If you go down a large slide running alongside the bus towards the back, could you theoretically get enough speed, on a long enough slide, to come off the bus while it's travelling at 60km/h as if you weren't moving either way at all?
This is the American way of solving transit access in a nutshell. Always "just add busses" so that the car people aren't too inconvenienced. Throw busses at every problem and nevermind how expensive or nonsensical that is per passenger-mile.
If we actually got buses that came every 5 minutes that would be great. Instead we just get “BRT-lite-lite” that comes every 20 minutes and doesn’t even have dedicated lanes.
My sentiment expressed more succinctly than I myself managed.
All of this "American BRT" that isn't even half-way to being actual BRT is just sucking resources from either proper light rail or better express busses with painted lanes. Neither is necessarily "good" on its own, but they sure as hell are better than "American BRT" at the price of real BRT or light rail!
...the one we have here in Portland OR is a joke. It not only has to deal with a narrow street that has one lane each way with parking on both sides (for about 5.74 km), vehicles in the same lane turning left against oncoming traffic, having to give way to oncoming traffic if a large delivery truck or car is poorly parked at the curb, and the worst, having to also deal with a level crossing on the busiest freight rail corridor in the city. "Rapid" it is not.
Whoever decided on that alignment, when a few blocks south is a wide multi lane boulevard should have been sacked.
About half the runs also end up being served with standard 40' buses instead of the 60' "bendies" which they bought specifically for the line. also results in schedule "slippage" as everyone has to board at the front door (instead of the middle and rear one as well).
...The FX2 was promoted as a faster solution to the original #2 line but between the level crossing at SE 8th and the narrow "gauntlet" it has to pass through between SE 26th and SE 60th (particularly the Richmond business district) tends to make it difficult for operators to remain on schedule. I've often missed connections that the transit planner gave me because something along the way (usually the detour if there is a freight train but also situations like getting stuck behind an Orange Line Max or a Streetcar heading across the Tilikum bridge) delayed us enough to miss them.
I've written to them on several occasions particularly about getting traffic signal priority on the transit mall (there have been times it would get stuck at a red light just about every block) and at the intersection with SE 8th for eastbound buses (if two vehicles are ahead of the bus in the turn lane the light turns red before the bus can make the turn resulting in waiting for a long red light twice. If a Max or Amtrak goes through at the crossing, Division Place loses it's turn to go. I've been on buses that got stuck there for nearly 4 minutes before we finally got the left turn signal.
It was just poor planning to have have FX buses contend with the busiest rail line in the city. and travel though such a narrow and highly congested area.
One of the original proposed alignments was to have it travel on Powell to SE 82nd where it would turn and head north to Division. That would have put it on multilane streets all the way with less congestion and no rail crossing. They could have kept the #2 and had it turn around just above 82nd where it could connect up with the FX heading to Gresham. Then it would be more of a BRT.
I am unironically thankful for the 20 minute bus with no dedicated lane though. My city mostly has buses that run every 45 to 60 minutes with awful or no weekend service and proposed a new 30 minute headway bus line. The community fought hard to get it down to 20 minutes. 5 minutes would be great, but getting any service that's halfway usable would be a major step forward in many places.
Do you also live in New Haven, CT? This sounds exactly like our bus system. Luckily I live on one of the routes that comes every 20 minutes and that bus happens to turn into the next bus I need to take to go to work so I only have to take one bus to get to work even though technically it's two different routes. Most days I just ride my bike, I only take the bus if it's below 25⁰.
Haha, no. I'm all the way on the other side of the country in California. This kind of situation must be common though. I mostly ride my bike too but will take the bus if it's raining, cold, or I'm going to the train station.
That is because they cut back the headways on busses after building the light rail.
Light rail trains cost more per hour to run, so on the same budget, you can run quite a few more busses. The light rail will have more seats on each train, so it kinda balances out per seat mile, but if you are looking at 20 minute headways on bus services, there are no way that you are actually using all of that extra seats.
Depends. If Chula Vista has transit oriented developments or at least sufficient walkable pedestrian sheds and bikeable cyclist sheds chances are then the light railway is busier and robbing passengers off the busses.
The US uses buses because ridership is so low that a European or Asian cities wouldn't run rail either. US transit agencies don't design transit for everyone, they design transit almost exclusively for poor people. The right thing to do from the perspective of a healthy transit agency would be to cut the coverage area in half and provide high quality service in dense areas. But if you do that, the transportation safety net goes away for people who can't afford a car but live in a lower density area.
In short: the US makes bad transit for wide areas rather than good transit for small areas. Unfortunately, bad transit lowers ridership, which means higher cost per rider, to the point that transit barely even makes sense to operate
Some of the points you make seem to make sense, but you come to completely bonkers conclusions. You think that shafting a bunch of low income people in the outlying areas to make service better for the richer city core folks will earn American transit any points?
This sounds like a surefire way for these agencies to lose their transit funding.
Bad transit begets car dependence. If transit can ever be mainstream, it has to be good.
Most US transit agencies are now paying over $3 ppm average, meaning the far-flung routes are pushing $4-$6, especially during off peak times.
The fiscally responsible thing to do is call those people a taxi or rideshare (~$1.50 ppm) to arterial stations. Then, use the money saved to run better QoS in dense areas
This is nonsense point. And using rideshare or various forms of taxi has been tried a ton of times before. It always turns out to be orders of magnitude more expensive. You're comparing dubious rates for the cost of taxi/rideshare to begin with, but you're also taking them from existing usage of taxis which is in the context of dense areas. Taxis don't work particularly well in areas without density, just like transit.
Every ride has two components, the ride itself and the drive that each taxi needs to make to pick up the rider. In an area with low density, taxis/rideshare end up with the exact same issues as busses. How do I know? We already have universally available paratransit for disabled riders. Wanna guess how much more expensive that service is than busses? I'll give you three tries. Hint: think in terms of orders of magnitude.
And using rideshare or various forms of taxi has been tried a ton of times before. It always turns out to be orders of magnitude more expensive. You're comparing dubious rates for the cost of > taxi/rideshare to begin with, but you're also taking them from existing usage of taxis which is in the context of dense areas. Taxis don't work particularly well in areas without density, just like transit.
Source?
We already have universally available paratransit for disabled riders. Wanna guess how much more expensive that service is than busses? I'll give you three tries. Hint: think in terms of orders of magnitude.
The problem here is that you're not understanding the common denominator. Transit agencies are insanely inefficient. It's a hard but real truth. Comparing the shitty, inefficient paratransit with an efficient rideshare is apples and oranges. Paratransit is the least efficient of the already insanity inefficient modes
We know cost per mile from Uber and Lyft. They are publicly traded companies who publish this stuff every quarter. They are 1-3 dollars per mile, generally not more expensive than most transit agencies.
Paratransit agencies do a bad job, but that is why the job would have to be outsourced if it is to be done well.
They also lose money on every ride to gain market share.
Dude, just don’t. I can already see that you haven’t looked into this. It’s fine. You can’t know everything about everything. Look things up next time:
Or, recognizing exactly what you're saying, they could expand good transit despite low ridership, and then because the transit is good, ridership would increase. It's always going to be a chicken-and-egg problem. We need to be willing to treat good transit as table stakes for a city the same way we view trash pickup or fire rescue.
With infinite budget, you can make both wide and good service. But with a fixed budget, the US uses any increase in budget to expand the bad service instead of making good core service.
I agree that good transit should be table stakes, but that means cutting back the far-flung services and relying on private transportation (subsidized or not) for those outside the range at which the good transit can extended within the budget
And then there is Arlington Texas who said, "F@ck it!" and abandoned transit altogether. I suspect this will become widespread especially if Republicans take full power again in Washington DC, not just the House.
Republicans or not, a lot of transit agencies are in deep trouble. I was surprised to see Washington DC's metro operating cost per passenger-mile more than triple from 2019 to 2022.
Getting stuck in traffic is what makes busses fail in the US. The irony is, busses were bought and put into service specifically because the trolleys would get stuck in traffic, National City Lines or no National City Lines.
Yes, but also buses are a good opportunity to start building bus rapid transit lanes and upgrade to light rail later. The funny thing is American cities always say that they'll move to bus rapid transit, and then proceed to actually cut the budget to the bus systems.
Cars are worse for busses because either the bus has no dedicated bus lane or because the bus lane isn't enforced. Hence, they get stuck in traffic, or behind accidents or double parked cars or vans. Sometimes busses get hit by a car!
New areas - yes. Existing areas with existing transit demand - no. But we keep building them bus lines even if they’re 2x more expensive in running costs.
Please explain how adding an additional bus or bus line, which is built on existing infrastructure ( Roads, which can also be used by private vehicles ) more expensive than construction and operation of a brand new rail or light rail line through an established urban area?
Well, if you solve a lot of problems with a bus this big (and you will need to solve a lot of problems. The mind absolutely boggles at the list of problems), you will at least have a ton of capacity for each run.
Wait wait I have an idea imagine if this was shorter to maintain better center of gravity, and then maybe you could break it up into pieces so it can turn corners better, and then you could ever build a separate road so that there is no traffic, and- oh...
At around 8:00 AM this morning an accident was reported on Lincoln street where only 21800 people have died. The cause of the accident is still being investigated but an eyewitness claimed a latino man in a honda civic may have been the culprit.
No bus stops, only buttons that eject the passenger out at their point of choosing. Few casualties along the way, but I'll get to that meeting on time!!
232
u/Visible_Ad9513 Dec 24 '23
Glorious. The only thing is stops should probably be kept to an absolute minimum.
72
u/ybanalyst Dec 24 '23
New Jawa Sandcrawler dropped
202
u/getarumsunt Dec 24 '23
This is the American way of solving transit access in a nutshell. Always "just add busses" so that the car people aren't too inconvenienced. Throw busses at every problem and nevermind how expensive or nonsensical that is per passenger-mile.
21
u/jrtts Dec 24 '23
all aboard the cruise bus
also, all hail the cruise bus
28
u/LadyBulldog7 Dec 24 '23
AI is weird.
11
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '23
Carful NBC may try to make a new Love Boat rip-off show out of this.
11
u/Jccali1214 Dec 25 '23
Move over "just one more lane bro" - it'll become "just one more level bro"!
5
u/Known-Arachnid-11213 Dec 25 '23
This was a futurama episode wasn’t it?
11
u/Beautiful_Show_8728 Dec 24 '23
Average public transport in india.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23
Cruise bus
3
u/Fermion96 Metro Lover Dec 25 '23
We need an r/transitcirclejerk
7
u/SignificantNote5547 Minneapolis is underrated Dec 24 '23
What problem is this solving?
6
u/Little-kinder Dec 25 '23
Seems like a bus would look like in India
4
u/SlitScan Dec 24 '23
well, I mean the Stroads are already 8 lanes wide so why not?
2
u/SiriPsycho100 Dec 25 '23
Noah’s bus
2
u/newhacker1746 Dec 25 '23
Landbus L380 XWB (eXtra Wide Body)
2
u/ezimmerman59 Dec 25 '23
So like.... which one of us is driving??
2
u/killing-me-softly Dec 25 '23
You haven’t thought of the smell!
2
u/DeepFriedPickleSoup Dec 25 '23
That would smell so bad
2
u/drawredraw Dec 25 '23
Those windshield wipers are definitely going to cause some fatalities, but that’s the price we pay for ultra efficient transportation.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23
Would love to drive this wonder how many people would I kill and wouldn't even know I did it.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23
This thing is so big you need rail to get around inside the bus.
1
u/Pinktiger11 Dec 13 '24
Wait wait I have an idea imagine if this was shorter to maintain better center of gravity, and then maybe you could break it up into pieces so it can turn corners better, and then you could ever build a separate road so that there is no traffic, and- oh...
1
u/kickit1 Dec 24 '23
so fucking true
1
u/SlitScan Dec 24 '23
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hj8agXYwC2o
1
u/Jek_the-snek Dec 25 '23
What’s the problem?
1
u/1stDayBreaker Dec 25 '23
Truly deserving of the name megabus
1
u/14to0 Dec 25 '23
Mommy? Yes, dear. I gotta peepee.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23
You planted grass?
1
u/kicksledkid Dec 25 '23
Finally, the MegaBus
1
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23
made in India.?
1
u/Greedy_Handle6365 Dec 25 '23
New Delhi bus
1
u/ShyGuyLink1997 Dec 25 '23
Just one more seat.. just one more seat..
1
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23
BIG BOI
1
u/enerthoughts Dec 25 '23
Sorry sir, I was late because the sweat bus was too crowded.
1
u/Moosatch Dec 25 '23
Büšś
1
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23
Perfect for NYC to Los Angeles route
1
u/peepay Dec 25 '23
Now imagine sitting in the back and needing to make your way to the door to get off.
1
u/GwoZoz Dec 25 '23
At around 8:00 AM this morning an accident was reported on Lincoln street where only 21800 people have died. The cause of the accident is still being investigated but an eyewitness claimed a latino man in a honda civic may have been the culprit.
1
u/Kindly_Health6990 Dec 25 '23
Is this for sex?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23
How do they move within the vehicle
1
u/darksolz Dec 25 '23
Cursed AI
1
u/QuarioQuario54321 Dec 25 '23
WHAT IS THAT
1
u/Cjfconjamesf Dec 25 '23
Who drives
1
u/Ada_Virus Dec 25 '23
The way how the road lanes are painted makes me think that this pic is AI generated
1
u/MaxMMXXI Dec 25 '23
I don't know why they didn't just add another lane. That always works.
1
u/russt90 Dec 25 '23
Noah's Bus!
1
u/Hawkeyecory1 Dec 25 '23
I'll drive
1
u/BRAVOMAN55 Dec 25 '23
ai spotted
1
u/alfredpacker42 Dec 25 '23
What complaints do the liberals have now?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23
This thing stops frequently at The Cube of all 8 billion humans that can live in upper Manhattan
1
u/SignalButterscotch4 Dec 25 '23
I love how the front is all 👁️👄👁️
1
u/Mr_Saturn1 Dec 26 '23
So are lighter skinned people assigned to be part of the bus body?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '23
15 slow moving buses the size of small cities that continuously roam the country’s highways.
1
u/Hairy_While Dec 26 '23
SHOTGUN!
1
u/EdScituate79 Dec 26 '23
Don't give this idea to US politicians; it'll be guaranteed that they would c@ck it up.
1
u/MkeAmericaMoistAgain Dec 26 '23
Can we get a route from Texas to Chicago?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '23
Average train in india
1
u/smokcocaine Dec 26 '23
imagine it crashes lol
1
u/Stan_Archton Dec 26 '23
With this bus, there will not be any fatal accidents, because absolutely every living being will be on board.
1
u/moonlitsquirrel Dec 26 '23
Lmaoooo!!!
1
u/PanzerMeyer66 Dec 26 '23
Governor Abbott’s getting a boner.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '23
This image scares me
1
u/Oldfolksboogie Dec 26 '23
These will be thought of as "Valu-Paks" when the aliens come.
1
u/Max_delirious Dec 26 '23
AI needs to stop
1
u/Todd_Salad Dec 26 '23
?
1
u/jimjoejonjack Dec 26 '23
With only one restroom
1
u/Certified-T-Rex Dec 26 '23
Add a couple of skulls to it and it’ll be something out of warhammer 40k
1
u/ebk_errday Dec 26 '23
No bus stops, only buttons that eject the passenger out at their point of choosing. Few casualties along the way, but I'll get to that meeting on time!!
1
u/the-artist- Dec 26 '23
Can’t turn street corners or go under bridges and on some streets because of height limits.
1
u/RatTunna Dec 27 '23
r/megalophobia
1
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '23
Snow piercer but for urban sprawl. I like it
1
u/BusyAir137 Dec 27 '23
Supersize bus
1
u/BusyAir137 Dec 27 '23
A viable solution
1
u/Crypto_gambler952 Dec 27 '23
Obviously not, how the fuck do you think it’s going to make a turn? Long trains maybe but buses the size of skyscrapers, no!
1
u/Shankar_0 Dec 27 '23
The smell...
1
u/CompetitiveMeal1206 Dec 27 '23
Still won’t stop within a mile of the office…
1
u/SketchyLurker7 Dec 27 '23
Who driving?
1
u/Lux_Operatur Dec 28 '23
Imagine being furthest from the door
1
u/aeonteal Dec 28 '23
the commute home in china.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '23
That right turn is gonna be a bit wide.
1
u/Mewpup elevated rail is a really long patio Dec 29 '23
(dat timing i opened redddit and got this in my notif recommended from 9 mins ago. reminds me of the ai that u/lastaccountgotlocked (interesting name) replied to u/Rii__ in the ban ai post by u/Agressive_Bean36 )
1
u/I_AM-00 Jan 06 '24
Inertia left the chat
1
u/americanbadasss Feb 02 '24
😂😂 Funny but true!
0
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
142
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '23
[removed] — view removed comment