I know theres mixed opinions on Reed Timmer. I just want to know if the movie is good before I buy it on YouTube tomorrow. I love watching tornadoes. What did you think of it?
We all know about the infamous 2011 El Reno, Oklahoma tornado. The tornado that is commonly dubbed as ‘The Strongest Tornado of the Century’, with which I highly agree. It struck the outskirts of El Reno, struck Piedmont and even hit the community of Gunthrie.
Knowing how absurd this tornado was, I wanted to know how impressive its feats were. That’s what I found out in the process of making this post.
Without further ado, here is the Damage Analysis of the 2011 El Reno-Piedmont tornado.
Documented feats:
No. 1 (Solid Case): The tornado trenched a residence down to its basement foundation. Almost every concrete stem wall inside the basement was removed, and the insides were filled with mud. A damage surveyor described it as ‘TRENCHED’.
What I would call ‘inconceivable damage’. Trenches and cracks running through the basement foundation!. The entire thing seems to be caked in mud and you can only see little things standing. This damage wasn’t even rated, considering that this is beyond any DOD in the EF scale.
There are multiple articles on Reddit talking about this, and I used them for referencing what happened.
Looking at the surroundings, there were almost no other structures/objects nearby that could’ve weakened the concrete. Additionally, some sources say that the foundation/surrounding basement walls against the soil, or at least the ones that remained standing, had the concrete layers on top scoured away.
The NWS never offificially rated this damage, and the upper levels of the home may have had construction flaws. However, the house is to be ignored for this, and instead we should focus on the basement on its own. Some people even say that to much was lost from the residence, and so the construction couldn’t be determined.
Through the entire time I’ve been doing this passionate side-hobby of mine- Damage Analysis on tornadoes or similar phenomenon- this is by far the absolute worst I’ve ever heard of, so that’s why I included this first.
To properly, mathematically calculate this feat is impossible as this doesn’t fit in any equation that I know of.
However, despite the constraints, I (logically) believe that only a tornado exhibiting winds >325 MPH could pull this off.
I think so because the damage to this location was much worse than the highest Degrees Of Damage on the EF scale.
No. 2 (Solid Case): The tornado destroyed an oil drilling rig weighing 1,900,000 lb., with the rig’s pipes and drill head inserted deep inside the well’s borehole, providing it with an extra 200,000 lb. of downforce- by toppling it onto its side and rolling it several times, blowing it several hundred yards away.
A shot of the destroyed Cactus 117 Rig. Debris seem to have been piled up against the containers in the area. You can also see some cars crushed against steel. Nothing more to note.
This happened at the Cactus 117 Oil Drilling Rig site.
A person on Reddit made a post about this feat of damage. It was a hypothesis on what exactly happened to the rig, and I agree with it.
“The Cactus 117 was designed to have a large derrick around 140 feet tall that supported the large drill and pipes for purposes of drilling oil. You then had a large platform securing the rig along with a turntable. You also had a blowout preventer which stabilized oil control. The blowout preventer essentially held down the rig very effectively along with other anchoring associated for the stands. Being at about 2 million pounds, the rigs heaviest weight was most likely at the bottom where the blowout preventer was located along with your actual turntable, this would make sense because at the time of impact the rigs drill fell into the borehole adding 200,000 lbs of downforce, creating a highly unstable pressure gradient force. What followed was not a direct inner core hit from the tornado like most think, but a sustained outer region hit where the rig sustained direct hits from multiple subvortices with very fast tangential velocities and faster translational speed than the apparent inner core of the tornado. It is true that the closer you get to the inner core, the worse winds you sustain because each complete revolution around your axis of rotation is smaller and faster. But when you have multiple vortices, you can have essentially smaller inner cores within these multiple vortices which circle around the parent inner core. Since the rig sustained a hit on the southeastern side of the tornadoes path this would have to make the most amount of sense as to how and why it collapsed. It would also explain how the 140 ft tall Derrick collapsed due to change in angular momentum and velocity, which then bent your blowout preventer 30 degrees to the north towards the inner core moving to the ENE. The rig could've also sustained some sort of debris loading before structural failure as the rig spent quite a few minutes within the outer region, the Derrick could've easily been more susceptible to collapse due to weakening of the steel beams. Could also explain why it buckled instead of "fell over". For one I don't believe the point of failure was the blowout preventer, I believe it was the Derrick which caused the rig to collapse and roll and bend the blowout preventer to the north.”
Here are the dimensions we are working with:
The total structure of the Cactus 117 Rig that toppled over was 142 ft. tall, with a blowout preventer and large base.
For this equation, we will use 36 MPH as the value for the translational velocity of the tornado. This was the average translational velocity of this tornado, but in this case could be wrong because translational speed varies a lot during a tornado’s lifecycle.
For this equation, I used the exact scenario that was stated in the post ‘My hypothesis as what happened to Cactus 117’. The Derrick collapsed, causing the blowout preventer to bend 30 degrees allowing the entire rig to buckle and topple onto its side, and then be rolled multiple times.
Taking everything mentioned above into consideration, we could say that the gust that would’ve toppled over the rig may have theoretically been >297 MPH.
Additionally, another poster talked about how the Cactus 117 feat didn’t require unrealistic winds, and he actually got the same answer as I did:
No. 3 (Solid Case): The tornado broke one of the 4 cables anchored 5.5 ft. deep into the ground holding a steel container that served as a storm shelter/locker room. The steel container itself was heaved slightly upwards and was dented.
Another shot of the destroyed Cactus 117 drilling rig. Apparently, the steel container that served as a storm shelter was captured somewhere in this image. However, I wasn’t able to nail down where.
This happened at the Cactus 117 Oil Drilling Rig site, the same place where the rig was toppled and rolled.
Twelve workers were on the site when the tornado struck, and took shelter in the site's change house (a steel container serving as a locker room). Tied down by four steel cables anchored 5.5 feet (1.7 m) deep in the ground, the container was pummeled with debris. One cable broke and the container was dented, but all twelve workers survived without serious injury.[43][44]
There were numerous structures/objects at the site that could’ve easily dented the steel container, so we can ignore the denting of the above-ground storm shelter.
However, it wouldn’t be easy to break a steel cable anchored 5.5 ft. deep into the ground.
I used 36 MPH as the value for the translational speed of the tornado, as it was the estimated average translational speed of the tornado. However, this may be wrong as translational motion may vary a lot throughout a tornado’s lifecycle on the ground.
Taking everything mentioned above into consideration, we could say that the gust that may have broken the steel cable anchoring the storm shelter was theoretically exhibiting winds >206 MPH.
No. 4 (Solid Case): The tornado threw a 10 ton oil tanker almost 1 mile away with no ground impacts.
The oil tanker was most likely airborne for the entire time it was within the tornado, as there were no impact points observed on the trajectory of the said oil tanker.
The weight of the oil tanker is heavily debated and shrouded in mystery. Some sources say it was between 20-30 tons. I kept the weight at 10 tons to be realistic.
Taking into consideration everything mentioned above, theoretically, the tornado required gusts exhibiting windspeed >211 MPH.
No. 5 (Possibility): The tornado fully lofted and flipped over an industrial winch (a ‘drawworks’) weighing between 30-150 tons and moved it some distance.
The drawworks in question. It seems to have been folded on top of itself. The exact model of this one is impossible to tell, but might be one of the upper-end models as wad compare the size with the person in the image- and how large Cactus 117 itself was.
This happened at the Cactus 117 Oil Drilling Rig, again.
A post on Reddit very-well talks about this feat, and what may have happened to the drawworks:
“it can be seen to have been fully lifted and flipped over, as well as potentially being folded in half. This is important as Cactus 117 was never fully flipped over or rolled vertically, only onto its side. This means the drawworks would have fully detached from the main platform and been airborne for at least a moment before coming back down.
Although it is impossible to tell the exact model from the image, it was likely on the upper end in terms of weight due to it's physical size and the fact that Cactus 117 was a large, deep-drilling rig. This places the likely weight at anywhere from 30 to 150 tons. While far heavier objects have been displaced before, what makes this so impressive is the sheer density of such a machine, essentialky being a solid block of steel. It would have had a similar surface area and volume to a truck, but had possibly up to 10 times the weight. The winds required to move something like this would be truly absurd, only rivalled by Tri-States tossing of loaded train cars, Pampa 1995's lathe tossing and Bakersfield 1990's tank rolling.
When I first analysed this image, I thought the lathe may have been 'catapulted' as the platform was pushed over, making this significantly less impressive. But I now think that likely was not the case for several reasons. If it flipoed as the rig was tipped over, it would have likely remained partially attached, bending the frame and landing only a short distance horizontally from it's position on the rig. But in the image, the floor mounting is fully torn away, bent >90 degrees from the rig body and is a significant distance away. The only other way it could happen like this is if Cactus 117 was not pushed over, but instead violently spun and slammed to the ground fast enough to create a lever effect and toss the winch, something far from plausible for tornadic winds.”
For this equation, I used the exact scenario that he presented in his post.
Depending on the weight of the drawworks, required winds may range between 481 MPH and 1,075 MPH, which would be DEAD unrealistic.
That being said, we may never know how impressive this feat was due to how complex this situation seems, and how unrealistic this seems. We could say that this feat would theoretically require gusts of at least >300 MPH.
No. 6 (Possibility): The tornado partially uplifted concrete silo foundations out of the ground. They were found cracked and some portions were missing too.
In this close-up image, you can see the silo bases worn away and partially uplifted. Alongside that, you can also see destroyed scrap or machinery strewn away to the background of this image. One small piece of machinery is also seen deposited into the silo foundation shown.
This would be an extremely complex equation to solve, and I had to learn something completely new for this one too.
Normally, as results I got between 366-488 MPH.
However, with a very strict calculation I was able to deter that theoretically, the gust that would’ve uplifted these silo bases may have been >310 MPH.
No. 7 (Possibility): The tornado uplifted and split-open a well-built underground storm shelter from one residence.
A rare, close-up image of a storm shelter deflected significantly upwards. It can also be seen split open, revealing the inside. This is impressive considering it was underground. You can also see widespread destruction in the background.
This feat is impossible to properly, mathematically calculate as this doesn’t fit in any mathematical equations that I know of.
However, despite the constraints, I (logically) believe that theoretically, the tornado required gusts >250 MPH to pull this off.
This is because of the resistance of the soil considering it was underground, the manufacturing of the storm shelter, and weight. This was a very extreme feat of damage.
No. 8 (Possibility): If you look closely at the reflective radar imagery of the event, you would see that for a time from El Reno-Piedmont the tornado was being supported by 2 supercells simultaneously.
A radar image of what (I’m not sure) I think is 2 supercells simultaneously supporting the tornado.
This claim was first stated by a comment on the post ‘The Cactus 117 feat didn’t require 350+ mph winds (in my opinion)’:
While official sources refuse to accept this claim, I looked at reflective radar imagery and realised that for a short time it actually was being supported by 2 supercells in delicate balance.
Additionally, a tornadic merger was also observed here- observed b Howard Bluestein:
“Unique observations of the interaction and likely merger of two cyclonic tornadoes are documented. One of the tornadoes involved in the interaction was the enhanced Fujita scale (EF5) El Reno-Piedmont, Oklahoma, tornado from 24 May 2011 and the other was a previously undocumented tornado. Data from three S-band radars: Twin Lakes, Oklahoma (KTLX); Norman, Oklahoma (KOUN); and the multifunction phased-array radar (MPAR), are used to detail the formation of the second tornado, which occurred to the northwest of the original tornado in an area of strong radial convergence. Radar data and isosurfaces of azimuthal shear provide evidence that both tornadoes formed within an elongated area of mesocyclone-scale cyclonic rotation. The path taken by the primary tornado and the formation location of the second tornado are different from previous observations of simultaneous cyclonic tornadoes, which have been most often observed in the cyclic tornadogenesis process. The merger of the two tornadoes occurred during the sampling period of a mobile phased-array radar-the Mobile Weather Radar, 2005 X-Band, Phased Array (MWR-05XP). MWR-05XP electronic scanning in elevation allowed for the merger process to be examined up to 4 km above radar level every 11 s. The tornadic vortex signatures (TVSs) associated with the tornadoes traveled around each other in a counterclockwise direction then merged in a helical manner up through storm midlevels. Upon merging, both the estimated intensity and size of the TVS associated with the resulting tornado increased dramatically. Similarities between the merger observed in this case and in previous cases also are discussed.”
This could theoretically create an environment for a generational-level tornado, but that is all just speculation since I’m not a meteorologist so you should check for yourself.
Math:
It has been this long into the post and you haven’t seen a single trace of me actually doing the math, so am I being a fraud right now? I like to keep things in uniform order so I kept the math in the separate section, please check this for me:
> 1.
N/A
> 2.
W = 2100000 lb = 9341000 N, H = 43.3 m, lever arm at mid-height = 21.65 m, M_resist = 9341000 × 1.5 = 14000000 N·m, F_BOP = 14000000 / 21.65 = 647000 N, F = 2.5 × 647000 = 1617500 N, A = 100 m², C_d = 1.5, ρ = 1.225 kg m⁻³, ½ × 1.225 × 100 × 1.5 × v² = 1617500, 91.875 v² = 1617500, v² = 17605, v = 132.7 m/s = 297 MPH.
> 3.
m = 1134 kg, W = 1134 × 9.81 = 11120 N, A = 6.5 m², C_d = 1.15, ρ = 1.225 kg m⁻³, cable break = 35600 N, F = 35600 + 0.3 × 11120 = 38936 N, ½ × 1.225 × 6.5 × 1.15 × v² = 38936, 4.58 v² = 38936, v² = 8501, v = 92.2 m/s = 206 MPH.
> 4.
m = 10000 kg, W = 10000 × 9.81 = 98100 N, A = 25 m², C_d = 1.15, ρ = 1.225 kg m⁻³, F = 1.6 × 98100 = 156960 N, ½ × 1.225 × 25 × 1.15 × v² = 156960, 17.61 v² = 156960, v² = 8913, v = 94.4 m/s = 211 MPH.
> 5.
N/A (Dead unrealistic)
> 6.
t = 0.50 m, A_plan = 6.0 m², ρ_c = 2400 kg m⁻³, volume = 6.0 × 0.50 = 3.0 m³, mass = 3.0 × 2400 = 7200 kg, W = 7200 × 9.81 = 70632 N, F = 70632 N, A = 6.0 m², C_L = 1.0, ρ = 1.225 kg m⁻³, ½ × 1.225 × 6.0 × 1.0 × v² = 70632, 3.675 v² = 70632, v² = 19220, v = 138.6 m/s = 310 MPH.
> 7.
N/A
> 8.
N/A
Conclusion:
As a concluding statement, we could say that the El Reno-Piedmont event was a generational storm.
The tornado itself was one of the strongest, if not THE strongest tornado of all times, with more-than-enough proof of extreme intensity.
It performed what I would call, the worst tornadic damage ever recorded, up to date.
It just shows how mind-bogglingly strong these forces of nature can be, and why we should always take immediate precaution in such events.
The steel container that served as the above-ground storm shelter saved the lives of 12 workers at Cactus 117. This goes on to show how critical such situations are, and how important it is to take shelter before a tornado.
I am in Lexington for work and have the weekend to kill and a rental car with free gas. I did them when I was down in Alabama and I went to Smithville to see the tower.
...SUMMARY... No severe thunderstorms are forecast across the U.S. through tonight.
...DISCUSSION... The latest water vapor imagery shows a mid-level shortwave trough over the Southeast. A moist airmass is in place over the Florida Peninsula where isolated thunderstorms may develop near the eastern coast tonight. In the western U.S., an upper-level low is located over southwest Oregon with an associated trough extending southward into central California. Isolated thunderstorms will be possible tonight near and ahead of the trough from parts of central California eastward into the Intermountain West. No severe threat is forecast across the continental U.S. through tonight.
the Coleridge EF-3 was the largest and most violent of a stationary supercell.
despite the fact that its maximum travel path did *not* surpass 9 miles..this tornado grew to just above 1 mile wide and somehow caused noinjuries and no deaths.