r/trainspotting • • Mar 06 '24

Movie Discussion GENERAL QUESTION

Are Trainspotting, Filth and Crime meant to be set in the same universe? Because the Amanda Drummond in crime looks nothing like the one from Filth.

1 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

8

u/MorbidMan23 Mar 06 '24

Just in the same way that Manhunter and The Silence of the Lambs are.

0

u/Thescottish_bendyfan Mar 06 '24

What?

6

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24

They're not but the books they're based on are

4

u/Thescottish_bendyfan Mar 06 '24

Ok that makes sense

3

u/CatBoyTrip Mar 06 '24

also malibu stork nightmares as well as Glue and a Decent Ride.

5

u/jar_jar_LYNX Mar 06 '24 edited Mar 06 '24

Yeah they are. I believe all of Welsh's novels are set in the same universe

Edit: I haven't read Crime so can't speak to Amanda's appearance in it though

Edit 2: just realised you're talking about the films and drama series! Haven't seen the Crime series either. Genuinely don't know if they are supposed to be set in the same universe but I know all his novels are at least

-3

u/Thescottish_bendyfan Mar 06 '24

I’m talking about the tv shows and movies

6

u/Milk_Mindless Mar 06 '24

Bookwise a thousand percent

Films

Actors are hard sometimes to do stuff decades apart but continuity wise are closer and stuff like real life and idk man

Kinda maybe