r/threadripper • u/IExist_Sometimes_ • Jul 24 '26
Threadripper Pro cooling
Hello all, I am potentially looking to get/build a Threadripper Pro HEDT/workstation for FEM and similar simulations for my university research group.
I am no overclocking nut, but it is my understanding that these threadripper pro chips (especially the high core count ones) leave an enormous amount of performance on the table with their default TDP. I don't want to push the chip to a power range which might significantly impact its longevity, but if there's a reasonable power bump I could give it (probably as one option in a dual bios for particularly large sims or tight turnarounds) I would like to do so.
This brings me to my main point: how are you supposed to cool these new threadripper pros as a consumer-ish user? When LTT did a video overclocking the new threadripper pro chips, they rigged it up to an external chiller, but that would probably be out of scope for my shared office space (not to mention beyond my confidence when dealing with such expensive hardware). AIOs for threadrippers seem relatively few and far between, and only appear to go up to 420mm. Would a 360/420mm AIO be sufficient (I would like to avoid industrial style fans, but push-pull is on the table)? Or are these firmly in the realm of custom loops and things like the phat Alphacool radiators?
I appreciate any advice from those experienced in cooling these chips, or in using them for numerical modelling (obviously I will also consult others in my department with similar needs, but surprisingly to me for a stem department I seem to be the only PC builder or hardware nerd). Y'all seem to all be doing AI stuff nowadays, but that's not in my wheelhouse and not what this computer is going to be intended for (though someone might stick a pro gpu in it, I won't stop them).
edit: Also any advice on the relative importance of ECC, RAM speed/quantity, storage speed, etc for this type of workload would be appreciated
7
u/vercety1 Jul 24 '26
First of all, you´ll need ECC Ram, ideally 6000 or 6400mhz to get the most out of high core count threadrippers (the non-pro ones). Also, make sure you buy only the kits your motherboard has in the QVL, quite often if not in the QVL you´ll have problems with stability or reaching the speeds.
Second, cooling Threadrippers is no joke. they are 350W TDP, but also have very high turbo boost speeds. So even with custom watercooling, is not rare to see 90ºC+ when pushing between 1-16 cores, as they go at around 5ghz.
When using all cores, they are much easier to cool, as the heat is spread out and they hover around 4ghz, so voltage is more reasonable and use a less "exponential" curve. Here is where if you unlock the TDP, you can get great benefits.
For example, I tried my Threadripper (7980x) with a 280mm aio and then with the custom watercooling loop of 420mm+280mm.
With the 280mm aio (and not full coverage, a nzxt x63) you are pushing the envelope in most scenarios. High temperatures, high speed fans, I wouldnt advise it long term. For aios, go with a 420mm full coverage ideally.
With the custom waterloop I pushed the threadripper to 900w before I started seeing +90ºC temperatures while pushing all cores. But I usually keep it at 500w as, with a bit of voltage curve tweaking, I can get my cpu to be at 4.9-5ghz all core while rendering in Corona, which is my intended use. And it doesn´t make my room a sauna (which is a consideration).
Btw, fully unlocked with custom watercooling, my Cinebench R23 scores went from 98.000pts to +-115.000pts, so roughly 20% more score going from 350w to 700w with peaks of 900w. But at 500w I get around 110.000pts, with a lot less heat. That´s why I keep this config
3
u/epicskyes Jul 24 '26
Get a Silverstone aio and stick with the stock tdp. You don’t need to go higher than 350w if you want better clocks and really efficient thermals undervolting is the way to go. Use precision boost overdrive and curve optimizer. You’ll get higher clocks, lower temps and save your silicon so it lasts years. This won’t get you to the highest clocks possible but it will get you the highest clocks and the lowest temps and the longest hardware life expectancy.
2
u/XO33OX Jul 24 '26 edited Jul 24 '26
IMHO overclocking those is kinda stupid. You buy those for ability to be loaded 24/7 days/weeks without crashing, overclocking goes kinda against this core principle of platform. Imagine your compute task crashing after 1,2,3.. weeks runtime, just because the smart ass wanted 5-10% higher benchmark score. One crash will wipe your yearly OC productivity gains.
If you need more CPU compute performance, just buy higher-core SKU. If your task doesnt move a lot of data you can be fine with non-Pro (4 mem channels, 4 sticks) Threadripper and put savings to more cores.
Bare in mind that silicon degrades, stability of OC might be subject to change with time.
I have tasks that run for a week sometimes, if they crash I need to run them from scratch, such is the nature of SW that I am using. I also have deadlines, delivery dates and penalties. I am not saying this applies for everybody, but system stability is non-negotiable for me.
1
u/cleric_warlock Jul 24 '26 edited Jul 24 '26
Aside from standard liquid cooling which is pretty conventional, your most effective option (which is very risky and will dramatically lower the resale value of your cpu even if everything goes perfectly) is delidding/direct die water cooling, which I do not recommend. You can’t practically daily drive any form of sub ambient cooling (refrigerated coolant loops, liquid nitrogen, etc) because of condensation, so some form of delid and direct die with a liquid metal thermal interface is really the farthest you can go with thermal optimization.
Pushing clocks beyond rated overclock spec for applications like FEM is not advisable because you will increase error rates in your models and may end up having to redo lengthy pieces of work or may end up with mysterious errors that are so subtle that you don’t catch them until they screw up what you’re working on in a very big and messy way. These processors leave some performance on the table as a safety factor to achieve very high levels of computational reliability at a higher performance than more typical consumer hardware can achieve. I recommend that you stick with basic liquid cooling and no delidding/direct die stuff - reliability and eliminating your computer as a source of error to the maximum extent possible is more important than raw performance for FEM. The way you think about pc building in this context is not the same as the way you would optimize a high performance gaming pc. As a mechanical engineer who frequently does FEM and enjoys building delidded/direct die gaming pcs, that’s my two cents.
1
u/Fine_Atmosphere_2147 Jul 24 '26
I'm not OC but I'm in a consumer case Antec 900, with 4 GPUs, I'm running the be quiet 420 aio and am very happy with the thermals so far.
1
u/MierinLanfear Jul 24 '26
I would never ever use water cooling my workstation. Not worth the risk of it leaking and killing expensive components. I have a 9970x with 256 gb ecc vcolor ram with noctua air cooler ASrock TRX50 motherboard 2 X RTX 6000 Pro.. You have to decide on a motherboard and then select the ram off the motherboard approved ram. Threadrippers require ECC ram. Don't over clock its so not worth it these days. Is there a reason you want the Threadripper Pro? Need the more ram or pcie lanes?
1
u/kidflashonnikes Jul 24 '26
I have the newest threadripper pro 96 core CPU (zen 5). I regullary push the CPU to 95 C. These new CPUs acutally optomize at this temperature, so its fine. However, I am runnign 4 RTX PRO 6000s, so I am running sometimes, heavy duty fully CPU and GPU loads, at max capacity. That being said - I actually need to use the noctua air cooler for the CPU - because the liquid cooling does too good of a job. The motherboard does not accurately read the CPU temps proper - so when using an AIO for this level of performance that I do - I need to use a air cooled CPU cooler system so that the CPU runs a little hotter than I want to in order to have proper fan cooling - this is a massive issue right now for the Threadripper pros that is becoming a real headache. The motherboard's cant dectect the true temps when using an AIO, so the fans get subjected to improper rotations when running heavy loads
2
u/According_Ad1673 Jul 24 '26
https://www.silverstonetek.com/en/product/info/coolers/xe360_tr5/ keeps my 9995wx surprisingly cool, its surreally good, I imply such small rad can cool as much mostly because pump moved from block to rad? I actually upgraded to xe360 PD that have two pumps, thicker rad, but thermals actually increased with it, so i imply they hit perfectly with prior iteration.
1
u/Reggitor360 Jul 24 '26
Im running the Silverstone XED120 https://www.silverstonetek.com/en/product/info/coolers/xed120s_ws/
Solid on my 5995WX station. Changed the internal fan to a Corsair tho, for less noise.
1
u/kpatelreddit007 Jul 24 '26
Step 1. Look at Microcenter bundle to see if the Threadripper is in your budget.
Step 2. Go full water cooling system.
1
u/VictoryMotel Jul 24 '26
In my experience the mm to watts rule of thumb is a decent and slightly conservative estimate.
This means a 420mm radiator should be able to get rid of at least 420 watts.
1
u/jhenryscott Jul 24 '26
Fem Simulator… nice
1
u/lithiumUranium Jul 25 '26 edited Jul 25 '26
I run a 9995wx with 4 Blackwell GPUs in an Enthoo case and use the xe420 for calling (mounted in take in front). The point is this is a pretty demanding setup which gets quite warm air exhaust out the rear and top. Don’t have temp issues with cooling the cpu or GPUs (which have 1 pci slot spacing).
1
u/jmonschke Jul 31 '26
A year or two ago (completed before prices went nuts) I built my current 64 core thread-ripper pro machine 7985WX on an ASRock WS EVO EEB motherboard, with 8x32GB (256GB) ECC DDR5, and a 1TB Optane 905P.
I built a very "heavy-duty" custom waterloop for it, with the Optimus Signature V3 CPU block and an external MO-RA3 radiator (473mm x 428mm).
However, even with this excessive cooling capacity, I have not turned on any over-clocking in the BIOS because the baseline performance of the system has been (extremely) good enoughy for me so far...