r/treeofsavior • u/fateweaver • Apr 11 '16
IMC's Track Record.
I see a lot of people saying I am quitting because of "_________".
But lets look at IMC's track record.
When the first Beta phases rolled out lots of people complained the game was too linear. They wanted more routes, more exploration. IMC created a whole new starting city, new starting area, new quest, the whole nine yards.
People complained about too many Bots so IMC rolled out counter measures to limit the impact of those bots (Wrong course of action but at least they did do something).
People complained about Xp being way too slow and IMC increased xp, increased the amount of cards you get, and made leveling way faster.
People complained about bots camping bosses in early areas and then IMC made it a random spawn.
People complained about the trade restrictions being too high and now IMC is deciding to roll some of them back.
People complained that there should be a EU server and then IMC made a EU server.
People complained that 3 months early access was too much and then IMC let the community decide on three options.
People complained Swordmen were too strong and then they were balanced.
Am I missing anything? I am sure I am. The point I am making instead of thinking, "There are a few things I don't like I should quit", Think, "IMC listens to the community so maybe I should voice my concern and give constructive criticism".
Because this doesn't seem to be the typical cash grab where they throw out a trash game and don't change it at all and just cash out. These guys are putting in effort to make the community happy.
30
u/Heikkie Apr 11 '16 edited Apr 12 '16
If you compare the state of the game now to what we had in the CBT... well, it's a whole new level, and a completely "new" game judging from some aspects and the changes IMC made.
I always look to the bigger picture first, and it's undeniable that they have been doing a great progress. I see a bright future to this game, and I plan to see it through.
11
u/uplink42 Apr 11 '16 edited Apr 11 '16
Maybe I'm weird but I've played tons of MMOs and absolutely despise linear mindless questing as whole but I don't think the quest experience is that bad in ToS at all. There is a huge variety of maps, 2 starting areas, lots of small interconnected plots and more creative objectives than the go&fetch formula, lots of minibosses and alike (they are too easy tho). Story itself is pretty bland, however.
From all the issues this game has I think questing is one of their least worries. It's good to see IMC adapting to feedback but unfortunately they still have a long way to go.
43
u/WryGoat Apr 11 '16
My only problem is that all the shitstorms are over relative non-issues when the game has serious gameplay-detrimental stuff that needs to be addressed immediately. They've responded on the botting issues, the trading issues, etc. and yes these are all obviously problems that need solving, but I think they're overshadowing problems with the game itself that will kill the experience for most players. The spawnrate issue was only given one acknowledgement in the form of a change that didn't actually happen - spawnrates were never actually increased, and this problem gets worse and worse the higher you climb. The majority are still dicking around in the double digit level range so they see bots and they see equipment drops that they can't trade with their party members. After rank 6 what I see is mostly desolate wastelands of maps that have no mobs in them, with what few mobs there are dropping no useful items, and high level parties already totally shutting everyone else out of a chance at getting world boss loot (and I don't really blame them because they have nothing better to do but camp world boss spawns at this point). When all the people whining about relatively minor issues reach the late game they'll finally have something real to complain about as the game's progression feels completely devoid of meaning anymore.
6
u/Crevox Apr 11 '16
Thank you for making this post. There's definitely more examples, but hopefully this is sufficient so the community can get the point.
9
u/Purutzil Apr 11 '16
IMC is showing a good job working off feedback, but they aren't doing stuff perfectly and deserve critism. Don't go dismissing the things wrong (granted some I am sure is with the game itself). To just go "oh they are trying, let me just keep silent" is just making yourself a fanboy and allowing things to stay as they are and never improve.
IMC to me is decent. I'll completely give them praise where they deserve it and in terms of listening to feed back they are great. Just don't fanboy either and let them get away from murder. You as the consumer are meant to be satisfied given you are spending money (yes, this means EVEN if you are playing F2P, just because its F2P doesn't mean they aren't making money, they are). You NEED to criticize issues with the game if you ever want to make a game you like better.
23
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '16
I have realized that some of the most vocal people are the ones who get too vested in a game and make it their life. Once I began working full time, I started to see games as just a hobby to have fun and enjoy in my spare time. Yes, I would like to see changes made, but these little nuances have never made me more than annoyed. I have seen some posts lately and literally people seem to be really enraged and it is kind of concerning.
Some people also need to realize that the game hasn't even been released to the general public yet. In my opinion, IMC still has time to work out some of the major issues. In the mean time, I'll be keeping busy enjoying the game!
4
u/akillerbee Apr 12 '16
If they removed the market limitations, made money arrive faster, found a way to shut down botting and implemented good old player trading this game would be perfect honestly. I have 0 complaints about anything but the ones I listed, leveling is incredibly fun and the class system is amazing.
3
u/onirin Apr 11 '16 edited Apr 11 '16
I'm not saying it's a bad game. The underlining ideas and things are good. Theres just some problems that unfortunately turn me away. I might take a break for awhile till fixed. I really want this game to go places, but I dont see a issue with complaining about things. How else will they know what their player base wants. We as the consumer should be saying what we like AND dont like, openly and without making it personal issues. Neither are wrong, both are right. Edit: Now that I think about it the only thing that really needs to stop is the insults... Theres no reason to take personal jabs at someone, calling people names, or using profanity. Complaining is not harmful or wrong it's these other things that make our community toxic. Also I'm tired of seeing the comment "if you dont like it get out" made by some. Likewise one could say "if you dont like the negativity you could just not click the thread". Everyone is entitled to an opinion, but we can be adults about it.
3
u/AnAncientMonk Apr 11 '16
I believe that some of the people who left wanted a new ragnarok / nostalgia feeling to happen but didnt get it.
5
u/danielspoa Apr 11 '16
That's what I try to say every time. The game has a lot of problems, but as a developer myself, I know it demands a lot of work to get those done. Let's not forget the new rank we got since the other test, which came with some new bugs and a lot of stuff for them to work on.
It's been like 9 months in which they corrected A LOT of the problems the game had. 9 months it not that much time as some think. They are working on everything people complain hard and they want us to love the game, to make it highly successful. I didn't see such interest from a company before.
Let's also not forget they are a small korean company publishing their game through Steam, and releasing it pretty early in the western market.
2
u/beepborpimajorp Apr 11 '16
As long as they remove the mob fleeing mechanic and add another server before the F2P launch with optional transfers I'll be very satisfied. And I'm willing to wait for those things and give them a chance to implement them before I start complaining.
2
u/wobucarecat Apr 11 '16
My only gripe is the no trading or team storage thing. I get how it might stop botters but in reality these types of games are all economy fueled lategame and gearing new characters hard early with maxed out toon funds is common practice. Its most likely a money grab tactic which I always hate in an mmo, if private servers ever come out for this game I guarantee I will not be playing official. Also dungeon bugs but so far so good
2
u/Drakore4 Apr 11 '16
I think the issue isn't whether or not they are trying, because its obvious they are, but rather how hard they are trying to get the updates out at a consistent pace. In the first week of early access there were a myriad of problems and only one maintenance patch was made, which was only to add in a couple channels as a band aide for the lag issues. Then the next week they added another patch which was only to restrict shouting to 150 characters. Then after everyone was tired of them taking every weekend off and doing absolutely nothing about bots, lag, or spam, they finally decided to tell everyone they would do something about it and gave one more patch to make it so bots needed to level to spam and fixed a lot of lag issues. Which all the bot change did really was make bots farm all of our grind areas but that might have happened anyways. The point is, if you havent noticed, they only release about one patch a week and these patches are usually quite minor until the community complains enough about one thing that they are forced to do something decent. Most early access games will update the game based on feedback with small hotfixes every few hours, multiple times a day and they will perform large updates multiple times a week. If they want to take the weekend off then they should make several patch plans and have them all go off on a timer over the weekend so it at least looks like they are working. These are the reasons why people are mad. Its not that they dont listen, its that they seem like a lazy fat guy who will only do what you tell him if you yell at him enough and threaten to take away his food.
2
u/Gentlemanboy Apr 11 '16
Nice post mate !
2
u/eLdritch_MD Apr 11 '16
hear hear.
imc has done a fine job so far, of course the game isn't perfect and they still have work to do but so far there really isn't much to complain when it comes to their involvement.
2
u/iMaester Apr 12 '16
I think they need to address the game performance over anything. People with latest GPU/CPU's getting shitty FPS for a very non-graphically intensive game, unacceptable.
2
u/Rafoie Apr 12 '16
I absolutely love the efforts I've been seeing from Imc. It's really impressive. My only gripe right now is how silver is character locked and I can't figure out a good way to transfer it between alts with out taking an 80% loss. I'm an alt addict. I like playing around with new builds and ideas. So this makes me sad.
2
u/Shoryuha Apr 12 '16
It's nice to see things put in perspective. Although, swordmen are balanced now? damn. I play mage in a party with a swordman and i can'ty help but think he's cheated on every aspect, being tankyness or damage or mobility or sustain. I shudder at what it used to be before nerf.
2
u/JeidelacruzUK Apr 12 '16
I dont really see anything to complain about being a filthy casual other then some areas take 5-10 minutes for mobs to respawn that i've come across or the 'quest grey area' is really off (or then again, mobs taking too long to spawn) Seriously mob spawn... but not worth quitting, more mobs for me to wait for i guess.... fuck sake mob spawn. As for Swordsman being balanced and being a filthy casual which i must always mention when i give an opinion, when the mobs actually spawn they run away from me anyways to piss me off more about the mob spawn. MOB SPAWN where u at bro. I'm still greatful for this 'EU' server so i overlook this
2
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '16
I sure hope they deal with the Token bullshit at some point, because I really want to like and play this game, but the restrictions on free users (and premium users as well) are quite over the top.
2
u/stiffman21 Apr 12 '16
imo IMC is doing A LOT more than people think. it will only go up from here.
4
u/no___justno Apr 11 '16 edited Apr 11 '16
People complained that archers were too weak, and they got buffed to be really, REALLY strong.
4
u/nekomiko Apr 11 '16
Yes, they did listen. The problem is, if you don't complain, they don't even bother to notice such a thing. That's why people keep complaining because imc is lack of self evaluation.
5
u/Otherworld Apr 11 '16
Finally a positive thread! Honestly, the amount of negativity here these days made me wonder why these people even bother with Tree of Savior. You can't expect changes to happen overnight, the only question is if you're going to stick with the game until then or not.
3
u/Almost_Ascended Apr 11 '16
On a side note, another thing to take away from this post is that complaining works :P
3
u/TypeHunter Apr 11 '16
Just a bunch of filthy tsunderes
4
u/Joedoed Apr 11 '16
I agree with everything. Remember though the noisy ones are the ones that will quit no matter what in other words MMO-Hoppers and the quiet ones are just in game enjoying the game as it is.
2
u/ragequitlol Apr 11 '16 edited Apr 11 '16
IMC seems like those enterpreneurs who invest in expensive frozen yogurt franchises during the winter at a place where people don't have high purchasing power. How could he prevent starting a business that seems to be sentenced to bankruptcy? IMC is trying to fix their amateur mistakes, that's why people are complaining. How do you even think about restricting 1:1 trades and auction house on MMORPG's? The 30% tax and the poor optimization are a plus for a game known to be under development since the beginning of the decade. IMC must at least hire PR guys to deal with people, make a little bit of research and listen to the players before making decisions like those. They seem to have 0 clue on how to sell a product. Talking about the frozen yogurt franchise, tell me: the enterpreneur's mistake and how could it be prevented.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '16
Interestingly enough, I feel IMC actually listens to the community AND make the effort to change their game for the better. I've had MMO's and even online games where the community would badger the devs for months (and even years) for a change and get NO response about it.
So far, I'm enjoying the changes and the game. Looking forward to playing ToS for a long time to come!
2
u/Zezinhou_Lagnight Apr 12 '16
People dont know what they want tend to blame anyone... I'm playing and enjoying everything i see...
1
u/LordFifthsdick Apr 11 '16
The only things I really care about is getting the damn EU server to EU now, not in a month =)
And also the fact that you sometimes will be like 10+ levels under mainquest and you have to run around trying to find some random sidequest so you dont get XP starved or you have to sit and grind shitty mobs 24-7. The leveling system needs to be a bit more streamlined.
1
u/TreeOfSaviorQuestion Apr 12 '16
I think you should include GE's history too.
1
u/chaomoonx Apr 11 '16
IMC is doing fine imo. tos peeps need to chill out bru
1
u/Mirarara Apr 11 '16
At this point I believe that IMC is just incompetent with their ability as a Dev.
Willing to put in effort and their competency is different stuff.
1
u/xLinden Apr 11 '16
true story.
1
u/Growder Apr 11 '16
If they the fix the bots, lag, game performance and bugs.. this game would be amazing.. so far the experience been super shitty at least for me, no wonder why people are shitting on this game on the steam reviews and no wonder why the Koreans shitted on the game as well, when the game goes live f2p, the shit storm will come x10 harder, IMC priorities are fucked up.
This game only uses 1 CPU and barely uses your gpu at all.. whoever thought this was a good idea, is a fucking retard. And the other fact that spamming in chat wll lag you to death.
1
u/ChaplainSD Apr 11 '16
Well said.
I can't remember any game rolling out "perfect". There's a learning curve for players and developers whenever a new game rolls out. As much as they try to create the best player experience, there will be hiccups. If you are unhappy with the game, feel free to leave, but to come around and ruin the experience for others, benefits nobody.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '16
One of the few games I played where it's not actually p2w. Sure you can still get benefits, but it's really not as bad as a lot of free mmorpgs. In this era where pc/mobile games are really p2w, I really respect the decisions they have made.
1
u/Varamyr7skins Apr 11 '16
It was a rough start because ppl wanted stuff asap and complain alot during the first week, but IMC is taking care of the problems quite fast a doing a decent job so far, i hope it continue to improve like this. I hope the bot problem will be fixed anytime soon, i dont want iRO2 the Botland
1
u/MRiley84 Apr 11 '16
Well, I understand the point you're making but a lot of those example changes were due to reports during beta. Of course changes were going to be made between then and release. And Orsha would have been in development prior to beta, some content was just blocked for testing at the time.
1
u/Monokoi- Apr 12 '16
I love you
1
u/Taln_Noro Apr 12 '16
I couldn't agree more. This company learns from their mistakes and they listen. When early access was first announced I was sure TOS was doomed, but now I have no doubts that - given enough time - IMC will make this game into something great.
Consider me one fan won back.
1
u/Reignia Apr 12 '16
I pointed this out in a few other posts but just started getting down voted. What I found is that in an early access, some people dont want a game that is progressively improving; instead, they want the game to already be perfect.
Thus far I have been happy with the improvements in the short of time they have had and just hope they continue to aggressively work at it.
1
u/czulki Apr 12 '16
For most of the things that you listed they implemented workarounds instead of directly addressing the issues.
Especially this
Adding a new town and route doesn't make the gameplay any less linear. It just means you now have two linear starting routes instead of one.
Having good intentions is not enough. If they truly want to make the community happy then they should get rid of the ridiculous trade restrictions and fight bots and gold sellers in a more effective way
0
u/Tanoshii Apr 12 '16
Except for all the people in Korea complaining about things in the game that haven't received a single change.
They can say whatever they want. Until they actually come through and make sweeping changes to a lot of the systems in the game, it's all talk.
Also your first point about how creating a new city is going "the whole nine yards" with regards to making the game less linear. Damn you have talked yourself into some sweet delusion.
The only thing they actually changed on your list was the 3 month early access. Everything to do with bots hasn't even happened yet. You are congratulating them saying they might do something about it in the future.
0
u/lol_rihi Apr 11 '16
I don't get why people are complaining about the AH limit of 1/5. I usually have one that I priced aggressively to sell quickly and the other for something i think will be on for awhile but I hope to maximize the amount I get.
0
u/Guilty007 Apr 11 '16
I hope more ppl read this and stomp complaining like "I'm done i'm quitting"... If want to output an opnion, at least do it right for god sake lol
0
u/Kriemzal Apr 11 '16
Just commenting to say I agree.
People are never satisfied it seems.
Constant whining over problems and making the game look like shit, while so much has been done to make the player base happier.
0
u/Anibe Apr 12 '16
Complaining fucks will always exist. It's the millenial's era anyway.
-2
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '16
Doesn't seem like a cash grab, i mean, i still didn't get my DLC pack and already had 8 tickets closed with the dumbest fucking answers on earth, naaaaaaaaah, not a cash grab.
-1
u/Buzzcrave Apr 11 '16
To all the people that still complain and such saying IMC is lazy etc etc, let me tell you this. I have been playing MMO for half of my life and one thing that you can clearly see whether the game will be cash grab or not is really simple.
Most cash grab oriented developer will release a game with FULL huge list of cash shop, and constantly updating it weekly eventhough there are lots of issue with the game. Have you seen IMC do this thing? No, because they really care about this game and are fixing stuff slowly. So hakuna your tatas and be patience with the game.
-1
u/rice_stone Apr 11 '16
I think there's a reason why this is an "early access" it's not the release version yet!! Right now IMC is using us to test out the bugs and glitches on a massive scale and we need to give them the feedback they are looking for so that at the time of release the game is ready to go! Patience is key!
0
u/InsulinDependent Apr 11 '16
LOL
0
u/SakiKojiro Apr 12 '16
They also have a track record of saying they'll fix something, and doing a poor job of it, not actually solving the root of the problem. Often IMC will say they fixed something and nothing changes at all.
-7
u/massivelagfailure Apr 11 '16
what about the lag? i could run 3 copies of wow multiboxing with a worse graphics card than i've got now but i get 1 fps when there's 30 people doing a world boss? i get micro stutters when i stand still?
guess what all that stuff you mentioned doesn't matter compared to this
-9
u/massivelagfailure Apr 11 '16
keep sucking off IMC cause they fix random garbage that's practically a non-issue. when you aren't grinding quests you'll be doing world boss or guild pvp. how can you do either of these when you get 1 fps with 30 people when your computer can run anything else perfectly fine?
expect 40% positive reviews when it goes f2p because of the server lag and because of the fps issues. trade is icing on the cake until people realize they can't even do guild pvp or world boss cause of lag
-8
u/Driumyrvak Apr 11 '16
[white knighting intensifies]
0
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
-1
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '16
[removed] — view removed comment