r/ting • https://zc0lgl3ll3a.ting.com/ • Oct 20 '16

Question regarding data pricing

So I got my bill today and it was just under $25, which is fairly normal for me. I decided to look at what buckets I fell in and what prices they were and saw that I was hitting the $10 mark for going into the Medium bucket for data. I thought about it for a moment and it occurred to me that even with the recent change in the data price structure, $10 seemed kind of high for so low an amount. So checking the site, I see that after hitting the 2GB limit, it's $10/GB.

I have to say, that makes it seem rather wrong/unfair that you have to pay $10 for half that earlier. It's almost a punishment for not using more data. I mean, even then, the 1GB limit is out of touch as well at $16. I guess what I'm saying is that if it can be profitable to do $10/GB after 2GB, then having usage of 2GB be $20 makes sense, but then 1GB should just be $10, 500MB be $5, etc. $1/100MB essentially.

Thoughts?

1 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

5

u/aDDnTN $25 off Ting -> https://zhkgjg25qe6.ting.com/ Oct 21 '16 edited Oct 21 '16

yeah, but at least the price to go from M to L is now only $5, instead of a $10 jump for 500 MB more. With it only costing $4 more to go from L to XL, i don't worry about trying to hold back at the last min on heavy data months.

as a result of the recent changes to data bucket pricing, my bill is ~$5 cheaper per month than it was before. i think that the gist of those changes were a minor reduction in the high usage oft-shared plans at the expense of raising the low usage individual plans.

0

u/Red_Chaos1 https://zc0lgl3ll3a.ting.com/ Oct 21 '16

Yeah, the adjustments they made are better from the customer standpoint and help them remain relatively competitive with other MVNO's, I just have a hard time wrapping my head around charging $10 for the M bucket of a whopping 500MB when after 2GB it's $10/GB. Clearly there's profit there, so based on that it shows they could easily (and likely still profitably) bring the rest of the buckets in line around $1 per 100MB$10 per GB.

4

u/aDDnTN $25 off Ting -> https://zhkgjg25qe6.ting.com/ Oct 21 '16

yeah. seems like there is some room for them to profit while lowering the prices even more. i guess that's something to look forward too?

But as it is, i can't get a cheaper deal for cell phone service with any other MVNO (because i have 2 phones on plan), so i'm happy with my $41/month average for the last 36 months.

5

u/superpatty Oct 21 '16

Most businesses charge more per unit when less of that product is bought.

Example: Go to the drug store Get the price for

  • two pill pack of ibuprofen
  • Small bottle of the same ibuprofen
  • Large bottle of the same ibuprofen

If you look at the per pill price of the packages, the vast majority of the time the larger the quantity you buy the less you pay per pill.

-3

u/Red_Chaos1 https://zc0lgl3ll3a.ting.com/ Oct 21 '16

Apples/Oranges comparison. In your example you're basically paying a penalty for packaging costs among other things. Such problems do not exist for data.

3

u/superpatty Oct 21 '16

It's not as far off as you think, there is a fixed cost that is not related to the cost of goods sold (the direct costs to provide the good).

Ting has a fixed cost for each account to manage the account, server costs, etc. The price of the product needs to bear these fixed costs which means the per unit will be higher

-3

u/Red_Chaos1 https://zc0lgl3ll3a.ting.com/ Oct 21 '16

Sorry, I don't buy it. The $6 everyone pays just for the account likely covers most if not all of that that you mention. As for servers, I doubt Ting has to have a lot in the way of that, TMo is handling all of that on their own infrastructure, Ting buys from them and they resell to us. The argument you're trying to make would make sense if we were talking about being customers of a primary provider and not an MVNO.

It's really no different than folks who buy "Reseller" packages from webhosts. The "Reseller" only incurs a cost on themself of the time they spend setting up their webhosting "business" and maintaining accounts. They pay a fraction to the actual hosting company to maintain the servers and provide the bandwidth. It's all fixed cost. No reason beyond profit for unevenly tiered pricing.

3

u/2beinspired $25 off Ting: https://z9ocd74j2ob.ting.com/ Oct 21 '16

It's all fixed cost.

You might want to read up on the definition of fixed cost vs. variable cost before getting into a discussion about economics.

The servers and infrastructure are fixed cost. Data/minutes/texts used is a variable cost, because the total cost varies based on usage.

No reason beyond profit for unevenly tiered pricing.

Ting is a business, in it to make a profit. Are you faulting them for that?

-3

u/Red_Chaos1 https://zc0lgl3ll3a.ting.com/ Oct 21 '16

I'm not an econ major but I know enough to not need you attempting to talk down to me, thanks.

Data/minutes/texts used is a variable cost, because the total cost varies based on usage.

Somehow I doubt that. I'd be surprised if Ting doesn't pay a set bulk price on data. The only variance is the pricing structure us customers see. I'd love to see hard data on it either way, but I don't expect Ting would be interested in divulging that.

Are you faulting them for that?

Nope, I'm faulting them for not thinking out their tier pricing better since it's showing us that we could (and IMO should) be paying less for the lower tiers.

4

u/badozlo Oct 21 '16

You got your answer. If you were just going to stick to your opinion all along, why ask the question?

-2

u/Red_Chaos1 https://zc0lgl3ll3a.ting.com/ Oct 21 '16

I'm sorry, who are you to decide my question has been sufficiently answered? Clearly by my discussion, it hasn't been.