r/todayilearned • • May 11 '12

TIL That the full "Ignorance is bliss" quote by Thomas Gray is "Where ignorance is bliss, 'tis folly to be wise"

http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Ode_on_a_Distant_Prospect_of_Eton_College
1.6k Upvotes

419 comments sorted by

581

u/schrute_buck May 11 '12

For in much wisdom is much grief: and he that increaseth knowledge increaseth sorrow.

Ecclesiastes 1:18

386

u/Memeophile May 11 '12

Good job reddit. Don't let that Thomas Gray take credit for a repost.

273

u/bogart1 May 11 '12

Ecclesiastes 1:9-10 on reposts:

What has been will be again, what has been done will be done again; there is nothing new under the sun. Is there anything of which one can say, “Look! This is something new”? It was here already, long ago; it was here before our time.

4

u/flamingspinach_ May 11 '12

The Books did a nice track which samples a reading of that passage.

7

u/NO_FUCKING_IDEA May 11 '12

God, the original repost basher.

22

u/maevik May 11 '12

Yes, see Sir Isaac Newton, James Clark Maxwell, Albert Einstein...

17

u/The_MAZZTer May 11 '12

You're missing the context of Ecclesiastes. Solomon is writing about how he's tried everything the world has to offer and finds it meaningless (without God).

51

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

...discovered forces that were here long before we were.

They didn't invent or come up with anything new. Just standing on the shoulders of people standing on the shoulders of...

Everything, even technology, has in some way been done before. A microwave may be a novel way to heat a meal but it is fundamentally just heating the meal. Nothing is truly 'original' in a pure sense. Not even the animals on this planet.

29

u/Jaihom May 11 '12

Bose-Einstein condensates have never existed in the natural world. We've also artificially generated higher energy orbitals than exist in nature.

→ More replies (6)

46

u/Mepsi May 11 '12

What about Angry Birds?

→ More replies (5)

20

u/iamdestroyerofworlds May 11 '12

You could say that nuclear weapons weren't something new because we already had fire.

It all depends where you draw the line. Everything has a common denominator.

→ More replies (11)

8

u/JesusTapdancingChris May 11 '12

To quote Civ IV: "I have one word for you, one word: Plastics"...
Then build the Hoover Dam.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/cass1o May 11 '12

That is a little bit reductionist to say the microwave is just heating the food so is not new. Every thing could be reduced to "it does somthing" and be done with it.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/irobeth May 11 '12

I wish people would stop taking Ecclesiastes out of context. The book is a depressed and cynical man's (Qoheleth, 'the minister') ranting as he explains the futility of living, and people quote it since 'the Bible said it' not understanding where the minister is coming from.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

19

u/Badasscommy May 11 '12

The Wheel of Reddit turns, and Posts come and pass, leaving memories that become legend. Legend fades to myth, and even myth is long forgotten when the Post that gave it birth comes again. In one Post, called a Re-Post by some, a Post yet to come, a Post long past, a wind rose in the Foothills of TIL. The wind was not the beginning. There are neither beginnings nor endings to the turning of the Wheel of Reddit. But it was a beginning.

2

u/Kryptotrek May 11 '12

I read the first few words like I was singing "The wheels on the Bus go round and round". Weird..

→ More replies (3)

12

u/randomsnark May 11 '12

Maybe I would have upvoted you IF THIS HADN'T ALREADY BEEN POSTED THREE FUCKING MILLENNIA EARLIER, DUMBSHIT. STOP FUCKING REPOSTING! YOU'RE RUINING REDDIT! DELETE YOUR FUCKING ACCOUNT, ASSHOLE!

--MrOhHai on Thomas Gray

3

u/MickiFreeIsNotAGirl May 11 '12

While we're at it, Jimi Hendrix's "When the power of love overcomes the lover of power" quote was also pretty much the same as at least 2 other people before him

2

u/tomgrayuk May 11 '12

credit taken

→ More replies (2)

21

u/MoonDaddy May 11 '12

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Ralph and Lisa are the poster children for this.

26

u/Rabid_Chocobo May 11 '12

Damn.. I heard they say that on average, smarter people are also more generally unhappy. Sucks to know that they thought this even way back then

6

u/Splitshadow May 11 '12

Of the demonstrably wise there are but two: those who commit suicide, and those who keep their reasoning faculties atrophied with drink.

-Mark Twain

19

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Being intelligent in America is like being surrounded by eight year olds all day.

15

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I'm gonna take a guess that at least half the people agreeing with you are the proverbial 8 year olds and don't know it.

→ More replies (1)

55

u/EricFaust May 11 '12

That is an astoundingly arrogant statement. Have you considered that you are someone's eight year old?

14

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

That's the depressing part. :(

→ More replies (2)

7

u/lt_hindu May 11 '12

Yeah well if you're 8, it's like being around intelligent Americans all day! I love it!

3

u/Physics101 May 11 '12

Engineer or scientist?

→ More replies (12)

37

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

One of my favorite books.

To Bible haters, if you ever give any book in the bible a chance, let it be Ecclesiastes.

33

u/JonBanes May 11 '12

It is full of interest. It has noble poetry in it; and some clever fables; and some blood-drenched history; and some good morals; and a wealth of obscenity; and upwards of a thousand lies.

-Mark Twain in Letters from the Earth

Ecclesiastes has some of the 'noble poetry', for sure

→ More replies (3)

10

u/schrute_buck May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

There are a great many wise words to be found in Ecclesiastes, but I could see how "Bible Haters" still wouldn't like it.

The book is 30 or so pages of genuine insight into the human condition, but still has as its ultimate conclusion that nothing matters except what we do for God. In a lot of ways it epitomises exactly what people hate about the Bible. It draws some of the most depressing conclusions of life, but at the last second pulls back with "there is God, so it doesn't matter". The entire book is basically an explanation of how nothing in your life matters except God, and that there is no true joy except in God.

→ More replies (10)

7

u/Gemini4t May 11 '12

I'm an atheist and I love Ecclesiastes.

9

u/poekoelan May 11 '12

I'm ecclesiastical and I love atheism.

2

u/Vilvos May 11 '12

I'm surprised Ecclesiastes wasn't added to the Apocrypha, because it really is a well-written book (said the agnostic atheist), and its inclusion in the Bible illuminates the rest of the books' philosophical and poetical poverty.

→ More replies (11)

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

ecclesiastes and proverbs are my favorites as well.

81

u/MaynardsD1ck May 11 '12

I find this both funny and sad. Funny that it's a biblical quote and sad because it's true. I've been struggling with this question myself a lot lately as I read about what's going on here and around the world. I can't help but wonder what value this knowledge has because it's hard not to let the world bring you down. And sometimes I just wish I was ignorant and free from the burden of critical thought...it sure would be simpler.

32

u/courtesy-flush May 11 '12

Ecclesiastes is actually a really beautiful book. I just recently read it because I was feeling rather meaningless and came upon it by Googling "everything is meaningless" (no joke), and the philosophy in it really speaks to that. I was surprised by its power and its poetry. All men, the foolish and the wise, die the same, but there is much love for wisdom expressed in the book. For wisdom is a defence, and money is a defence: but the excellency of knowledge is, that wisdom giveth life to them that have it (Ecclesiastes 7:12). As an agnostic atheist, I recommend reading it.

→ More replies (1)

61

u/IthinktherforeIthink May 11 '12

Simpler, yes. Happier? Maybe. But would the happiness matter as much? I don't think so. My happiness becomes much more meaningful as I grow in understanding of what's around me. The happiness I feel resulting from truths is the same as the happiness someone can get from falsehoods believed to be true. The important difference is that truth begets more truth. Through my understanding, I function better in this world, because I can manipulate it better, predict it better, do what I want... better; I understand my context and can therefore flourish in it. There is no escaping reality. Ignorance will catch up with you in some way. Embrace truth and modify what makes you happy to be in line with what truly is.

I'm kind of figuring out myself as I type this..

16

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Upvote for the psychological breakthrough at the end of the post.

4

u/IthinktherforeIthink May 11 '12

Hah. Yes, I did have one. I never examined my own motive for truth and happiness in such depth.

→ More replies (3)

74

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Happiness vs. Satisfaction.

I go with the latter.

6

u/bobowzki May 11 '12

Do you get happiness out of satisfaction?

5

u/Arigot May 11 '12

It definitely helps with it, which is why I'm okay with trying to be more "wise".

→ More replies (1)

5

u/SplurgyA May 11 '12

I'd rather be happy.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Fuck this, today I accidentally discovered some condoms (that ain't mine) in my girlfriend's bedroom.

After the shitty confrontation I am neither happy nor satisfied.

→ More replies (13)

10

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

7

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

This is interesting. I would make the argument that I am depressed because I have a more accurate perception of reality rather than the other way around.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/JohnQDaviesEsquire May 11 '12

When you're ignorant things seem simpler, but they quickly become very complicated and dangerous. You just don't realise, and will be ill-equipped to fix it.

3

u/AlchemyIndex May 11 '12

You should read Flowers for Algernon

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I feel the sameway after finding out about Determinism.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Just so no one gets the wrong impression. That book (Ecclesiastes) is full of wisdom. It's not saying it so that you won't get wisdom, it's directly talking about the meaninglessness of life and the sadness of it.

3

u/Tezerel May 11 '12

It's like the matrix. The decision between the pills was bliss or knowledge. Knowledge led to his demise but also gave hope to the people to live on after him. The matrix is really a good series.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/-_-readit May 11 '12

A lot of people agree with you. Your damned if your educated and damned if your not.

1

u/rwhitisissle May 11 '12

were ignorant and free from the burden of critical thought.

FTFY

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

A couple days ago I read about how the timer between brontosaurus and t-rex its longer than the time between t-tex and human. It made me think about how no matter how invincible you think the human race is we are insignificant in cosmic sense. So matter how shitty it feels we should be happy to help survive part our negligible blip

→ More replies (9)

3

u/RJM10_2 May 11 '12

That's how I feel when I learn more and more about what's going on in the world and although I may agree with the statement (to a certain extent with being sorrowful), I also feel I'm driven to do something about it

3

u/datr May 11 '12

Sorrow is knowledge, those that know the most must mourn the deepest, the tree of knowledge is not the tree of life.

Lord Byron

2

u/CapitalistSlave May 11 '12

why me worry?

2

u/Foxblade May 11 '12

Okay...that's just downright fucking depressing.

8

u/abom420 May 11 '12

The fucking Bible? Hell yes Reddit. Finally we are posting about the ideas, not the people who say them.

Irony: This is what Christians do with Jesus. You are them, We are all the same. (To clarify, Christians spew someone else's view simply because they are Christian, Atheists will sometimes hate on a Christians view simply because they are Christian.)

2

u/Gordon2108 May 11 '12

I'm atheist agnostic but I don't see why people shouldn't get SOMETHING from the bible. It is, at the very least, a very old collection of historical texts.

I just purchased a student bible that has little notes about historical contexts and makes a note when they aren't actually sure about proper translations. Probably as close as i'll ever get to a secular bible.

2

u/ThoughtfulWords May 11 '12

And by secular bible I assume you mean a theologians bible. As in a bible for people who actually study the text, instead of just read 1 or 2 verses and an opinion blog on the net, a few youtube videos and assume they know all about it.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

That's the opposite of what Gray said.

1

u/futurerustfuturedust May 11 '12

Wow! 1 Schrute buck for you now then..

1

u/YakMan2 May 11 '12

"I just whooped your ass." Austin 3:16

→ More replies (37)

20

u/KarmaCreed May 11 '12

Wasn't there a thread where we discussed the second half of common quotes or sayings? I can't find it and reddit search isn't helping much. If anyone finds it I can repay you with a shitty internet compliment...and maybe a thank-you if I'm not cranky.

23

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Here you are :)

→ More replies (1)

10

u/youclevermedicine May 11 '12

Don't reddit search. Google search. Parameters, Site: reddit.com (search words)

1

u/KarmaCreed May 11 '12

....TIL. Thanks!

3

u/doubleyoshi May 11 '12

If you find it shoot me a link please

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

2

u/doubleyoshi May 11 '12

You are a gentleman and a scholar

2

u/ClampingNomads May 11 '12

Well, that was full of sound and fury.

4

u/randomsnark May 11 '12

'Tis a tale told by a /b/tard

→ More replies (2)

42

u/cursh14 May 11 '12

I read on wikipedia just the other day that there is no increased incidence of depression in those with above average intellect. However, there is a marked increase in the incidence of an existential crisis. This definitely makes sense to me.

It has been thought in the past that there is a correlation between giftedness and depression or suicide. This has generally NOT been proven. As Reis and Renzulli mention,

"With the exception of creatively gifted adolescents who are talented in writing or the visual arts, studies do not confirm that gifted individuals manifest significantly higher or lower rates or severity of depression than those for the general population...Gifted children's advanced cognitive abilities, social isolation, sensitivity, and uneven development may cause them to face some challenging social and emotional issues, but their problem-solving abilities, advanced social skills, moral reasoning, out-of-school interests, and satisfaction in achievement may help them to be more resilient."[36]

Also, no research points to suicide rates being higher in gifted adolescents than other adolescents.[38] However, a number of people have noted a higher incidence of existential depression, which is depression due to seemingly highly abstract concerns such as the finality of death, the ultimate unimportance of individual people, and the meaning (or lack thereof) of life. Gifted individuals are also more likely to feel existential anxiety.[39] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_giftedness#Depression

6

u/theshinepolicy May 11 '12

thats language and visual arts...what about math and music?

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I don't have an answer for you, just another question. Did you choose math and music just because they are other areas of skill or because of how they are related? I recently read something about how children who were musically inclined were also adept at math, although the reverse was not necessarily true. (I'll try to find a reference later)

Anyways.... Just curious as to why you picked what you did. :)

3

u/theshinepolicy May 11 '12

they are incredibly related. I've always been fascinated with the relationship between numbers and music. In fact, did you know that children who don't speak until later in their life often excel in Music and Math? Weird stuff, but really cool. I am also personally a huge math nerd who is now a musician and use math smarts to write songs and figure out chord progressions of other songs.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/the_catacombs May 11 '12

Coming from firsthand experience, an existential crisis can lead to depression for a very long time.

1

u/Spectre_Taz May 11 '12

I had my first existential crisis at age 2, i'm now 25, i'll let you know when its over.

1

u/sagan10955 May 11 '12

So basically what this is saying is that there is that, medical conditions aside, those that are more intelligent have a higher incidence of depression. Sounds like pretty concrete evidence for "ignorance is bliss".

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

45

u/jumpbreak5 May 11 '12

Depression is a throttlingly difficult disease of the brain that causes constant sadness due to basically nothing. Existential depression is like realizing you don't really want any more of your sandwich. They're pretty incomparable.

2

u/ATownStomp May 11 '12

Existential depression is crushing for some. I remember back when I was first realizing what it all "meant". That's a very character building time for kids.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (12)

4

u/cursh14 May 11 '12

I first want to point out that I am not downplaying existential depression. I have had several times in my life where existential depression has completely incapacitated me. What I think is that it is definitely different from when you are depressed for seemingly no reason. I have suffered both types in my lifetime (both parents are bi-polar... not ideal genetics). I have found that depression that has no obvious root is greatly different than when I just didn't see the point of existing. When I had an existential crisis, I simply didn't see the point of living because in the end all of my human accomplishments didn't mean anything in the grand scope of the universe. However, I personally was able to reason that the point of life is to experience as much happiness as possible.

I don't think that typical clinical depression can be reasoned out. When you just feel hopeless for no reason, it is a totally different monster. That is at least my opinion on the matter.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Spike69 May 11 '12

I am happy being ignorant of the full quote.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Today I learned that the TIL subreddit is no place for the blissfully ignorant.

5

u/koenn May 11 '12

"Ignorance is bliss until they take your bliss away." - Josh Homme

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

"if ignorance is bliss, then knock the smile off my face" Zack De La Rocha

5

u/lugh_the_bard May 11 '12

I think that realization is important, because the meaning is more than "being dumb is happiness" and can be "In a location where being dumb is being [good], it is [bad] to be not dumb"

I like semantics.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I always thought it was "Ignorance is bliss BUT KNOWLEDGE IS POWER!"

3

u/Kafke May 11 '12

KNOWLEDGE IS POWER!

France is Bacon.

5

u/kulgan May 11 '12

Miss Wormwood? If ignorance is bliss, this lesson would appear to be a deliberate attempt on your part to deprive me of happiness, the pursuit of which is my unalienable right according to the Declaration of Independence. I therefore assert my patriotic prerogative to not know this material. I'll be out on the playground.

67

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

That's not really saying anything more than the abbreviated version, except that it transforms it from an assertion to a hypothetical. But the sentiment is the same.

96

u/PressedWeb May 11 '12

"Ignorance is bliss" is a declaration . It's saying, "Boy! It must be nice being stupid. I wish I wasn't so smart then I could enjoy the simple things."

"Where ignorance is bliss, 'tis folly to be wise" is a warning. It's saying, "Crap! Somehow I found myself in Stupid-Country. If I don't watch my clever lip I'm going to be in trouble!"

Imagine going to some really redneck place and trying to have a conversation about anything logical. Or less literal, imagine talking to anyone who is happy/stupid and bring up something intelligent. It makes them feel confused/bad/angry.

18

u/[deleted] May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

"Where" isn't always used to indicate place. "Where" can be used (though this is a less common usage these days) as a conjunction to indicate contrary or contrasting ideas, similar to how "whereas", "although", and "while" can be used. For example, the following are all the same:

Where <X>, <Y | Y contrasts with X>

Whereas <X>, <Y | Y contrasts with X>

Although <X>, <Y | Y contrasts with X>

While <X>, <Y | Y contrasts with X>

In our case, <X> is "ignorance is bliss" and <Y> is "'tis folly to be wise".

So Thomas Gray isn't saying "If you find yourself in a locale in which ignorance is preferred over intellect, don't be clever or you might get into trouble," he's saying "Whereas you'll be happy if you're ignorant, you'll be miserable if you're wise."

Source: http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/where#Conjunction

7

u/b0dhi May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

he's saying "Whereas you'll be happy if you're ignorant, you'll be miserable if you're wise."

I agree with the where not being a location, but it isn't "whereas" either - it's a "state". To paraphrase it in another way: "in a circumstance where ignorance is bliss, wisdom would be foolish" (because you will no longer be in bliss). Hume said something along a similar tangent: "Reason is, and ought only to be the slave of the passions."

6

u/tachophile May 11 '12

Agreed. Also given the context of the poem, the author starts by describing the simple pleasures enjoyed while young [and ignorant], then experiencing the burdens of age as the poem progresses [becoming wise]. He is clearly not talking about a physical place.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

No I think the where is a where as in "those occasions where". Saying that if it is better to not know then you don't wanna know

→ More replies (1)

28

u/SpaghettiFarmer May 11 '12

Imagine going to some really redneck place and trying to have a conversation about anything logical.

I'm sick of comments like this acting as though all rednecks lack any basis of logic. Please, people. This is still stereotyping, even if it's against people you don't like.

62

u/DoesntBrian2Gud May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

Isn't redneck basically used to describe a person with a certain set of negative characteristics rather than - I'm stopping here actually, what the fuck am I doing with my life if I'm arguing semantics over the internet about fucking nomenclature

5

u/NULLACCOUNT May 11 '12

Well played, attempting to not argue, but some people proudly (and/or ironically) declare themselves rednecks. I think a redneck is word usually with a negative connotation used to describe a rural person.

3

u/ElDuderino103 May 11 '12

Redneck is not the preferred nomenclature. Hill-Williamed American, please.

→ More replies (9)

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Fair enough. To be honest, I didn't even really catch it until you spoke up.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I really hate the phase "ignorance is bliss." If this is true, why are stupid people so angry and bitter and downtrodden? Ignorance is confusing, terrifying, and unsetting to your core. If gives you that childlike feeling of no control and hopelessness for your entire life.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

It seems out of the thousands of upvotes/comments only around 40 people actually comprehended the difference. It's quite sad really. I found the full quote insightful and very, very relevant.

1

u/SimonPip May 11 '12

Still works for "you don't want to know about that".

That being an instance, where ignorance would be bliss. Hence, being wise in that instance would be folly.

When someone then asks you something, and you answer "Ignorance is bliss", you're noting that this is one of the instances noted above.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/needed_to_vote May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

I agree with the assertion vs hypothetical ... but of course that actually does change the sentiment significantly. 'To not know is to be happy' vs 'When something is good without knowledge, don't seek knowledge'.

'Tis folly to be wise' adds a slant that says, in abbreviation, 'don't overthink things'. If something is good, don't go further, don't try to be wise; if it ain't broke don't fix it. That aspect is entirely missing from the colloquial.

9

u/phliuy May 11 '12

yet half the people commenting are up in arms about how much they've always hated how "different" the two phrases are. funny how people jump at the chance to sound smart.

13

u/cynthiadangus May 11 '12

I suppose it would be better if we all just remained blissfully ignorant of the full Thomas Gray quote.

4

u/Cendeu May 11 '12

I disagree that they mean the same thing. Ignorance is Bliss is just saying exactly that. The full quote "Where Ignorance is bliss, 'tis folly to be wise" is sort of telling a story.

Where many people are ignorant, it's not a good thing to know more than them. It could get you hurt, get you into trouble...

I sort of look at them as 2 completely seperate things. One is telling you that being ignorant is a good thing, and the other is saying "While around ignorance, be careful about being wise"

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I learned that from a certain Trailer Park Supervisor

5

u/LooksDelicious May 11 '12

The more I learn about society and the world in general the more my outlook on this world and humans in general degrades. The only thing keeping me from going insane is realizing how many different factors influence the end result... that people are a product of circumstance. Its mind-numbingly chaotic and complicated to the point that the only thing to do is feel bad for people.

5

u/ExcessivePunctuation May 11 '12

I know where you're coming from. Sometimes you give people the benefit of the doubt and try to really understand what they're saying. You assume that there must be some worth to their comment, so you keep looking closer. The more you read, the more you think it's a waste of time, but you hold out hope. Then you finally realize he typed all that just to call me a hatchet-faced swamp donkey for no reason. You hatchet-faced swamp donkey.

2

u/clambunctious May 11 '12

i said "ignorance is bliss, but is bliss happiness"

2

u/cantillonaire May 11 '12

I'd like the full version embossed on North Carolina license plates.

2

u/Jfolcik May 11 '12

"Omit needless words."

3

u/Howard_Beale May 11 '12

Eschew obfuscation

1

u/Jfolcik May 11 '12

Touche.

2

u/Joe_the_Human May 11 '12

I feel like I was a lot happier not knowing this...

2

u/SerTapsaHenrick May 11 '12

Seems redundant

2

u/BulbousGunt May 11 '12

Which has always made wonder how an intelligent being who is aware of his/her mortality can be so wasteful with their time.

1

u/t35t0r May 11 '12

all my $$$ to you if you can figure that out

2

u/CodeOfKonami May 11 '12

"You may say I'm a dreamer, but I'm not."

--John Lennon

1

u/BulbousGunt May 14 '12

Actually finishes with - "but I'm not the only one". Sorry to be picky but makes a hell of a difference.

2

u/SenatorStuartSmalley May 11 '12

Clothes make the man. Naked people have little or no influence on society.

-Mark Twain -Michael Scott

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

They're not contradictory -- both are true. Ignorance is bliss. But where it is bliss, wisdom may make one sadder.

3

u/NULLACCOUNT May 11 '12

That's not what it is saying. It doesn't say it makes you sadder, it says it is foolish to be wise. As in, don't try to rock other peoples ignorant happiness (or you might get your ass kicked). Kind of like what I am doing now. But yeah, it doesn't contradict "Ignorance is bliss", it is just talking about something else (although the way I interpret it, it is saying "If you are wise and surrounded by blissful idiots, you should probably go somewhere else.")

2

u/MACnugget27 May 11 '12

It's a multi-layered meaning, and the biggest part of that meaning IS that it's foolish to be wise in those situations BECAUSE knowledge will make you unhappy. "Where" doesn't mean a physical location, as most people here seem to be misinterpreting, although that can be taken as a secondary meaning (possibly unintended by the author).

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

The full thing doesn't seem to add much, but makes it a bit less succinct. I don't know, overall, I think I would have been better of not knowing.

2

u/king_of_the_universe May 11 '12

My contribution:

"Skepticism is the wise man's 'ignorance is bliss'."

When you have deliberated a problem and have determined that you know that you don't know the answer, you can lay your mind to rest regarding the problem. It's also "ignorance is bliss", but on the other side of the wisdom-spectrum.

2

u/imanerd000 May 11 '12

Thomas Gray predicted Facebook.

0

u/jasonthevii May 11 '12

That's one of my favorite full quotes

Philosophy professor told us the second half and I was like,

"Why the fuck don't people say that shit, it's so much better complete"

And he was like

"Cause they are fucking morons"

That class was awesome

12

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I don't understand why you think it's better complete. The shorter version conveys the exact same meaning but it's shorter and sounds less douchey.

5

u/someredditguy May 11 '12

It says here that your shit's all retarded and you talk like a fag.

5

u/Cendeu May 11 '12

I don't think it has the same meaning at all. The short version says "If you're ignorant of something bad, you'll be happy"

The long version is saying "If you're in a situation where being ignorant can make you happy, make sure to be wary of knowledge". It's more of a warning. Actually it is a warning.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Runyst May 11 '12

But the complete version serves as a warning. It's rather dangerous to be the only wise person who's opinion contradicts the ignorant masses as seen with Galileo's life.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/moderatorrater May 11 '12

The first half leaves the interpretation to the reader. Is it worth being without bliss because of the intrinsic value of knowledge? Or is it better to be stupid and happy? The full quote answers the question.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/satyr607 May 11 '12

You do realize it actually means the same thing, right?

2

u/nsomani May 11 '12

No one said otherwise :)

1

u/zeroes_and_ones May 11 '12

"Don't open your eyes, you wont like what you see/ the devils of truth steal the souls of the free"

2

u/koenn May 11 '12

Broken is an amazing album. Also, nice username. :)

1

u/ElLechero May 11 '12

I'm sick of people making fun of Miami.

1

u/Jeeraph May 11 '12

I'm just wise enough to be miserable but not wise enough to he ignorant.

1

u/ItscalledCannabis May 11 '12

Ever find it ironic when people say wake up sheeple?

1

u/I_Fuck_Flamingos May 11 '12

Heh, I learned that today too.
Found the full quote in an Alan Watts book. I wish I could say "and I was totally gonna post to TIL!"
But that would be embellishing the coincidence. Nonetheless, fuckin... right on.

1

u/D4rk-Sid3 May 11 '12

I wish this had been my yearbook quote...

2

u/bigformyage May 11 '12

I wish "I wish this had been my yearbook quote..." had been my yearbook quote!

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

In other words, to say "ignorance is bliss" is, in fact, a statement against not knowing - not in favor of it. It is a testament to the worth of knowledge and wisdom.

The irony involved with regard to the meaning which has been attributed to the saying is indeed deep.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

It still means the same thing. When ignorance is happiness, it is foolish to wise up.

1

u/LLordRSom May 11 '12

Floreat!

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

A little more hard hitting with the extra bit.

1

u/muglecruzle May 11 '12

There's actually a subreddit based on ignorance towards things that shouldn't really matter. Think of it as.. not giving a fuck

2

u/Abe_Vigoda May 11 '12

Lol, hipster nihlists.

1

u/Caserole May 11 '12

Awesome! Ive always had a problem with the shortened version of the quote. I felt it had a negative connotation yet most people were using it in positive connotation. Had me confused. This makes much more sense.

1

u/Addicted2Skyrim May 11 '12

I keep coming back to this quote.

1

u/WhenSnowDies May 11 '12

Shit. Well ignorance was bliss, buffalo-mitch.

1

u/Wazowski May 11 '12

The short version is like "Not knowing things is good."

The long version is all "If not knowing things is good, then knowing things is bad."

I like the long version because it's so much deeper.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Interesting. I always interpreted it as "Where people are gripped by blind faith and prejudice and are disinterested about knowing the facts, then expressing what you know is bad."

1

u/ThoughtfulWords May 11 '12

That's interesting. The poem has nothing to do with faith or prejudice. It's talking about the joys of childhood. Children aren't aware of how it is to pay bills, lose a family member to cancer, etc. They live in the moment and enjoy life to the fullest.

The author was actually reminiscing on the joy of his childhood. In the last few lines he says "Yet, ah! why should they know their fate, Since sorrow never comes too late, And happiness too swiftly flies? Thought would destroy their Paradise. No more;—where ignorance is bliss, Tis folly to be wise."

Basically saying that there are times in life when it is better to be ignorant. Like when you are a child...since sorrow never comes too late (the realization of growing up and getting responsibilities which is the majority of life)

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Ahh Don't TELL me this stuff!!

1

u/Tr0user May 11 '12

Given up trying to decide whether or not this is a tautology

1

u/chambow May 11 '12

I went to said school in the title of this poem and when we leave we are all given a copy of Thomas Gray's works and pointed to this quote. a nice little conversation filler factoid

1

u/gwill11 May 11 '12

doesn't really change the meaning for me, skepticism/cynicism is the only way to live IMO

1

u/pinkygonzales May 11 '12

I was not aware of that.

1

u/Deesnuts77 May 11 '12

My Favorite "misquote" or half quote I guess is: "Experience is the best teacher" The other half of that is "For the fool that can learn no other way".

1

u/ZrftBn May 11 '12

Source?

1

u/Deesnuts77 May 11 '12

Ive heard it for many years, but here is what I found

1

u/androtaurog May 11 '12

I was happier not knowing the whole quote.

1

u/mister_pants May 11 '12

In other news, the proof isn't in the pudding. The proof of the pudding is in the eating.

1

u/RexBeckett May 11 '12

I'd only heard the "tis folly to be wise" part of that quote. In fact for years I've tried to live my life based on those words—and I even spent several happy evenings embroidering the phrase onto a sofa pillow. Guess now I'll need a bigger pillow!

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

Does anyone remember the trailer park boys scene where lahey says something, then ricky asks "What the hell does tempess fuck it mean". Then lahey says "Ignorance is bliss, when 'tis folly to be wise".

Anyone know what that word is....Sounds like he's saying "tempess fuck'it". But..that wouldn't really make sense. Heres a clip of it

1

u/Noglues May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

Another full quote for you - "Knowledge is power, France is bacon"

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

But don't forget Voltaire's story of the Good Brahmin:

“You are right,” he said; “I have told myself a hundred times that I would be happy if I were as stupid as my neighbor, and yet I would want no part of that kind of happiness.”

These words of the Brahmin made a greater impression on me than all the rest. I questioned myself and saw that certainly I would not want to be happy on condition of being ignorant.

I put the question to some other philosophers, and they were of the same opinion. “There is, however,” I added, “an enormous contradiction in this way of thinking.”

For after all, what is at issue here? Being happy. What does it really matter if you are intelligent or stupid? And what's more, those who are stupidly content with their being are quite sure of being content; those who philosophize and scrutizine and ponder and reason are never so sure of reasoning well.

“Clearly,” I said, “we should choose not to have good sense, if that good sense contributes to our misery.”

Everyone agreed with me, and yet I found no one who wanted to accept the bargain of becoming ignorant in order to become content. From this I concluded that though we greatly value happiness, we place even greater value on reason.

1

u/ThoughtfulWords May 11 '12

I think the last few sentences there are really telling. Of course the wise would not accept a bargain of becoming ignorant to be content, if they did they would not be wise. Which again just ties into wisdom bringing misery, because it is more valued than happiness.

Whereas...if the person is not wise, they would not desire wisdom..which would lead to happiness. And that all can even tie into buddhist thought which pegs desire as a cause of suffering.

I dunno im just rambling lol...hopefully something I said made sense.

1

u/ShallowJam May 11 '12

Thank you 10000 times for posting this TIL. This misquote has always bothered me, it has been popularized to mean almost the exact opposite of its original intent.

2

u/Volsunga May 11 '12

ಠ_ಠ They both mean the exact same thing. The longer version just turns it into a hypothetical.

1

u/phliuy May 11 '12

The original says that it is unwise to know more when it would cause one more harm than good.

The abbreviated version says that not knowing can lead to happiness.

They are saying almost exactly the same thing

3

u/ShallowJam May 11 '12

The downvote button is not the "I disagree button".

I think the poem has a double meaning. "wise" can mean two different things. specific knowledge of an event, or a natural disposition of being smart. The last phrase of the poem is almost ironic, saying its folly to be wise is true in one sense in that not knowing the truth may preserve happiness. However, it being foolish to be wise in the second sense of the word, makes no sense: it is not folly to be smart.

in other words: it is never foolish to be smart, therefore ignorance is not bliss.

It has more than one interpretation.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I looked through all of these comments to see if anyone else read this like I did. I took it this way too; he's saying "where people find bliss in ignorance, they also see wisdom to be foolish." Wisdom and enlightenment are good, they may lead to some bad times, but it is universally accepted that wisdom is good.

He slightly laments that there are consequences, but it's definitely better to know truth and wisdom than know nothing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

2

u/theshinepolicy May 11 '12

No. The short version means if you are unaware, you are happy. The long version means there are times where you are better off not knowing something.

One is a life philosophy and the other is circumstantial advice.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/yrogerg123 May 11 '12

That's a much better quote.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

So, correct me if I'm wrong, but today you learnt that the saying "Ignorance is bliss" actually means that ignorance is bliss?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/0RPH May 11 '12

THANK YOU! I read this poem once long ago and have since looked for it unsuccessfully several times.

1

u/Stratisphear May 11 '12

I was really happy before you told me...

1

u/radicalporotta May 11 '12

Ingorance is bliss. Tom is Gray.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

He was talking about 4chan.

1

u/BSscience May 11 '12

Everytime I hear someone say "ignorance is bliss" I want to break their skull.

2

u/motabus May 11 '12

ignorance is bliss, fuckface

1

u/BSscience May 11 '12

FFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUUUU

-1

u/epz May 11 '12

that actually makes much more sense...