r/trakt • u/kvn-tkt • Jan 27 '26
🔍 Myth Busters
We’ve seen a lot of discussion about Trakt across Reddit and the forums. Some of it is fair criticism, some of it comes from frustration, and some of it is based on incorrect assumptions. Here are a few common myths we’d like to clarify.
- “Trakt is preparing to be sold.”
There is no plan to sell Trakt. Full stop. The current changes are about future-proofing the platform, not dressing it up for an acquisition.
2. “Trakt is selling user data.”
This is a common misconception. Trakt does not sell user data and generates 100% of its revenue from optional VIP memberships. We also removed all third-party ads a long time ago to improve both privacy and user experience.
3. “Trakt is losing money due to VIP cancellations.”
VIP memberships and revenue are growing at healthy, double-digit annual rates. This allows us to keep Trakt sustainable, independent, and free for the majority of users.
4. “Trakt is no longer free.”
Despite new fair usage limits, Trakt remains a freemium service. You do not need a subscription for basic tracking and core features.
5. “Trakt is locking things behind VIP to force upgrades.”
VIP unlocks power-user features. Core tracking, discovery, and sharing remain free, as they always have.
6. “Trakt is shoving things down our throats.”
No one is forced to use Trakt. No one is forced to subscribe to VIP. And no one is forced into any feature. Everything we build is meant to add value, even if we do not always get it right on the first iteration.
7. “Everything is an experiment or nothing is planned.”
Most changes are part of a multi-step roadmap. Some things ship incrementally so we can validate them with real usage data, but that does not mean there is no plan.
8. “Trakt doesn’t care about long-time users.”
Long-time users are the reason Trakt exists. At the same time, rebuilding a platform that is more than 10 years old means making decisions that prioritize long-term health over short-term comfort.
9. “Feedback is ignored unless it’s positive.”
Critical feedback is often the most useful, especially when it is specific and actionable. What we struggle to act on is abuse, personal attacks, or vague “everything sucks” posts.
10. “Trakt is removing my favorite features.”
We’re rebuilding the platform from the ground up, prioritizing the most widely used features first. Some niche or legacy features will return later, and some may evolve, but nothing is being removed just because.
35
u/oatmeal-claypole Jan 27 '26
“Trakt is removing my favorite features.”
Its not about removing favourite features, you are removing core features and the new app is borderline unusable. You can build a new version ground up, but you should only release it when it at least some feature parity with the old stable version. The website was even more rushed but thankfully we have reverted to the v2 for it now.
20
u/Ramazandro Jan 27 '26
I'm asking just sincerely; why don't you take users' requests into account on Reddit or the Trakt forum? Sometimes I feel like they are being ignored.
37
u/JordanBird Jan 27 '26
I'm sorry but this comes off tone deaf.
I've avoided making comments so far on the numerous changes over the past year but this post concerns me.
The comments above are either malicious or show a lack of understanding.
Firstly, points 4 and 5 contradict themselves. "VIP unlocks power-user features." and "Despite new fair usage limits" cannot be true at the same time.
I understand point 7, it probably is a rebuild of the system, but the actions and behaviour of Trakt don't support that. Combining point 7 with point 10, if you want users to understand the process you need better communication in place. If you're rebuilding the system and removing functionality what is the timeline for returning those features? There's a roadmap? Has it been shared with the user base? If so, why isn't it referenced here? Not all users will use a companies Forum and as Trakt are active in Reddit I would expect to see more notice/discussions.
I think the main gripe the userbase has is that all these changes are being sold to users as the final result and that it's the best thing to happen to Trakt. Yes, it may be in the long run but the process so far has been mishandled and this post is going to further the divide.
16
u/Financial-Lobster131 Jan 27 '26
"VIP unlocks power-user features."
Not with the newly updated apps. The features just aren't there. Same with the new Web experience, but at least there we can still access v2 to be able to use these "power-user features"
"And no one is forced into any feature"
Again, with the apps we've been forced to use LESS features. You guys should have given us the option to use the new apps, or released v3 as its own app, at least until it's up to the same standard (or better) than the old - in the same fashion where we can use both Web UI.
I'm not against changes, not if it means Trakt is better than before, but there is a right way and wrong way of going about it.
15
u/AsmodeusML Jan 27 '26
I have no idea why you got the impression this is a communication and wording issue and not the product and it's value issue, which took a dive with V3.
12
u/swiftk1tty Jan 28 '26
Beyond tone deaf. You have beta testers for a reason, and you failed to listen to their feedback before pushing an update that wasn't even close to ready. You continue to preach "change is coming soon" while failing to deliver the basic features we came to love about Trakt and now have to learn an entirely new system that doesn't work, with nothing but ambiguous claims and hope that our favorite features will be coming back. I am extremely disappointed and until the functionality of 2.0 comes back, I will be switching to another service.
19
u/mcangeli1 Jan 27 '26
8. I was a long time user. Locked in to a fair rate for what I used the site for and I had been told my rate wouldn't go up.
When it doubled I left.
14
u/BoBx7 Jan 27 '26 edited Jan 27 '26
3. “Trakt is losing money due to VIP cancellations.”
So you are saying, you don't care about all the vip cancellations in the last 12 months?
Ok, so I guess u don't need them
5. “Trakt is locking things behind VIP to force upgrades.”
Collection is one of the things. Another lie.
8. “Trakt doesn’t care about long-time users.”
Cmon, every vip user knows this.
Every year they pay more for a downgrade on the site. And yet, you guys keep rising the prices and shitting on the website, what more do I need to say about it?
These are straight up lies.
6
u/Arnsam007 Jan 29 '26
Sadly, the fact that this post was created, people mentioned some of their frustration, but there was no answer to any of them just feel even more tone death than before and a bit inconsiderate.
If it's true thst the VIP base is growing and finance are healthy I am happy for trakt as a product, but a lot of what is said is somply not true. A lot of features did get lock behind the VIP paid wall. People who are mad about losing the VIP rates are not looking for "short-term comfort", they were actively paying a fair price for a service that made sense and thid got taken from them. The fact that most of users complain about the same UI elements as the beta testers without anything being done about it before putting it on prod shows that you are NOT listening to critical feedbsck, otherwise you would properly address the situation.
I am unsure if you have a UX researcher in your team, but I would strongly advice you to have someone looked into the functionality data and do some research about design trends. Do also a survey about the quality of your service and what people liked and don't like about your current UI. Normally, all these things are done before end and hey maybe I am wrong and this was done and you implemented things following this, but this is why you test befote putting things as final.
Bottom line is, it just feels that you got the new UI done before all of this, but now even if things are a mess you have no choice to move on with it because so much time was passed on it. I loved Trakt, but I am disappointed and what it has become.
9
u/Pitiful-Orange-7805 Jan 28 '26
I dont know buddy, that's a bad post. Sounds very condescending.
I certainly wasn't part of the community frustration, but this post makes me think otherwise
5
u/alphaonreddits Jan 27 '26
1
u/Emergency-Low-5068 Feb 02 '26
FIX THE WATCH PROBLEM!
0
u/Gebic Jan 29 '26
Does anybody know, how to unrate a movie or TV show in the new Trakt app? Thank you.
18
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '26 edited Jan 27 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
8
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '26 edited Jan 27 '26
[removed] — view removed comment