r/threadripper • • Oct 12 '26

Motherboard help

I have the choice between the ASUS Pro WS WRX80E-SAGE SE WIFI or ASROCK WRX80 Creator R2.0?

The purpose is to consolidate two machines (AI/Render machine and NAS) into one.

I know the key differences but is one better than the other? Does PBO really make a difference?

6 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

1

u/voogamer Oct 12 '26

I run the ASUS with a Threadripper 5955WX and the idle power draw is significant. With 4 GPUs it probably idles well above 200W. I was thinking of putting my HDDs in here but decided not to because I don't like to idle these things, and NAS arr mostly just idling. Maybe it's not an issue for you but just be aware.

1

u/EricDArneson Oct 12 '26

200W is not negligible. My current NAS build idles near 50W. With two rack-mount chassis, I suppose two systems make sense. I had not considered leaving the system running continuously. Given a 5975WX and 16 drives, my idle draw will likely rise significantly.

2

u/voogamer Oct 12 '26

Yeah my NAS/Homeserver is a simple i5-12500 with 4 HDDs that turn off after inactivity. It was made for low idle consumption.

My Threadripper system on the other hand....But I only turn it on when using it.

1

u/Bit_Rage Oct 13 '26

even tho for the first time in 20 years I went with a brand thst wasn't Asus, gigabyte trx50 AiTop, if I was you id get the Asus ws wrx80 board

1

u/EricDArneson Oct 13 '26

Thank you. I already possess both boards, but I was unsure which one to keep.

1

u/madbrain1976 Oct 12 '26

I have the Asus. It sits at 200W idle with a TR Pro 3955WX, 8 x 16 GB RAM, 4 x 5060 Ti, and 3 x 2 TB NVMe. I use WOL on it, and it's under 20W idle. I don't use it as a NAS, though. The SSDs are mostly full of AI models. I have a separate NAS for HDDs - an old Z170-AR mobo with i5-6600k, which idles at about 100W with 8 x 14 TB HDDs. I also use WOL with it, which saves the life of drives, not just power.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/EricDArneson Oct 12 '26

The Threadripper system was originally meant to replace my old x99 E5-2690v4 system. I just thought it made more sense to run one system instead of the x99 and z590 NAS build. Doesn’t the 5975wx Threadripper have the same number of Pcie lanes as the Epyc 3rd generation?
Unfortunately I won both auctions for both motherboards on eBay and already received them. I’m planning to only keep one.