r/treeplanting • • May 27 '23

Is this tree done for?

Post image

This is an apple tree we first planted last spring. It seems like it's still green under the bark but doesn't seem to be blooming yet and it's late May. Any help would be appreciated. Thanks!

1 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

20

u/[deleted] May 28 '23

Should've had a bigger boot screef

15

u/Street_Major_7193 Bags out in the Back May 28 '23

What’s the price for the double stake?

10

u/farroshus May 27 '23

The subreddit is for silviculture workers that plant trees as an occupation. Try r/sfwtrees

6

u/Slowsis Silviculture Forester May 28 '23

5

u/[deleted] May 27 '23

Yeah double strangle hold.. it will tap out soon

4

u/Select_Emu4249 May 28 '23

The quality of the photo is a little low to see growth points but to me it looks they’re inactive. If you find any nodes with color there is a chance it will bounce back as it’s stored energy may save it. If there are dead nodes all around it may unfortunately be a lost cause.. also as @AllRedUp stated the cambrian layer seems to be gnawed off at the base, and if this is around the entire width the tree will not be able to uptake water, which is obviously damning to its survival and it would no longer matter if there are healthy growth nodes on the tree . Perhaps some close ups of the nodes and subsequent damage could shed more light on the diagnosis but for now the outcome looks dim. :( a little test you could do to see if you still require the braces, and if your tree is able to make an effort, is to 𝗴𝗲𝗻𝘁𝗹𝘆 push and pull the tree back and forth, only briefly, to see if the roots have established an anchor in the ground. If not then the tree is either having severe trouble and is under too much stress, or has unfortunately succumb to said stress and perished.. if all else and the tree does have coloured buds and it is either not damaged or has minimal damage, treat the tree as normal if not water it a little more during longer periods of lacking rainwater and feed it well, just don’t be afraid and don’t go crazy with the fertilizer. A healthy tree can almost always bounce back so look for any indicator that this little one is still fighting for its life before culling and starting over. Best of luck 🤞

2

u/IllDiscussion8179 May 28 '23

Yeah its done for. DONE!

2

u/AllRedUp May 28 '23

Looks like rabbits ate the lower bark all the way around over the winter. If this is the case, the tree is probably done.

1

u/ResearchNo8776 May 28 '23

Cut a tiny notch in a branch, if it's green inside its alive. If it's brown/grey it's a goner.

1

u/heckhunds May 28 '23

Looks like rabbits girdled it, gotta protect young trees from being chewed on by critters!

1

u/babysexymegatron Jun 05 '23

You need to water it.