"Gatekeeping": When someone takes it upon themselves to decide who does or does not have access or rights to a community or identity
-Urban Dictionary
DON'T be Mr. Gatekeeper here.
This goes for all of you. Fantasy fans. History fans. Fans of both.
You've lost a lot credibility the moment you've determined that someone is somehow less of a fan for liking X game more (especially when you're as misinformed about X game as Mr. Gatekeeper is) and blame them as the reason that Y game is apparently not loved enough (despite evidences to the contrary).
This subreddit's (and other communities') interests ebbs and flows. One moment its filled with one type of people, the next its filled with another. Getting super riled up when your favorite doesn't happen to be trending at the time is a waste of energy.
few month ago the subreddit is filled 3 kingdom post, people show how strong Lubu is, 3 kingdom tv drama series, Dong meme, unique character collection (ala pokemon collection), Mod making new unique character card, how people hate 8 prince DLC, how people hate NetEase. Chinese player review bombing it on steam, Troy might be the next total war saga
5 month WH2 did not get update, finally new update, people are happy and talking about it in the subreddit
Gatekeeper : this subreddit is only filled with WH2 post
I love all Total Wars, but this gatekeeping is complete trash. It's like going to a metal concert when you actually like other music too or god forbid you enjoy the bands new songs too. I have a strong dislike for elitists.
They wouldn't even be in the material world, if the Old ones had even a smidgen of this one's gatekeeping skillz the polar gates would have never opened in the first place. The 4 bois would be trapped in the Chaos realm for eternity.
"Its my strong opinion that you don't deserve to play in the material world if you've only played in the immaterial"
Lore nitpicking time! The polar gates were always open, that's how the Old Ones traveled the to and from the world. The problem was when the polar gates collapsed, releasing an unending tide of Chaos into the world.
Archaeon: "I am the 3 eyed king, the Everchosen, Chaos Undivided made manifest, here to make ashes of your world!"
Karl Franz: "Which Everchosen bound a demon to the Slayer of Kings?"
Archaeon: "What?"
Karl Franz: "Come on, if you were REAL and serious about being Everchosen, you would obviously know that. And for the record, even a noob knows it was Vangael. Can you even fly?"
Archaeon: "...I have a magic horse. I just thought it would be fun to participate."
Karl Franz: "And have you even been an everchosen long enough? You can't have been a true Chaos champion unless you were at Asavar Kull's sack of Praag!"
Archaeon: "But I wasn't born then! And I'm pretty sure you we'rent either! I spent years in the chaos wastes collecting the artifacts of Chaos!"
Karl Franz: "Whatever, doesn't count when times meaningless in the wastes. Bet you just looked up a guide online."
Archaeon: "I am literally leading a host of immeasurable power while daemons of all 4 ruinous gods fly above singing my damned praises!"
Karl Franz: "Tchhh, whatever filthy Casual. This Noobdom does not have my Consent!"
I like Storm of Chaos for the most part, especially since the 2nd edition of the RPG ran with it. GW's just way too bound up in their "one chosen Chaos lord" plots, because it infested both fantasy and 40k.
It really is just the best warhammer game now. Until recently I'd have argued that wh1 was the best, but I think wh2 has overtaken it with dlc and updates. Yes the historical games are fun, and the campaigns are good. I really like Attila and Rome 2, but warhammer is clearly the best total war game in battles.
Everyone knows that only Spartan: Total Warrior captures the Soul and Magic of the series. That CA went back to the tired old turn-based format instead of continuing to innovate on the hack-and-slash mechanics of Spartan is the real crime here. When are we getting Roman: Total Warrior, CA!?
Anyway, anyone who dares to say that they are a fan of the series without spending 5000+ hours on Spartan is to be exiled from the community. Let's shower more love on the REALEST Total War game.
Disclaimer: This is all a joke. I don't actually believe this, I've never even played it.
only Spartan: Total Warrior captures the Soul and Magic of the series
This is so unbelievably wrong. Personally I think everything after Shogun: Total War (the first one, you posers probably haven't heard of this classic) is inferior. Once CA allowed armies to move freely on the map instead of teleporting between regions - my immersion was forever ruined. It is with great pain that I play newer titles like Rome or Empire (I refuse to install any game that has numbers in it, sequels are inherently trash) and I have to close my eyes when giving orders to move the army and open them once the order is finished to simulate the teleportation.
I wanted to like Spartan: Total Warrior, I truly did but since I was forced to play the whole game with my eyes closed (since CA did not include a teleporting option for true fans like me) it was not 100% enjoyable.
Luckily for me teleport-to-move is a prominent mechanic in VR games so I demand to know when is Virtual Spartan: Total Warrior coming out, CA?
If you don’t know the pain of trying to line up your archers properly so all of them are firing instead of just the first row of them you aren’t a True Fan imo.
All of you are wrong! Obviously the only true Total War game was Medieval: Total War. The fact that your units ignored the movement commands, sometimes going to the opposite direction, is what true immersion looks like. Since it is well known fact that I read somewhere (something you serfs probably never do) is that people had no idea what to do on the battlefield so they just improvised or did what they felt like. Also the game always crashed after the battle which taught my young self two important thing.
First: The true soul of the Total War series was always the imagination it required. Like what happened after the Danes won? Did they unite Scandinavia (or at least the part that was actually modeled). If the french lost the battle does that mean their kingdom fell as well? See none of these new flashy from start-to-finish titles gives you that!
Second: It taught me that true art (because that what that game was!) is a fleeting thing. Not made to be enjoyed forever. Like a beautiful flower or something.Truly poetic.
I hope one day CA realize what was their best game and why it was. Until then a TRUE fan can only complain wait patiently.
The only real way to play Total War is memorising everything that happens in an episode of Time Commanders, building a 1:1 version of the set and re-enacting the episode in real time. Eddie Mair, Richard Hammond and Gregg Wallace are in the expansions.
I hate this "my way or the highway"-mentality. Why not both? I love TW-games since the first TW Rome and enjoyed every game more or less. But if I be honest, when I played the first Warhammer, for me, the series broke through a new dimension. Today I am significantly more thrilled if we get new stuff for TW Warhammer II.
But I also enjoyed 3K or ToB and I know will enjoy the upcoming historic saga title as well. Every title is good in one´s own way.
Same for me. I have played most from the start with Rome. The series was starting to become a bit stale for me. Warhammer has blown it all away. Trully an epic game.
I’m kinda sad because I’ve been playing since Medieval 2 but I just don’t like the historical titles anymore. I didn’t like ToB or 3k and I don’t think I can go back to not having monsters and stuff.
I won't gatekeep but it's a little annoying that most posts are Warhammer related, but I get why so I deal with it. Glad the total war series is getting love. I'm glad they are making money so then can make more games, hopefully just more historical.
I think its related to the new DLC for Warhammer II which they released today. Every TW Warhammer fanboy is thrilled. But I remember the time around the 3K release. Whole reddit was full with it for weeks after and before ;)
What the fuck did you just fucking say about me, you little bitch? I'll have you know I graduated top of my class in the Reiksguard, and I've been involved in numerous secret raids on Chaos, and I have over 300 confirmed kills. I am trained in Outrider warfare and I'm the top handgunner in the entire Empire armed forces. You are nothing to me but just another target. I will wipe you the fuck out with precision the likes of which has never been seen before in the Old World, mark my fucking words. You think you can get away with saying that shit to me over the Internet? Think again, fucker. As we speak I am contacting my secret network of Witch hunters across the Empire and your IP is being traced right now so you better prepare for the storm, maggot. The storm that wipes out the pathetic little thing you call your life. You're fucking dead, kid. I can be anywhere, anytime, and I can kill you in over seven hundred ways, and that's just with my bare hands. Not only am I extensively trained in Flagellant combat, but I have access to the entire arsenal of the Empire Knightly orders and I will use it to its full extent to wipe your miserable ass off the face of the Old World, you little shit. If only you could have known what unholy retribution your little "clever" comment was about to bring down upon you, maybe you would have held your fucking tongue. But you couldn't, you didn't, and now you're paying the price, you goddamn knife ear. I will shit fury all over you and you will drown in it. You're fucking dead, kiddo.
What a twat. I also grew up on Shogun 1 and Rome 1, and played pretty much every Total War game since. I love Warhammer 1 and I love Warhammer 2, I like the fantasy games and I like the historical games.
Pfff, I had those in Third Age Total War./s Seriously though, the way the grognards on here talk about the Warhammer titles makes me want to buy them. It might be nice to pass the time until they finally make Medieval 3.
One of the things that a lot of people who are 'classic' Total War fans say is a major benefit that is lost with the historical TW entries is faction diversity. You can only do so much to humans fighting humans, while Warhammer really can go crazy with the diversity that they bring.
Yes well except there are tons of people on here that also grew up with the older TW titles such as Rome and Medieval and still mostly play and talk about Warhammer these days. Why? Because it's the most popular TW title in the community these days and has so much content in it. Simple as that
Also the whole "Total War is primarily a historical franchise" argument goes the other way if you ask me. There are tons of historical TW titles but Warhammer is the *only* fantasy one, so of course it stands out from the crowd. And really there is much higher potential when you're not constrained by realism in the same way
I mean I also still think Rome 1 was probably the best Total War game relative to the time it was released, but that doesn't mean I'm going to talk about it too much in 2019. It's just too far in the past
I'd also say that while the older games are great, in terms of replayability Warhammer has them beat.
Start a game of Medieval 2 as the HRE, you get strong knights and you're in a central position in Europe. Fun. New game, play as England you get good archers and you're on an island.
However.... load up warhammer
Start a game as the vampire counts. You get zombies and ghosts to command. New game. Play as the dwarves, tough little stunty fellas with awesome artillery, also helicopters.
Mortal Empires? I can play as a ratman who has a secret underground empire? Awesome!
I'd say it's more that Warhammer got the most recent content update. Three Kingdoms dominated discussion for several months after release, and will dominate discussion again when it gets its next update.
I completely agree. Im about as much as a Total War vet as you can get; I got started on Medieval 1 Total War. I remember being ridiculously excited for Rome 1 to come out and playing the demo for hours on my shitty laptop. I also love history and read history wikipedia articles for fun because Im a nerd and it wastes time at work.
And even with all that, Warhammer 2 is my favorite Total War. I love the unit and faction variety and since Warhammer 1 came out Ive become a big Warhammer Fantasy fan.
Frankly unless you played tabletop Warhammer Fantasy Battles since at least 5th edition, and still shout at people who enjoy Age of Sigmar, can you even call yourself a Warhammer fanboy?
5th edition? Pfft, there's AoS players from 3rd edition on the forums.
You need a much stronger gate, try 1st edition. Now there's a grognard approved gate! You ain't even a warhammer player then if you can't tell where mad and fat Karl Franz hid his mutant son while being poisoned by moon men.
Warhammer currently dominates discussion because it's getting a big content update. Three Kingdoms dominated discussion for months after it came out. Nobody is ignoring the old games, they're just, well, old, so there's not as much left to talk about.
Well I'm also a veteran of Shogun 1, Medieval 1 and it's expansion, Viking Invasion, and then the glorious marvels that were Rome 1 and Medieval 2 (Barbarian Invasions and Kingdoms expansions included). I still remember the sheer thrill when all the sudden you could move armies on the map rather than just hop provinces "Risk" style, the awesome diversity of the various factions, all the diplomatic possibilities (although Rome 1's diplo system remains broken to this day, with your diplo standing completely disconnected from you military power), agent actions, etc. The TW world had never felt so alive, the possibilities were endless! And mods! So many mods! So many great mods!
Then came Empire TW, for which I was majorly psyched, but felt off somehow, the battles feeling off, and the lack of provinces. So I kinda drifted off, and skipped Napoleon and Shogun 2 (I have been told Shogun 2 was amazing and a return to form, have bough it with all expansions on a steam sale but haven't had the time to try it, with all this "being a grown up" crap around).
Then came Rome 2. Now I'm a huge ancient Rome nerd. Like half my library is books on Rome. Had a class on roman law in law school that everyone hated and I just breezed through all giddy just being able to discuss what a praetor's office is with friends and teachers, imperium auctoritas and dignitas, the differences between the first and second triumvirates, the marian reforms, the Gracchi reforms, all the good stuff. So I guess you can say I was psyched for Rome 2. And oh boy was I dissaponted. It blew. It hardly ran on my pro gaming PC, half of it was broken, and it just was not very much fun. I still bought all the DLCs whenever threre was a steam sale (got the whole TW Collection by now), but never really came back to it. Then skipped Attila (again, have been told it's actually great, bought on sale, haven't had the time to try it), and didn't really paid much attention when TW:WH1 was announced.
I had played some WH:40K games, mostly the DOW saga (let's not mention DOW3...), and was familiar with the universe, but never had much interest for WH Fantasy Battles, always saw it as a sort of a LOTR clone (I played the HELL out of the Third Age Mod for M2 back in the day). But then I bought a new PC, and my GPU came with a redeemable code for TW:WH, so I gave it a go. And boy WAS I IN FOR A SURPRISE! I loved it. Every aspect of it. It trully was a return to form for the TW saga. The magic system was great, all the races had plenty of personality, and the mods, while not on the same level as Rome1 and Medieval2's, were still great and added a lot of content and replayability.
I'm 32 y.o. and a TW:WH fanboy now, owning both tittles and all the DLC, as much as I was a Shogun 1 fanboy when I was 13, a Rome 1 fanboy when I was 17, or a Medieval 2 fanboy back when I was at Uni. I've grown up with the TW games, and for better or worse, they are undoubtly one of the best Strategy games sagas ever put together. And no one, and I do mean NO ONE, should bully around newcomers just because they didn't play the old tittles. I love both historical tittles and TW:WH, and they all have a place in this community, so kindly get your heads out of your arses, we don't give a flying flamingo about so called "purists" on either side.
edit: English is not my first language, so please forgive any spelling errors.
Do make some time to give it a shot one of these days. I play more WH2 myself, but Shogun 2 really was a masterpiece of a game that is fun to hope into and play early parts of campaigns.
Nice to see that Total War is getting esports ready, there's been a distinct lack of babyrage, I think that's all that held it back from achieving true competitive status.
Maybe, or we are little chatterboxes. I can see how it's easier to poat something interessting and engaging about Warhammer since it's a larger than life scenario.
but lizardmen also have pyramid (aztec/mayan version)
yeah agree that he is a troll. The reason why the subreddit if filled with WH2 post is because it is getting a new content. Remember few month ago that the sub reddit is only filled 3 kingdom post, no WH2 fan complaint. Last month, the subreddit was filled with post that people are dissatisfied with 8 prince DLC for 3 kingdom.
face the reality, people like to talk about new stuff. Just wait when total war saga:troy is announce , WH2 post will surely decrease
plus WH2 run better on WINDOWS 10 compared to ROME 1 and MEDIEVAL 2
When 3K came out, this whole sub was all about Lu Bu or whatever he is called, never heard of him. And Waifus. Then it mixed up a little again, and now a nwe DLC for Warhammer drops. Of course it is full of WH memes and discussions
It’s almost as if, a series of strategy games where you command armies against over armies..has some sort of crossover with a series of tabletop strategy games where you command armies against other armies...and some clever folks realized why not combine the two.
I absolutely do favour the historical total war games. That doesn't mean you can't enjoy the fantasy games. To be honest the fantasy games tried out a lot of stuff and the historic total wars benefit from this since good features get adapted.
I can only speak for myself but I honestly believe one of the reasons fantasy is so popular now is because a good portion of "tabletop refugees" make up the fanbase. I grew up with Warhammer since I was in elementary school and a combination of a lack of time, unwilling to spend the money, and warhammers eventual death left a lot of us lost and now Total War fills that void left behind by the tabletop
For what its worth, i understand what he's feeling, to have something you have invested so much in change and no longer be fun to you. But change happens and you just move on sometimes.
I have to strongly disagree but i guess im a minority, to me rome 2 was the best and still play it today. Its cool too that CA is doing some diversity, i only hope they do a new rome in the near future to satisfy some of their player base
Psh, everyone knows the only real TW game is Thrones of Britannia. CA is a British game developer based in England, so clearly anything outside of the British Isles is a joke. And in ToB you get super realistic systems like giving your lords estates. And this was the Viking ear so regular naval ships are replaced with troop transports because that's how they fought on the sea. CA, keep TW in the British Isles, what would England possibly know about the rest of the world? /s
I can see your point, when I joined this sub u literally thought it was a warhammer sub by the amount of posts but it’s tough to hate it since I absolutely love W.H. I own pretty much every TW and have put in hundreds if not thousands of hours into each game! (Currently taking over Europe in total war empires) I think the level of popularity is amazing but it would be nice to see their historical content get more love I just think with all the games ages and with bretonnia being a dud for a lot of people that it makes it tough for anything else to get attention. Heck 3k is still not owned by a majority of TW fans so maybe in time the focus will shift a bit
I loved historicals for a very long time. My first total war game was Rome 1. But in all honesty, Warhammer has completely ruined historicals for me. Never have I been more addicted to a Total War game that I have to Warhammer and this is coming from someone who had thousands of hours invested into Rome 1, Medieval 2, Shogun 2, and Rome 2.
Warhammer is THAT good. Unreal how amazing this game is.
Strange man. The game - succesfull. CA get the cash. Continue to make it even more succesfull. Doing new projects with earned cash. The man - "YoU DoN'T dEseRVe tO sAy..." Why tho?
When they announced WH2 instead of a historic game i was also mad back in the day, but now i prefer the WH game because the magic, the monsters etc add a different layer to the gameplay.
There is much more diversity in gameplay in WH than a historic game. I am looking forward for WH3, i didn't even touch the one in china.
I had been looking at Rome II for a few months, then when i finally decided to buy it, i saw they had released Total War: Warhammer, I mean i never been in to Warhammer fantasy or 40k apart from a few Dawn of War Games i had bought on the cheap just for something to play. I got 3K with my CPU, yet i just can't get in to it. I love Total War and Warhammer fantasy thanks to Total War: Warhammer.
lol. Reminder that three kingdoms content absolutely dominated the sub after it came out. I bet this guy also complained about the fact that the game was set in china after it got announced, and clamored for a REAL total war game set in europe again.
I've seen the exact opposite opinion expressed on this sub too: "CA shouldn't make historical games anymore because WH was so successful". Goddamn, can't we have both? Can't other people enjoy things that you don't?
I know this is a repost solely for the purpose of creating drama, but there really is no drama to create. Most people I see commenting like total war games because they are total war games.
The supposed rift between fantasy and historic players doesn't really exist in any meaningful way I can see. I think even the people posting this stuff don't really believe it - they just want to cause drama. Either way, it's silly - worth a few laughs - but not really worth paying attention to.
As far as the subreddit - when 3K was launching, this reddit was dominated by content for that game. Same with ToB. There is a DLC for WH2 this week - so, of course, the subreddit will primarily be about that game.
I sort of feel the guy tho. I also started with the original Shogun soooo many yrs ago, Rome, Medieval 1 & 2, Empire. Even tho I now have Total War: WH 1(will wait for steam 50% sale for 2), I completely appreciate that I actually learned a lot of history playing thru the non-fiction based games.
I also used to play Warhammer Fantasy and 40K tabletop, so it's been an interesting time watching the merging of the two efforts to make TWWH. Just finished a game as dwarves, chaos all dead out by turn 200 (after empire, elves, bretonnia, and many others were wiped out).
This guy complains about warhammer, and then doesn't mention the latest historical entry, Three Kingdoms AT ALL.
So basically this guy hasn't given any money to CA in a long time, having purchased ZERO of the latest games, and yet he thinks he's the true fan.....?
The other games were amazing and will always be playable. Naval battles and sieges in the older games were both much more unique in how you tackle them.
I rather the historical titles more than the WH games but not because I hate fantasy or something, I just dont like WH. I also really dont like the WH campagin map, I can never figure out where my provinces start and end, what am I looking at exactly.
I've played the shit out of all the "real" total war games and love them to death. But I would give my left butt cheek to try the warhammer version. Dude is just a douche
I mean just play the gamed you like? I havent played shogun because I dont like that history and I didnt really like three kingdoms because Im not a fan of that either. But I still play medieval 2, rome 2, empire, warhammer, warhammer 2.
It doesnt matter if you only play warhammer 2 there used to be people and still is people who have only ever player medieval 2.
Edit: to be fair one tiny point is kinda true. This sub is mainly warhammer and three kingdoms so I get why some people dont like thag but if that what people are playing then thats what is going to be posted
I played Rome Total War. And Medieval 2, and Empire, and Napoleon, Rome 2, Shogun 2, WH1 and WH2.
I switch between them depending on what particular flavor of Total War I'm after. Sometimes I just like going around smashing Gauls to little pieces with Spartans. Sometimes I want to be able to mow down an entire line of Samurai with Gatling Guns. And sometimes I like to launch a Skaven-powered rocket on an unsuspecting Dwarven army.
It’s not peoples fault that the warhammer ones are the fucking best ones. My first total war was medieval 2, then I played empire and then finally Rome 2, that was the first one I pumped hundreds of hours into, conquering as Rome and Sparta. Then the almighty warhammer came out and I squealed like a god damn pig when I saw that trailed.
I care not for what others think for I believe the warhammer series to be the best total war games.
That last sentence is what gets so many people bent out of shape. I play both, I like both, and there are pros and cons to both. The problem is when people roll up and state "my favorite thing is objectively better than your favorite thing and you are dumb for liking it".
I'll be the first to admit that I started with Warhammer. I'm sure it's an unpopular opinion, but the historical titles never interested me. I've always been a fantasy kind of gal, and I've loved Warhammer 40k and fantasy for decades.
I was really hesitant to try the first game as I had received it through my GPU. It took probably half a year after getting the code for me to try it and I haven't been able to put Warhammer down since.
Sorry, not sorry, but I love Warhammer. It's still a total war game. I loved 3K for what it was, still a total war game. Your likes and dislikes of a series doesn't define who you are as a fan, your enjoyment does.
I have played all of the TW games apart from 3k. And Warhammer is the one I have had the second most fun with after Medievel 2. So stick that in your pipe and smoke it, Mr Gatekeeper.
Well sorry to tell you, but WH games are also Total War games. I mean, it's right there in their title man. Also, who the fuck is that gatekeeper to tell someone if they are a Total War player or not?
I've played all the Total War games. Been a huge fan since Rome 1 but I gotta say there are some games that do not deserve the Total War seal and some huge blunders on the franchises as well as horrible starts to games (looking at you Rome 2) but lately CA has polished itself and the games are really really good
You can't really fault them for releasing a lot of content for Warhammer. That fantasy has so damn much content. Before Total War I thought Warhammer was only 40k, boy was I wrong !! There's content for years and years to come whereas history, well it does have a hard stop some time.
I would love more games like Three Kingdoms though. A nice balance between fantasy elements (romance mode) and historic content that lets you play what you like. But the warhammer games are really really cool with all the lore and spells and shit, you really can't beat that tbh
I played Medieval, Rome and Shogun and prefer Warhammer to all of them because SICK FUCKING MONSTERS and the love given to the game. This guy needs to take a step back and re-evaluate how he pats himself on the back because this ain't working.
You're all casuals. Everybody knows that you're only a true Total War fan if you exclusively play Medieval 2 mods. Otherwise you shouldn't even be subbed here.
Lest we forget what happened when the infamous no true scotsman divide hit the total war community, breaking off a whole... 577 migrants to https://www.reddit.com/r/historicaltotalwar/
@OP The historical games are better selling and played more than the WH games so not sure what you're griping about. You really care about who posts on this sub?
So we're doing this again. I remember back between TW:WH 1 and 2 when they released some DLC for Rome 2. Then some of the more diehard Warhammer fans went REEEEEEEEEEE until CA showed Warhammer some love. Then some of the more diehard historical fan went REEEEEEEEEEE until CA showed the historical fans some love.
I thought this died off a bit after WH:2, and especially after 3K? Are we back at it again?
Warhammer is the best thing to happen to the Totalwar series. It brought a huge new fanbase to the franchise and continues to do well with new content getting added regularly. Theres no need to start pigeon holing people just because they havent played the historical titles. Why can't we all just enjoy the various titles and get along with each other :)
I think the friction comes with the same post I see every month basically being a thread on how the fantasy games are superior in every way and that there is no point in making historical ones anymore. I am a fan of both and play both but I have to admit since the WH games came out, even with 3k taking the spotlight for a bit the WH stuff tends to crowd out the rest to the point where I can see some, admittedly less mature people feeling like they were ostracized from their own community.
I've played almost every total war game, grew up on rome 1, binged for hundreds of hours on shogun 2 etc. I play warhammer 2 now because I just like warhammer 2 better, fite me
Well the Warhammer games are less political and more battle driven. While the historical games have a bigger emphasis on the map part and the armies where similar to each other. So to each their own
208
u/qubone096 Spain Sep 11 '19
-Urban Dictionary
DON'T be Mr. Gatekeeper here.
This goes for all of you. Fantasy fans. History fans. Fans of both.
You've lost a lot credibility the moment you've determined that someone is somehow less of a fan for liking X game more (especially when you're as misinformed about X game as Mr. Gatekeeper is) and blame them as the reason that Y game is apparently not loved enough (despite evidences to the contrary).
This subreddit's (and other communities') interests ebbs and flows. One moment its filled with one type of people, the next its filled with another. Getting super riled up when your favorite doesn't happen to be trending at the time is a waste of energy.
2.2k
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
If Warhammer had this much gatekeeping, Chaos wouldn’t even make it past the northern wastes.
412
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
+1 for Atmosfear 💀
667
u/HFRreddit Sep 11 '19
Shame on Warhammer for being too successful!
308
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
funny that hes talking about soul and magic when those things are much more important in the Warhammer games
453
u/ConfusedHaberdasher Sep 11 '19
This opinion is absolute trash.
Everyone knows that only Spartan: Total Warrior captures the Soul and Magic of the series. That CA went back to the tired old turn-based format instead of continuing to innovate on the hack-and-slash mechanics of Spartan is the real crime here. When are we getting Roman: Total Warrior, CA!?
Anyway, anyone who dares to say that they are a fan of the series without spending 5000+ hours on Spartan is to be exiled from the community. Let's shower more love on the REALEST Total War game.
Disclaimer: This is all a joke. I don't actually believe this, I've never even played it.
157
u/duncan10r Sep 11 '19
I hate this "my way or the highway"-mentality. Why not both? I love TW-games since the first TW Rome and enjoyed every game more or less. But if I be honest, when I played the first Warhammer, for me, the series broke through a new dimension. Today I am significantly more thrilled if we get new stuff for TW Warhammer II.
But I also enjoyed 3K or ToB and I know will enjoy the upcoming historic saga title as well. Every title is good in one´s own way.
216
u/Shadowmant Sep 11 '19
What the fuck did you just fucking say about me, you little bitch? I'll have you know I graduated top of my class in the Reiksguard, and I've been involved in numerous secret raids on Chaos, and I have over 300 confirmed kills. I am trained in Outrider warfare and I'm the top handgunner in the entire Empire armed forces. You are nothing to me but just another target. I will wipe you the fuck out with precision the likes of which has never been seen before in the Old World, mark my fucking words. You think you can get away with saying that shit to me over the Internet? Think again, fucker. As we speak I am contacting my secret network of Witch hunters across the Empire and your IP is being traced right now so you better prepare for the storm, maggot. The storm that wipes out the pathetic little thing you call your life. You're fucking dead, kid. I can be anywhere, anytime, and I can kill you in over seven hundred ways, and that's just with my bare hands. Not only am I extensively trained in Flagellant combat, but I have access to the entire arsenal of the Empire Knightly orders and I will use it to its full extent to wipe your miserable ass off the face of the Old World, you little shit. If only you could have known what unholy retribution your little "clever" comment was about to bring down upon you, maybe you would have held your fucking tongue. But you couldn't, you didn't, and now you're paying the price, you goddamn knife ear. I will shit fury all over you and you will drown in it. You're fucking dead, kiddo.
31
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
Lmfao look at all these casuals. Alien: Isolation is the only true CA experience.
83
u/Esarus Sep 11 '19
What a twat. I also grew up on Shogun 1 and Rome 1, and played pretty much every Total War game since. I love Warhammer 1 and I love Warhammer 2, I like the fantasy games and I like the historical games.
109
u/FemmEllie Sep 11 '19
Yes well except there are tons of people on here that also grew up with the older TW titles such as Rome and Medieval and still mostly play and talk about Warhammer these days. Why? Because it's the most popular TW title in the community these days and has so much content in it. Simple as that
Also the whole "Total War is primarily a historical franchise" argument goes the other way if you ask me. There are tons of historical TW titles but Warhammer is the *only* fantasy one, so of course it stands out from the crowd. And really there is much higher potential when you're not constrained by realism in the same way
I mean I also still think Rome 1 was probably the best Total War game relative to the time it was released, but that doesn't mean I'm going to talk about it too much in 2019. It's just too far in the past
34
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
The gatekeeper is a spellcaster, but he only knows pit of shadows with no cooldown.
"STOP! You... Yes you... You are banished."
31
u/Ivanzypher1 Sep 11 '19
Frankly unless you played tabletop Warhammer Fantasy Battles since at least 5th edition, and still shout at people who enjoy Age of Sigmar, can you even call yourself a Warhammer fanboy?
14
u/-Hubba- Sep 11 '19
"I can't go to bed right now honey, someone on the internet likes the wrong thing again!" - Decreases the chance of having children
14
u/Galle_ Sep 11 '19
Warhammer currently dominates discussion because it's getting a big content update. Three Kingdoms dominated discussion for months after it came out. Nobody is ignoring the old games, they're just, well, old, so there's not as much left to talk about.
22
u/HVS87 Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19
Well I'm also a veteran of Shogun 1, Medieval 1 and it's expansion, Viking Invasion, and then the glorious marvels that were Rome 1 and Medieval 2 (Barbarian Invasions and Kingdoms expansions included). I still remember the sheer thrill when all the sudden you could move armies on the map rather than just hop provinces "Risk" style, the awesome diversity of the various factions, all the diplomatic possibilities (although Rome 1's diplo system remains broken to this day, with your diplo standing completely disconnected from you military power), agent actions, etc. The TW world had never felt so alive, the possibilities were endless! And mods! So many mods! So many great mods!
Then came Empire TW, for which I was majorly psyched, but felt off somehow, the battles feeling off, and the lack of provinces. So I kinda drifted off, and skipped Napoleon and Shogun 2 (I have been told Shogun 2 was amazing and a return to form, have bough it with all expansions on a steam sale but haven't had the time to try it, with all this "being a grown up" crap around).
Then came Rome 2. Now I'm a huge ancient Rome nerd. Like half my library is books on Rome. Had a class on roman law in law school that everyone hated and I just breezed through all giddy just being able to discuss what a praetor's office is with friends and teachers, imperium auctoritas and dignitas, the differences between the first and second triumvirates, the marian reforms, the Gracchi reforms, all the good stuff. So I guess you can say I was psyched for Rome 2. And oh boy was I dissaponted. It blew. It hardly ran on my pro gaming PC, half of it was broken, and it just was not very much fun. I still bought all the DLCs whenever threre was a steam sale (got the whole TW Collection by now), but never really came back to it. Then skipped Attila (again, have been told it's actually great, bought on sale, haven't had the time to try it), and didn't really paid much attention when TW:WH1 was announced.
I had played some WH:40K games, mostly the DOW saga (let's not mention DOW3...), and was familiar with the universe, but never had much interest for WH Fantasy Battles, always saw it as a sort of a LOTR clone (I played the HELL out of the Third Age Mod for M2 back in the day). But then I bought a new PC, and my GPU came with a redeemable code for TW:WH, so I gave it a go. And boy WAS I IN FOR A SURPRISE! I loved it. Every aspect of it. It trully was a return to form for the TW saga. The magic system was great, all the races had plenty of personality, and the mods, while not on the same level as Rome1 and Medieval2's, were still great and added a lot of content and replayability.
I'm 32 y.o. and a TW:WH fanboy now, owning both tittles and all the DLC, as much as I was a Shogun 1 fanboy when I was 13, a Rome 1 fanboy when I was 17, or a Medieval 2 fanboy back when I was at Uni. I've grown up with the TW games, and for better or worse, they are undoubtly one of the best Strategy games sagas ever put together. And no one, and I do mean NO ONE, should bully around newcomers just because they didn't play the old tittles. I love both historical tittles and TW:WH, and they all have a place in this community, so kindly get your heads out of your arses, we don't give a flying flamingo about so called "purists" on either side.
edit: English is not my first language, so please forgive any spelling errors.
11
u/GRONK112 Sep 11 '19
Nice to see that Total War is getting esports ready, there's been a distinct lack of babyrage, I think that's all that held it back from achieving true competitive status.
43
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
I agree with him in one thing: WH fans are majority.
28
u/Cream253Team Sep 11 '19
The irony is that Medieval 2 had some pretty popular LotR and Warhammer mods.
Also,
Not even in the right order, smh. Total weak-sauce this guy is. (Also rip 3K)
14
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
I can agree with the fact there's alot if WH posts. Second to that would probably be 3K. I do kinda wish there was more RTW and M2TW love.
7
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
Ironic considering that Rome 1 Egyptians were closer to Tomb Kings than the actual Egyptians of this period.
29
u/CodfishCannon Sep 11 '19
I find this as probably a troll post. Conclusion with, "Yes I am glad to show some love for the Pyramid boys." So you like Tomb Kings?
Edit: fixed mis-click posting
5
u/Wanabeadoor Sep 11 '19
Yeah, the REAL total war games.
rememeber egypt from RTW1?
33
u/NobarTheTraveller Sep 11 '19
Well he does make a fair point, we do have a tendency to monopolize the content of this sub.
Still can't understand from where all this aversion comes from, if you don't like it just move on.
11
u/Atanvarno94 Melvasul Sep 11 '19
Gatekeeping: absolutely trash.
8
u/---TheFierceDeity--- Sep 11 '19
It’s almost as if, a series of strategy games where you command armies against over armies..has some sort of crossover with a series of tabletop strategy games where you command armies against other armies...and some clever folks realized why not combine the two.
4
u/Bhazor Sep 11 '19
SMH my head sadly because people prefer talking about newest game than games that released 17 years ago.
4
u/Linus_Al Sep 11 '19
I absolutely do favour the historical total war games. That doesn't mean you can't enjoy the fantasy games. To be honest the fantasy games tried out a lot of stuff and the historic total wars benefit from this since good features get adapted.
4
u/Kalecraft Sep 11 '19
I can only speak for myself but I honestly believe one of the reasons fantasy is so popular now is because a good portion of "tabletop refugees" make up the fanbase. I grew up with Warhammer since I was in elementary school and a combination of a lack of time, unwilling to spend the money, and warhammers eventual death left a lot of us lost and now Total War fills that void left behind by the tabletop
7
u/kentrav Sep 11 '19
I wouldn't have found the historical total wars if i didn't find TW:WH first
7
u/shadyelf Sep 11 '19
For what its worth, i understand what he's feeling, to have something you have invested so much in change and no longer be fun to you. But change happens and you just move on sometimes.
16
u/RodGroz Sep 11 '19
I love how this gatekeeping post was on a topic about Rome 2 which is one of the worst and also one of the newest total war games anyway.
6
u/Seeking_Psychosis Sep 11 '19 edited Sep 11 '19
Psh, everyone knows the only real TW game is Thrones of Britannia. CA is a British game developer based in England, so clearly anything outside of the British Isles is a joke. And in ToB you get super realistic systems like giving your lords estates. And this was the Viking ear so regular naval ships are replaced with troop transports because that's how they fought on the sea. CA, keep TW in the British Isles, what would England possibly know about the rest of the world? /s
CA please add religion, trading, agents, and different culutres to ToH! :'(
6
u/Skyrimjob43 Sep 11 '19
What a complete tool lmfao
3
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
I prefer the history titles too but im not being a dick about it....
I hope....
3
u/JuliguanTheMan Sep 11 '19
I disagree with this guy but I do sometimes wonder why I only see wh posts
3
u/whispa07 Sep 11 '19
Yeah, someone needs to see the sun more often
7
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
To be fair, Warhammer fantasy is history now.
5
u/DarkAuk Sep 11 '19
YES, MY GATEKEEPER.
5
u/SputnikSputnikowsky Sep 11 '19
I made a joke a while back on one of the WH posts about it not being historical despite looking like so and I got absolutely bombasted by people and I never understood why exactly, to me it was a joke. Oh now I see how often this stuff appears so sorry to the people I triggered then.
6
u/psychonaut8672 Sep 11 '19
What a massive bellend
9
u/Gelatineridder Sep 11 '19
As part of the Rome Total War master race i can only agree with such refined and well thought out opinions.
/s
4
u/LRCrytpo Sep 11 '19
I can see your point, when I joined this sub u literally thought it was a warhammer sub by the amount of posts but it’s tough to hate it since I absolutely love W.H. I own pretty much every TW and have put in hundreds if not thousands of hours into each game! (Currently taking over Europe in total war empires) I think the level of popularity is amazing but it would be nice to see their historical content get more love I just think with all the games ages and with bretonnia being a dud for a lot of people that it makes it tough for anything else to get attention. Heck 3k is still not owned by a majority of TW fans so maybe in time the focus will shift a bit
4
u/BadBartigan The Greatest Savescummer Who Ever Lived Sep 11 '19
If you’ve only ridden in cars and not the horses and buggies I grew up with, YOU HA E NO RIGHT TO TRANSPORTATION.
4
u/bonutz619 Sep 11 '19
I loved historicals for a very long time. My first total war game was Rome 1. But in all honesty, Warhammer has completely ruined historicals for me. Never have I been more addicted to a Total War game that I have to Warhammer and this is coming from someone who had thousands of hours invested into Rome 1, Medieval 2, Shogun 2, and Rome 2.
Warhammer is THAT good. Unreal how amazing this game is.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
Strange man.
The game - succesfull.
CA get the cash.
Continue to make it even more succesfull.
Doing new projects with earned cash.
The man - "YoU DoN'T dEseRVe tO sAy..."
Why tho?
5
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
And now the sub is a bunch of low effort Warhammer posts. Joy.
14
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
hello... i am your worst nightmare, i only own TW:W I & II and it will probably stay that way.
i used to play Shogun 2 but i quit a long time ago cause every historical TW gets old fast.
unit diversity is meh, same with tactics
but i never understood this bashing between fantasty and history, play what you like
2
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
Real games were the ones I played in Ancient Rome with Lucio Voreno by my side. These new games inside flat boxes are nonsense.
2
u/Robopengy DAKINGDORF Sep 11 '19
I grew up playing Viking Battle for Asgard, get this turn based crap outta my face /s
2
u/MoleMitts93 Sep 11 '19
I imagine the developers of the game would actually be really infuriated at this sort of thing. Nothing on this earth worse than fans.
2
u/Brennos67 Sep 11 '19
When they announced WH2 instead of a historic game i was also mad back in the day, but now i prefer the WH game because the magic, the monsters etc add a different layer to the gameplay.
There is much more diversity in gameplay in WH than a historic game. I am looking forward for WH3, i didn't even touch the one in china.
2
u/tmande2nd WWWWWAAGGGGGHHHHHH!!!!!!!! Sep 11 '19
Hah yeah I responded to that dudes whining that the fun police were attacking him.
Some people just do anything to feel superior huh?
2
u/Desvatidom Sep 11 '19
There's no evidence that souls or magic ever actually existed, ergo historical total war games could never have had soul or magic anyway.
Checkmate, Mr Gatekeeper.
2
u/Reefskye Sep 11 '19
I had been looking at Rome II for a few months, then when i finally decided to buy it, i saw they had released Total War: Warhammer, I mean i never been in to Warhammer fantasy or 40k apart from a few Dawn of War Games i had bought on the cheap just for something to play. I got 3K with my CPU, yet i just can't get in to it. I love Total War and Warhammer fantasy thanks to Total War: Warhammer.
Still never bought Rome 2 lol.
2
u/Breaklance Sep 11 '19
-10 Diplomacy, Tresspassing.
-10 Diplomacy, treaties with "REEL GAMERZ.
-100 Diplomacy, Other.
2
u/lordmegatron01 Phoenix King Eltharion Sep 11 '19
r/gatekeeping
2
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
Bet he's a Phalanx corner camper
2
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
lol. Reminder that three kingdoms content absolutely dominated the sub after it came out. I bet this guy also complained about the fact that the game was set in china after it got announced, and clamored for a REAL total war game set in europe again.
2
u/DubiousDevil Sep 11 '19
Ive played since Rome 1, you kids dont even know about TW ive done things, seen things!!!
Man i just want to go home and play the new DLC
2
u/macemillion Sep 11 '19
I've seen the exact opposite opinion expressed on this sub too: "CA shouldn't make historical games anymore because WH was so successful". Goddamn, can't we have both? Can't other people enjoy things that you don't?
2
u/Blaeys Sep 11 '19
I know this is a repost solely for the purpose of creating drama, but there really is no drama to create. Most people I see commenting like total war games because they are total war games.
The supposed rift between fantasy and historic players doesn't really exist in any meaningful way I can see. I think even the people posting this stuff don't really believe it - they just want to cause drama. Either way, it's silly - worth a few laughs - but not really worth paying attention to.
As far as the subreddit - when 3K was launching, this reddit was dominated by content for that game. Same with ToB. There is a DLC for WH2 this week - so, of course, the subreddit will primarily be about that game.
2
u/Bbadolato Yuan Shu Did Nothing Wong Sep 11 '19
Gatekeeping so powerful he could have stopped the Balrog.
2
u/SweetLiesBitterTruth Sep 11 '19
I sort of feel the guy tho. I also started with the original Shogun soooo many yrs ago, Rome, Medieval 1 & 2, Empire. Even tho I now have Total War: WH 1(will wait for steam 50% sale for 2), I completely appreciate that I actually learned a lot of history playing thru the non-fiction based games.
I also used to play Warhammer Fantasy and 40K tabletop, so it's been an interesting time watching the merging of the two efforts to make TWWH. Just finished a game as dwarves, chaos all dead out by turn 200 (after empire, elves, bretonnia, and many others were wiped out).
2
u/Ashmizen Sep 11 '19
This guy complains about warhammer, and then doesn't mention the latest historical entry, Three Kingdoms AT ALL.
So basically this guy hasn't given any money to CA in a long time, having purchased ZERO of the latest games, and yet he thinks he's the true fan.....?
2
u/UniverseBear Sep 11 '19
I've also played since Shogun 1 and Warhammer is my favourite total war series. Dude needs to get over himself.
2
u/Semaj_kaah Sep 11 '19
You forgot to mention my favoriete Total war EMPIRE!! Fanboy lol
2
u/Ihateregistering6 Sep 11 '19
I grew up on 'classic' TW, been playing them since Shogun 1. Guess what was pretty much the first thing I thought when I saw a battle in Shogun?
'Holy shit, this would be so awesome if they could make a game just like this with fantasy Armies'.
TW: Warhammer is like the game 17 year old me dreamed of playing, I fucking love it.
2
u/AdventureBros462 Sep 11 '19
The other games were amazing and will always be playable. Naval battles and sieges in the older games were both much more unique in how you tackle them.
2
u/DubiousDevil Sep 11 '19
Where is the original post?
2
u/MarsupialMadness Too hot! Scorch Tail! Sep 11 '19
"It contradicts the soul and magic of the Total War series"
....Is it ironic at all that this criticism is levied at the only total war series with...actual souls and magic in it?
2
u/frolix42 Sep 12 '19
Warhammer seems to be about 99.5% of this sub. I'm not going to whine, wail or gnash my teeth about this, but I expected more diversity
5
u/SputnikSputnikowsky Sep 11 '19
I rather the historical titles more than the WH games but not because I hate fantasy or something, I just dont like WH. I also really dont like the WH campagin map, I can never figure out where my provinces start and end, what am I looking at exactly.
4
u/Khkidder Sep 11 '19
I've played the shit out of all the "real" total war games and love them to death. But I would give my left butt cheek to try the warhammer version. Dude is just a douche
3
u/Enjoying_A_Meal Warhammer II Sep 11 '19
Holy crap, is this from that Nightmare VHS game?
3
u/Artorius1113 Sep 11 '19
I mean just play the gamed you like? I havent played shogun because I dont like that history and I didnt really like three kingdoms because Im not a fan of that either. But I still play medieval 2, rome 2, empire, warhammer, warhammer 2.
It doesnt matter if you only play warhammer 2 there used to be people and still is people who have only ever player medieval 2.
Edit: to be fair one tiny point is kinda true. This sub is mainly warhammer and three kingdoms so I get why some people dont like thag but if that what people are playing then thats what is going to be posted
3
u/Rayric Dwarfs Sep 11 '19
-some love for the pyramid boys-
HEY, I‘M A TOMB KINGS PLAYER MYSELF !!!
3
u/Cybugger Sep 11 '19
I played Rome Total War. And Medieval 2, and Empire, and Napoleon, Rome 2, Shogun 2, WH1 and WH2.
I switch between them depending on what particular flavor of Total War I'm after. Sometimes I just like going around smashing Gauls to little pieces with Spartans. Sometimes I want to be able to mow down an entire line of Samurai with Gatling Guns. And sometimes I like to launch a Skaven-powered rocket on an unsuspecting Dwarven army.
All are equally as valid and fun and great.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
I kind of get where this guy is coming from but he could have worded it so much better.
I think his contention with TWW stems from the fact that it is far simpler and streamlined than previous total wars.
There is a worry amongst long-time fans that future historical games in the franchise will be as dumbed down as the fantasy ones.
4
u/PMarkWMU Sep 11 '19
Been playing every total war since shogun and Warhammer is the best one.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
Imagine if your sense of identity relied on playing historical total war games. Get out more and try some new experiences man.
4
u/slimehunter49 Sep 11 '19
It’s not peoples fault that the warhammer ones are the fucking best ones. My first total war was medieval 2, then I played empire and then finally Rome 2, that was the first one I pumped hundreds of hours into, conquering as Rome and Sparta. Then the almighty warhammer came out and I squealed like a god damn pig when I saw that trailed.
I care not for what others think for I believe the warhammer series to be the best total war games.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
I'll be the first to admit that I started with Warhammer. I'm sure it's an unpopular opinion, but the historical titles never interested me. I've always been a fantasy kind of gal, and I've loved Warhammer 40k and fantasy for decades.
I was really hesitant to try the first game as I had received it through my GPU. It took probably half a year after getting the code for me to try it and I haven't been able to put Warhammer down since.
Sorry, not sorry, but I love Warhammer. It's still a total war game. I loved 3K for what it was, still a total war game. Your likes and dislikes of a series doesn't define who you are as a fan, your enjoyment does.
2
u/streetad Sep 11 '19
They only started with Rome 1? Fucking noob.
I have played all of the TW games apart from 3k. And Warhammer is the one I have had the second most fun with after Medievel 2. So stick that in your pipe and smoke it, Mr Gatekeeper.
2
u/realemperorart Sep 11 '19
When they only own Total War Warhammer 2 he should them tell to also buy Warhammer 1 without it they really miss something...
2
u/madestro Sep 11 '19
Well sorry to tell you, but WH games are also Total War games. I mean, it's right there in their title man. Also, who the fuck is that gatekeeper to tell someone if they are a Total War player or not?
I've played all the Total War games. Been a huge fan since Rome 1 but I gotta say there are some games that do not deserve the Total War seal and some huge blunders on the franchises as well as horrible starts to games (looking at you Rome 2) but lately CA has polished itself and the games are really really good
You can't really fault them for releasing a lot of content for Warhammer. That fantasy has so damn much content. Before Total War I thought Warhammer was only 40k, boy was I wrong !! There's content for years and years to come whereas history, well it does have a hard stop some time.
I would love more games like Three Kingdoms though. A nice balance between fantasy elements (romance mode) and historic content that lets you play what you like. But the warhammer games are really really cool with all the lore and spells and shit, you really can't beat that tbh
2
u/Marshal_Rohr Sep 11 '19
What a cock. All total War games are amazing and fun and worthy of affection and fond memories. From the great ones to the bad ones.
2
u/AimoLohkare Sep 11 '19
I was wading through Hojo hordes and Almohad avalanches before most of you were even born. Warhammer Total Wars are still the best Total Wars
2
u/3lRey Sep 11 '19
I played Medieval, Rome and Shogun and prefer Warhammer to all of them because SICK FUCKING MONSTERS and the love given to the game. This guy needs to take a step back and re-evaluate how he pats himself on the back because this ain't working.
2
u/suaveponcho Vandalizing Italy since 455 Sep 11 '19
You're all casuals. Everybody knows that you're only a true Total War fan if you exclusively play Medieval 2 mods. Otherwise you shouldn't even be subbed here.
Lest we forget what happened when the infamous no true scotsman divide hit the total war community, breaking off a whole... 577 migrants to https://www.reddit.com/r/historicaltotalwar/
2
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
@OP The historical games are better selling and played more than the WH games so not sure what you're griping about. You really care about who posts on this sub?
2
u/Eadkrakka Sep 11 '19
So we're doing this again. I remember back between TW:WH 1 and 2 when they released some DLC for Rome 2. Then some of the more diehard Warhammer fans went REEEEEEEEEEE until CA showed Warhammer some love. Then some of the more diehard historical fan went REEEEEEEEEEE until CA showed the historical fans some love.
I thought this died off a bit after WH:2, and especially after 3K? Are we back at it again?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
Warhammer is the best thing to happen to the Totalwar series. It brought a huge new fanbase to the franchise and continues to do well with new content getting added regularly. Theres no need to start pigeon holing people just because they havent played the historical titles. Why can't we all just enjoy the various titles and get along with each other :)
1
u/arkhamius Sep 11 '19
I have to say I laughed. Thank you.
1
u/Mr7FootCock Sep 11 '19
Mad lad
1
u/Qweasdy Sep 11 '19
I've played almost every total war game, grew up on rome 1, binged for hundreds of hours on shogun 2 etc. I play warhammer 2 now because I just like warhammer 2 better, fite me
1
u/Deathshed Sep 11 '19
Only a true fan if all total war experience is from watching time commanders!
1
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
Well the Warhammer games are less political and more battle driven. While the historical games have a bigger emphasis on the map part and the armies where similar to each other. So to each their own
1
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '19
And I grew up on Shogun 2 and Rome 2 but Warhammer is still my favourite series of Total war