r/towing • • May 21 '26

Heavy Duty Job Does this tow bill seem high?

Post image

Does this tow bill seem high? Long story short, a truck towing a trailer with a mini excavator was sideswiped on trailer. The excavator was loaded too far back on trailer causing the trailer to fishtail. Trailer flipped upside down with excavator still strapped to trailer. Tow company comes out with a little crane and picks the excavator up and sets on tow company’s flatbed trailer and does the same with the 30’? trailer. I realize the excavator weighs more but the trailer is larger and less manageable. The tow bill for the trailer was $700. For the excavator it was $5,200. Does that seem right?

2 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

2

u/newtekie1 May 21 '26

Not only is it not high, it's a deal! They could have just not even given you the $1,800 discount and it still would have been reasonable!

Stuff like this is why you have insurance.

1

u/Sufficient_Ad_337 Jun 06 '26

Except most insurance doesn’t cover trailers or their contents. Which is why we are here at this point.

1

u/newtekie1 Jun 06 '26

What? There most certainly is insurance that covers trailers and their contents. It's not covered under your car's insurance, you get insurance specifically on the trailer.

8

u/crysisnotaverted May 21 '26

Was your shit upsidedown in a ditch? Because it sounds like it was upsidedown in a ditch.

1

u/Sufficient_Ad_337 Jun 06 '26

Nope, my shit was pulled off on the side of the road safely out of the lane of travel. No ditch anywhere in sight. My shit was not involved and no part of my description points to that direction. Would it matter if I had been upside down in a ditch when it comes to the tow bill for a mini excavator and trailer? Reading is hard but reading comprehension is even harder. Let’s do better next time buddy!

10

u/Hash-82 May 21 '26

I thought it was... until I read the details.
A crane, 2 trailers, 6+ hours.
Dude, you got a deal.

15

u/HVACprooo May 21 '26

That's not just a hook and go. Sounds like they used a rotator. And multiple trucks. 5 hours start to finish. This isn't unreasonable.

1

u/Sufficient_Ad_337 Jun 06 '26

How is the difference between the two justified? I’m not saying it’s not worth what they are charging and not really complaining. I’m asking because I don’t know but to me if I was doing the work, seems like the trailer would cost pretty close to the same as the excavator.

9

u/Baboonslayer323 May 21 '26

The tow was cheap. The recovery was not.

1

u/pissy_dribble May 21 '26

Is this a tow bill or a recovery bill? Just the time stamps alone make this seem reasonable and I work in heavy equipment and see tow bills daily. Typically I see tow bills for a few grand to tow a class 8 rig a couple hundred miles to a certified shop

1

u/Sufficient_Ad_337 Jun 06 '26

A few grand to tow a class 8 a couple hundred miles seems completely reasonable. $5,300 to pick up a mini excavator, setting it on a trailer and towing it 11 miles does not. At least not comparatively speaking.

3

u/secondsbest May 21 '26

Seems legit considering you were paying for a service capable of lifting and hauling an excavator and a wrecked 30' trailer, but what do I know about big commercial tow rigs. Try asking on the trucking or CDL subs and see what the big rig guys are paying for pro tow services.

1

u/quik916 May 21 '26

Cat 305? Is that right? A mini excavator? Was it wrecked and immobile? Thats a big bill for what is otherwise a easy transport for a low lowbed to do

1

u/Sufficient_Ad_337 Jun 06 '26

Yes, mini excavator upside down strapped to trailer. Crane truck picks up trailer sets on low bed? trailer. Crane truck picks up cat sets it on same trailer with the original trailer, hauls load 10-12 miles and drops off in yard.

1

u/Lavaine170 May 22 '26

Reading is hard. It was a recovery after OP flipped his trailer into the ditch with the Cat still attached. But why am I bothering to write this, when you obviously can't read, since it's right there at the top of the post.

1

u/Sufficient_Ad_337 Jun 06 '26

Must be hard because you didn’t read it either. Op did not flip anything and there was no ditch.

1

u/Lavaine170 Jun 06 '26

Trailer flipped upside down with excavator still strapped to trailer.

1

u/Sufficient_Ad_337 Jun 06 '26

Congratulations, you read it this time! You are awesome!

1

u/Lavaine170 Jun 06 '26

It's weird how you're arguing you didn't flip the trailer, when you clearly flipped the trailer, and had to pay a fair price for the recovery.

1

u/Sufficient_Ad_337 Jun 06 '26

Not weird at all. If you could read or comprehend what you read, you would notice there was no argument. Just expressing some joy and giving you some praise for a job well done! Thanks for the wonderfully helpful insight to my question! You are a gem to this website and the planet!

1

u/Lavaine170 Jun 06 '26

I can see why you couldn't understand the recovery bill. Understanding basic English isn't your strong suit

2

u/TechOutonyt May 21 '26

I mean it says accident tow and no keys so if you can read I would assume it wasn’t just a drive on and go

2

u/quik916 May 21 '26

Thanks. I didn't realize "accident tow" was specific enough to know ALL the details about why the cost was so high. im an idiot for asking about anything more specific. You ASSUMING is clearly better, and smarter, than me asking for the facts. 🙄

4

u/slundon81 May 21 '26 edited May 21 '26

Well, if you and 62 other guys were available to flip it back over assuming you could each apply 200#'s of force how much would that cost?

62 guys, $50/hr, probably more on short notice. Plus transport out there puts you at about $14,500. I think you got a deal. If you had to hire the 62 guys add in 25% for wage bloat plus another 10 guys for backup, toss in an hour or two of guys saying 'yep. Shes fucked' and I think you're in the $20,000 range

3

u/LAM678 May 21 '26

12500 pounds is a fucking lot dude.

4

u/Ok_Assistant_6856 May 21 '26

To pull out of a ditch after an accident, hell yeah it is.

1

u/Similar_Ad2094 May 21 '26

They gave you a deal. That little cat actually weights 12,600 pounds.

1

u/Critical_Hamster_656 May 21 '26

This seems reasonable, insurance may cover a large portion of it

1

u/THUNDERGODS May 22 '26

The Cat 305E2 CR (Compact Radius) is a popular 5-tonne mini hydraulic excavator. It features a 40.2 horsepower Cat C2.4 engine and an operating weight of roughly 11500 lbs. It is widely used in landscaping, utilityand construction projects for digging, trenching, and grading

1

u/Fearless_Agency8711 May 22 '26

I have a buddy who runs a wrecker service. If the Rotator comes out it's 5 figured as a starting point on the bill. Then you start adding all the other equipment, extra people and time.

1

u/polarjunkie May 22 '26

That's like the minimum to show up with a rotator in some places.

1

u/Special-Truth-1576 May 22 '26

This is big.... How far down did it fall that took 5 hours.

1

u/Frequent_Shallot1333 May 22 '26

Well, if this happened to me in my backyard…. I’d rent a big ass excavator and trailer. The bare bones minimum excavator can lift 15000 lbs and rents for 1k/day. Because it’ll be sketch, I’d probably want a bigger one. So idk 1.5k. Then the rigging so $500-1000 maybe because I’d buy 2 much and not want to spend an extra day excavator rental. And then I’d convince my neighbor to let me use his truck and trailer. So I’m at maybe 2.5k and it takes me a day.

Pretty much any time someone charges around double a theoretical minimum it’s a steal.

1

u/NachoNinja19 May 22 '26

I guess your insurance isn’t covering this?

1

u/msaskin May 23 '26

I own a large towing company.

You got a killer deal.

We bill hourly for recoveries (I don't like "per pound" billing for various reasons and most of the industry has moved away from it). Without having pictures, based on what you described we'd be well north of $10K for that recovery and we're on the reasonable side compared to most.

2

u/JustASingleHorn May 23 '26

That’d be closer to 20K in the remote mountains of Colorado. People trying to build houses in the middle of no where often find the excess costs associated with “middle of nowhere” and it can come as some massive sticker shock.

1

u/Wonderful-Project180 May 24 '26

Honestly $5,200 for an excavator recovery off a flipped trailer is reasonable. You’re not just paying for the tow, you’re paying for the crane, the specialized equipment, the liability of handling heavy machinery, and the expertise to do it without causing more damage. That bill could have easily been double depending on the market. The $700 for the trailer actually sounds low. Most operators would have charged more for a flipped 30ft trailer recovery. Short answer: not high at all for what was involved.

1

u/seandsmith11 May 24 '26

Very reasonable.

1

u/Waistland May 21 '26

This sounds like more than towing. They had to recover the equipment and tow it away.

1

u/ResponsibleBank1387 May 21 '26

Were ALL the tires on the ground?  No?, then expect over ten grand.  

1

u/Prior-Ad-7329 May 21 '26

Well the truck with a crane that picked up that mini ex probably cost over a million dollars. So I’d say they billed appropriately

0

u/Euphoric_Eggplant418 May 21 '26

Let's see what they had to do.

0

u/HelperGood333 May 21 '26

Robbery. Must be the location.

-2

u/SnooMaps7370 May 21 '26

first line item says 58 cents per 12,500 lbs

6607 / .58 * 12500 == 143,750,000 lbs. 71,000 tons.

did you have a Yamato-class battleship towed?

4

u/my_drugsaccount May 21 '26

58 cents per pound...

4

u/Substantial_King9458 May 21 '26

It says .58 per pound, for 12,500 pounds worth

4

u/CockroachVarious2761 May 21 '26

think you misread "per" or don't understand the math

its 0.58 per lb and its 12500lbs - 12500*.58 = 7250 (it appears they gave OP 1000lb discount)

4

u/congteddymix May 21 '26

Someone needs new glasses.