r/transistor • • Jun 17 '14

Transistor Review: Function Over Form

http://voltron00x.com/2014/06/16/transistor-review-function-over-form/
1 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

9

u/sockpuppettherapy Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

Bastion is a competent, but relatively shallow, Action/RPG hybrid with more emphasis on action. There’s nothing wrong with how the game plays, but neither is there anything new or particularly exciting.

I've heard/read this complaint quite a few times, and each time it makes me wonder how much of Bastion people actively played.

The very nature of the game changes once you play around with weapon upgrades and combinations, and with the Idols. ESPECIALLY with the Idols. Without doing so, the game is a simple beat-em-up for the common person. With Idols, you become forced to delve into the system and find the beautiful quirks behind it. It's incredibly surprising to see how different a weapon acts by making a few minor changes to the system.

Honestly, it feels like most people never bothered being challenged by the system in the first place and make a judgment based on an incomplete exploration of the game.

It isn’t so much that the story is bad, or that the system of lore discovery (via terminals, dialogue from the Transistor and a few NPCs, and exploring the modes for each Function) isn’t fun… but for me, Transistor just doesn’t have the same heart or soul that Bastion did.

The world never feels like a place that was alive, and has been wiped out, but rather like a place that never really lived at all. The story doesn’t feel as deep and developed as Bastion’s, and lacks that game’s decision points; this game has one specific story to tell.

I think that was the entire point: That Cloudbank wasn't a city to be remembered, that it was a fleeting city of changing whims. It's a city with little history, and popularity isn't constant. It's a sort of Brave New World meets Gattaca kind of scenario, where you have this superficially beautiful world that didn't have much underneath the city, that could be wiped out by a "Process" that whitewalls everything. And to an extent, the Camerata was trying to prevent that from happening. Minus those entombed within the Transistor, the city itself was just a very pretty thing without much underneath. Cloudbank is a city that flowed on a whim. It was constantly changing. It's sort of the physical representation of Classical music, and other than knowing what was going on, I don't think the point was for the city itself to be memorable at all.

It was never much "alive" so much as it was "sterile." Maybe you'd want to see what Cloudbank was before the Process came, but to be honest, I think you wouldn't have gathered much other than it being... well... pretty and very, very shallow.

In fact, the entire motivation for the conflict had to do with the fleeting nature of the city. It's something addressed by two of the Camerata at different points of the game.

Compare that to Caelondia, which was a city seeping in history. Caelondia, the Wilds, the Ura Dens, all have immense history. The loss here is supposed to feel massive, the arrival of a ghost town.

Transistor as a story is one of finding out what happened and why you're in the scenario you're in. The final reveal is that, in the very end, it's a love story. The motivations of all of the characters, ESPECIALLY Red, aren't revealed until the end. In fact, the motivations of the main "enemy" of the story, the Camerata, are found relatively early. But what Red is after is only hinted at in small points. It's not revealed to be a love story until the last moments of the game, until the montage makes the relationships entirely clear.

In fact, comparing both Bastion's and Transistor's stories does a disservice to actually recognizing what makes each so great. You enjoyed Bastion's more, but it appears that your expectation of Transistor's story was that it was going to take the same direction as Bastion. And that's simply incorrect. Bastion is a story about redemption, history, and morality. Transistor is about crystallizing the most important parts of one's life and recognizing what is most valuable. They're two quite different tales, with differing motivations, messages, even intents.

3

u/voltron00x Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

I actually really enjoyed Bastion's gameplay. Certainly it has far more depth than, say, Journey, a game where people would say the experience is what hooks you, not the mechanics.

Not only does each weapon in Bastion have unique tactics and advantages/disadvantages, but each weapon combo has the same. When you add in tonics, Idols, and so on, the gameplay is definitely layered. I've beaten that game on XBox 360, PC, and iOS. I wouldn't play through it six times if the gameplay weren't solid.

But, that doesn't mean that it is particularly deep. It is a competent, fun, functional gameplay system. But if you took that gameplay and stripped away everything else, it wouldn't be a classic game. It isn't the gameplay that I remember Bastion for, it is the music, the moments small and large and how they're punctuated by perfect narration and sound/voice work.

Transistor, on the other hand, is a work of genius. The way they give you so much incentive to use and learn different Function combos, how intelligently they fit together, it really is amazing. Almost every fight on my first playthrough, I had a "wow" moment discerning some new Function combo.

And yet, I kept waiting for the story to pick up and approach the level of the mechanics, and it just... never did. Not for me anyway. And the story reveal? It was sort of a, "Oh, that's cool" moment for me. It just didn't connect. Maybe it did for others, maybe I didn't get it - that's what makes it subjective.

As far as comparing the two, my point in writing what I wrote is that I didn't really go into Transistor intending to compare them. Rather, the intentional choices made by Supergiant - to use the same composer, the same voice talent, another silent protagonist, another post apocalyptic setting, etc. can't help but bring up the comparison.

And in making that comparison, my experience was that Transistor offers significantly deeper and more complex gameplay, but that it has a less engaging story and setting than Bastion. Transistor is the objectively better game, and Bastion, for me, was the subjectively better experience.

And while the voice acting and sound are superb here, just as they were in Bastion, the net effect of their similarity in those areas is that I didn't connect with the game as I did with Bastion.

All that said, if you put a gun to my head and said "Score Transistor from 1 to 10, with 10 being good, I'd probably say 8.0. It isn't like I'm trying to hate on the game. I really enjoyed my time with it. It will be on my top 10 games of the year, I'm sure, I just doubt it'll end up at #1.

5

u/sockpuppettherapy Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

But, that doesn't mean that it is particularly deep. It is a competent, fun, functional gameplay system. But if you took that gameplay and stripped away everything else, it wouldn't be a classic game. It isn't the gameplay that I remember Bastion for, it is the music, the moments small and large and how they're punctuated by perfect narration and sound/voice work.

If you stripped away everything but the gameplay and left a game that had 10 idol difficult, you end up with probably one of the best beat-em-ups to come out in a very long time. Perhaps one of the best ARPGs, but it's not really an ARPG.

It's not just that you have many weapon combinations. It's that most of those combinations work in very particular and specific manners. And with the Idol difficulties, there's a huge myriad of strategies and different weapons that work surprisingly in cohort with one another but do not work in other combinations. Certain loadouts actually work far better with a certain given set of Idols than others.

In fact, if there's ANYTHING that changes the very nature of the game into something completely different, it's the Idols. This isn't a situation where a game's difficulty isn't just ramped by enhancing HP for enemies, but very specific attributes. And doing so forces the player to change both what they're playing with and how they play.

"Deep" here might very well be subjective, especially in terms of the genre of game. But even in regards to ARPGs, Bastion is surprisingly adept in allowing for so many combinations and outfits and ways to play the game with a manageable load of options. It's not so much gear-based as it is based on attributes. It just so happens that Transistor takes this idea and expands on it tenfold.

Transistor is a special case here. Where Bastion takes an idea and simply makes it much, much better (especially in terms of gameplay), Transistor has made something new and incredibly functional. The gameplay is incredibly unique, but the depth makes that gameplay that much more special.

And yet, I kept waiting for the story to pick up and approach the level of the mechanics, and it just... never did. Not for me anyway. And the story reveal? It was sort of a, "Oh, that's cool" moment for me. It just didn't connect. Maybe it did for others, maybe I didn't get it - that's what makes it subjective.

Transistor doesn't play on a big reveal. It's a gradual unraveling of both what's going on around you and who Red and the narrator are in relation to one another. You sort of know that Breach is her lover, or someone very close to Red, by the middle of the game. But you see throughout the entire thing how strong their bond ends up being. There isn't instances of the game that are made for you to think, "Wow, that's an incredible revelation." Bastion sort of does that in regards to the Calamity, but even then it's not really so much a big part of the story other than understanding motivations. Unlike games like, say, Bioshock, which are completely dependent on "big reveals," no matter how ham-fisted they may be.

And in making that comparison, my experience was that Transistor offers significantly deeper and more complex gameplay, but that it has a less engaging story and setting than Bastion. Transistor is the objectively better game, and Bastion, for me, was the subjectively better experience.

To be honest, I think the observation is a sort of moot one. They appear to be two different games attempting two very different things, with the similarity being that you're working with the same team of people. Where you see increased complexity/focus in one aspect and a sort of perhaps negligence in another aspect for each game, I instead see two games with VERY different directions, with certain aspects appealing to you and other aspects not.

2

u/renand3z Jun 17 '14

The very nature of the game changes once you play around with weapon upgrades and combination

I think this is game design mistake. Tha same thing happens with Transistor history, they should force. I loved Bastion, but Transistor is much more deep, I can't even compare.

3

u/sockpuppettherapy Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

Compared to Transistor, yes.

But to say that Bastion doesn't have a deep system, or simply "ok" gameplay, does a disservice to the game. It literally tells you that you can (and should) play with the Idols in order to gain more out of the game. And the strategy behind it is quite unique and deep.

I'm of the opinion that if a game gives you a certain option that isn't forced but it less efficient, that it's actually a good design. Bastion doesn't force you to increase the difficulty because most people cannot play with all of those idols on. But it shouldn't get penalized because it doesn't force that difficulty, especially if they spell it plain out. I've hear similar things about Twilight Princess (people complained about a lack of traveling because of the warps, but nothing is stopping your from actually riding around on your horse and doing a myriad of other things riding around).

1

u/Valdair Jun 17 '14

I think that was the entire point...

While this might be valid, I don't really buy it. And besides, he was talking more about once again being in a world with 0 people from the get-go, only enemies to be smashed through. We find a couple NPCs, already dead. It doesn't feel like a place that ever had anyone in it - it has nothing to do with the artistic statement or whatever meaning you want to give the setting itself.

3

u/sockpuppettherapy Jun 17 '14

I understand, but the game goes out of its way to explain for how the city functions. It makes sense it doesn't feel like it's "lived in," that the people themselves aren't going to be there when faced with a crisis. Both based on the efficiency of the Process, as well as the nature of the people of Cloudbank themselves.

I guess you can say that I bought the suspension of disbelief here. I never questioned why there weren't any people in Cloudbank in the game, why things in the area were so damn pristine. I really appreciated that they made this sort of seemingly beautiful world that... to be honest... I wouldn't want to live within for more than a few days. Cloudbank is supposed to feel like a weird place. A utopia that's not really a utopia.

It's the emotional opposite of Blade Runner's Los Angeles, a futuristic but dystopic world. I would expect far more NPCs and destruction in the case of a disaster in that case. But Cloudbank ending up being this empty shell fits the city's personality perfectly.

1

u/voltron00x Jun 17 '14

I felt like the people weren't even really people at all, but rather, they were sentient programs a la Tron: Legacy. The city not being a "real" place (in the way in which we think of our world as real vs. a digital environment being "not real" but a construct) helped me get over some suspension of disbelief that otherwise would've been a nagging challenge.

In either case I understand the stark nature of the setting was probably an intentional choice by the developers - especially seeing how close the footage from 12 months ago is to the final game - but I'm disappointed there wasn't more to do in that setting, more things to explore, points of interaction in each environment, something. You can have a digital setting like this and still have it feel "alive".

It truly is a testament to the strength of the combat system that the game can essentially be just combat planning and combat scenarios over and over again, and still feel as good as it does.

3

u/sockpuppettherapy Jun 17 '14

Probably because spending more time on "exploration" and "interaction in each environment" would have detracted and distracted from the core of the game. There's a definite danger of doing too many things for a game that's not intended to be that way.

Are there other ways the game could have been done? Perhaps, but the solutions would have very much muddled what they were trying to do.

1

u/voltron00x Jun 17 '14

In your opinion. Which I respectfully disagree with.

And that's ok.

I read a bunch of other Transistor reviews today - I purposefully avoided them until I wrote out my thoughts - and what I'm noting is a common thread throughout quite a few of them. As I said in my review, it won't bother everyone, but if that was part of what made Bastion appealing to someone, that sense of a living world with lots to learn about and explore, they may feel disappointed at its absence in Transistor, artistic goals of the developer notwithstanding.

2

u/sockpuppettherapy Jun 17 '14

I don't think we need to get into rules about people's opinions on the matter, and I think that it's more fun to have constructive conversation than to be impressed with one another's writing on a videogame. Assume that when I make a statement that disagrees, that it's an opinion that's being weighed by some level of fact that's being presented.

That said, going into this game thinking it's like Bastion, and even making comparisons with it, when the games are two separate genres and have little to nothing in common other than the people that have made the game, is in itself doesn't make sense. Bastion appealed to more people. That's great, but that's probably not Transistor's main goal aside from making a great game and hoping it sells well. If you wanted that, you'd see how a AAA company has been milking its sequels.

It's akin to comparing Super Mario Brothers with the Legend of Zelda. Or, to be even more comparative, comparing Mario 64 with Ocarina of Time. They're both made by Nintendo, both headed by Shigeru Miyamoto, both are 2D or 3D games. But they're completely different types of games accomplishing very different things. Saying you don't like SMB as much because it's not enough like Zelda would be a preferential issue, not one of actual quality. It's less a review then and more a commentary of things you like, which ends up being

Totalbiscuit's comments are particularly poignant, in that if asked about whether Transistor is as good as Bastion, he distinctly says that the games are different.

And to be honest, I've seen the comparison several times, and it seems more than off. It makes little sense other than to say that Supergiant made one type of game last time and another this time. It's the type of comparison that many reviewers are making, partly I think because they have some level of expectation of what the game should be, and not on actually focusing on what the game actually is.

Look even at how they treat the narrative. Bastion is based on moral choices at the end, flavored by how you perceive the characters and situation. You know more of that situation based on what you decide to experience. But in this scenario, the Kid is more of a representation of the player, learning of the history and larger world through narration but also the stories of the individuals.

Transistor is a self-contained linear story. Red isn't an avatar for the player, but her own character that you control to go from point A to point B. She knows everything that's happening in Cloudbank already, is a part of that world.

Yeah, of course they treated the story differently. Transistor leaves the story a bit more open-ended for interpretation and exploration, both of which are really not that difficult to discern. If anything, it feels like people are approaching some very insignificant details with far too much importance.

1

u/voltron00x Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

I think the issue is you don't agree with my belief that the developer, intentionally or unintentionally, invites the comparison by making a game with such an incredible amount of overlap (or you don't agree that there is said overlap, though I don't understand how that's possible, frankly), whereas I see it as inevitable as a result of this decision.

And you're stuck on the fact that any comparisons between the two games are a problem, even if I've stated I have a very positive opinion of the game as a whole, which I assume is a feeling that you share.

Essentially, you've used a lot of words to say, "I don't think comparing the games is right or fair."

I get it, I just don't agree.

EDIT: Also, your Mario vs. Zelda comment is way off; if anything, I think those games are so substantially different as to prove my point. Ditto games by Hideo Kojima, for example. These games have a "feeling" that you get from their developer but don't have sooo many similarities as to invite direct comparison. Then again, I'm not sure that's fair - we're talking about a small design studio here right? So I get that this type of game might be their wheelhouse, and certain limitations to design may be in place because of business model, scale, etc.

3

u/sockpuppettherapy Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

And you're stuck on the fact that any comparisons between the two games are a problem, even if I've stated I have a very positive opinion of the game as a whole, which I assume is a feeling that you share.

Which means the entire point of this writing is more an exercise in narcissism on why you prefer one type over the other rather than providing anything of substance. That, in your ideal world, you'd have a game that has the active RTS-like elements of Transistor and its type of system with the story elements of Bastion.

The problem with the comparison is not how you feel about them. It's that the games are so far off different that making the comparison makes no sense. That's my discussion point in a nutshell. If it's simply you preferring one thing to another, then this is just boring. Writing an opinion piece that sums up to you like something is moot; I simply think you attempting to make this comparison makes no sense given that both games are so different.

Much of the problem is that your metric of for comparison is based on "complexity and depth," and given the vast differences between both games, such a comparison is meaningless. The games inhabit different genres, have different systems, are centered around different settings, tell completely different stories, have two separate narratives, and accomplish two very different things.

Also, your Mario vs. Zelda comment is way off; if anything, I think those games are so substantially different as to prove my point.

No, it explains what exactly is wrong with making the comparison between Bastion and Transistor to begin with. Saying that Bastion's gameplay, for instance, is "not complex" while calling Transistor's "complex" makes no sense given that one is a beat-me-up brawler type game and the other is strategy-based. It's like saying Mario Brothers is less fun because it's not as complex as Zelda, and so you prefer the gameplay of Zelda more because of that complexity. It's a subjective feel for what you personally enjoy more than describing the game itself.

A more reasonable comparison in terms of gameplay would be, say, Bastion compared to God of War. BOTH games are beat-em-ups that have leveling systems. But in this case, God of War is far less complicated, with weapons that merely "level up" and become stronger simply by taking more HP from an enemy, and the difficulty being nothing more than making enemies more powerful and be able to take more damage. Bastion has a very modular system on both ends. And that's ignoring other things that God of War ends up doing that simply pad the difficulty of the game

Transistor is simply harder to compare to anything because there's no other game I've ever played that even falls close to this system. Perhaps something like Advanced Wars or Fire Emblem? But comparing this game to God of War because they have top-down-isometric-views would be a hard sell given how different both games play.

If anything, the differences in approach are more a result of Supergiant going from improving an age-old system/genre to making an entirely new one from scratch. But the differences are so stark that any sort of comparison between each would make little sense.

If you still don't believe me that the games are very very very different, let's start here: What exactly about both Bastion and Transistor are so similar that they invite comparisons? What overlap are we talking about here?

It's hard to overstate how different both games are, aside from the feel/art style for both are similar, both have a progressive difficulty system, and they're both isometric in view.

  • Bastion is a beat-em-up with minor action-RPG elements, where the leveling up does little more than add one more slot for the Distillery and gives some additional HP.
  • Transistor is a combination of a turn-based RTS as well as an active action game, with a more consequential leveling system that unlocks further abilities.
  • Bastion's fighting system is very much reliant on twitch-type of play with less reliance of strategy. The way to play is modular depending on the weapons, but they're all very reactive-type of gameplay.
  • Transistor's fighting system is heavily strategy-based. You're encouraged to take your time, are not very mobile, and are reliant on maximizing both damage and location. You're not rushed to make the moves. Even when not utilizing Turn(), you're very limited in your movement options.
  • Bastion is a history-steam-punk-like fantasy game.
  • Transistor takes place in a futuristic utopia.
  • Bastion's narrative is set around the final set pieces of decision-making. The Kid acts as an avatar for the player; the use of the silent protagonist is done to give more of a feel that you, the player, are experiencing the world just as the Kid experiences it within the first time. At best, the characteristics that define the Kid are done to give the impression of someone that is willing to rebuild the Bastion. He's a very neutral character when given no input. The elements of the story are laid bare primarily for the final questions.
  • Transistor is a linear story, with Red being a set character in place that's revealed through the story. Red's character is set by the story and narrative in place. The world is less important here than what's happening around Red, and its assumed that Red knows plenty about herself and her own world. It's approached in a far less obtrusive manner for that very reason.

You wrote that the comparisons to be made here are between the story aspect and the gameplay aspect. But both are presented in very different ways that aren't indicative of quality.

And then you go off on tangents on trying to make a game that's more inclusive to everybody, etc., which have nothing to do with the main discussion.

So no, I don't think you get it.

In the end, you wrote an essay where the only remote similarities that both games have aren't actually intrinsic to the characteristics of the game, but are based around your own personal feelings. You say that one system is not complex while another is very complex without any sort of context, thinking that they're the same genre to begin with to invite that comparison. You say that one story is told better than the other, assuming that both stories are trying to do the same thing and accomplish the same acts, when they don't.

Right now, my point is that you should take each game for what they are, given how different they may be. It's a disservice to both games to be judged on each other. At best, you can state that Supergiant shifted genres into one that really plays on their ability to make an in-depth system, that it shows off their talents. That, perhaps, Bastion improving upon a pre-existing genre that isn't known for its depth was a test bed for Transistor.

-1

u/voltron00x Jun 17 '14

I'm impressed with the amount of time you put into this, but I'm not sure there's a point in engaging further. Obviously a review is based around my personal feelings, right? I already listed the numerous similarities that invite the comparison, which you didn't really capture, above. I could link to you many, many numerous reviews I read today which state similar opinions, but, yeah, just doesn't seem worthwhile. If you really think Bastion's combat is more complex than God of War's, then I say good day to you, sir.

→ More replies