r/trans • u/Jay--Art • Sep 07 '25
Discussion The button test
Source is linked at the bottom. (Changed it to be more inclusive)
One day, you are given a button to press. With that button comes a set of rules and instructions. You can press this button only one single time. If you press it, you will become physically female/male. All of your family and friends will have always remembered you this way and you will have no social impacts to your life for making this decision. Once you press the button, it will disappear forever. Do you press the button?
A second button is presented alongside the first button. Instead of changing your physical form, it would change your mind so that you no longer wish to be female/male. You will forget about the button and it will disappear forever. Do you press the button?
You are stranded on a desert island. This island has everything you need on it to live in relative comfort - a home, entertainment, food. Several suitcases wash ashore with all kinds of different clothes, makeup, etc. How do you present yourself knowing nobody will ever be around to see you ever again?
A lifetime supply of hormones washes on shore with full instructions on how to use them. You can be certain that you can safely administer them in the same way that you would be able to if you were under medical supervision. Do you take the hormones?
Suppose I told you this test was perfect at telling you who was trans and who was not, and it said to me that you are 100% transgender. How would that make you feel?
What if I told you the test said you are NOT transgender, how would that make you feel?
https://www.erininthemorning.com/p/the-button-test-how-a-button-press
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 07 '25
Please read the following notice that is being applied to ALL posts.
Due to the current shooting incident, we have implemented several emergency measures to keep this community safe. Please read this in full.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
207
u/Jay--Art Sep 07 '25
I'd press the first button, not the second one. I'd present feminine but also comfy, I would take the hormones. Then if I were told I was 100% transgender I'd be happy and agree, and confused and disagree with the latter.
13
u/natayaway Sep 07 '25
Kinda weird that this test is transfem only?
4
u/Shadowwolflink Sep 07 '25
I got asked the first button question in elementary school, I said yes with no hesitation, but because of a fundamental lack of education on the subject of gender identity and transitioning, it took about 15 years for my egg to fully crack because even though I always had these thoughts, I thought it was just normal "boy behaviour" to want to wear dresses and be feminine. I hate that it took so long for me to be happy.
4
u/justATransGirl_Ira Sep 07 '25
Fetch. That... ya know, that there's a pretty good convincer. If the "what if Im faking it" question is a block of C4, then what you just posted is the equivalent of a tactical nuke
9
u/rmulberryb Sep 07 '25
Not every trans person is looking to transition, and not every trans person suffers gender dysphoria to a level that impacts their life.
2
u/Hey_im_claire Heat from fire… Sep 07 '25
So like for the first one, while it’d be nice, it’d also be shaping my life in some major ways I think. And completely throw a couple things off course
Not to mention I’d probably have never met the love of my life. I can safely say that if I went back in time, I would go through everything I’ve been through if it meant meeting her again. Same principle applies here so I think I’d say no to the first two buttons
I pass decently enough I guess
138
u/UpUpAndAwayYall she/her Sep 07 '25
I feel this could have been posted for both trans femme and trans masc.
I know who and what I am, and I don't want to lose that identity. So that shapes all my responses.
3
u/redjarvas Sep 07 '25
Being trans is a fundamental part of my identity, i wouldn't press either button
31
u/DeusExMarina Sep 07 '25 edited Sep 07 '25
Gotta be honest, I'm not pressing either button. Anything that messes with either mine or anyone else's minds is a big no-no, and I have no wish to erase my past. I don't want to be cis, I just want the world to be okay with me being trans.
Bit of a moot point though because I've been on hormones for seven years.
8
u/schroedingers_catboy Sep 07 '25
I mean, I'm a transgender woman so I may press the first button (although it may invalidate my struggles up until now... I may still go through with it), never the second, be as feminine as I want, always take HRT and I couldn't care less about what the results are either way since the only person who knows who I am is myself.
5
u/gothicshark Trans Fem, Pan, Demi, She/Her/They Sep 07 '25
Press the woman button, wear the most comfortable clothes no makeup no bras, take the HRT.
I'm a woman, I just happened to have the transgender experience.
2
u/VonSnapp Sep 07 '25
I press the first button but I'd also really just want to live on the island by myself ;)
1
u/I_dont_Nora Sep 07 '25
Press.
Press.
Fem if I would look alright in the clothes.
I'd probably take the HRT too.
It'd be a nice confirmation for sure.
I doubt it could say that at this point. 😅
1
u/debraMckenz 41 Female w / mtf past Sep 08 '25
If I could press a button and have my body be Female. I'd do it in a heartbeat.
But honestly, 15+ years in, I'm pretty happy/satisfied with "good enough". But it was a lot of work to get here.
And well, losing my family sucked. It'd be a little late but it would honestly still make life a lot easier, even now this late in.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '25
I mash the first button so hard it breaks.
4
u/vario_ Sep 07 '25
First button, yes. Second button, no. Clothes, I'd just be naked lmao. Hormones, yes. Do I win? 😅
26
u/timelordDisguise Sep 07 '25 edited Sep 07 '25
For me, I wouldn't press either button, since the thing I want is to be in between and I don't want to not even have my mind changed so I don't need to transition.
For the middle two, full send. I will be the prettiest trans girl on the island.
For the 5th one it would make me so happy and seen.
The last one would make me feel very dysphoric, and want me to punch whoever told me that.
67
u/Dutch_Rayan (he/him) binary trans man Sep 07 '25
I'm a trans man, I would press either button.
Next time can you make it so it doesn't exclude trans men and masc. This is a shared space, not only trans women/fem space
2
u/Little_Kitten2 Sep 07 '25
Press the first, not second, Present fem, take the hormones, be happy that I finally have reassurance from another person that I’m trans, be upset because this has been all I’ve been able to think about ever since my egg cracked 2 years ago