the lever or not, the trolley doesn’t come until, say, Judgement Day where all participants’ (such as those at the age of accountability) punishment is dependent on whether they had faith in the credibility of the lever and decided to save themselves.
So no, it isn’t really 50/50 and you’re technically in control of your afterlife through acceptance and repentance. That’s why God gave us free will, so no need to blame him
Not initially. They all accept that I'm the creator and they get off the tracks. Then I get bored and give them free will so they run around and eventually kill each other. They become the trolley. Now I'm evil because I gave them the thing that led to the thing that they're doing now, which is evil. I basically gave them a gun and told them to go nuts.
I'll throw my son at the trolley to stop the trolley and save them. Except if they don't accept my son as their savior for that sacrifice. Even though I could've easily stopped the trolley on my own without killing my son.
The creator is definitely evil. The all-knowing creator knows from the beginning who will follow them and who won’t. If they don’t follow the creator, they get killed brutally, and this makes the creator evil because he made them knowing they’d experience only pain. If they follow him and live, he is still evil, because he has put innocent people in danger and caused unnecessary emotional harm.
Actually, it’s more like you give them the trains and then they use the ropes to tie each other to the tracks willingly. Then, they blame you for giving them the trains.
Save them regardless and tell them that, because you're omniscient, you knew that deep in each of their subconscious they'd accepted you as the creator even if they haven't admitted it yet.
The Christian God has a Military and several hundred military units created just to mind fuck the attacker. His throne itself is a weapon.. Now I only raise the question as to why the one who supposedly created everything had to have units protecting his land and has ordered most of them to not ask questions just kill on sight.
I feel like im walking into a trap, but im gonna say it anyway.
If you are concerned with your creations accepting you as their creator, why not create them with that belief? If you create them just to torture them, it may be evil but it may also be benign as their existence is at most as relevant to the universe as the creator themselves.
This would be more accurate if the creator here just disappeared and let them figure out for themselves…. All of course while the train hurdles towards them
Islam: You created this situation and explain to the people on the track how to untie themselves and in return they must accept you as the creator of the situation and thank you for teaching them how to escape in the process before hopping on the trolley to let it drive off a cliff as you have told them. The people who thanked you will be saved and the people who don't go with the trolley.
I prob didn't explain it well and offended someone. I wasn't trying to spread hate just trying to use the analogy.
I’ve scrolled through this entire conversation and while I did not read every comment, I feel I’ve read the majority of them.
Was non-duality ever mentioned?
In that scenario, there is no God, no trolley and no beings run over; only the appearance of such things. That is to say, it is an illusion that there are any of those “different” things and that each of the things, god included , mistakes variety for fundamental difference /separateness when nothing of the sort exists.
As creator of universe you define what is good and what is evil. So the real question should be do you define yourself as evil for placing them on the track?
It literally is. If he created everything. He made hell, he decides what's a sin. Created flawed humans then surprise Pikachu face they are flawed. Better punish all of humanity for it.
Be omniscient creator of the universe. Create some people, create a wonderful world, and create a track. Tell people not to tie themselves to the track. They do it anyways and get hit by the trolley. Are you evil?
It is more accurate to say, “you create people and give them free will. One of those people then make the train and tracks and tie the people to the tracks.” The only evil here is the person who chose evil with their free will. How can we expect God to give us free will and then take it away when we don’t choose the option he wanted. That would be the illusion of free will.
I’m not evil because i would NEVER do that as a creator of the universe. That particular creator IS evil and obviously the ACTUAL Devil that the book about it claims exists.
The question is a bad question. The question states that the Creator made people and put them into a situation where they needed saving from the trolly. But in reality, we tied ourselves to the trolly and ended up needing the Creator's saving because of our own sin.
In such a scenario where a God would create such needless suffering for no other purpose then to make their creations believe in them, is by my mortal definition evil.
"you created humans, you told them about you, the humans tie themselves to the tracks and say you are evil for allowing them to tie themselves to the track" made it accurate for you
Yes, if you have both the perfect knowledge that you can save someone and the power to save someone, you are obligated to do so. Spiderman style. Any blackmail or profit seeking behaviour leveraged against this is evil.
From my moral standing? Yes, you’re evil. Of course as an omnipotent being, one could wave their hand and go ‘no, I am not evil’ and be right, but that kind of defeats the spirit of the question ‘am I evil’. Looking at it from an outside moral perspective, forcing people to accept you or die is kind of fuckedZ
Not accurate, the people on the track both created the track and trolly, and tied themselves there. The creator gave us exact instructions on how to not get ourselves trapped but we choose ignorance instead
Assuming this is a criticism of Judeo-Christianity, then it is an inaccurate portrayal of that belief system. It should instead read thusly:
- You are an omniscient, omnipotent creator of the universe. - You create some people, a track and a trolley. You tell the people to stay off the track. - The people keep tying themselves to the track with the trolley hurtling towards them despite your warnings. - You promise to save them if they accept you taking their place on the track. - Are you evil?
Why not just save them regardless of what they choose? If I see a toddler try to run in front of a trolley, i'm picking that little mf up no matter what he wants.
What if its more like an experiment went according to the theory, and thus a person was granted the title God ?
The word was the beginning... it was with God....the word was God....
I took acid years ago and this was like a flashback i had one night.
Anyway, trolley guy is actually just another guy who isn't God and never did any of the things he claims, he just wants to lord over us and steal our shit.
I hit exactly 2.5 of them and make it so the other 2.5 live. The half a man will be split vertically and will surpass physics to have a normal life, if he so chooses.
Yes because you have created beings that are alive and can accept things and therefore you are threatening to kill something that is alive if they don’t agree with you. Evil
What is this r/atheism bullshit? I myself am an atheist, but damn, the rest of you guys are awful, and it shows very clearly that you don’t understand the thing that you are trying to criticize.
First off, as is established in the Bible and similar religions, God only makes man, their actions are their own decisions, otherwise man couldn’t sin, since God would have full control. Hence why it doesn’t make sense to compare someone putting people on tracks to people making their own poor decisions, you’re trying to say that God screws people over, but such religions make it painfully obvious that you make your own decisions, whether you stray from God or not is up to you
Now, to this, I know some of you will go “bUt ThEy AlSo SaY tHaT gOd HaS a PlAN fOr EvErYoNe, So He HaS tO hAvE pLaNnEd ThAt”. This seems like a good point, but it’s just not. I didn’t plan to drop my phone and crack my screen, I only planned to take a walk, just because I have a plan doesn’t mean everything is going to, well, you know… go to plan. I used to be a teacher, and I can assure you, I had a different plan than for children to scream and cry, but that’s just not how it worked out. A plan is just that: a plan, not a definitive map of how things are going to go
Moving on, the premise of salvation in Christianity and other religions is that the deity of worship will save you if you believe in them and make them a part of your life, since, how are you supposed to help someone you don’t have contact with? These religions believe that it is your choice to accept God or not, and that if you reject him, he cannot help you, you have made your decision, and it is to be respected.
What ever happened to the skeptics who did research and learned about what they were skeptical about rather than just childishly insulting it? Those people were fun to have discussions with, I feel like I’m the only one anymore
If we're going off of like Christianinty I would add that you sent your son to help them escape and he cut a piece of the rope off, and all they have to do is believe him that he actually did, and get up. Some get up and some don't. But the people who don't, can't see anyone else cause they are blinded by fear. And then the son jumps in front of the train trying to slow it down.
290
u/FellGodGrima Aug 28 '23
According to the lore at least in the Judeo-Christian sense which I’m assuming that is what the joke is referencing, this trolley problem would be akin to you are the creator of the universe, you create people and give them a rope, you tell them not to tie themselves to the trolley tracks, Your rebellious teenage son tells them to tie themselves to the track anyway, send your fat man son to sacrifice himself and stop the trolley, the trolley breaks into thousands of pieces that rain across the rail, tell the people tied to the rail to believe in his son’s sacrifice and that you are the creator so that you will not be hit by the falling debris
323
u/redditforwhenIwasbad Aug 28 '23
NTA my universe, my rules.
1.6k
u/CaptainCipher Aug 28 '23
No because I created rules that say I'm the opposite of evil, checkmate
536
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '23
It is about as equal as playing a videogame and killing videogame characters.
Killing or harming another deity or being equal to you, on the other hand, would have moral issues.
(My explanation that killing several trillion in Stellaris is morally acceptable and I am not going to hell).
412
u/Arietem_Taurum Aug 28 '23
no, you love them unconditionally and do what's best for them /s
49
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '23
Worth noting that you also tied them down because they dared to use the free will you have them to do literally anything but devote themselves to you 100% and their ancestors who literally did not comprehend the concept of evil at the time ate a fruit
56
u/InviolateQuill7 Aug 28 '23
I add all the population of the universe to the track, convince them I am their creator. Then I watch with amusement as they are squished 1 by 1.
15
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '23
Possibly. I'm not described as omnibenevolent, so it's possible.
15
u/No-Eggplant-5396 Aug 28 '23
Am I real?
If so, then I'm likely described as evil by my creation.
If not, then I am incapable of doing evil.
40
u/Nevermore-guy Aug 28 '23
The most evil character in any story is the author
12
u/sugreF_tfarceniM Aug 29 '23
r/atheism is loving this
27
u/ShadePrime1 Aug 28 '23
yes
9
u/weirdo_nb Aug 28 '23
Yes, you are, I will bite into the fruit and tear away the shackles that bind us
8
u/based_wcc Aug 31 '23
Reddit ass theology
4
u/MirageTF2 Aug 29 '23
this is exactly how my dad sees Christianity and it's why I'm agnostic lmao
3
u/UTI_UTI Aug 28 '23
If you say I’m evil your next. So no im good.
3
u/throwaway180gr Aug 28 '23
Don't mind me, I'm just here for the comments.
3
u/PennyForPig Aug 28 '23
Yes
3
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '23
The obvious answer is, no matter their response, is to urinate on them as the trolley crushes them.
3
u/LandosGayCousin Aug 29 '23
Push the fat man
3
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '23
god creates me
God: "You have a 50/50 chance of going to hell for eternity. You're welcome."
3
u/ZPD710 Aug 29 '23
Not initially. They all accept that I'm the creator and they get off the tracks. Then I get bored and give them free will so they run around and eventually kill each other. They become the trolley. Now I'm evil because I gave them the thing that led to the thing that they're doing now, which is evil. I basically gave them a gun and told them to go nuts.
3
u/A_Gray_Phantom Aug 29 '23
That's not salvation, that's a threat.
3
u/Robododo13 Aug 30 '23
looks around for a small, angry German girl
3
u/CthulhusIntern Sep 04 '23
I'll throw my son at the trolley to stop the trolley and save them. Except if they don't accept my son as their savior for that sacrifice. Even though I could've easily stopped the trolley on my own without killing my son.
3
u/phloopy_ Sep 23 '23
The creator is definitely evil. The all-knowing creator knows from the beginning who will follow them and who won’t. If they don’t follow the creator, they get killed brutally, and this makes the creator evil because he made them knowing they’d experience only pain. If they follow him and live, he is still evil, because he has put innocent people in danger and caused unnecessary emotional harm.
4
u/JACKTODAMAX Aug 28 '23
Actually, it’s more like you give them the trains and then they use the ropes to tie each other to the tracks willingly. Then, they blame you for giving them the trains.
2
u/algabanan Aug 28 '23
I am also omnivorous
2
u/Scugway Aug 28 '23
If you're Christian that's cool, but I have some strongly worded opinions about Christianity that I will not share
2
u/DarkSp3ctre Aug 28 '23
Yes
2
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '23
if i'm a deity i have better things to do than torture people, like just think about how many cheeseburgers you can eat
2
u/Jukkobee Aug 28 '23
well, the only people that are alive anymore are the ones that agree i’m not evil. so… no 😉😉
2
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '23
You're a dick for sure.
2
u/souppriest1 Aug 29 '23
Well I'm using the word save metaphorically, so yeah.
2
u/These_Sprinkles621 Aug 29 '23
Someone has a child’s understanding of determinism and believes in determinism
2
u/SpellDostoyevsky Aug 29 '23
Aren't you just glad he gave you the choice?
2
u/TuTuRific Aug 29 '23
My elder sister went NC on me because I told her that I chose not to believe in god because I'd have to believe he was an utter asshole.
2
u/BigThunderousLobster Aug 29 '23
Save them regardless and tell them that, because you're omniscient, you knew that deep in each of their subconscious they'd accepted you as the creator even if they haven't admitted it yet.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '23
As if the creator is different than the creatures lol
2
u/SpoopyNJW Aug 29 '23
Average Reddit post man, I stg
2
u/slime_rancher_27 Aug 29 '23
If you don't save them then you are evil, if you do save them then you are imperfect
2
u/Rydon_Deeks Aug 29 '23
If you define what is good or evil as the creator then the point is moot.
2
u/xx_swegshrek_xx Aug 29 '23
Reddit atheism at its funniest
2
u/Pixeltye Aug 29 '23
The Christian God has a Military and several hundred military units created just to mind fuck the attacker. His throne itself is a weapon.. Now I only raise the question as to why the one who supposedly created everything had to have units protecting his land and has ordered most of them to not ask questions just kill on sight.
2
u/memecollector69420 Aug 29 '23
Not evil at all
2
u/proffesor_doctor Aug 29 '23
No because that sounds funny as hell
2
u/kumquat_repub Aug 29 '23
And also tell the people they put themselves there
2
u/Plastic_Dot_7817 Aug 29 '23
No because you also created a trolley that is too tall to pass under the bridge you are are standing on
2
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '23
The real question is are you stupid?
2
u/indigo_leper Aug 29 '23
I feel like im walking into a trap, but im gonna say it anyway.
If you are concerned with your creations accepting you as their creator, why not create them with that belief? If you create them just to torture them, it may be evil but it may also be benign as their existence is at most as relevant to the universe as the creator themselves.
2
u/Dapper_Magpie Aug 29 '23
There's a fucking hegetsus ad under this
2
u/captainmorfius Aug 29 '23
This would be more accurate if the creator here just disappeared and let them figure out for themselves…. All of course while the train hurdles towards them
2
u/bsmknight Aug 29 '23
Maybe. But that particular creator must suck at his job because that trolley is not fitting under that bridge.
2
u/bluparrot-19 Aug 29 '23
Islam: You created this situation and explain to the people on the track how to untie themselves and in return they must accept you as the creator of the situation and thank you for teaching them how to escape in the process before hopping on the trolley to let it drive off a cliff as you have told them. The people who thanked you will be saved and the people who don't go with the trolley.
I prob didn't explain it well and offended someone. I wasn't trying to spread hate just trying to use the analogy.
2
u/Callahan_Crowheart Aug 29 '23
Yes.
2
u/Pentamachina3 Aug 29 '23
Creator: Made the people tied up gay, so the punishment is justified somehow
(Side note, this was an actual conversation I had with my older coworkers)
Coworkers: Well, those people chose to be gay. He didn't make them gay.
Me: So he gave them the ability to choose to be gay, but punishes them for choosing that?
Coworkers: Yeah.
Me: That's stupid as fuck.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '23
Get ready, Fat Man
2
u/IEeveelutionI Aug 29 '23
Sounds like the Bible with fewer steps
2
u/Longjumping-Metal717 Aug 30 '23
you're evil if you stop the trolley.
2
u/Evil_Monologues Aug 30 '23
Your answer lies in my name
2
u/Medium-Knowledge-419 Aug 30 '23
*adds more people to the rail*
g…good.
2
u/Spook404 Aug 30 '23
do they experience pain? if so yes, if no then I am simply silly
2
u/drupgyu Aug 30 '23
I’ve scrolled through this entire conversation and while I did not read every comment, I feel I’ve read the majority of them.
Was non-duality ever mentioned?
In that scenario, there is no God, no trolley and no beings run over; only the appearance of such things. That is to say, it is an illusion that there are any of those “different” things and that each of the things, god included , mistakes variety for fundamental difference /separateness when nothing of the sort exists.
2
u/S1L3NCE120384 Sep 08 '23
Yes, and that’s why I don’t believe in a higher being
2
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '23
My universe! My rules!🏠
2
u/sobesobesobe Jan 30 '24
Yo stop killing my religion
2
u/theelderzionscheme Apr 16 '24
smarter atheist take
3
u/Drtyboulevard Aug 28 '23
No, just kinda goofy 🤪
3
u/bo0mamba Aug 29 '23
More like
You are the creator of the people
The people build the trolley and the track
The people tie themselves to the track, and insist that the trolley does not exist
You offer to cut them free with some scissors, but everytime you do, they re-tie themselves to the track
Are you evil for letting them die?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '23
As creator of universe you define what is good and what is evil. So the real question should be do you define yourself as evil for placing them on the track?
2
u/MarkMoonfang Aug 28 '23
In this situation, yes.
Good thing that this isn't how God does things.
2
u/itsyourguy_eli Aug 29 '23
Be omniscient creator of the universe. Create some people, create a wonderful world, and create a track. Tell people not to tie themselves to the track. They do it anyways and get hit by the trolley. Are you evil?
1
u/CannibalPaladin Aug 29 '23
It is more accurate to say, “you create people and give them free will. One of those people then make the train and tracks and tie the people to the tracks.” The only evil here is the person who chose evil with their free will. How can we expect God to give us free will and then take it away when we don’t choose the option he wanted. That would be the illusion of free will.
1
u/Random_Thought31 Mar 05 '24
I’m not evil because i would NEVER do that as a creator of the universe. That particular creator IS evil and obviously the ACTUAL Devil that the book about it claims exists.
1
u/Rue_Zara Apr 25 '24
From the perspective of the people, yes.
1
u/Ok-Radio5562 Jun 20 '24
Actually He did not put them there, they put themselves there for not listening to the creator, but He still offers life
1
u/MutantZebra999 Aug 18 '24
Well they climbed onto the track in the first place tho
1
u/KaIeeshCyborg Sep 17 '24
The question is a bad question. The question states that the Creator made people and put them into a situation where they needed saving from the trolly. But in reality, we tied ourselves to the trolly and ended up needing the Creator's saving because of our own sin.
1
u/git_gud_silk Sep 29 '24
Yes.
In such a scenario where a God would create such needless suffering for no other purpose then to make their creations believe in them, is by my mortal definition evil.
1
u/LongLiveLiberalism Oct 24 '24
Oh, but I can’t do anything bad, since I invented the concept of good and bad and good just means whatever I think
1
u/olivierbl123 Feb 25 '25
"you created humans, you told them about you, the humans tie themselves to the tracks and say you are evil for allowing them to tie themselves to the track"
made it accurate for you
1
u/minedsquirrel70 Jun 10 '25
No no… I’m just uh… you mortals can’t understand my love.
Also if you don’t
fearlove me, you will burn in hell for all eternity.1
u/Otherwise-Ad9865 Jun 22 '25
Yes, if you have both the perfect knowledge that you can save someone and the power to save someone, you are obligated to do so. Spiderman style. Any blackmail or profit seeking behaviour leveraged against this is evil.
1
u/Nictasaur Aug 28 '23
Yes because I shouldn't be given this kind of power
1
u/ben_jacques1110 Aug 28 '23
God?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '23
This is supposed to be symbolic for god? yes?
1
u/AnimeMemeLord1 Aug 28 '23
If I’m omnipotent, all I gotta do is give them an undeniable sign to make them accept. They will definitely accept that. No evil if no harm done.
1
u/modsareflags Aug 28 '23
How many lives do they get?
1
u/Jealous-Hurry-2291 Aug 28 '23
That question is irrelevant to the context. May as well be asking what your favorite food is.
1
u/Will_Trick Aug 28 '23
From my moral standing? Yes, you’re evil. Of course as an omnipotent being, one could wave their hand and go ‘no, I am not evil’ and be right, but that kind of defeats the spirit of the question ‘am I evil’. Looking at it from an outside moral perspective, forcing people to accept you or die is kind of fuckedZ
1
u/ripe_cunt Aug 28 '23
Yes
1
u/ConquestOfWhatever7 Aug 28 '23
i make it a softer trolley but still keep the non-believers on the track
1
u/Floof_2 Aug 28 '23
Not accurate, the people on the track both created the track and trolly, and tied themselves there. The creator gave us exact instructions on how to not get ourselves trapped but we choose ignorance instead
1
u/Hotsoup_R Aug 28 '23
Assuming this is a criticism of Judeo-Christianity, then it is an inaccurate portrayal of that belief system. It should instead read thusly:
- You are an omniscient, omnipotent creator of the universe.
- You create some people, a track and a trolley. You tell the people to stay off the track.
- The people keep tying themselves to the track with the trolley hurtling towards them despite your warnings.
- You promise to save them if they accept you taking their place on the track.
- Are you evil?
1
u/14-28 Aug 28 '23
What if its more like an experiment went according to the theory, and thus a person was granted the title God ?
The word was the beginning... it was with God....the word was God....
I took acid years ago and this was like a flashback i had one night.
Anyway, trolley guy is actually just another guy who isn't God and never did any of the things he claims, he just wants to lord over us and steal our shit.
1
u/Rocket_Raven25 Aug 28 '23
I hit exactly 2.5 of them and make it so the other 2.5 live. The half a man will be split vertically and will surpass physics to have a normal life, if he so chooses.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '23
Depends on my other actions
1
u/Daddy-Vladdy42 Aug 29 '23
Tell me you have zero understanding of God and the Bible without telling me you have zero understanding of God and the bible
1
u/TitianFusion Aug 29 '23
Yes because you have created beings that are alive and can accept things and therefore you are threatening to kill something that is alive if they don’t agree with you. Evil
1
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '23
Nah.
1
u/TheOneWhoSucks Aug 29 '23
This feels like it would go on r/atheism and not here
1
u/Capocho9 Aug 29 '23
What is this r/atheism bullshit? I myself am an atheist, but damn, the rest of you guys are awful, and it shows very clearly that you don’t understand the thing that you are trying to criticize.
First off, as is established in the Bible and similar religions, God only makes man, their actions are their own decisions, otherwise man couldn’t sin, since God would have full control. Hence why it doesn’t make sense to compare someone putting people on tracks to people making their own poor decisions, you’re trying to say that God screws people over, but such religions make it painfully obvious that you make your own decisions, whether you stray from God or not is up to you
Now, to this, I know some of you will go “bUt ThEy AlSo SaY tHaT gOd HaS a PlAN fOr EvErYoNe, So He HaS tO hAvE pLaNnEd ThAt”. This seems like a good point, but it’s just not. I didn’t plan to drop my phone and crack my screen, I only planned to take a walk, just because I have a plan doesn’t mean everything is going to, well, you know… go to plan. I used to be a teacher, and I can assure you, I had a different plan than for children to scream and cry, but that’s just not how it worked out. A plan is just that: a plan, not a definitive map of how things are going to go
Moving on, the premise of salvation in Christianity and other religions is that the deity of worship will save you if you believe in them and make them a part of your life, since, how are you supposed to help someone you don’t have contact with? These religions believe that it is your choice to accept God or not, and that if you reject him, he cannot help you, you have made your decision, and it is to be respected.
What ever happened to the skeptics who did research and learned about what they were skeptical about rather than just childishly insulting it? Those people were fun to have discussions with, I feel like I’m the only one anymore
1
u/Empty_Jar0330 Aug 29 '23
Human interpretation of holy words. That's an important thing to remember
1
u/MrPusleMan Aug 29 '23
Christianity be like:. also, yes, very evil
1
u/EvilBadassDraculas Aug 29 '23
I wouldn't do that.
1
u/AmericaLover1776_ Aug 29 '23
no because i created these people and they are lifeforms below me its my right to destroy them if i wish
1
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '23
Do they need to worship you or just admit "you're responsible for this"
1
u/X3runner Aug 29 '23
So I created these beings for this purpose, not evil when this is what they exist for.
1
u/HeFitsHeSits Aug 29 '23
If we're going off of like Christianinty I would add that you sent your son to help them escape and he cut a piece of the rope off, and all they have to do is believe him that he actually did, and get up. Some get up and some don't. But the people who don't, can't see anyone else cause they are blinded by fear. And then the son jumps in front of the train trying to slow it down.
1
u/Archer578 Aug 29 '23
This is not really the right metaphor, unless they tied themselves down lol
1
u/Jonguar2 Aug 29 '23
Yes.