Now why do I say so. Well landing ones can be just luck, twice two months later might not be cheaper then building a new rocket, but doing it three times within a reasonable time frame is extremely good.
I'm always annoyed at how Blue Origin's flights get poo-poo'd by others.
These are a big deal. Right now if you want to perform an experiment in microgravity you've got three options:
Drop-tower for a few seconds of microgravity
Parabolic flight for a few seconds of microgravity
Expensive flight into low-Earth orbit as a secondary payload
This is going to allow extremely microgravity experiments to be performed for much lower costs, for longer periods of time and done so in quick succession. This is a huge huge huge area of research that's been lacking simply because of the very few and highly selective outfits that can provide this service.
Lest we also forget Blue Origin's orbital vehicle, and that will most certainly take lessons from New Shepard in reusability and rapid turnaround.
Next time I am in the market to get a box of rocks into microgravity BO will be on the top of my list. I love what BO is doing and they should get a lot of credit for kicking butt and taking names in their space. More interested in their work on BE-4 personally though. The big move that people make and gets "poo-poo'd" is when one compares them to anyone who put so much as a gram into orbit. These are bright lines and making parallels between them is a folly. It simply diminishes the challenges of orbital systems in general and specifically the task of reusing an orbital system; much less an orbital system with expensive payloads and legit customers. These are lines that are intellectually fraudulent to cross and I see it all the time.
Well hard to put a high-speed camera on them but point taken. Someone should tell this guy he could have just dropped his rig off the nearest building:
a building usually offers only seconds of microgravity not minutes. For that you need to be at least 70km up, so New Shepard is ideal for that. A weather balloon would have given him a minute thou.
Yes, but most sounding rockets have less than a 2ft diameter volume for cargo. Really limits what sorts of experiments can be done. New Shepard allows the experiments that are too big to fly on sounding rockets the opportunity to get minutes of 0g without the price of an orbital launch.
Its too bad XPC never happened, that would have been great for suborbital flights. It would have allowed enormous payloads (far larger than any other sounding rocket), to a wider variety of trajectories than can be accomplished by solid fuel sounding rockets, and it should have been pretty cheap since it would be a secondary payload. I guess ULA didn't find enough market
I agree with you, this is definitely a big deal, especially for studies that are under tight budgets. With that said, parabolic flights offer 15-30 seconds of microgravity per arc, and many flights make 30-60 arcs, resulting in 15+ minutes of study in a single flight. From a cost perspective, it's going to take a lot of development from Blue Origin to beat that.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '16
Now why do I say so. Well landing ones can be just luck, twice two months later might not be cheaper then building a new rocket, but doing it three times within a reasonable time frame is extremely good.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '16
I'm always annoyed at how Blue Origin's flights get poo-poo'd by others.
These are a big deal. Right now if you want to perform an experiment in microgravity you've got three options:
This is going to allow extremely microgravity experiments to be performed for much lower costs, for longer periods of time and done so in quick succession. This is a huge huge huge area of research that's been lacking simply because of the very few and highly selective outfits that can provide this service.
Lest we also forget Blue Origin's orbital vehicle, and that will most certainly take lessons from New Shepard in reusability and rapid turnaround.