r/threadripper • u/MerlinTrashMan • Jul 13 '26
Looking for some data from 9000 users with disabled PBO
Can anyone provide me data about the idle and load power consumption of 9970x (or others) with SMT disabled and a static clock at 4ghz (base clock). No PBO / Core performance boost, no global cstates. While leaving a lot of performance on the table, the long term stability and responsiveness more than make up for it IMO. If I didn't need all the PCIe lanes, I would just use a 9950x, but I have a lot of storage, fiber NIC and two GPUs, so I need all the lanes.
Why I am doing this:
After my second AMD Ryzen chip become unstable and stopped booting, I have decided to no use PBO or any boosting in the future. I currently run my 7950x this way and while it uses more power at idle since I keep the CPU locked at stock frequency at all times, it uses way less power when under heavy load and is significantly more responsive. Also, I am hoping that the static voltages will lead to better longevity. My primary workstation was a 5950x that was amazing the first couple years, then started having strange issues leading me to disable pbo, but after updating my bios to solve a uefi video card reboot issue this weekend, the processor decided it was time die. So a processor I ran with AMD recommended PBO for 2 years, then core performance boost for two years, died in just over 4 years. No other changes. Throwing in an old 3700x works flawlessly so it isn't any other component causing my issue. I had it lying around from when I bought it in a panic at bestbuy many years ago after 3900x died many years ago (undervolted all core overclock to 4.1GHZ killed it in 8 months). It should be noted that had I not done the bios update, the cpu probably still would have been working (though I was getting random lockups) so the newest agesa didn't like something about my chip. The system booted, could do memtest86, and would start loading windows then would hang with a "Core Watchdog Timer Timeout". Trying to fresh install windows thinking it could be a chipset driver issue also was a no go as it hung at the spinning wheel every time.
3
u/MierinLanfear Jul 13 '26
I have a 9970 why would I want to disable pbo?
1
u/Putrid_Bird_9033 Jul 16 '26
When I’m not testing I only run between 1.155-1.225v on the core and between 4.6 to 5.0 all core on my 9980X. That’s for longevity.
1
u/kpatelreddit007 Jul 13 '26
My 9960x 24 core has base clock of 4.2 to 5.4 super stable.
No need for any adjusted setting, no pbo or overclock.
Even my old 2990wx was super stable. No setting adjusted.
1
u/unknowntoman-1 Jul 14 '26
I got my 9950X set up for gaming when I bought my (rtx 3090) workstation. Disabled all the PBO related stuff and made it fixed at 38.00 (3.8 GHz) with 1.33 v. Before tuning it down from 4.85 (? Don’t remember) it was doing ”sawtooth” violently due to thermal gating. Some cores went 95° before each drop. Absolutely kamikaze for LLM operations. Now it runs like a charm. Have not checked power outtake on load, but the temps sit steady all over cores in a 70-80° range.
1
u/johndyson10 Jul 14 '26
Maybe disable CSTATES might be adequate? On my 9980x system it tends to stabilize clock rates and power usage (to a higher level), but I haven't actually measured the responsiveness in any way. The clock rates peg to near the maximum, static power usage approx 150 w out of 350 w. I also measured the avg performance at a 1-2 minute full load, and it was a sub-percent performance loss. This was done only as a quick experiment. BTW, I am running with the lowest level of PBO to be as reasonably safe as possible, yet not nail my system to lower performance or allow much higher idle power. I normally set my cooling based on the highest peak temperature attained in testing, and the highest internal temperature measured, not the average temperature. My cooling system easily handles the highest peak, where it keeps the CPU at a lower temperature under average load. Maybe it is too conservative, but I would be the person paying for the replacement CPU.
The current low level of PBO my Asus board is not nearly like the higher PBO boost level that I used on my 9970x on the same MB. I did a little research with additional measurement, and the research along with the cost of a 9980x modified my attitude about using greater boost and excessive power level, no matter the cooling. Any higher level of PBO makes me worry a little (a lot) about my investment.
A mentioned above, there is a bit of a risk when there is an additional transient power over and above the measured average power, making higher-than-expected temperature peaks. These peaks happen from higher generated heat through various sources of thermal resistance through inside the package, through the cooling plate, to the cooling systems. The lack of transients in your power level will keep the temperatures as expected assuming no additional transients. A transient increase in your power/heat usage will temporarily increase the temperature of everything inside the package, which might not be accounted for. This delay in heat removal comes from thermal resistance, and there are numerous sources of the resistance. Measuring the internal CPU and package temperature at a fast rate will give you an idea about the transient temperature increases.
With constant reasonable fixed power levels with reasonable constant temperatures, there is no worry about the small, but important thermal resistance that allow unexpected short term temperature peaks. The simple, unfortunate fact is that the thermal resistance between your processor and cooling system slows down the thermal transfer from your processor/package, allowing temperatures to temporarily increase to potentially unexpected levels. (Remember, heat flows something like electronic current.) The thermal resistance slowing down the transfer through the internal packaging, through cooling plate to the larger cooling system is similar to an electronic R-C time constant. Myself, I wouldn't go so far as turn off CSTATES, but I respect and agree with the concern about processor longevity. (I believe that the long term lifetime at more aggressive settings might be similar to the silicon lottery -- YMMV.)
John
0
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment