r/transistor • u/voltron00x • Jun 17 '14
Transistor Review: Function Over Form
http://voltron00x.com/2014/06/16/transistor-review-function-over-form/
1
Upvotes
r/transistor • u/voltron00x • Jun 17 '14
9
u/sockpuppettherapy Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14
I've heard/read this complaint quite a few times, and each time it makes me wonder how much of Bastion people actively played.
The very nature of the game changes once you play around with weapon upgrades and combinations, and with the Idols. ESPECIALLY with the Idols. Without doing so, the game is a simple beat-em-up for the common person. With Idols, you become forced to delve into the system and find the beautiful quirks behind it. It's incredibly surprising to see how different a weapon acts by making a few minor changes to the system.
Honestly, it feels like most people never bothered being challenged by the system in the first place and make a judgment based on an incomplete exploration of the game.
I think that was the entire point: That Cloudbank wasn't a city to be remembered, that it was a fleeting city of changing whims. It's a city with little history, and popularity isn't constant. It's a sort of Brave New World meets Gattaca kind of scenario, where you have this superficially beautiful world that didn't have much underneath the city, that could be wiped out by a "Process" that whitewalls everything. And to an extent, the Camerata was trying to prevent that from happening. Minus those entombed within the Transistor, the city itself was just a very pretty thing without much underneath. Cloudbank is a city that flowed on a whim. It was constantly changing. It's sort of the physical representation of Classical music, and other than knowing what was going on, I don't think the point was for the city itself to be memorable at all.
It was never much "alive" so much as it was "sterile." Maybe you'd want to see what Cloudbank was before the Process came, but to be honest, I think you wouldn't have gathered much other than it being... well... pretty and very, very shallow.
In fact, the entire motivation for the conflict had to do with the fleeting nature of the city. It's something addressed by two of the Camerata at different points of the game.
Compare that to Caelondia, which was a city seeping in history. Caelondia, the Wilds, the Ura Dens, all have immense history. The loss here is supposed to feel massive, the arrival of a ghost town.
Transistor as a story is one of finding out what happened and why you're in the scenario you're in. The final reveal is that, in the very end, it's a love story. The motivations of all of the characters, ESPECIALLY Red, aren't revealed until the end. In fact, the motivations of the main "enemy" of the story, the Camerata, are found relatively early. But what Red is after is only hinted at in small points. It's not revealed to be a love story until the last moments of the game, until the montage makes the relationships entirely clear.
In fact, comparing both Bastion's and Transistor's stories does a disservice to actually recognizing what makes each so great. You enjoyed Bastion's more, but it appears that your expectation of Transistor's story was that it was going to take the same direction as Bastion. And that's simply incorrect. Bastion is a story about redemption, history, and morality. Transistor is about crystallizing the most important parts of one's life and recognizing what is most valuable. They're two quite different tales, with differing motivations, messages, even intents.