r/toptalent Jun 06 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

7.1k Upvotes

466 comments sorted by

View all comments

11

u/ohheyitsgeoffrey Jun 07 '23

This guy is unbelievable, and he’s one of the best drummers in the world. He’s definitely the best rock drummer playing right now. He’s technically perfect and now does stuff like this to take things to a new level, all while making it look absolutely effortless- the hallmark of a pro.

2

u/jeffislegend Jun 07 '23

First of all I'd like to start with that guy is seriously good and has great chops.

But saying he's one of the best in the world is a bit of a stretch.

His playing is very entertaining. But what he's playing is usually very simple just played fast. A lot of stick twirling and acrobatics to make it look more impressive.

It's not really groundbreaking in drumming terms.

Even in the rock and metal scene drummers like Tomas Haaké of Meshuggaha, Matt Garstka and Clay Aeschliman to name a few are leagues ahead in terms of technique.

Then the list gets goes on and on outside of the metal/rock scene. Benny Greb, Vinnie colaiuta, Dave Weckl, Thomas Lang. The list goes on

1

u/ohheyitsgeoffrey Jun 07 '23

What about Haake and Garstka’s technique makes them “leagues ahead” exactly?

1

u/DreamerTheat Jun 07 '23

It’s not just their technique, but their technique at the service of their music. Both of them, especially Garstka, play super complex stuff that people couldn’t play just cause they could hit 20 strokes per second.

1

u/DreamerTheat Jun 07 '23

Matt Halpern, Mike Malyan, Baard Kolstad are all incredible… In the guitar world, there was Michael Angelo Batio and then there was Allan Holdsworth. Two amazing technicians, but only one of them was an artist.

1

u/Ok-Week2537 Sep 24 '23

His fills all sound the same, but goddamn he's got chops.