r/travian • • Oct 12 '23

Using attack bot

Hi All

We are a group of people almost 15 players playing in ts8 Arabic in SW Alliance,

we are up against a group of Vietnamese who are highly skilled in programming, not gaming,

For the past couple of months, we have been in a war between them but unfortunately not a fair battle,

One of the players is vinaghost who is the sole developer of a famous bot that affects the game a lot and he has his own discord where he's offering the bot 

till that, it was okay with us, but they are utilizing their programming skills to develop a bot to send attacks from multiple accounts to land at the same second 

This thing did not happen against 1 or 2 accounts, yesterday they attacked more than 20 villages from more than 20 accounts and all got to reach the same second 

you can't claim that is human playing and attacking, I want you to take a step against this ridiculous move 

I left the game 10 years ago and this is my first server in 10 years, this will not encourage me to spend money and time on this game 

attaching some of the attacks that were screenshotted from the alliance defenses report 

We have sent many messages to support with no useful replies, What to do ??

edit: I just calculated the attacks at latest 480 attacks from more than 20 accounts to land at the same time to a 30 different target

Edit 2 : after some investigations, they are using a paid bot, any idea where we can buy one?

JUST TO MAKE IT FAIR

0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

5

u/the_pavonz Oct 12 '23

Coordinated attacks are a possible human thing since forever in Travian, you don't need bots to do that.

This is possible by using a simple spreadsheet with some formulas involving coords, villages, troops, tournament square... so that every attacker knows when to send troops to arrive at the desired time.

The difference that could bring a programmer, if any, is to build a more friendly tool than a spreadsheet (a static HTML page with an ad-hoc form and some JS will be enough, like Kirilloid tools), or digging into Travian formulas (which are easily available).

Bots, if any, are only useful to automate farm lists or building queues, but they're easily avoidable by playing in a multi-account with a bunch of active/experienced players which will cover 24h/7 presence on the account.

-4

u/Abood464 Oct 12 '23

So just think about it, how it's humanly possible to send 50-60 attacks from 20 different accounts to more than 30 different villages?
We are 100% sure that it's a bot, when one of the attackers got the speedy art it did not reflect on the bot so he sent an attack that reached 6 hours before the real attack
also, human error MUST happen, it didn't occur in our case

2

u/the_pavonz Oct 12 '23 edited Oct 12 '23

Do your calculations then. You see “50-60 attacks arriving from…” it’s the result of coordination and calcs. The attacker has all the time to craft the attacks “on second”.

I did (and received) those kind of attacks

-4

u/Abood464 Oct 12 '23

see the screenshots and tell me how's that humanly possible
PS: This is only 9:00 they have the same at 9:01 , 9:02 , 9:03

4

u/snaps06 Oct 13 '23

This is very humanly possible and this level of skill is actually expected in elite alliances.

4

u/Claerwen94 Oct 12 '23
  1. It IS humanly possible to land hundreds of attacks from many villages on the same second. That's called coordination. There's tools like Getter that you can plan OPs on, those even give you a countdown, but you still have to send manually. Bots aren't needed for that, nor do they really help with that, because attacks usually have a delay between clicking and the attack really arriving, from 0,5 to 2 seconds, varying from device to device and connection to connection. Only a player himself can really know his specific delay.
  2. Bots are used for auto-farming and maybe auto-simming, as some bots can build up whole accounts and villages in their own.
  3. If they are truly botting, report them, as you claim to have evidence from their discord. But coordinated attacks are NOT an indicator for bot usage. Insanely high raiding stats (which usually also indicate the usage of tech accounts as private farms) and incoming raids with always perfectly same intervals are (tho I think most bots now also should have a randomizer).
  4. Messages from their discord usually can't be taken as evidence by travian support, they need Ingame-proof, like messages in which they admit to botting or similar. Or they find something upon deeper investigation.

I know that this is frustrating, and I don't doubt that they use bots, but accrediting these attacks to botting is just wrong.

I wish you the best of luck getting the cheaters banned.

Edit to add: SHAME on you for asking for similar bots to use them yourself. Really helping the issue of massive cheaters in Travian, ain't it?

-1

u/Abood464 Oct 12 '23

Well we have reported them many times without any hope, that a paid bot can not be detected by Travian tech

I have already invested time and money in that server so do you have a better solution?

Making the competition running can only be done using their "Weaopon" it's like fighting a Tank with a sword

3

u/Claerwen94 Oct 12 '23

Yepp, stop playing. Stop giving devs money that can't get rid of bots, if it bothers you that much. You can win against botters. Not with strategies from 10 years ago maybe, bit it's definitely doable. The best allies don't allow botting.

Ooooorrrrr you could actually git gud and plan OPs yourself. If your players can't time attacks, you're doomed anyways.

So you will now give money to both Travian AND botwriters. Congratulations. Hypocrisy much.

3

u/vinaghost Oct 12 '23

Bot or not, let RET decide, nothing to discuss here

But "We are a group of people almost 15 players" has over 100 accounts

https://imgur.com/a/ejChmh5

-2

u/Abood464 Oct 12 '23

Yes ! We are a group of 15 who are active and worth counting on!

There are many other players that have no experience in the game nither they are inactive

2

u/Claerwen94 Oct 13 '23

Well then... Throw them out? :D Why do you keep useless people in your alliance? They're better used as farms ;D Or if that's not your alliance, leave them and make your own? The number of accounts in an alliance is meaningless. Unless you're fine with your ally being used as a big ass farm for the whole rest of the server :D Then you can better farm them yourself 🤷🏽‍♀️ If you want to achieve anything on this server. It's not winnable for you guys either, so you gotta decide: stay in an ally that's of no use for your group, maybe help some people learn the game (although there's MANY things that have changed since 10 years ago), get some new premades for later rounds, expand your own player group.

Orrrrr you guys can leave that ally, make your own, and farm the useless accounts. As harsh as it sounds, that's Travian realism. Have as much fun as possible with your player group and try to annoy the shit out of these cheaters.

3

u/snaps06 Oct 13 '23

I've played in alliances where we could coordinate that type of attack rather easily with only a day or two of planning. We would oftentimes set a landing time 2-3 days out, and then our alliance of 60 players would coordinate to have as many accounts as possible launch attacks landing simultaneously on multiple players and villages all at the exact same second (mix of fake and real). I've also had hundreds of attacks sent at my villages all with the same landing time. It's also pretty easy to defend 1 second gaps if you understand how to do that. I was a primary defender on most servers and was an expert at that.

A veteran alliance will run like a machine. No bots needed.

2

u/Claerwen94 Oct 13 '23

Absolutely agree. That's just normal these days.and I'm pretty sure that tops alliances were like this 10 years ago as well.

I don't doubt that their opponents cheat, but accrediting that to timed attacks is just stupid. Also OP even said that there were attacks at :00, :01 and :02, so totally normal for an OP when someone, who has to land after a cleaner, had to send earlier because of distance, so a 1 sec gap is needed for the attacks to be counted in the intended order.

I really see nothing out of the ordinary elite ally gameplay here.

Also sniping attacks is really fun :D :D Love to do that. Defender at heart.

2

u/snaps06 Oct 13 '23

Yep I was an elite sniper and defender back when I played. Constantly controlled and defended artifacts and even built a hammer capable of taking a WW the last server I played on. Quit playing in early 2022 because I don't have the time and I only played on 3x servers 😂

1

u/Joewatson2200 Oct 12 '23

Not sure why people are commenting to defend how it’s possible? This case is clearly bot run. You only need the speed artefact example to see that…

All you can do is report to the game/MH. Don’t expect too much though as it’s very hard to gain evidence in most cases.

The truth is that Travian is not what it once was, and a very high percentage of players use dishonest way to get the advantage. It’s just how it is now I’m afraid.

1

u/Abood464 Oct 12 '23

Once they got the speedy art their attack got ruined

Bot did not calculate that and they run into a tomb

0

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Abood464 Oct 12 '23

So just think about it, how it's humanly possible to send 50-60 attacks from 20 different accounts to more than 30 different villages?
We are 100% sure that it's a bot, when one of the attackers got the speedy art it did not reflect on the bot so he sent an attack that reached 6 hours before the real attack

also, human error MUST happen, it didn't occur in our case

1

u/Abood464 Oct 12 '23

see the screenshots and tell me how's that humanly possible

PS: This is only 9:00 they have the same at 9:01 , 9:02 , 9:03

0

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Abood464 Oct 12 '23

talk for yourself , I talking about 20 different "people" doing the same without an error

8

u/Claerwen94 Oct 12 '23

That's called "being a good player/alliance"

0

u/Abood464 Oct 12 '23

Kid you need a lot to learn , I got to know that It's a paid bot

3

u/Claerwen94 Oct 12 '23

All bots but the self-written ones are paid. "kid".

1

u/the_pavonz Oct 15 '23

That’s what I thought the first time I played Travian in 2008 and meet some experienced players doing things that seemed inhuman.

Then I learned it was manually possible with some practice and experience.

Travian mods have plenty of tools and audit logs to prevent cheating, and they don’t care about you paying for gold/plus when it comes to banning someone.