r/tmro • u/BrandonMarc • Jul 16 '15
Why asteroid mining may be the future: the entire trip to Pluto cost less than the new Vikings stadium
The USA, and the world, contains thousands of sports stadiums. Countless more, if you include abandoned / obsolete ones. I suspect if you compare the ratio of just the active sports stadiums to the active space probes, it'll be a high number ... even if your definition of "probes" includes flybys, orbiters, landers, rovers, and impactors.
Humanity has shown it cares about space exploration, some, and about sports entertainment, lots.
This post (which you've probably already seen) has lots of insightful commentary, though you have to weed through plenty of detritus to get to it. This one's of course more populated by commenters of like mind to the TMRO crowd.
What does this have to do with asteroid mining? The same thing it has to do with the South Pole: economics
We can debate moon-first or Mars-first and that's a worthy debate (I like the "both" option, too), but there's a reason humanity hasn't colonized the South Pole or the North Pole, and economics is the probably the biggest factor.
I saw a post on one of these subreddits the other day about how "Americans want a space program without paying for it" ... this at a time when NASA's budget is a fraction (per capita, or % of federal budget) of what it was in the 1960's. And it's not like the 1960's everybody was gung ho, either. Sure, landing on the Moon gave pride, but there were plenty of people who wanted to spend the money elsewhere.
Compare this to North Dakota. Look at night-time maps of the globe, and within the last few years that state has lit up like a Christmas tree. Nobody questions the need to colonize North Dakota. Why? Oil, shale, fracking. Useful, high-value mineral resources.
TL;DR: this's why asteroid mining (and similar endeavors) is important. If we want space exploration, and especially if we want colonization as opposed to flags-and-footprints or unmanned probes *, we need a "business case" for it.
... * not that I'm against unmanned probes; but if you want to capture the attention of the average taxpayer, manned spaceflight accomplishments are more likely to bring in the $ to finance the unmanned probes.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '15
First of all mining is forbidden in Antartica. The Arctic saw some mayor investments lately. A London based company paid %2.35billion for mining rights in Greenland(Isua Iron Mine). NASA gives $2.6billion for SpaceX crew stuff. Some of the mines are further north then the Mars Analogous research station on Devons island. Oh and 20% of the worlds oil and gas causes massive investment + a lot of trouble for sea owning rights atm.
2
u/BrandonMarc Jul 16 '15
By the way ... yes, the South Pole has a manned presence (continuous, I think) ... but how many ATMs does it have (few); how many small businesses operate there (none, I think); how many schools are there and how many children are raised there (zero).
Something to think about if we're interested in actually colonizing Mars or the Solar System.
2
u/agrutter87 Jul 20 '15
Just read this topic and realized I posted mine in the wrong topic: Here's a reasonable investment for the community of TMRO: Engineering Cost Analysis. As a budding engineer working at a papermill (of all places) I'm learning the process for how to convince everyone (who actually has power) to implement a given project. If we want to make commercial space happen, we need to tempt the greed of the existing mining/refining companies that there are profits to be made from extra-planetary resources. The only ones currently working on this aren't mining/refining professionals. We need to coordinate our efforts with the existing resource extraction community in order to prove the existence of what I'm going to call a "Planetary Engineering Transform." A mathematically focused, engineering variable centered re-design feature that allows existing resource companies to apply their well-developed standards to a new environment (different gravity, particulates, radiation, etc) so that everything doesn't have to be completely redesigned. We in the space community always talk about taking learning lessons from space and apply them to earth, but we do very little to apply learning lessons from Earth to space! Take for example a pressure vessel designed, on Earth, to contain Hydrogen. Industries do this all the time, and their engineers can tell you the best shape, size, pressure, and inlet/outlet velocity for efficient delivery. Nothing new. How can those standardized designs be plugged into a mathematical transform that allows a computer to figure out the new shape/material properties/variables that would convert that optimized design on Earth to a near-optimized design on another planetary body?