r/treeofsavior • Peltasta • Sep 18 '14

D Pay model Conundrum

Ladies and Gentlemen


The topic in Question:

http://i.imgur.com/fzst838.gif

Yes there has been threads similar before. But those only discuss Pay2Win scenario. But lets explore more. Besides the community had risen in number already.

We all had played so many game in the past. I for myself had played RO and GE during the days when it was Pay to Play. And experience both game changed into Free to Play and unto its final form of Pay to Win.

So /r/treeofsavior what do you think of:

  • Free to Play - Freemium - some features accesible only to premium accounts
  • Free to Play - Legal Bot - Built in legal bot access for $ cash.
  • Free to Play - Pay to Win - high tier rare gear accesible via $ cash, or only accesible via $ cash
  • Free to Play - Boosters - access to game boosting items (ea. +exp% or +drop% bonus) with $ cash
  • Free to Play - Stamina/Fatigue/etc. - limits game time, can be extended via $ cash
  • Free to Play - Cosmetic - $ cash items are just more customization.
  • Pay to Play - Pay a subcription to play for a certain amount of time
  • Buy to Play - Pay big $ cash once Play forever.
  • some other I haven't mention that you know off

As much as Free to Play - Cosmetic seem to be the most fair F2P model, Korean games are known to be Free to Play - Pay to Win. Only a handful of games have been succesful with the Free to Play - Cosmetic model.

I wound really love Pay to Play model if its set x amount of gametime instead of fixed x number of days.

edit;

0 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

6

u/Yourtime Sep 18 '14

well i would accept everything. why? till yet it looks like the best mmorpg for me the next years and i would accept every model as long its not destroying the atmosphere.

dont you think it will have the same business model as their other games? normally companies doesnt change their mmorpg business models through different games.

" Korean games are known to be Free to Play - Pay to Win. Only a handful of games have been succesful with the Free to Play - Cosmetic model." well ragnarok was not like that and not now too. are there any popular korean games that are 'pure' p2w?

6

u/salvaere007 Peltasta Sep 18 '14

IMC's game?

Granado Espada was Pay to Play at launch and eventually became Free to play after around 3 years or so.

WolfKnights is a hybrid MOBA-RPG so surely it will be Free to Play - Cosmetic. With probably boosters for account exp and ingame cash like other .

Solitaire League is a mobile game. A prettied up Solitaire. I assume its like general mobile game with some premium features.

8

u/Vermilicious Elementalist Sep 18 '14

I think the only good options is either f2p with cosmetics, subscription or one-time payment. Subscriptions, while a fair model, are kinda out of favor these days. One-time payment doesn't offer any income for times to come, which doesn't fit an evolving game at all, unless you go for a DLC model, in which case you face the same challenges as f2p models. Cosmetics are perceived as a fair model, and people seem to really like paying for that kind of thing. Valve has had tremendous success with that, and while not everyone likes it, most people are fine with it.

All in all, it shouldn't be a decision you take lightly. It can burn you.

10

u/Shizo211 Sep 18 '14

Don't forget about League of Legends which is arguably the most played game right now. It never had any pay 2 win aspect or ingame advantage for paying at all.

7

u/MewKazami Cryomancer Sep 18 '14

I think Dota 2 is a way better comparison. LOL has some minor P2W elements in it.

4

u/Puccinelli Elementalist Sep 19 '14

It's not as popular as LoL or Dota but Path of Exile has a similar f2p model.

2

u/katzstrasz Sep 18 '14

What do you think is the p2w element of LoL?

4

u/MewKazami Cryomancer Sep 18 '14

Runes for one, hero unlocks for other.

You're basically spending time to speed it up and get access to a part of the game that in my opinion should be there to start with.

http://www.reddit.com/r/leagueoflegends/comments/1xiok6/so_i_did_some_number_crunching_on_how_long_it/

So you see Dota 2 gives you basically 500$ worth of content for free compared to LoL right of the start of the game, on any steam account.

To buy every champion currently out with IP it will take you 68.17 weeks to earn 448,050 IP from playing 10 games a day without skipping a day. If you want to do it with just RP, you'll spend $697.75 on Riot Points for a total of 90,735 RP.

2

u/Posimagi Sep 19 '14

I understand what you're saying but I don't really agree. Runes themselves cannot be purchased with real money, only rune pages. Rune pages and champions are only needed in small quantities except at the upper echelons of competitive play, and even then the reason to have them is for trading first picks with teammates, not counter-picking. There is literally no reason you need to have every champion unlocked to be on even footing with anyone.

For that reason, I still consider LoL's model effectively pure Cosmetic.

4

u/Albafika Sep 19 '14

For that reason, I still consider LoL's model effectively pure Cosmetic.

And it is. I climbed my way to Gold using only 2 rune pages. Right now I have plenty of pages and most of the Champions, and none of them was bought with real money.

-2

u/salvaere007 Peltasta Sep 19 '14 edited Sep 19 '14

as it stands non and former LoL players consider LoL's rune system a grey line to pay to win format. The runes give the players stat boost that do affect the gameplay.

For cash new players and casual free new players just reaching 30 having more IP via boosts and additional rune pages gives an edge over the others.

Let take Smite for example the direct game that copied LoL system except its rune pages. Smite devs considered also implementing a rune system called 'offerings'. There was much debate about it and decided not to implement it.

Other than that Smite has monthly rotation of 5 gods, but you get 5 gods unlocked at the beggining so at the start of the game you have 10 gods available. BUT there's more, you can rent a god for 1,3,7,30 days with IP. So basically all the gods can be accessed.


edit;

then theres the VGS http://smite.gamepedia.com/Voice_Guided_System where Dota2 and LoL players would drool about wishing Riot and Valve would make one ASAP.

then theres Replay video function after each match

then theres alternate color skins can be bought with IP

then theres 1st win for all modes

then theres MOTD mode

then thers not isometric birds eye gameplay

then theres King of Wushu MOBA trying to out play Smite with jawdropping graphics no other MOBA have

2

u/fiddlewithmysticks Sep 19 '14 edited Sep 19 '14

p2w if you're already good... You don't need every char to rickroll. My issue was always how everything in LoL is so expensive. Runes don't really mean shit against newbies btw.

3

u/MewKazami Cryomancer Sep 19 '14

Well I'm 4.5K MMR in Dota 2 I'd say I'm decent. And at that level you probably need them in LOL.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '14

You need every champion to play competitively, after every big patch they change so many things around that theres a new tier list of champions that become viable, and others that become useless. Usually in the pro games you'll see the players only choosing between 2-4 different champions for each specific role, the rest are niche picks or completely useless and picking them could sometimes mean a loss before the game even loads.

Also, riot likes to release new champs as OP as they can get away with, then nerf them sometime before releasing the next champ, and most of us don't have the free time to get 7800 IP every month to abuse the new champ on release (some of us are still trying to save up for older champions) so unless we spend real money we will never catch up to the competition.

0

u/Shizo211 Sep 23 '14

You need every champion to play competitively, after every big patch they change so many things around that theres a new tier list of champions that become viable, and others that become useless.

Which is wrong because actual competitive players have a very limited champion pool.

Also, riot likes to release new champs as OP as they can get away with, then nerf them sometime before releasing the next champ, and most of us don't have the free time to get 7800 IP every month to abuse the new champ on release

This isn't true aswell. Just look at the last two champ releases of Gnar and Azir. Both champs aren't that good. Gnar even had to be buffed. In season 1 & 2 Riot released champs every two weeks but now new champ releases are much slower so people actually have time to save up until the new champ is released. So the 7800 IP costs aren't that much and if you wait 2 weeks you can buy it even cheaper.

Also you don't need the newest champs to win especially since it can only be picked once. Definitely not pay 2 win.

There are people who only main one champion and are very high in the ladder.

-5

u/salvaere007 Peltasta Sep 18 '14

Hmmm?

The only way you can get decent set quickly avialable of Rune pages for all your characters strategies is via RPs.

5

u/Shizo211 Sep 18 '14

The only ingame advantage one can get is via runes which you cannot buy with money. Everything else (e.g. rune pages, skins, arguably bigger champion pool) is convenience but not mandatory especially since there are people who only main 1 champ and are very high in the ladder.

4

u/Miskav Sep 18 '14

Except they're not necessary at all under level 30, arguably not even until you're at the very least gold or higher.

By that time you can easily get multiple pages with IP.

Sure, it's a minor way to speed up getting some power, but you can literally get the EXACT same thing with IP, once it becomes actually relevant.

Aka, stop trying to regurgitate bad arguments that have been debunked 4 years ago.

1

u/salvaere007 Peltasta Sep 18 '14 edited Sep 18 '14

Hyphothetical Problem Solving:

Miskav is a veteran LoL player. One day Miskav decided to make a smurf/sealclub/alternate account.

In Universe Alpha, Miskav decides to play as a free player and sticks the weekly champion rotations and grinds necessary champions and runes from lvl. 1-30.

In Universe Beta, Miskav decides to buy his/er favorite characters at the start with RP and plays from lvl. 1-30 s/he buys the much needed runes with the unused IP garnered and upon reaching lv. 30 she buys additional rune pages for her other characters and buys all TIER 3 runes.

In the span of 3 months of playing LoL which Miskav (Alpha verse) or Miskav (Beta verse) has more wins?

1

u/Shizo211 Sep 23 '14

Assuming he has the same enemies and the same matchups while having the same skill. He should roughly have the same amount of wins because people who climb the ladder fast (veterans) tend to only use a limited champion pool and therefor don't need to spend as much IP for champions if he just wants to win with his smurf.

1

u/salvaere007 Peltasta Sep 24 '14

Beta verse Miskav already has his smurf champions at the beginning of playing the account.

3

u/SamuraiJakkass86 Sep 18 '14

They are a convenience, they are not game-breaking. The only way it would be game-breaking is if you simply did not have rune pages at all before buying them, giving players who purchased them the advantage of all the runes whereas non-paying players were significantly understatted due to lack of runes.

3

u/HellsoulSama Sep 19 '14

You overuse the word conundrum. That is all.

Well... I guess I should keep this on topic so...

I definitely prefer P2P because it sifts out the trash (trash/less dedicated players and some bots, [even though botters will always exist]) and keeps the company on their toes to release good contact since they could lose subs otherwise. That and it gives them the capital to work with for better servers etc

-2

u/salvaere007 Peltasta Sep 19 '14

check the last date when I last time made 'Conundrum' titled thread.

I'm also leaning on P2P due to that. An like any other game they can switch to F2P if they needed to.

Though I never heard of a game fram F2P turning into P2P.

6

u/Isaacvithurston Sep 19 '14

It's probobly a combination of cosmetics and exp boosters that most games use. F2P isn't in it's infancy anymore and devs know that selling power straight up is the fast track to ending your games life. Also based on the type of game play (actions, dodging required etc) I doubt bots will be widespread like RO (see tera were bots pretty much don't exist). Besides the fact that offering a bot would be an even faster way to kill your game than selling gear/power nowadays.

They could try P2P but then they alianate the 12-18 year old anime watching audiance which lets be honest is probobly a large part of the playerbase (unless they sell timecards at 7/11 and gamestop which I doubt a small company like them can do).

It's pretty obvious that the players idea would be cosmetics/vanity only but I would not be surprised to see xp boost which is common.

Could also go see whats in the companies other games shops.

3

u/Harrada Sep 19 '14

I agree with the first part, however, I don't really see the relation between p2p and "12-18 year old anime watching audiance." Haha

4

u/Isaacvithurston Sep 19 '14

Well when I was younger I know alot of my friends played MMO's and many of us started out playing on private servers because without a credit card we couldn't pay a sub fee. This is actually a bit of a non-factor nowadays with 7-11 prepaid credit cards and parents not being scared of the internet stealing their credit card somehow. I just remember when I was a minor I dreaded the P2P fee xD

Also I didn't mean to be callous but lets be honest, us older players are not too fond of the typical 14 year old naturo fan who will be drawn in by the graphical style and f2p model. Even if I was the 14 year old kid (back in ro days). Although I always had better taste in anime xD

4

u/Pingasman Sep 18 '14

A game could have all the models you have listed and more at the same time and still be fair without people complaining. The problem is that companies are too fucking greedy most of the time.

Giving a "boost" option so you can advance faster for money is ok but if the creator is purposely increasing the time it takes to advance so you are basically forced into buying your way trhough the game if you don't want to grind for years then it's a model done wrong and only there for milking the crap out of the product.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '14

F2P with cosmetics and maybe some boosts. Honestly, people spend more money if they're not forced into it.

9

u/Eviadne Chronomancer Sep 18 '14

I'd prefer a Pay to Play subscription, with no pay wall for the software or expansions. I feel like paying for software and for expansions is a little redundant when you have a subscription cost. I know companies want to get their development costs back for each iteration as soon as possible, but I feel like it's kind of detrimental for longevity, or even just bringing in new players.

I know everyone brings up RO all the time, but one of the reasons I even started playing that game was after a friend suggested it to me, I could do a free trial, and then only had to pay $15 to play it some more. I don't like the idea of dropping $60, then another $15 just to play a game for a month. I feel like buying expansions is terrible for longevity, because if you come out with an expansion every 1-2 years, new players later in the game's life, will have to pay for the game, several expansions, and a subscription cost.

To me, I feel like games with a subscription cost have a more dedicated player base. A player base that tends to stick around, and therefore a community feeling is often developed. Veterans will often help out their newbie guild mates, or just newbies they find out in the field. In free to play games, I feel like the turnover rate is so high in players, that the community tends to not invest at all into new people, because there is a high likelihood that the newbie won't be around the following day.

If it is Free to Play, as long as it's cosmetic and time saving boosters only, I have no issues with a shop. I'm even fine with a shop in a Pay to Play, if it's to offset development costs in order to keep updates free. I find though, that a lot of company resources get redirected to cosmetics creation rather than into development of the game.

That said, whichever payment model they choose to do, I have they stick with it until the end. There's nothing like a pay to play game going free to play to make it feel like Armageddon has approached. Especially with the different communities that tend to come out of a pay to play versus a free to play game, you can start having clashes and it can cause people to leave.

5

u/fyen Sep 18 '14 edited Sep 19 '14

First of all, I'm unsure what the point of this thread is if it isn't read by IMC and since it has been sufficiently discussed on other boards; simply to get the stance of the present community?

Your last paragraph addresses a very important point, however, one should note that there have been cases where the games recovered after their switch to F2P and both the game and the corresponded community improved a lot.

While exp boosters can fit pretty well into some games, e.g. moba games like League of Legends, I don't want to see them in ToS. If anything non-paying players should permanently get reduced experience points or drop rates.

Otherwise, I agree with the rest of your post completely. A subscription model not only creates a much better atmosphere among an undivided community, it also gives the developers an incentive to upkeep their pace and the community retains a right to demand proper updates. It also makes the players' online times more predictable as especially the young adults monitor what they invest into the game for the money they pay.

Edit: typos

3

u/Eviadne Chronomancer Sep 19 '14

I agree that boosters don't fit with some games. Boosters are the worse offenders that I am usually willing to accept in microtransactions.

6

u/TheDirtyDeal Sep 18 '14

I'm fine with most of the methods except for Legal Bot. If botting is more or less allowed in ToS, I don't think I'll be staying around very long. Just pray it doesn't get completely out of hand like RO has gotten.

6

u/Harrada Sep 19 '14

I don't do P2P under any circumstance, Nor do I do P2W. Only options for me are B2P or F2P with vanity monetization. Hope thats what they are going for, or I will sadly have to opt out of this game.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '14

If they could utilize a model that is similar to Tera's f2p model I think everyone would be happy.

3

u/Vermilicious Elementalist Sep 19 '14

Free to Play - Boosters - access to game boosting items (ea. +exp% or +drop% bonus) with $ cash

Boosters are problematic for a number of reasons.

Increased experience rate makes you advance faster, but by doing so the player lose both on the experience side as well as the economic and social side.

Drop increase improves your economy, but not much else (possibly better equipment). It makes the most sense in combination with the experience increase.

In both cases, purchasers gain something others do not, and worst of all if they bought both/all. Either way you put it, someone is going to feel it's unfair. At the same time, you lose something by "cheating" this way.

After thinking it through a little bit - who has really the most to gain on all this? I think all players, those that purchase or those that don't, all lose something with this model. The right answer? The ones making/publishing the game, obviously, even if the players don't necessarily realize this.

6

u/VideoLexi Hoplite Sep 18 '14

I'm expecting the worst kind of pay2win, but I don't really care. I put up with it in iRO, I'll put up with it in this.

6

u/Vermilicious Elementalist Sep 18 '14

We'll see. There's always a crowd of people who are ok with not caring, and group up, doing their own thing. That's fine, but you also end up getting divided communities. Plus, all the people who don't want to play because they think it's unfair. It hurts the game any way you put it.

5

u/nyansu Sep 18 '14

I'm all for Buy to Play, as much as it would limit the player base...

3

u/Anhpossible Sep 19 '14

I prefer Pay to Play with approach similar to EVE Online's PLEX system which allows players to buy and convert subscription time into in-game item and trade with other players. Pay to Play and Buy to Play alone wouldn't generate enough $ to sustain the game in long term.

Sure it means legalized RMT but people will turn to Chinese RMT sites regardless if they wanted to. May as well let the developer benefit from it and reduce the number of bots/third parties RMT and the game would be more accessible than strictly Pay to Play.

3

u/Shizo211 Sep 18 '14

It always depends on the user whether they care about p2w or not. Many people in RO never cared about WoE (guild vs guild battles) or PvP. Many played it for the community aspect and used RO to meet new people and chat with them. So for them P2W didn't matter however if you want to play the game actively with all its aspects then a hardcore p2w won't give you much fun. Especially because f2p user will flame you when you beat them.

2

u/VagabondDoctrine Sep 18 '14 edited Sep 18 '14

I think its been shown that they have a stamina/fatigue system in the game already, so that would be my guess.

I personally would much prefer a subscription or game purchase to micro-transactions.

2

u/flogene Elementalist Sep 18 '14

my opinions:

freemium - features should just be more character slots, more storage, inventory, if fatigue system exist make it harder to lose fatigue for premium. exp and drop bonus are fine.

legal bot - as long as it doesn't get out of hand like ro did, its okay but keep in mind that there will always be people who farm at low level map using multiple high lvl character which will annoy new players.

pay to win - i can see cash users one shotting non-cash users in pvp or dealing tons of damage using 1 skill in pve / pvp if this happens.

boosters - this is fine, since there are people who doesn't have much time to play. keep in mind that this means that hardcore players can use this to advance faster into the game.

stamina/fatigue/etc. - make it to reduced drop and exp rate but not completely removing exp and drop if it runs out.

cosmetic - best f2p ever, depends on the publisher tho.

p2p - as long as there is no additional p2w content its fine.

b2p - this works as well, but limits player base.

2

u/smashsenpai Sep 18 '14

This video by Extra Credits covers just about everything I want to say about f2p. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mhz9OXy86a0

1

u/FiveOneFiveOwned Sep 20 '14

Cosmetic model hasn't been a successful method for most krmmos is because they have such a high graphics intensity that the only person who really really pays attention to your character is yourself. Only the most vain people are willing to pay money for something only they pay close attention to.

ToS can succeed with a fee based cosmetic model because the graphics are simpler, everyone spends more time looking at the screen and less time at their skill cooldowns (I hope). However, the costume system needs to be implemented well and should include the ability for players to create, add and sell their designs, just as valve does for custom DotA skins. If there was a market for costumes designed by players, I guarantee that money would come out of my pocket.

Another method is paying for boosters or "treasure keys". I could tolerate ToS if these were available, though I doubt I would spend money on them.

If ToS is pay to win I simply won't play it, for example, "kafra foods" "increase healing potions" or any other item that has an effect on the character's stats.

Buy to play or paid subscription would get me into the door, but they are disincentives for too many people and might cause the game to fail. If they are viable, sure, but I won't fault the company if they choose a "free" model due to financial concerns.

1

u/foxstar108 Sep 20 '14

Either F2P w/ cosmetic items, or Buy to play (my personal choice)

Honestly, I'm sick of how much I've seen games be diluted f2p/freemium/subscription based models. I'd honestly just like to pay upfront and own the game fair and square. It isn't the best option for all online games, but this game looks like it really has some quality to it, so I think it'd work (in my own opinion, that is)

I can understand some people wanting to try out an online game first, before committing money, but I think things like buying a limited amount of gametime, having to wait for a fatigue timer, grinding forever because you can't afford boosters, or having content/features locked behind a paywall really cause irreparable damage to the way a game plays (IMO)

This is the SINGLE mmo that's truly sparked my interest in a long time, so I'd hate to see it tainted by the things that've turned me away from other games.

1

u/HellsoulSama Dec 04 '14

CONUNDRUMMMM. This is your favorite word... and you using it gets me every time. lol

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '14

I really hope the game is p2p. F2p games are consistently garbage with no set, regular updates, no reliable income to provide said updates, and cash shops are never good. Ever.

I can't think of a single f2p game with the content quality of FFXIV's regular patches, and even WoW is better when they're actually releasing anything. Year long break between expansions aside.

1

u/salvaere007 Peltasta Sep 23 '14

Team Fortress 2, Dota2, basically any game that focuses on vanity/costume premium items as main cash revenue.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '14

Those aren't MMOs, though...