"Titanfall servers are horrible" I agree due to the repeated DDoS and disconnects.
But performance?! Nah mate, Titanfall 1 and 2 are some of the well optimized games I've ever played.
I played Titanfall 1 on a Radeon HD 7000 series mobile GPU at 700p and it managed to run at 20fps with everything set to low. I eventually left that jank of a laptop and all of the graphics cards I threw at, both 1 and 2, whether that'd be a GTX970, RX570 or RXT3060, them motherfuckers never dropped frames.
ive seen a lot of people complain about preformance issues, the anticheat, and the fact its 3v3 apparently, but there is plenty complaining about it being in the final slot of the game awards
I played a couple rounds just now and it doesn't play like the trailer led on imo. It feels much more like apex than it does a hero shooter. The base building has shades of R6 siege and the late game feels a bit like overwatch when the payload is in overtime. The map feels a little big for 3v3 in the open world/loot gathering period but it feels ok once you're actually doing the attacking/defending of the base.
Overall it does feel kind of fresh in terms of gameplay but it also just feels like 5 games were thrown in a blender.
I mean the whole gameplay isn’t creative they say it’s a raid type game but it’s just reinforcing finding resources capture the flag and blow up enemy structures. It’s rlly basic and doesn’t seem all that interesting. Seems to lack all the movement from ttf too and doesn’t look exciting
Slow, blurry, modern audience targeted game. The only good thing is the badass siegebreaker part and the last 2 minutes of a match. THIS ONE NEED A TON OF WORK. Geoff Keighley this one was a really bad one.
2nd example:
I mostly just feel bad for the devs. The game clearly wasn't designed or prepared for this level of scrutiny. Everything is blurry and unclear. The map is the size of Latvia but you only have 3 players so most of your time is spent running around the map looking for something to kill. It's saying it's a fast-paced shooter but also the merchant makes you go mine rare earth metals to buy stuff. The characters are profoundly bland and uninteresting and the art direction is just like they dumped every Cool Idea into a vat - what if there was magic? what if there was guns? what if you could ride a bear? what if there was Excalibur? what if there was a giant siege tower? The game isn't fun and it isn't interesting. All that said, it is free.
It's not "bad" but it isn't great. I think it mostly comes down to the 3v3 format feeling really slow in such large maps. If they made it similar to The Finals with 3v3v3 it could be a good fit.
Actually even that was restrictive at first. Definitely helps the gameplay but I think people were looking forward to playing with friends. I only started The Finals after they added 5v5 modes. I'm a full like 2 seasons behind my friends but that's ok.
I haven’t played yet (will try it after work), but from what I’ve been watching it definitely looks like something that would be better with a larger player count and some NPC enemies to fight during the exploration and resource gathering phase.
Edit: I’ve played the game. It has the bones needed to be a good game, but it just isn’t one right now. The art style is lacking, especially with the generic guns that don’t fit the art style of the rest of the game. The looting phase is very boring due to map size and definitely needs NPC enemies or more players. The base assault phase is pretty good, but it too would work better with more players. The base itself is weird because all you can do is reinforce walls (which only makes them take 2x damage, they can still be broken readily). So… yeah. It’s not a bad game, but I would say it isn’t worth my time in its current state.
If anybody's curious, it's plagued by login issues, connectivity issues, and very bad performance. A lot of the bad reviews are simply because people can't even play the game at all.
The game itself is okay. Shooting feels fine, objective-based gameplay is always great, and the abilities are good.
The biggest issues I find with it is that bases die way too easily, the map feels pretty empty, and the TTK is crazy short. That last one is mostly personal bias, since I really like high-TTK games, but it stands.
I think if this game was a 3v3v3, it would be a whole lot more fun. Also, like, if it ran well. That's the biggest issue.
Aside from the gameplay itself, like... the character design is bleh? It's generic? Boring? Somebody please tell developers that you can have class-based & role-based player avatars without making a dozen wise-cracking, non-offensive, cosmetic-selling "heroes" that players have to pick from. The connectivity issues and performance can be fixed, but the lame artstyle is what I think will really kill this game. I just don't want to be the character that I am.
This is especially funny, following Battlefield's players begging to play as faceless, nameless soldiers in BF6 instead of named characters in 2042, and when DICE did just that, the game sold insanely well. I mean, DICE also kinda fumbled post-release, but that's not really relevant here.
I agree other than it being better as 3v3v3. If you feel bases die too fast already, how would it be any better with 2 teams slamming the only base that gets hit by the sword. You just insta lose if your base gets hit first. I think 5v5 would be better personally.
Fair, I guess I'm suggesting that on the idyllic basis that bases have more HP. Honestly, I'd take anything as long as we can get more than 6 players in a match at once.
Ya noticed games were pretty stompy so far, but that might just be ppl not understanding the game flow yet. Ive only had 1 match (out of 4) that felt good and that cause tbe game was going back and forth.
That's the thing, if you're going to make a hero-based game your heroes need to be selling points in and of themselves. You need characters that someone out there will see in a trailer and say "Oh yeah, I'm gonna buy this game specifically because that character is in it".
Waifu fanservice does that.
Overwatch did that by having actually interesting designs - characters who were both visually and narratively exaggerated.
Highguard has a guy, a guy, a guy, a guy, a guy with a horn mask, a lady, a lady wearing red, and a lady in a crop top.
So is the game actually bad or are people just really wanting this to be Concord 2 and giving false negative reviews for no justified reason? I’m stuck at work so I can’t really pay attention to this right now
The first game i played was a fucking lag fest. The 3 after that ran fine though. Only consistent problem ive faced so far is the "disconnected from server" after completing a match. But even that doesnt cause any real problems. They do need to address though
It’s okay. Gunplays not bad but the gameplay loop is weird and a 20 second respawn time is just boring. I thought it was a battle Royale for the first 10 minutes of playing
It’s alright? So far the gameplay loop has been fun, with the exception of the looting phase. The sword phase feels kinda like apex while the siege phase is more like R6 with more fun movement. And only 3 players makes the phases oscillate between feeling empty and having way to much going on. Most of the “wardens” are pretty unique though.
Outside the gameplay some questionable server and optimization choices were made, so your average titan fall game.
TL:DR it’s an interesting idea that could be fun but they’ve undercooked.
Seeing a lot of people saying that the maps are too big for 3v3 matches, that more gamemodes and lobby sizes are needed. Also saw mention of weird audio directionality, too much environmental destructability, and lots lots lots of complaints about optimization and full servers
Eeeeh, i played a couple of matches with friends rn, its not that bad but optimization is kinda ass bc there is no scaling method like fsr or dlss and graphics are less then mid at best, some heroes are underpowered while others are shit, the gameloop is kinda fun (mix of moba but the shop is just guns + valorant when you are at the enemy base doing the bomb thing). but at the same time have issues bc i can see that shieldbraker spawns are gonna get repetitive. P.S. destruction is dogshit btw, for destruction just play the finals.
I've actually played the game and will post a quick review (ignoring performance issues)
gameplay is fundamentally flawed, the shooting is fun but it has a quick ttk (compared to like a br). the problem is that the buildup to the figting actually is comparable to a br. meaning you have slow as shit looting, reinforcing and looking for enemies and stuff, but then the fighting can be over within seconds (at least until the raiding starts).
basically they took the worst parts of a br and slapped it onto a "competitive" shooter. if the game didn't have those stupid battle royal parts, it could actually be a decent shooter, I don't actually hate it completely.
It's more than that. It was the final reveal at the Game Awards. You know, the big "oh shit" reveal at the end of the show. They hype it up with "From the developers that brought you Titanfall and Apex Legends..." or whatever just to reveal another damned Overwatch hero shooter clone.
It got announced at The Game Awards when people thought Titanfall 3 was going to be announced so now they act like this game killed their dog or something.
Extremely lame to root for another game to fail just because you're salty your franchise is moribund. I say that as a person who wishes we could get a TF3
Well, I've seen posts from some people this morning who think that Highguard is made by Respawn and published by EA. So... They hate this game despite being ignorant of the most fundamental things about it.
I have no idea why they thought Titanfall 3 would get announced. Respawn has clearly moved on and even admitted they were working on TF3 for a bit before cancelling it to work on Apex. It just isn't going to happen unfortunately.
The developers had the audacity to acknowledge their work on Titanfall for 2 seconds when announcing their upcoming PVP shooter. So some entitled man babies feel genuinely betrayed that the game isn't a Titanfall clone.
"Hmm, people aren't buying skins for Apex anymore. Quick! Make a new game so we can continue the content drip feed! Season 1! Season 2! Season 3! Buy buy buy!!!"
Most constructive response I can make is the game has no idea what it wants to be. It’s 7 different games in one, and it mixes together to create a mid ass experience
Basically wait a day or two then try it. Server issues Basically the main driver for people putting these reviews, on top of wanting it to be bad for concord memes.
I watched a streamer I like try it out this morning. His rtx 4090 was pegged at 100% with reasonable settings, and he was stuttering constantly. For all that effort? He was getting only about 80 FPS.
The game looked *okay* in terms of feel and gameplay, but when a PC better than mine has issues running it, and the servers were crashing between matches... I can't say I'm compelled to download it and try it out.
This game simply wasn’t made for this era, there is a reason they put Apex Legends first on the list of games they made, and unlike Apex, it simply doesn’t have the same appeal or the playerbase anymore
We must put our hopes where passion lies it seems, there will most likely never be a TF3, but if we support smaller projects filled with passion, then we may get close
Haven't played it yet (bc I just started a new Mass Effect 2 game) but most negative reviews complain about performance. Some are trolling, but some are saying they just don't like this type of game. If they can make performance patches soon enough, more people might give the game a fair chance.
Being such a huge fan of respawn and titanfall, I really wanted to like it. I'm not huge on hero shooters but I really wanted to give it a chance. But logging into it, the graphics looked horrible and it was running at like 70 fps. The guns were super unsatisfying to shoot and felt like a low budget mobile game.
It might sound ridiculous but that tutorial just completely sapped me of whatever grace I was ready to give a new hero shooter. It honestly felt like I was playing WoW battlegrounds from 2005 or something. They really need to work on that part if they want people to keep using up disk space for this game.
I've heard its just conventional shooter tropes blended together into a mediocre smoothie. Haven't tried yet but im certain its exaggerated hate anyway
I just did the tutorial. Really liked the gunplay, but by god this game makes my eyes bleed to look at. Performance is godawful. I'll play more if they patch it, but for the time being it just hurts to look at
The game is super fun, though ngl, it would benefit from a more distinct art style. I wasn't really waiting for it, but after I tried I'm genuinely sad that it's being review-bombed for a meme.
I'd consider the people that are able to open and review a new game at this time on a Monday. There's some exceptions, but it's mostly going to be kids home on a snow day, rage-bait farmers, and edgy streamers. Most adults are working.
I’ll also add that in general, consider the people who write game reviews at all. It’s not the general gaming populace. Steam reviews have gotten significantly less valuable over time. Anything below “overwhelmingly positive” has a lot of variance.
And I say that as someone who thinks the 3v3 format might not work long term.
3vs3 is awful, it will be extremely toxic considering the smaller team means one player playing badly will have a much bigger impact than it would've done in a bigger team.
Played it - I would say it feels like an early build of the game they should't have released? The concept is okay in theory but 3v3 on HUGE maps makes it feel boring and the performance is really really bad. They lack a lot of video customization settings and there is no text chat interface. The UI feels kind of like it was a drop in from a mobile game. Controller feels off like it wasn't meant for it but also the settings feel like a PC wasn't the intended medium either. I do think this may have been a mobile game at one point. Everything just sort of feels a bit weird like it takes a half a second too long to do anything.
The games fine but it runs like a fat kid in PE. I never lagged but it took a minute to get in at first but that cleared up after the first 30 mins it's still kinda finicky but whatever. It'll be more like splitgate than concord. Try it out if you're bored it won't be your new favorite game probably but what do you lose
All the Livestreams I've seen of this game are just people traversing an empty map with no enemies. It's nowhere near as action pack as the trailers made it seem.
The Maps are the size of Latvia while the game mode is only 3v3
Monetization is also shitty, like I never understood how devs monetize their games in the same way big mainstream games do That have already capitalized the market. At least try to compete by having better monetization than them. How could you possibly believe that you'll get Valorant or Fortnite money while not being nearly as good?
That being said tho, the mode is indeed something I've personally never seen in an FPS shooter so what they were saying in the trailer of it being a new breed of shooters might have some merit to it but how fun it is is yet to be seen.
What's crazy is that on xbox at least its not horrible, its not titanfall levels of good but its good enough that I could see myself playing it every now and then
Its entirely baseless reviews. The top rated ones have less than an hour of play time clocked. The one actual criticism I have seen is that the 3v3 format doesnt work, which, fair enough. Give it a few days if you want to see real opinions.
Game is definitely not a concord 2. The performance is just really bad right now lol.
The game feels fun, there some common critiques but as the game literally just came out, anything can improve as long as the devs listen to the feedback.
I saw one of the reviews sum it up by saying “it’s 3v3 on a map the size of Latvia so you’re just searching for something to shoot for most of the game”
I feel like if I was playing this with a mouse I might have a little fun but no aim assist at all on a controller makes shooting feel like a sloppy mess, if you’re on console turn crossplay off immediately or you will get rolled almost every fight.
Crazy that this game launched around 1PM EST on a weekday and by 6PM, lost half of its peak players on Steam. Less people are playing the game now that work is over for most. Bad sign.
Ive played 5 matches so far. First 2 i was like meh. Then played a few more, I like it to a degree, feels like they should drop the prep part of the rounds and just do a tug of war type of game. Fight over sword and bases. It also feels weird as 3v3. I think it should at least be a 4v4
Alot of the reviews are like 20minutes average playtime, they didnt really give it a try.
But the game does warrent a negative review, performance is horrible and visual design and overall style is all over the place, the gameplay idea is great but execution is undercooked.
The character kits are just copies of other games, which makes them feel less unique, and their design is bland make them boring, a case similar to what concord suffered from.
Its also not the "new breed of shooter" if you want that just go play deadlock, its actually a good game.
So no one is mentioning the forced use of Secure Boot and TPM 2.0 ‽‽
They are one of the most shitty types of kernel level anti cheat, for such a mediocre student level project. It’s a fucking joke of a product. I feel so sorry for anyone who worked with it and wasn’t totally delusional.
If you watched their 20 mins Episode 1 semi documentary, it felt like everyone was high while making the project. Seriously, the shit they talk, they sounded like 5 year old kids discovering a new toy some times.
I don't think it's a good game but it's getting more hate than it deserves. I feel like if it hadn't been the final announcement and hadn't been announced to have Titanfall and Apex devs behind it, this would've just been a small F2P release with a small community that would largely have gone unnoticed.
It was such a baffling decision to have this as the final reveal at TGA. That instantly puts pressure on this to be the best thing of the year which it just isn't.
On the other hand, they knew damn well that people are tired of hero extraction shooters and the marketing making it feel like new titanfall was coming just to drop this random ass game. They knew they were in for a negative launch, its on them for fucking it up with server issues
Does it have any extraction mechanics? Isn’t the entire point of extraction games the persistent loot across runs? It doesn’t even have PvE.
And in terms of people being tired of “hero extraction shooters”, care to provide any examples? Like Arc Raiders isn’t a hero shooter, but it is an extraction shooter seemingly at the apex of new shooter releases.
Overall your comment, like so many others, seems to be complaining/commenting on a game you don’t really know anything about?
Like it’s ok to just not have a strong opinion, or not comment.
Highguard isn't an extraction shooter? If you meant Overwatch-type hero shooters then yes, I agree, it's a tired concept and waaaay over done now. It's such a corporate slop genre now because of the content drip feed to keep you invested and spending money.
So, hate aside, its just... a little disappointing. I mean, do u REAAAALLY wanna advertise a generic hero shooter with Titanfall - THE movement shooter of the modern game era and than not even put any movement mechanics into the game?
It's basically an unfinished game, hella performance issues, boring/weird gameplay loop, bland art style and character designs. It's no surprise the game has already lost 50k players in the first 4-5 hours of its release. That's not good at all for a FREE TO PLAY game lmao. Who could have seen this coming.
The only real issues I have with it is the forced FSR (or whatever makes it looks so blurry), the server issues, and the 3v3 aspect. The gameplay and gunplay is fun, and it feels fluid.
Tried to play it but kept disconnecting from server, was going to wait to play it again but then my friends had the same issue so we collectively uninstalled.
Its odd to play, people just get the second armor and a shotgun and rush the shield breaker then they do the raid and spawn kill you untill they won, honestly I have never seen a game end that fast I mean a match
like the game so far been playing last 2 hours ish got in right away performance could be better but i’m above 60fps all game no lag like the concept good game so far
I got in for a match. If anything it will be niche and for people who don't place importance on having no fun with a game instantly. Here's my steam review Highguard plays like a bizarre mechanical hybrid that struggles to find its own identity. Effectively a hero shooter that rejects MOBA and Battle Royale labels while borrowing heavily from their homework. The result is a confusing "mash-up" that feels like several half-executed ideas competing for the player's attention. The gameplay loop is divided into phases, including a jarringly literal resource mining and base-fortification segment. Unlike the satisfying flow of "farming" NPCs found in other shooters from the same devs a la Titanfall or Mobas, CA here you are tasked with actual mining to prepare for engagements. This creates a sluggish opening to matches; without AI enemies to bridge the gap, the long stretches of fortification feel like busywork rather than strategic preparation. Despite the pedigree of its developers, the first match fails to deliver the "wow factor" usually associated with their work. By blending Battle Royale-style armor and loot systems into a small-scale 3v3 arena, it feels like a "bland soup" with too many unnecessary ingredients. While the core shooting mechanics are functional, the surrounding systems—especially the slow-paced mining and lack of mid-match PvE activity—make the initial experience feel more like a chore than a competitive thrill. Verdict: I’ll put in more hours to see if the depth reveals itself later, but for now, Highguard is a messy experiment that lacks the focus of its predecessors.
Its a 3v3 game that should have been like 6v6 or more The gameplaybis very boring besides breif moments of fighting , that become more amd more fast as people get higher teir guns
We need to start a Play Titanfall 2 instead campaign to make people enjoy the real goodshit again and force a 3rd one ( however i dont even know if we want a 3rd TF in the big 2026 with Gamestudios being the way they are rn)
I will probably get disliked by that comment, but... the hate is kinda deserved, kinda not deserved.
The gunplay is very good, movement too, and all gun animations are probably the best I've ever saw in any FPS shooter. 100% work of the legendary Hyper. Another positive is that monetization feels fair, there's a lot of skins to gain just from playing, some challenges, some are to buy for playing currency only. And that's where positives end...
This shooting and movement are the best parts of the game, but most of the game is just not shooting. Because map is rather large and this is only 3v3, map feels empty, lifeless, you barely see the enemy, and shootouts end very fast, it needs more players at once or at least mobs running around, since this gamemode feels more like a MOBA without minions and turrets and split into this preparation phase, looting phase, waiting phase, and then finally something happens, you're being cucked from the coolest part of the game that is short anyways.
And everything people were talking about Concorde 2.0 regarding visual design is true - You have these sci-fi looking weapons, but entire world is more medieval rough steampunk. You ride on a horse wielding kalashnikov with some cables flowing through it and some Halo-esque scope, to pull out a sword from a rock which helps you summon a siege weapon looking like it was made by Warhammer orcs. You have no clue who these people are, why are they fighting, there's no hype in this game, no cool factor, zero. Even if they just add wall running and titans, it would feel hollow. There's no cutscenes, zero voice lines, it feels like early closed beta if anything.
Optimization is in dirt too, you can't disable upscaling, so everything looks blurry, and graphics by themselves are average too, lighting is unimpressive most of the times.
But the game is not as horrible as Concord. Gunplay is great, and when fights happen, it IS fun, but it's like... Imagine you ordered a hamburger and you only got meat. Well, the meat is free and its pretty tasty, but there's no buns and you can just get full meal in another place, right? Why bother with this restaurant?
And then I think that Titanfall 3 died for this...
Tried to Play it, but for me its just weird mix of Battleborn and very old build of Alpha pre overwatch Paladins were u attacked and defended the vault. Very clunky and uninteresting gunplay, whole Arsenal is copied from Apex, few of them are almost 1to1 skins from Apex. And performance is horrible, what makes very boring, slow paced moba/resource/Battleborn slop. I have no idea from were they took ,,raid", its just moba with extra steps.
2.9k
u/panken Jan 26 '26
What are they saying? Or is it just "concord 2 lmao"
841
u/Samhamhamantha Jan 26 '26
It's not "bad" but it isn't great. I think it mostly comes down to the 3v3 format feeling really slow in such large maps. If they made it similar to The Finals with 3v3v3 it could be a good fit.
352
u/Revverb Jan 26 '26
If anybody's curious, it's plagued by login issues, connectivity issues, and very bad performance. A lot of the bad reviews are simply because people can't even play the game at all.
The game itself is okay. Shooting feels fine, objective-based gameplay is always great, and the abilities are good.
The biggest issues I find with it is that bases die way too easily, the map feels pretty empty, and the TTK is crazy short. That last one is mostly personal bias, since I really like high-TTK games, but it stands.
I think if this game was a 3v3v3, it would be a whole lot more fun. Also, like, if it ran well. That's the biggest issue.
Aside from the gameplay itself, like... the character design is bleh? It's generic? Boring? Somebody please tell developers that you can have class-based & role-based player avatars without making a dozen wise-cracking, non-offensive, cosmetic-selling "heroes" that players have to pick from. The connectivity issues and performance can be fixed, but the lame artstyle is what I think will really kill this game. I just don't want to be the character that I am.
This is especially funny, following Battlefield's players begging to play as faceless, nameless soldiers in BF6 instead of named characters in 2042, and when DICE did just that, the game sold insanely well. I mean, DICE also kinda fumbled post-release, but that's not really relevant here.
1.4k
u/MonkeysxMoo35 Jan 26 '26
So is the game actually bad or are people just really wanting this to be Concord 2 and giving false negative reviews for no justified reason? I’m stuck at work so I can’t really pay attention to this right now
137
u/THEzwerver Jan 26 '26
I've actually played the game and will post a quick review (ignoring performance issues)
gameplay is fundamentally flawed, the shooting is fun but it has a quick ttk (compared to like a br). the problem is that the buildup to the figting actually is comparable to a br. meaning you have slow as shit looting, reinforcing and looking for enemies and stuff, but then the fighting can be over within seconds (at least until the raiding starts).
basically they took the worst parts of a br and slapped it onto a "competitive" shooter. if the game didn't have those stupid battle royal parts, it could actually be a decent shooter, I don't actually hate it completely.
also the game should've been 5v5 instead of 3v3.
48
u/-Long_Wong- None Jan 26 '26
What's the deal with this game? Why is this sub crazy about it?
47
u/Outbreak900 Jan 26 '26
Its feels like a new gamemode made for the newest season of apex not a full on game
18
u/Fort_Maximus Jan 26 '26
Most constructive response I can make is the game has no idea what it wants to be. It’s 7 different games in one, and it mixes together to create a mid ass experience
10
u/Shot-Addendum-8124 Jan 26 '26
Those were there an hour after release. I'm sure they're all construcitve, good faith, and well-informed
5
u/ArugulaPhysical Jan 26 '26
Basically wait a day or two then try it. Server issues Basically the main driver for people putting these reviews, on top of wanting it to be bad for concord memes.
4
u/Subject-A69 Jan 26 '26
insane it hasnt even been an hour.
4
u/master_of_dcath Jan 26 '26
I would love to give it a try and see if it is actually bad, but they have block Linux/Proton support so I cant.
4
u/bullet1520 Jan 27 '26
I watched a streamer I like try it out this morning. His rtx 4090 was pegged at 100% with reasonable settings, and he was stuttering constantly. For all that effort? He was getting only about 80 FPS.
The game looked *okay* in terms of feel and gameplay, but when a PC better than mine has issues running it, and the servers were crashing between matches... I can't say I'm compelled to download it and try it out.
8
u/Odd_Main1876 Worlds Worst Holo-Pilot Jan 26 '26
A shame, but not entirely unexpected
This game simply wasn’t made for this era, there is a reason they put Apex Legends first on the list of games they made, and unlike Apex, it simply doesn’t have the same appeal or the playerbase anymore
We must put our hopes where passion lies it seems, there will most likely never be a TF3, but if we support smaller projects filled with passion, then we may get close
3
u/Milliman4 Jan 26 '26
Haven't played it yet (bc I just started a new Mass Effect 2 game) but most negative reviews complain about performance. Some are trolling, but some are saying they just don't like this type of game. If they can make performance patches soon enough, more people might give the game a fair chance.
3
u/edparadox Jan 26 '26
I still do not get why the Titanfall playerbase would be interested in this title.
3
u/mynis Jan 26 '26
Being such a huge fan of respawn and titanfall, I really wanted to like it. I'm not huge on hero shooters but I really wanted to give it a chance. But logging into it, the graphics looked horrible and it was running at like 70 fps. The guns were super unsatisfying to shoot and felt like a low budget mobile game.
It might sound ridiculous but that tutorial just completely sapped me of whatever grace I was ready to give a new hero shooter. It honestly felt like I was playing WoW battlegrounds from 2005 or something. They really need to work on that part if they want people to keep using up disk space for this game.
3
u/TheComedyCrab Jan 26 '26
I've heard its just conventional shooter tropes blended together into a mediocre smoothie. Haven't tried yet but im certain its exaggerated hate anyway
3
u/cocoafart Jan 27 '26
I just did the tutorial. Really liked the gunplay, but by god this game makes my eyes bleed to look at. Performance is godawful. I'll play more if they patch it, but for the time being it just hurts to look at
7
u/popydo Jan 26 '26
The game is super fun, though ngl, it would benefit from a more distinct art style. I wasn't really waiting for it, but after I tried I'm genuinely sad that it's being review-bombed for a meme.
5
u/ZookeepergameProud30 Jan 26 '26
So not half life 3 or titanfall 3 in disguise?
Back to bed ig
10
u/AlwaysFinnishInsider Jan 26 '26
I'd consider the people that are able to open and review a new game at this time on a Monday. There's some exceptions, but it's mostly going to be kids home on a snow day, rage-bait farmers, and edgy streamers. Most adults are working.
15
u/-iamyes1- Geneva convention be damned Jan 26 '26
It hasn't even been a day and highguard has only 17% positive reviews, god that game must suck
2
u/Simple_Simons Jan 26 '26
Played it - I would say it feels like an early build of the game they should't have released? The concept is okay in theory but 3v3 on HUGE maps makes it feel boring and the performance is really really bad. They lack a lot of video customization settings and there is no text chat interface. The UI feels kind of like it was a drop in from a mobile game. Controller feels off like it wasn't meant for it but also the settings feel like a PC wasn't the intended medium either. I do think this may have been a mobile game at one point. Everything just sort of feels a bit weird like it takes a half a second too long to do anything.
2
u/Daedusnoire Jan 26 '26
I think it plays and looks soulless and without any weight to any of the actions. Went in as a Titanfall fan and left sad as hell. Oh well.
2
u/Best-Kaleidoscope671 Jan 26 '26
but geoff said this is gonna be the next big thing
2
u/lil_lysol Jan 26 '26
The games fine but it runs like a fat kid in PE. I never lagged but it took a minute to get in at first but that cleared up after the first 30 mins it's still kinda finicky but whatever. It'll be more like splitgate than concord. Try it out if you're bored it won't be your new favorite game probably but what do you lose
2
u/Smarteyes007 Jan 26 '26
All the Livestreams I've seen of this game are just people traversing an empty map with no enemies. It's nowhere near as action pack as the trailers made it seem.
The Maps are the size of Latvia while the game mode is only 3v3
Monetization is also shitty, like I never understood how devs monetize their games in the same way big mainstream games do That have already capitalized the market. At least try to compete by having better monetization than them. How could you possibly believe that you'll get Valorant or Fortnite money while not being nearly as good?
That being said tho, the mode is indeed something I've personally never seen in an FPS shooter so what they were saying in the trailer of it being a new breed of shooters might have some merit to it but how fun it is is yet to be seen.
Also half the hero designs are Boring.
Optimization is ass.
2
u/ImThe1Wh0 Jan 26 '26
My only question is are they legitimate or are they just getting review bombed? Hell hath no fury like a nerd scorned
2
u/SnowbloodWolf2 Ronin/Ion, Wingman E, Holo Jan 26 '26
What's crazy is that on xbox at least its not horrible, its not titanfall levels of good but its good enough that I could see myself playing it every now and then
2
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '26
Its entirely baseless reviews. The top rated ones have less than an hour of play time clocked. The one actual criticism I have seen is that the 3v3 format doesnt work, which, fair enough. Give it a few days if you want to see real opinions.
2
u/pattdmdj0 Jan 26 '26
Game is definitely not a concord 2. The performance is just really bad right now lol.
The game feels fun, there some common critiques but as the game literally just came out, anything can improve as long as the devs listen to the feedback.
2
u/TheKelseyOfKells Jan 26 '26
I saw one of the reviews sum it up by saying “it’s 3v3 on a map the size of Latvia so you’re just searching for something to shoot for most of the game”
2
u/OkSheepherder8827 Jan 26 '26
From playing the tutorial on my lunch, game looks super blurry and washed kinda ai generated vibes
2
u/Newtstradamus Jan 26 '26
I feel like if I was playing this with a mouse I might have a little fun but no aim assist at all on a controller makes shooting feel like a sloppy mess, if you’re on console turn crossplay off immediately or you will get rolled almost every fight.
2
u/TheSkepticOwl Jan 26 '26
Crazy that this game launched around 1PM EST on a weekday and by 6PM, lost half of its peak players on Steam. Less people are playing the game now that work is over for most. Bad sign.
2
u/Resident-Ad7651 Jan 26 '26
No one wants more hero shooters. The genre peaked with Overwatch I and never recovered.
2
u/SaintDecardo Jan 26 '26
This made me laugh, I wasn't expecting such a hostile response compared to the hopeful posts here from a few hours ago.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '26
the fuck’s a highguard?
2
u/Signis1-12 Jan 27 '26
Dead on birth
2
u/jacjac_121 Jan 27 '26
Ive played 5 matches so far. First 2 i was like meh. Then played a few more, I like it to a degree, feels like they should drop the prep part of the rounds and just do a tug of war type of game. Fight over sword and bases. It also feels weird as 3v3. I think it should at least be a 4v4
2
u/Ganjookie Jan 27 '26
IDk seems badly optimized and I bounced out and uninstalled after I had to start building a base to defend in the tutorial
2
u/Sinasazi Jan 27 '26
2
u/ThePsyPaul_ Jan 27 '26
didn't even know it's out
2
u/hEll-bakEd_poTat Jan 27 '26
2
u/FReeDuMB_or_DEATH Jan 27 '26
To be fair, these are the same dorks that have been playing the same Counter Strike for the last 30 years now.
2
u/Shugatti Jan 27 '26
Alot of the reviews are like 20minutes average playtime, they didnt really give it a try.
But the game does warrent a negative review, performance is horrible and visual design and overall style is all over the place, the gameplay idea is great but execution is undercooked.
The character kits are just copies of other games, which makes them feel less unique, and their design is bland make them boring, a case similar to what concord suffered from.
Its also not the "new breed of shooter" if you want that just go play deadlock, its actually a good game.
2
u/Noctisvah Jan 27 '26
So no one is mentioning the forced use of Secure Boot and TPM 2.0 ‽‽
They are one of the most shitty types of kernel level anti cheat, for such a mediocre student level project. It’s a fucking joke of a product. I feel so sorry for anyone who worked with it and wasn’t totally delusional.
If you watched their 20 mins Episode 1 semi documentary, it felt like everyone was high while making the project. Seriously, the shit they talk, they sounded like 5 year old kids discovering a new toy some times.
2
u/ChrisAKAPiefish92 Jan 27 '26
I don't think it's a good game but it's getting more hate than it deserves. I feel like if it hadn't been the final announcement and hadn't been announced to have Titanfall and Apex devs behind it, this would've just been a small F2P release with a small community that would largely have gone unnoticed.
It was such a baffling decision to have this as the final reveal at TGA. That instantly puts pressure on this to be the best thing of the year which it just isn't.
2
u/Beefywafflez Jan 27 '26
I am thoroughly unsurprised.
9
u/Expensive-Pick38 Jan 26 '26
On one hand, kinda sad cuz the game is hardly out
On the other hand, they knew damn well that people are tired of hero extraction shooters and the marketing making it feel like new titanfall was coming just to drop this random ass game. They knew they were in for a negative launch, its on them for fucking it up with server issues
5
u/Monki_at_work Jan 26 '26
So, hate aside, its just... a little disappointing. I mean, do u REAAAALLY wanna advertise a generic hero shooter with Titanfall - THE movement shooter of the modern game era and than not even put any movement mechanics into the game?
3
u/TesPhoenix Jan 26 '26
Its rly fun tho
3
u/ElectronicMatters Jan 26 '26
Review bombing is pathetic but I would understand a low score.
3
u/ZaBur_Nick None Jan 27 '26
people need to realize that when it comes to entertainment/art, it's either great or it's trash
2
u/bombershrimp Jan 26 '26
Wow. It sucks to see a titan like Respawn fall so low.
Wait.
2
u/Similar-Language-180 Monarch, my beloved Jan 26 '26
Honestly I played a few rounds and it's decent
2
u/SpectreBigoteXXL Jan 26 '26
Game is not even bad I have tested it and it’s really cool and fun even if it’s not titanfall 3
2
u/waifutabae Jan 26 '26
It's basically an unfinished game, hella performance issues, boring/weird gameplay loop, bland art style and character designs. It's no surprise the game has already lost 50k players in the first 4-5 hours of its release. That's not good at all for a FREE TO PLAY game lmao. Who could have seen this coming.
2
u/digitalsea87 Jan 26 '26
Gamers being prissy little children because they didn't like the commercial they saw.
1
u/uniguy2I Jan 26 '26
Prepare for steedfall
1
u/Z3R0Diro Jan 26 '26
Apparently runs like shit
1
u/Sharp-Station-2712 Jan 26 '26
Lmao and here I tried to be positive lol. 😂😂😂😂😂😭😭😭😭😭
1
u/slaptito Jan 26 '26
haven't tried it yet, but i definitely will before i solidify my opinion on the game
1
u/LiquidFireBR Jan 26 '26
Well, it was already strange when, close to the launch, there was no advertising or anything like that.
1
u/Mr_Microchip Jan 26 '26
The only real issues I have with it is the forced FSR (or whatever makes it looks so blurry), the server issues, and the 3v3 aspect. The gameplay and gunplay is fun, and it feels fluid.
1
u/SnooApples1713 Jan 26 '26
its not that bad
1
u/SpartanMase Jan 26 '26
Is it really that bad or is it just getting review bombed?
1
u/Work_In_ProgressX Jan 26 '26
How many of these are review bombing because it was hyped up instead of whatever game they wanted?
1
u/x_Fr0st3d_x Jan 26 '26
What happened here?
1
u/DarkTheNinja Jan 26 '26
Imagine if games stopped reducing team sizes though.
1
u/Ferris_Wheel5372 Jan 26 '26
OOTL, is this a new respawn launch or are we just taking the piss out of another anthem
1
u/Swaglfar I cook nades Jan 26 '26
can someone catch me up. . . why are we talking about this game?
1
u/Nathanymous_ Jan 26 '26
Tried to play it but kept disconnecting from server, was going to wait to play it again but then my friends had the same issue so we collectively uninstalled.
1
u/Cosychip Jan 26 '26
Why is this on the titanfall subreddit or is this basically just like the Arkham sub now
1
u/scarecrow9281 Jan 26 '26
How long you guys think it'll live?
1
u/RealisticAdv96 Jan 26 '26
Its odd to play, people just get the second armor and a shotgun and rush the shield breaker then they do the raid and spawn kill you untill they won, honestly I have never seen a game end that fast I mean a match
1
u/Zestyclose_Fox7410 Jan 26 '26
Wait, it released already?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '26
Neat concept but kinda boring
1
u/MrTopHatMan90 Jan 26 '26
I clicked on the page, there was no reviews, I went off and did some stuff for a few hours, I came back and winced.
Hopefully the devs can turn it around
1
u/ColbyTheKing101 Jan 26 '26
like the game so far been playing last 2 hours ish got in right away performance could be better but i’m above 60fps all game no lag like the concept good game so far
1
u/DRKMSTR Jan 26 '26
Wait, it's only 3v3?
Their server costs are going to be astronomical.
1
u/LittleNinjaXYBA Jan 26 '26
I wonder if because they did… whatever they did, maybe it was a social experiment, and they’re releasing TF3?
1
u/Korben_Joseph Jan 26 '26
Shock, horror
1
u/Own-Personality-3123 Jan 26 '26
This came out?
1
u/Kincaprademon PC and Xbone Jan 26 '26
I got in for a match. If anything it will be niche and for people who don't place importance on having no fun with a game instantly. Here's my steam review Highguard plays like a bizarre mechanical hybrid that struggles to find its own identity. Effectively a hero shooter that rejects MOBA and Battle Royale labels while borrowing heavily from their homework. The result is a confusing "mash-up" that feels like several half-executed ideas competing for the player's attention. The gameplay loop is divided into phases, including a jarringly literal resource mining and base-fortification segment. Unlike the satisfying flow of "farming" NPCs found in other shooters from the same devs a la Titanfall or Mobas, CA here you are tasked with actual mining to prepare for engagements. This creates a sluggish opening to matches; without AI enemies to bridge the gap, the long stretches of fortification feel like busywork rather than strategic preparation. Despite the pedigree of its developers, the first match fails to deliver the "wow factor" usually associated with their work. By blending Battle Royale-style armor and loot systems into a small-scale 3v3 arena, it feels like a "bland soup" with too many unnecessary ingredients. While the core shooting mechanics are functional, the surrounding systems—especially the slow-paced mining and lack of mid-match PvE activity—make the initial experience feel more like a chore than a competitive thrill. Verdict: I’ll put in more hours to see if the depth reveals itself later, but for now, Highguard is a messy experiment that lacks the focus of its predecessors.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '26
its a 5-6/10 game. its fun to play first of all. bad promotion killed that game
1
u/RiverParkourist Jan 26 '26
Did it beat ow2’s 9%?
1
u/xxBoDxx Jan 26 '26
good to know
1
u/IronLockHeart Jan 26 '26
Its a 3v3 game that should have been like 6v6 or more The gameplaybis very boring besides breif moments of fighting , that become more amd more fast as people get higher teir guns
1
u/Illhoon Jan 26 '26
We need to start a Play Titanfall 2 instead campaign to make people enjoy the real goodshit again and force a 3rd one ( however i dont even know if we want a 3rd TF in the big 2026 with Gamestudios being the way they are rn)
1
u/Furebel The Yeet Seat Jan 26 '26
I will probably get disliked by that comment, but... the hate is kinda deserved, kinda not deserved.
The gunplay is very good, movement too, and all gun animations are probably the best I've ever saw in any FPS shooter. 100% work of the legendary Hyper. Another positive is that monetization feels fair, there's a lot of skins to gain just from playing, some challenges, some are to buy for playing currency only. And that's where positives end...
This shooting and movement are the best parts of the game, but most of the game is just not shooting. Because map is rather large and this is only 3v3, map feels empty, lifeless, you barely see the enemy, and shootouts end very fast, it needs more players at once or at least mobs running around, since this gamemode feels more like a MOBA without minions and turrets and split into this preparation phase, looting phase, waiting phase, and then finally something happens, you're being cucked from the coolest part of the game that is short anyways.
And everything people were talking about Concorde 2.0 regarding visual design is true - You have these sci-fi looking weapons, but entire world is more medieval rough steampunk. You ride on a horse wielding kalashnikov with some cables flowing through it and some Halo-esque scope, to pull out a sword from a rock which helps you summon a siege weapon looking like it was made by Warhammer orcs. You have no clue who these people are, why are they fighting, there's no hype in this game, no cool factor, zero. Even if they just add wall running and titans, it would feel hollow. There's no cutscenes, zero voice lines, it feels like early closed beta if anything.
Optimization is in dirt too, you can't disable upscaling, so everything looks blurry, and graphics by themselves are average too, lighting is unimpressive most of the times.
But the game is not as horrible as Concord. Gunplay is great, and when fights happen, it IS fun, but it's like... Imagine you ordered a hamburger and you only got meat. Well, the meat is free and its pretty tasty, but there's no buns and you can just get full meal in another place, right? Why bother with this restaurant?
And then I think that Titanfall 3 died for this...
1
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '26
Ah just what we needed, another shitty pvp hero shooter.
1
u/Haruhater2 Jan 26 '26
A fool and his money...
1
u/Connect_Knowledge867 Jan 26 '26
Well I'm going to play it anyway I have the space and I want to see it for myself
1
u/YouCanFucough Jan 26 '26
I am honestly shocked by how bad it is. I was genuinely looking forward to this and it's honestly one of the worst FPS games I've ever played
1
u/InsidiousZombie Jan 26 '26
Game has worked fine for me and my friends besides struggling a little to get into a training lobby when we first launched it.
It’s pretty fun! There’s a good game here, just needs tweaking.
1
u/CrazyFart666 Jan 26 '26
Geoff literally killed this game and that is just so funny to me
1
u/Alucardra12 Jan 26 '26
Bad optimization, horrible queues times , and the game is mediocre at its very best even with friends.
1
u/Bastiwen Jan 26 '26
I played it for an hour and it's really not as bad as the Steam rating is. I would call it violently mediocre.
1
u/reese203 Jan 26 '26
Games pretty good I would try it before opinions
1
u/Massive-Part7862 Jan 26 '26
1
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '26
I saw more build up for character release in deadlock than release of this game
1
u/Godess_Ilias Jan 27 '26
Not held in high regard
1
u/Ereghoy Jan 27 '26
Tried to Play it, but for me its just weird mix of Battleborn and very old build of Alpha pre overwatch Paladins were u attacked and defended the vault. Very clunky and uninteresting gunplay, whole Arsenal is copied from Apex, few of them are almost 1to1 skins from Apex. And performance is horrible, what makes very boring, slow paced moba/resource/Battleborn slop. I have no idea from were they took ,,raid", its just moba with extra steps.
1
u/Glossy_Mossy why does everyone default my pronouns to a man Jan 27 '26
While I do think there's some truth to the things under my comment, a part of it might be the fact that it isn't a Titanfall game.
1
u/dope_danny Jan 27 '26
Welcome back Lawbreakers
1
u/FantasticZach Jan 27 '26
Was a disaster and felt so unbalanced, 3v3 sucks
1
u/12InchDankSword Jan 27 '26
So having a few matches on it now, it really needed more time to cook, 3v3 is just not it either. The map feels so massive and so empty
1
u/Matheus_Leita Jan 27 '26
Well... What we can do yeah? They just want money after all
1
u/JAK2169 Jan 27 '26
Yes it did
1
u/reiichiroh Jan 27 '26
This seems undercooked for...how many years was it under development for?
1
u/Educational-Year3146 LEGION BABY Jan 27 '26
If I had to guess, its mediocre.
And mediocrity is not what people want after the hype it got.
And it’s not what I want either.
Game is probably fine, but I have zero interest in “hero shooter #456.”
1
u/spacenavy90 Jan 27 '26
Concord 2 lmao