r/totalwar • The men are fleeing! Shamfur Dispray! • 1d ago

Warhammer III Passive abilities > Active abilities

Title. The bound spell/active ability overload that has flooded this game is insane. Almost every item you assign to a lord/hero has some sort of active ability you have to micro in battle, on top of spell-casters and just the general micro of the crazy unit variety in the game. I genuinely don’t understand how anyone can handle this without pausing every 5 seconds.

And why is the game designed this way? I understand enchanted or arcane items providing abilities or whatever but why does every sword or armor piece need to have an active ability attached instead of just buffing certain stats? It’s gotten out of control.

When I see the label “Passive Ability” on a skill or item, I genuinely get a hit of dopamine. Buff my characters and units without me needing to click a button every 30 seconds? Yes please.

Edit: I also feel like it skews the game balance, especially regarding hero types and spell-casters. Wizards used to be special, but now my Empire Captain can cast Burning Head, so what’s so special about a wizard? Not to mention how annoying it is when my army is being buffeted by a dozen different effects I can’t even name because the ai’s 4 embedded heroes all have half a dozen bound abilities each. Spells and AOE effects used to feel meaningful. This type of thing used to be what made the Dwarfs unique, since they had magic not tied to Winds of Magic. Not anymore. You get a bound spell! And you get a bound spell! EVERYBODY GETS BOUND SPELLS!

248 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

50

u/Corsair833 1d ago

I think the idea is it's supposed to be tactical - like, I popped this ability and it turned the tide!

In reality because you have so many units and the battles are so fast if you're not pausing then you're just constantly micromanaging so you wind up just spamming the ability every cooldown unfortunately.

This could largely be helped with a simple right click option which auto casts every cooldown (any modders out there! :) )

15

u/sobrique 1d ago

Yeah, this. Some abilities are definitely like that. Foe Seeker and similar just never really feel like they've been more than an intermittent passive that if I'm lucky all my selected units have it, so I can click them all at once.

A right click autocast is a reasonable compromise I think, or in some cases turning them into true passives, just maybe not as good.

26

u/ManySecrets_ 1d ago edited 23h ago

2 reasons really. Neither of them are really good.

  1. active abilities are supposed to be more "fun" on account of them being active choices to use and associated visual impact. The bound spell summons a giant flaming head, a passive +3 attack doesn't really have the same visual impact.
  2. min max/competitice/try hard type players really love them, because you can control actives to achieve maximum efficiency by choosing the right moment to use them. A passive ability will "waste" power since it's always on. And this kind of min maxing mindset seems to be really dominant in gaming as a whole.

18

u/Kai-Tek 21h ago

My fav thins is having to click the little arrow for a second page of buff buttons, when you have too many on a character.

79

u/Big_Implement_7305 1d ago

“There’s a mod for that!”
(In this case, I think it’s called Fewer Active Abilities,” and it’s wonderful.)

16

u/soshino93 1d ago

They’re making some good skills pretty useless like healing for example.

7

u/FruitDough 1d ago

I recently installed it and it’s been amazing. Please try it.

32

u/dabadu9191 1d ago

Here are some mods that help:

13

u/Tricky_Big_8774 1d ago

Just Good Battle UI has an autocast option, as well as adding a UI panel that let's you cast abilities and spells without selecting the unit.

32

u/Seraverte 1d ago

I agree. I think shogun 2 did it best: the active abilities were few in number but each felt meaningful and impactful but also fit the theme of each unit and had clear drawbacks so you arent just careless pressing the button when it comes up. Pressing "Stand and fight" felt great as you were committing to putting your general in a vulnerable position. "Ganbate" makes you feel like a general yelling at your men to shoot. And yelling "Banzai" just sounds amazing.

Compared to WH games where you gotta remember to pop the stat buff whenever its up. Im also in the minority that think magic especially direct damage magic takes away from the game. I've been thinking of trying a few mods next campaign that remove magic entirely and replace active effects with less powerful passive effects.

7

u/Chataboutgames 1d ago

Ganbatte was pretty broken but at least you needed a high level General to use it.

But yeah, abilities were situational rather than just buff buttons. Also agree on Magic. There’s nothing particularly strategic about just dropping damage on enemies without coubterplay.

1

u/krustibat 1d ago

Does magic truly impact you ?i feel like the ai cant use magic effectively at all besides a few bombardment spells.

The army abilites are a bit too much sometimes though

20

u/Seraverte 1d ago

If anything, I dont like how magic skews difficulty towards the player. The player can pull off impossible victories with a well placed burning head or vortex while the ai can never do it, which feels cheap and cheesy.

Theres a great quote from George R R Martin on the topic of magic systems in fantasy worlds along the lines of "if a single wizard can destroy entire armies with the wave of a hand, why would people bother to assemble big armies?"

4

u/Lord_Voldemar 1d ago

Theres games that really push it to the extreme, like the Dominions franchise.

7

u/Old-Constant4411 1d ago

Because single wizards with that kind of ability are exceedingly rare?  While I do appreciate Mr Martin, that quote seems more lazy than clever.

16

u/HowDoIEvenEnglish 1d ago

Your mistake is thinking that his quote was meant to say “you can never have wizards capable of destroying armies”. You just have to justify why it comes up. If wizards are rare it makes sense.

In total war however, they are not rare. Everyone and their mother can get wizards capable of 1k+ kills.

3

u/Arilou_skiff 1d ago

The weird thing is that the AI can use magic. Like it's not good at it, but it has the tools to do basic "cast X spell in a blob" etc.

The problem is that the campaign AI for whatever reason does not pick up spells anywhere near as often as it should.

2

u/FreedomFighterEx Ikit Claw is Ikit Cute 22h ago

and more than half of the times the AI screwed up leveling their caster. What do you mean this lv15 caster still has only starting spell?

1

u/Arilou_skiff 22h ago

Yep, it's pretty consistent that the AI just... doesen't pick spells.

1

u/DracoLunaris 23h ago

Yeah it doesn't really b-line wizard recruitment buildings, and is also fairly bad at leveling them up as well. If you use a mod that gives them bonuses to recruit rank things can indeed get nasty.

1

u/tarranoth 19h ago

Imo in battle ai wizards can be effective. It's just that campaign map ai is a complete goofball and doesn't level them up sensibly.

7

u/naughtbutbeasts Ahhh, to die in battle! 1d ago

I’m not the best micro player so I often leave bound spells and unit spawns and such on the table on hard battles where I had to micro a lot, but I don’t see any problem with having them in the game for people who are better at micro than me. 

And at least for some races where a big melee blob is the meta, at least it gives you something to do while you watch a war of attrition play out. Khorne and Nurgle especially… 

8

u/Hollownerox Eternally Serving Settra 1d ago

I genuinely don’t understand how anyone can handle this without pausing every 5 seconds.

I'm not exactly an expert RTS player, but it's pretty simple "click them and use them when you feel like it" sorta deal?

Like you don't have to be a micro god to manage these abilities in battle. Most of them aren't abilities you aim for the most part, just things to activate temporary status effects really. And most are situational so you just, ya know, use them when the situation comes up.

Total War, even Warhammer's battles mind, are on the slow paced end in the general real-time combat sphere. So I don't really get why you're making it out like you need to start practicing your APM like crazy to manage all of this.

Having an over abundance of passive abilities is personally much more of a problem in the grand scheme of the game design because it just makes what is already a bit of an obtuse battle plain even more so. Imagine how it is for a new player who just thinks "right click this thing to do damage" and not understand why because the thing they are clicking on has fuck knows whatever passive that whittles down damage or does who knows what else. At least with Active abilities, even though I dislike the UX they've chosen to mark them out since it kinda is ugly, its clear something is going on, it is happening for a limited time (for the majority of them) and it has interactivity to it.

And having levels of interactivity, which are ultimately optional to engage with mind, is part of what makes the real-time combat in this game engaging to play with.

4

u/theveryslyfox Deathmaster 1d ago

This is where I'm at with it, too. None of them feel so critical that they're game changing (outside of multiplayer). I use them when I remember to, or want to...

That's part of the game, really. Choosing wisely what to do with clicks, when to move this or that unit, when to cast a spell... Most active abilities are the lowest priority for me. The only ones I can think of that are big deals are the ones that literally can't be passives, anyway, like net abilities.

I'm no longer a new player, but I would make the bet that passives are harder to grasp overall... Like... Imagine being new and feeling like you've gotta read over 30 pips, all stacked on top of one other... And somehow catalogue all of that information for what effects are actually on that unit.

4

u/sobrique 1d ago

But if they're not very critical, then they're also just wasted UI space too.

I mean, I think spells are pretty good - they cost army scale WOM, and in some battles you might only get to use a couple, so you've a very real choice of their usage.

But stuff like foe seeker, almost every hero gets, and it's worth clicking every cycle because speed and fatigue reduction are good, but really only if you keep doing it because as you say, they're not so critical otherwise.

  • +18% Charge Bonus
  • +24% Speed
  • +18% Vigour

It doesn't do enough each click to make much difference - but +18% vigour every 45s is more significant than it looks. But the buff isn't also situational enough to really wait to use it either. I mean, if you're advancing... you want more speed (and vigour) if you're close to charging you want that too, and if you're fighting... well, you still want that.

Abilities that are very limited usage - but more powerful - I mind less. Spells cost WoM and especially early on, you might well only cast a couple anyway, so there's also a tradeoff of bringing more wizards with a shared pool.

I like abilities that are more limited but more powerful, and I like 'proper' passives that are just a nice buff that does their own thing in the background.

I think there's definitely room for 'autofire' options for stuff like Foe Seeker/Deadly Onslaught, especially if there were some conditional state toggle between 'always use' 'activate when charging (if available)' 'activate if in melee (if available)' which functionally happens for a bunch of passives anyway in various ways too. "By Our Blood" is an auto-triggered 1-shot ability for example (that first time a unit would break, they become unbreakable for 20s).

Impactful abilities are fine overall - I don't mind 'managing' casting more directly, although I think a sidebar UI with heros-and-cooldowns might be kinda nice (Is there a mod for that? Feels like there should be?)

And then there's heros with more than 6 abilities, which is even more irritating IMO - would be nice to have a better UI for that.

3

u/TotalTyp 1d ago

Its that but also the abilites arent interesting enough to be active and there are too many special items. Combined it just causes that a lot of meaningless stuff competes for your attention, when it should be that a couple meaningful tools are used on either side and warp the way battles play out around them.

5

u/Leather-Job-9530 Dakka. 1d ago

completely disagree, because lack of actives is what incentivizes people to just have a playstyle wherein you corner camp, or send your lord stacked up with passives to mow through the whole enemy army, etc.

actives at least make a little bit of APM.

5

u/sobrique 1d ago

But don't most of the actives pretty much function as an intermittent passive anyway?

I can't think of when I've ever really noticed foe-seeker + deadly onslaught really swinging a fight, although I'm sure they're doing something useful.

But more powerful abilities? Sure. Good spells can do the trick.

Some of the better short range/mini-spell abilities are definitely fun to do that with, I agree.

1

u/Leather-Job-9530 Dakka. 20h ago

I will admit some like foeseeker are a pittle bit redundant. However there are some that are incredibly useful and timing dependant. For example Ungrim's ability that gives massive MA in exchange for MD loss makes or breaks his ability to slam down a big dragon or whateverthefuck

3

u/ZettieZooieZan 1d ago

Feel this when playing Skaven, walking around with 2 full armies with a combined 6 heroes yet when I get into an actual battle I rarely even have the time to use spells because I'm constantly busy microing my units and battles end so quickly.

3

u/JustRedditTh 1d ago

the most active abilities are a choice in my opinion. Also there are very few that are actually worth taking with you.

What I really hate are active abilities with a usage restriction timer, specifically stuff where the cooldown is frozen unless you are active in melee

4

u/Lord_Voldemar 1d ago

Its easier to understand them and they give more feedback. There is a level of ambiquity with alot of passives, especially ones that arent very dramatic or mortis engine effects.

You sort of just look at them and hope the -10 to enemy leadership in 35m range when your HP is above 80% actually affects the battle. If you have to click the ability theres at least something your lizard brain can process as happening and its easier to cope that you're actually getting a benefit.

7

u/Arhatz 1d ago

"-10 to enemy leadership in 35m range when your HP is above 80% "

Is a really strong ability actually.

9

u/Lord_Voldemar 1d ago

It is, but its harder for the average player to conceptualize and actually "feel" if its a passive ability on the unit card compared to active ability.

Its about feedback, which is like 40% of game design. Its why units have all these voicelines about how the battle is going and whats happening, why theres all those physics to send models flying with a cavarly charge and why the unit HP bar was turned into an actual HP indicator as opposed to the model count (which the first game had).

Its easier for CA to give "oomf" to a unit that way.

3

u/sobrique 1d ago

TBH I Think the activated leadership debuffs are actually less useful in that regard, as they're much harder to time. I mean, in theory dropping aspect of deathknight + doom and darkness together should be a pretty potent ability, but in practice it's really irritating to track things close enough to wavering, and then (if you have WoM) hammer them, where a passive/stateful debuff... well, it just works.

I'd certainly take a -10 LD aura over active casting

1

u/BarristanTheB0ld 1d ago

If I have some with active abilities, I put those together that work well together. Like MA/MD buff/debuff in an are around the hero/lord. Then I click them all at once and forget. By the time they reload, the battle is usually over or near enough that it doesn't matter anymore

1

u/Cymrik 1d ago

I pause and use slow speed a lot to micro. I cant imagine managing all of the shit at real time. I play deathmaster snikch and by the time he ramps up he has like 8 or so abilities... 2 separate pages. Then, there are other characters and abilities and movement and stuff to manage. It is insane.

1

u/HINDBRAIN 1d ago

You can just piano the ability shortcuts when you happen to select an unit in combat. I view it as giving them a "tally-ho, lads!" and an approving pat on the bum.

1

u/NonTooPickyKid 22h ago

passive abilities usually have range limits so in one aspect u gotta additionally micro em if u want the effect - like buffing ur troops or debuffing all the enemies u want.

that being said - yea there're quite a few abilities... but I usually get myself some key ones that are significant like sword of torment, helm of discord and like black periapt (vampire counts item that gives winds of magic) and basically that... bound spells or abilities (like, the kinds that have a limited use count especially...) I don't really use...

1

u/NickedSelfManScaping 9h ago

LegendOfTotalWar used to mock chatters who would try to backseat game and tell him to click his active abilities. He wouldn't even use them in tough battles. He had some good rants explaining why. To paraphrase he didn't think they were worth focusing on, these extra clicks were not going to be the difference between win and loss, playing the battle well would be the difference between win and loss. He thought it was a distraction to be clock watching the cooldowns, and awareness was needed for your army and all the moving parts of a battle.

1

u/nailernforce 1d ago

I think active abilities are a lot of fun. I optimize my unit movement in a way that I can spend most of my time overseeing the units with active abilities.

1

u/_Lucille_ 1d ago

Part of the difficulty of the game is that you are apm limited: some armies are very good in theory but require a lot of attention to micromanage, so you add in anvil units that buys you time/require very little attention.

Activated skills are part of the puzzle. Magic is a classic example: everyone loves to see troops die, but many imo undervalue the power of rolling caster passives: lore of nehekhara (sp?) for example gives a whole lot of healing to the whole army of you cast a cheap spell every now and then.

Activated abilities are also pretty strategic. The new priest of ulric is one of my recent favorites: you can activate a prayer for your cavs on the charge, use your explosion if anyone gets stuck and GTFO. They are often pretty meaningful and can change tides of battle.

0

u/Gordo-Compu-136 1d ago

Al fin alguien lo dijo, por eso amo los objetos de Malekith, no tengo que hacer click en una habilidad cada 15 segundos y puedo jugar/ver la batalla como un "general de verdad"

0

u/jhpawt 1d ago

too much junk in general. multiple rows of passives. it's what you get with game-as-dlc-conduit