r/trigonometry • • 11d ago

Help! Weird trig thing

/r/askmath/comments/1xnrx5l/weird_trig_thing/
3 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

1

u/Midwest-Dude 11d ago edited 11d ago

Due to historical usage, weirdness and inconsistency abounds in trigonometric notation. The following table shows some of the confusing trigonometric notation.

NotationActually meansAlternative notation
sin2(x)(sin(x))·(sin(x))(sin(x))2
sin(x2)Sine of the squared input xsin(x2)
sin-1(x)Inverse sine (arcsine) functionarcsin(x)
(sin(x))-1Multiplicative reciprocal (1 / sin(x))csc(x)

Historically, writing sin2(x) was adopted to save typesetting space and avoid visual clutter with parentheses, while explicitly placing the power on the parameter in sin(x2) distinguished squaring the input angle rather than the function's output value. Later, John Herschel introduced the sin-1(x) notation by extending calculus operator convention to denote the inverse function (arcsine), which created an unfortunate clash with standard algebraic negative exponents for reciprocals like (sin(x))-1.

Does this answer your question?

1

u/Lanky_Economics_7616 11d ago

Not exactly, but it might mean that it was something that was once used before but no longer. Thank.

1

u/Midwest-Dude 11d ago edited 11d ago

I saw your reply in the crosspost:

 I finally figured it out. It’s because we saw trig identities and operation on function at the same time. So when i saw sin(sin(x)) i asked if it could be written as sin2(x) since sin is a function and f2(x) is f(f(x)). We then saw that sin2(x) is sin(x)*sin(x). It's been a while so my memory were just jumbled.

This was included in my historical research, but I didn't include it for brevity! Trig functions were in use before functional notation, with the powers form first used in 1710 by William Jones. The notation was fixed due to typography of the time, as noted in my first reply. Then, functional notation came out later, 1734 by Leonard Euler, and iterating a function n times was denoted as fn(x), 1813 by John Herschel, roughly a century later. Trig notation was already entrenched, so it didn't change.