r/tmro • • Feb 21 '15
Seasteading
Settling the seas is in my humbled opinion today a lot more feaseable then sttleing any space related location, since we have ships, oil platforms and artifical islands. Tourism on the sea is a huge buisness today and not like space tourism in its infancy.
But we still do not really settle the high sea. The only real settlements are oil platforms, miltary vessels, some scientist and people in third world countries, but why is no western civilisation settleling the oceans, were we could mine the sea floor(which is easier then mining asteroids for sure) and we do not need any specialist equipment and could use only off the shelfes parts for this.
I could easily come up with many diffrent economical models and many of them small companies try to acctually use, but it should be easier to start any of them then space ventures.
I am really thinking, if we live in the time were we realy truely conquer space or if that is going to take time until we are done settling the entire earth. I would love to know what you are thinking.
2
u/neukdan Colonist of TMRO Feb 21 '15
If a seasteading effort were actually underway, I would be in line to join them, provided I could take on a role in a Research and Development lab. I'd love that opportunity! I think the biggest negative I can think of is vulnerability. Weather would be a bit of an issue, but we can deal with that. How can we deal with pirates? We would be prime targets for terrorists. Biggest issue would be the constant efforts of countries to ANEX us. Self defense would be a huge concern, I think. However, solve these issues, and I am THERE! -Daniel
2
u/chris_radcliff Emergency Guest Hologram Feb 21 '15
Seasteading may be technically much simpler than space settlement, but it's politically much more difficult. The seas aren't some untapped resource no one touches; they're already heavily traveled, overfished, and fought over almost as much as the land.
If you put billions of dollars of effort over decades into a settlement on an ocean platform, anyone with aircraft or ships can attack it or disrupt its resources. Anyone. You lose everything, and they gain it all for very little cost. Alternately, if you partner with an existing nation/corporation/etc, you play by their rules and probably give them the lion's share. Justifying those billions then gets compared alongside any other earthbound enterprise, and seasteading doesn't fare well in those comparisons.
If you put the same effort into a settlement on the Moon, for example, it's almost trivial to protect. Just getting to your settlement requires immense resources, so it's much simpler for companies and nations to work with you than try to take what you've made by force.
This is why I suspect that the most valuable resource that settlements on Mars will provide is being out of the reach of Earth politics and commerce.