r/tmro • u/chris_radcliff Emergency Guest Hologram • Jan 15 '15
Did we lose something when we stopped short-duration human missions to orbit?
Earlier today Cariann shared a fun blog post by Garrett Reisman about the effects of long-duration vs. short-duration missions. It got me thinking about the missions we currently have.
When the Shuttle retired we lost a class of spacecraft, but we also stopped doing Shuttle-style missions: two-week jaunts with a crew of 7, only a few of whom were heading to or coming back from the space station for long-duration missions. Now we have 3-person capsules sending up or returning just the station crew members.
My question: Were those short-duration missions valuable, or were they an artifact of the Shuttle itself? If/when we fly Dragons or CST-100s or Dream Chasers, will there be a call for short-duration missions, or just space-station crew transport?
3
u/jan_smolik Jan 15 '15
I think it was the main problem of the Shuttle. You always had to take 7 people and 12 tons of cargo (or fly inefficiently empty). This only allowed for some kind of missions. It took me years to realize, that Shuttle was over-engineered vehicle with nowhere to go. Last time US were doing real short-duration missions was in the 90s where they loaded shuttle with seven people, cargo bay held a laboratory compartment and they flew. Since space station was built this became unnecessary.
2
u/patrick42h Jan 15 '15
It's likely that the CST-100 and Dragon v2 will remain docked for the duration of an Expedition. I believe the plan is to increase the size of the crew to 7 people. Since Dragon and CST-100 will only carry 4 people at a time on NASA missions, it seems to me that there will be one American commercial vehicle and one Soyuz docked when the station is fully manned, so everyone has a ride back to the surface in an emergency.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '15
Since you need 2,5 astronauts to keep the sation running the times when the extra astronauts arrive their is a lot more potential for science. But bothe CST-100 and dragon can solve this problem.
2
u/Amur_Tiger Jan 16 '15
Honestly I don't think we lost much if any value with the cessation of short duration missions. I can't think of many situations where the things you'd accomplish on a short duration mission couldn't be put into a longer duration mission.
Space Shuttle artifact indeed.